Skip to main content
. 2022 Nov 29;9(1):648. doi: 10.18063/ijb.v9i1.648

Table 4. Comparison between various hemostatic biomaterials with potential application and commercial hemostats.

Reference hemostat (commercial) Hemostat type/composition In vivo injury model Time to hemostasis Advantages Reported disadvantages Mechanism of action References
Fibrin glue InjectableZHyaluronan conjugate with inorganic polyphosphate (HA-PolyP) Mouse liver bleeding model <5 minutes Hemostatic efficiency similar to fibrin glue None Initiation of contact pathway of blood coagulation cascade, increased coagulation factor V activation, fibrin clot stabilization, promotion of factor XI feedback activation by thrombin [229]
Fibrin glue Injectable/Glycosylated catechol- and glucose-grafted poly(L-ly-sine) hydrogel Liver hemorrhage model of SD male rat <20 seconds Strong tissue adhesion, good injectability, irregular shape filling ability, high performance hemostasis (outperforming fibrin glue), wound healing Non-glycosylation leads to compromised biocompatibility Hydrogel induced sealing of wound site by wet adhesion, higher absorption of RBCs and platelets [186]
Fibrin sealant and floseal InjectableZPotassium aluminum sulfate (PA) and calcium chloride (Ca) entrapped chitosan based composite hydrogel (Cs-PA-Ca) Rat liver and femoral artery hemorrhage model Cs-PA-Ca (20 ± 10 seconds, 105 ± 31 seconds), Fibrin sealant (77 ± 26 seconds, 204 ± 58 seconds), Floseal (76 ±15 seconds, 218 ± 46 seconds) Faster blood clot formation over commercial hemostats Material retention even after 8-weeks post-surgery Accelerated pIateletZRBC aggregation, activation of the coagulation cascade [230]
Gelatin sponge Subcutaneous implan- tationZ chitin-glucan composite sponge Rat femoral artery, non-compressive liver puncture injury model <60 seconds Higher hemostatic efficiency over commercial hemostat, robust mechanical property, blood triggered shape memory None RBC aggregation, accelerated collagen synthesis, and new blood vessel formation [231]
Surgicel, Curaspon Chitosan loaded β-cyclodextrin polyester (CDPE-Cs) hydrogel Liver punch biopsy model in rats, rabbits, pigs - Higher hemostatic efficiency than commercial hemostats - - [232]
ChitoGauzeeXR and Spongostan™ Graphene oxide (GO)Z chitosan (CS)Z gelatin (GEL)Z polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) based aerogel Rat tail amputation model Coagulation up to 95% within 240 seconds Faster hemostasis over commercial hemostat by -4-5 times None Activation of erythrocytes and platelets on the aerogel surface [233]
Celox® Iota-CarrageenanZxylo- glucanZserine powder incorporate with tranexamic acid (IC:XYL:SER:TA-x%) Rat tail amputation model IC:XYL: SER:TA-2%: 136.2 ± 14.0 seconds Celox® : 129.4 ± 18.9 seconds Hemostatic efficiency comparable to Celox®, Light weight, easy to use, antibacterial, antioxidative, promising alternative for controlling external bleeding Hemostasis performance in large mammals might be advantageous Enhanced adhesion of RBC [234]