Skip to main content
. 2022 Oct 29;9(1):632. doi: 10.18063/ijb.v9i1.632

Table 2.

Stiffness values of bio-inks at different scales

Material Modulus Modulus value Dimension Test mode Condition Concentration (w/w) Refs.
MW
PEGDA E 6.5-30 MPa Nanoscale AFM 700 Da * [97]
E 36 kPa Macroscale Compression 2000 Da 15.0% [98]
G 10 kPa Macroscale Compression 2000 Da 15.0%
E 200-400 kPa Macroscale Tension 3000 Da 20.0% [99]
E 40 kPa Macroscale Tension 6000 Da 5.0% [100]
E 200 kPa Macroscale Tension 6000 Da 10.0%
E 320 kPa Macroscale Tension 6000 Da 15.0%
E 430 kPa Macroscale Tension 6000 Da 20.0%
Temperature
GelMA E 133 kPa Nanoscale AFM 25° 10.0% [101]
E 171 kPa Nanoscale AFM 25° 20.0%
E 2.86 ± 0.1 kPa Macroscale Compression 25° 5.0% [102]
E 2.41 ± 0.38 kPa Macroscale Compression 37° 5.0%
E 288.24 ± 62.34 kPa Macroscale Compression 25° 30.0%
E 216.81 ± 10.28 kPa Macroscale Compression 37° 30.0%
E 2.08 ± 0.43 kPa Macroscale Tension 25° 5.0%
E 1.67 ± 0.56 kPa Macroscale Tension 37° 5.0%
E 264.74 ± 11.08 kPa Macroscale Tension 25° 30.0%
E 226.80 ± 39.97 kPa Macroscale Tension 37° 30.0%
Agarose E 168 kPa Nanoscale AFM 25° 1.00% [101]
E 230 kPa Nanoscale AFM 25° 2.00%
Alginate G 0.203 ± 0.013 kPa Macroscale Compression 20° 0.70% [103]
G 1.300 ± 0.129 kPa Macroscale Compression 20° 1.50%
G 3.010 ± 0.084 kPa Macroscale Compression 20° 3.00%
Collagen (Type I) E ~200 Pa Nanoscale AFM 20° 0.20% [104]
E ~500 Pa Nanoscale AFM 20° 0.30%
E ~800 Pa Nanoscale AFM 20° 0.40%

Abbreviations: AFM, atomic force microscopy; E, elasticity modulus; G, shear modulus; MW, molecular weight. *Poly(ethylene glycol) diacrylate (PEGDA) of this molecular weight is liquid.