Skip to main content
. 2023 Feb 17;13(2):e070962. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2022-070962

Table 3.

Instruments and evaluation periods for the assessment of long-term patient-relevant outcomes

Outcome category Instruments At discharge* After discharge* Other time References
28–30 d/1 m 60 d/2 m 90 d/3 m 180 d/6 m 1y 3–5 y
Survival (n=24) Mortality x† 44–46 48 54 64–67 71 74–76
x x x 63
x 57 61 69
x‡ 61 69
x‡ x‡ 70
x‡ 59
42
42 56 68
x‡ 60
At discharge to rehabilitation, to home and in rehabilitation 39
HrQoL (n=5) SF-36 x 62
EQ5D VAS x 52
EQ5D VAS x** x** 59
EQ5D domain scores, EQ5D VAS x 73
QALYs 42
PICS—cognition (n=9) Modified Rankin Scale; Glasgow Outcome Scale Extended 68
Glasgow Outcome Scale 55
Modified Rankin Scale 61
Functional Independence Measure x 62
CAM-ICU; Digit Span Forward and Backward test; TMT A and B x†† 40
Tower Test; dysexecutive questionnaire, MMSE x x 52
Glasgow Coma Scale x 69 73
ASIA motor and sensitive score x 56
PICS—physical health (n=5) Physical Function ICU Test-scored, Functional Independence Measure x 62
Timed Up-and-Go; Katz Activities of Daily Living; Functional Activities Questionnaire x x 52
Mobilisation level x 69
ASIA motor and sensitive score x 56
Mean physical component summary score, Barthel index 61
PICS—mental health (n=4) Sickness Impact Profile 72
IES-R; HADS; need for psychotherapy, anxiolytic and/or antidepressant medication x 73
Antipsychotic medication use x 49
Mean SF-36 mental component summary score 61
Care-related outcomes (n=17) Discharge destination x 42 47 48 50 51 53 59
Change in residence x 41
Discharge to usual residence 70
Return to independent living x 75
ICU readmission rate, ICU discharge destination other than home x 53
Inappropriate continuation of stress ulcer prophylaxis x 58
ICU-free days and ventilator-free days 55 57
Ventilator-free days x‡‡ 57 74
Readmission rate x 43
Risk of remaining in the ICU Until day 20 39
Discharge diagnosis of aspiration pneumonia x 61
Adverse events (n=1) Adverse events x‡ 69
Social health (n=1) Return to work x 73

Studies68 69 are separate outcome analyses of unique data collected within one clinical trial (ClinicalTrials.gov identifier: NCT01656317).

*ICU and/or hospital discharge.

†After discharge, except for one study that considered those discharged before 28 days to be alive44 and one study that assessed 30-day mortality after hospital admission.76

‡After stroke.

§After ICU/hospital admission.

¶After trauma/haemorrhage.

**EQ5D VAS measured at 90-180 days after the index event.

††Right after ICU discharge.

‡‡After trauma57 or hospital admission.74

ASIA, American Spinal Injury Association; CAM-ICU, Confusion Assessment Method for the ICU; d, days; EQ5D, EuroQol 5 dimensions; HADS, Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale; HrQoL, health-related quality of life; ICU, intensive care unit; IES-R, Impact of Event Scale-Revised; m, months; MMSE, Mini-Mental State Examination; QALY, quality-adjusted life year; SF-36, Short Form (36); TMT, Trail Making Test; VAS, visual analogue scale; y, years.