Skip to main content
. 2023 Feb 22;9(8):eadd4675. doi: 10.1126/sciadv.add4675

Table 1. TCSA values and statistical results for archaeological, experimental, and ethnographic points.

  n Min Max Mean (SD) Median (IIQ) Versus Mandrin points Versus Mandrin micro/nanopoints Source
Mandrin points 127 12 175 56.3 (34.7) 50 (33–70) <2.2 × 10−16, P < 0.05 This study
Mandrin micro/nanopoints 86 3 98 19.5 (14.9) 16.50 (10–24) This study
Ethnographic arrowheads 118 7.9 145.8 32.53 (20) 29.87 (22–38) 2.165 × 10−12, P < 0.05 9.689 × 10−13, P < 0.05 (21)
Experimental arrowheads 50 7 99 30.79 (19.8) 26.75 (16.5–40.4) 3697 × 10−8, P < 0.05 0.0001, P < 0.05 This study
Experimental lightweight Javelin 29 47.5 216 89.72 (39.7) 75 (63–104) 1.528 × 10−16, P < 0.05 8.118 × 10−15, P < 0.05 (22, 38)
Experimental dart tips 23 20 87.5 52.8 (20) 52.8 (37.5–64.5) 0.6669, P > 0.05* 3.81 × 10−10, P < 0.05 This study
Ethnographic dart tips 40 20.3 94.3 57.9 (18) 60.3 (44.7–69.2) 0.09108, P > 0.05* 5.547 × 10−16, P < 0.05 (21)
Ethnographic dart tips 103 66.6 488.4 240.02 (101.5) 240.7 (172.3–315.2) <2.2 × 10−16, P < 0.05 <2.2 × 1016, P < 0.05 (23)
Experimental thrusting/hand-cast 36 50 392 165.8 (80.7) 148.5 (123.0–189) 6.53 × 10−15, P < 0.05 <2.2 × 1016, P < 0.05 (21), This study
Experimental thrusting spear tips 47 46 406 153.9 (61.7) 143.5 (119.5–169) <2.2 × 1016, P < 0.05 <2.2 × 1016, P < 0.05 (38)
  n Min Max Mean (SD) Median (IIQ) P value    
Mandrin micropoints 49 3.5 98 22.28 (15.8) 19 (15–27) 0.003, P < 0.05    
Mandrin nanopoints 37 3 72.5 15.77 (12.9) 12 (9–18)    

*There is no significant TCSA difference between ethnographical dart tips from Shea and experimental dart tips from Initiarc and Mandrin E points.