TABLE 2.
Summary of neurophysiology studies.
References | Pre-registration? | Treatment | Control | Sample size | Observed post-dosing effect | P-value | Effect size | # of studies reporting consistent findings | # of studies reporting inconsistent findings | Strengths | Limitations |
Carhart-Harris et al. (12) | No | LSD in saline (75 μg/10 mL) | 10 mL saline | 20 | Increased CBF in visual cortex associated with decreased alpha power in OC | 0.029 | NA | 0 | 0 | Motion correction took place for analyses of neuroimaging data making it robust | Not performed as a double blind RCT. Performance of neuroimaging techniques at separate times. |
Decreased alpha power associated with hallucinations | <0.05 | NA | 2 | 0 | |||||||
Muthukumaraswamy et al. (89) | No | Psilocybin in saline (2 mg/10 mL) | Saline | 15 | Reduction in oscillatory power in delta, gamma, alpha, beta, and theta bands | <0.05 | NA | 3 | 0 | Robust statistical analyses of measures. Vast neuroimaging data collected | Low generalizability to population of those that have no experience using psychedelic drugs. Removal of MEG data due to head movement. Small sample size. |
Murray et al. (87) | No | Two LSD sessions (13 μg and 26 μg) | Water | 22 | Reduction in oscillatory power in delta, gamma, alpha, beta, and theta in MPC, PCC, TPC | <0.05 | NA | 3 | 0 | Blinded study with participants acting as their own controls. Robust EEG data collected | Affected brain structures were inferred from the location in which the extra cranial electrodes were located. Small sample size. |
Riba et al. (86) | No | Two doses of Ayahausca (0.6 mg DMT Kg–1, 0.85 mg DMT Kg–1) | Water | 18 | Decreased absolute power of theta, delta, alpha, and beta | <0.05 | NA | 3 | 0 | Blinding and placebo control were used while participants acted as their own controls. | Small sample size |
Kometer et al. (88) | No | Placebo with ketanserin 50 mg, and placebo with psilocybin (215 μg/kg) | Placebo | 17 | Decrease in alpha power in POC after pretreatment with placebo | <0.01 | NA | 1 | 0 | Blinding and placebo control were used while participants acted as their own controls. Validated measures used such as SCID | Small sample size |
This table highlights the main studies into psilocybin-assisted therapy and neurophysiological outcomes reviewed. Brain regions are signified by their abbreviations; CBF, cerebral blood flow; PC, posterior cingulate cortex; MPC, medial prefrontal cortex; TPC, tempo parietal cortex; POC, parieto-occipital cortex; OC, occipital cortex. The column titled “# of studies reporting effect” refers to the number of studies reviewed which reported findings that are consistent with the post-dosing effect observed in each main neurophysiology study included in the table. Similarly, the column “# of studies reporting contrary” refers to the number of studies reviewed which report findings that are contradictory to the effect observed in each main neurophysiology study. NA signifies information pertaining to effect sizes is unavailable.