Table 2.
Material | Modulus | Modulus value | Dimension | Test mode | Condition | Concentration (w/w) | Refs. |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
MW | |||||||
PEGDA | E | 6.5-30 MPa | Nanoscale | AFM | 700 Da | * | [97] |
E | 36 kPa | Macroscale | Compression | 2000 Da | 15.0% | [98] | |
G | 10 kPa | Macroscale | Compression | 2000 Da | 15.0% | ||
E | 200-400 kPa | Macroscale | Tension | 3000 Da | 20.0% | [99] | |
E | 40 kPa | Macroscale | Tension | 6000 Da | 5.0% | [100] | |
E | 200 kPa | Macroscale | Tension | 6000 Da | 10.0% | ||
E | 320 kPa | Macroscale | Tension | 6000 Da | 15.0% | ||
E | 430 kPa | Macroscale | Tension | 6000 Da | 20.0% | ||
Temperature | |||||||
GelMA | E | 133 kPa | Nanoscale | AFM | 25° | 10.0% | [101] |
E | 171 kPa | Nanoscale | AFM | 25° | 20.0% | ||
E | 2.86 ± 0.1 kPa | Macroscale | Compression | 25° | 5.0% | [102] | |
E | 2.41 ± 0.38 kPa | Macroscale | Compression | 37° | 5.0% | ||
E | 288.24 ± 62.34 kPa | Macroscale | Compression | 25° | 30.0% | ||
E | 216.81 ± 10.28 kPa | Macroscale | Compression | 37° | 30.0% | ||
E | 2.08 ± 0.43 kPa | Macroscale | Tension | 25° | 5.0% | ||
E | 1.67 ± 0.56 kPa | Macroscale | Tension | 37° | 5.0% | ||
E | 264.74 ± 11.08 kPa | Macroscale | Tension | 25° | 30.0% | ||
E | 226.80 ± 39.97 kPa | Macroscale | Tension | 37° | 30.0% | ||
Agarose | E | 168 kPa | Nanoscale | AFM | 25° | 1.00% | [101] |
E | 230 kPa | Nanoscale | AFM | 25° | 2.00% | ||
Alginate | G | 0.203 ± 0.013 kPa | Macroscale | Compression | 20° | 0.70% | [103] |
G | 1.300 ± 0.129 kPa | Macroscale | Compression | 20° | 1.50% | ||
G | 3.010 ± 0.084 kPa | Macroscale | Compression | 20° | 3.00% | ||
Collagen (Type I) | E | ~200 Pa | Nanoscale | AFM | 20° | 0.20% | [104] |
E | ~500 Pa | Nanoscale | AFM | 20° | 0.30% | ||
E | ~800 Pa | Nanoscale | AFM | 20° | 0.40% |
Abbreviations: AFM, atomic force microscopy; E, elasticity modulus; G, shear modulus; MW, molecular weight. *Poly(ethylene glycol) diacrylate (PEGDA) of this molecular weight is liquid.