Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2023 Apr 1.
Published in final edited form as: Nat Med. 2022 Sep 22;28(10):2194–2206. doi: 10.1038/s41591-022-01942-9

Table 3.

Clinical trial sample size estimates

Pre-symptomatic prevention trial (CDR®+NACC-FTLD Global = 0)
Primary endpoint - Sample Size Estimates (50% Treatment Effect)

Genetic Group Estimated number of eligible participants Inclusion Criteria CDR®+NACC-FTLD-SB Neuropsychological Tests NfL (log) MRI Volume

2 Yrs 4 Yrs 2 Yrs 4 Yrs 2 Yrs 4 Yrs 2 Yrs 4 Yrs
C9orf72
MRI=Temporal
NP = Trails B
171 All CDR 0
>10000 4994 >10000 6784 3397 699 1639 394
13 CDR 0 & NfL (log) > 3
582 334 1113 386 >10000 638 537 173
38 CDR 0 & DA > −5
508 224 657 184 527 153 424 119
20 CDR 0 & DA > −2.5 266 111 364 96 439 123 402 102

GRN
MRI=Frontal
NP=Trails A
168 All CDR 0
3144 1526 3844 1576 684 271 826 459
7 CDR 0 & NfL (log) > 3
250 179 250 140 158 51 71 46
26 CDR 0 & DA −5
297 182 267 130 99 30 52 27
10 CDR 0 & DA −2.5 182 104 159 79 84 26 37 24

MAPT
MRI=MTL
NP=MINT
94 All CDR 0
7073 2733 >10000 3741 3059 802 1492 526
4 CDR 0 & NfL (log) > 3
283 188 373 220 >10000 501 147 72
19 CDR 0 & DA −5
362 190 641 265 595 149 108 39
14 CDR 0 & DA −2.5 191 97 311 134 438 117 72 24
Early symptomatic treatment trial (All CDR®+NACC-FTLD Global = 1 enriched with 0 and 0.5 participants)
Primary endpoint - Sample Size Estimates (50% Treatment Effect)

Genetic Group Estimated number of eligible participants Inclusion Criteria CDR®+NACC-FTLD-SB Neuropsychological Tests NfL (log) MRI Volume

1.5 Yrs 2 Yrs 1.5 Yrs 2 Yrs 1.5 Yrs 2 Yrs 1.5 Yrs 2 Yrs
C9orf72
MRI=Temporal
NP = Trails B
94 ALL CDR 0.5 and 1
188 129 340 203 811 483 639 367
37 All CDR 1 & (CDR 0 & 0.5 if NfL > 3)
161 115 370 222 1806 782 645 358
83 All CDR 1 & (CDR 0 & 0.5 if DA > −2.5)
176 124 400 207 740 423 678 360
67 All CDR 1 & (CDR 0 & 0.5 if DA > 0) 117 79 275 161 628 384 669 359

GRN
MRI=Frontal
NP=Trails A
67 ALL CDR 0.5 and 1
76 66 115 79 133 76 44 30
33 All CDR 1 & (CDR 0 & 0.5 if NfL > 3)
97 84 124 92 182 110 49 36
48 All CDR 1 & (CDR 0 & 0.5 if DA > −2.5)
79 68 105 74 127 75 36 26
38 All CDR 1 & (CDR 0 & 0.5 if DA > 0) 39 32 62 41 124 72 32 22

MAPT
MRI=MTL
NP=MINT
43 ALL CDR 0.5 and 1
175 136 300 196 845 437 124 74
11 All CDR 1 & (CDR 0 & 0.5 if NfL > 3)
89 66 138 91 1719 769 95 59
43 All CDR 1 & (CDR 0 & 0.5 if DA > −2.5)
164 120 244 163 779 419 109 63
31 All CDR 1 & (CDR 0 & 0.5 if DA > 0) 96 66 150 104 627 359 83 48

Note. Sample size estimates (total n for a trial) are first presented for pre-symptomatic prevention trials in which all enrolled participants are presymptomatic based on CDR®+NACC-FTLD = 0. Within each genetic group, sample sizes are estimated for trials enrolling all presymptomatic participants as well as three additional scenarios in which NfL or Disease Age are used to enroll high-risk participants likely to be proximal to symptom onset. In the bottom half of the table, estimates are presented for an early symptomatic trial in which all participants with a CDR®+NACC-FTLD Global = 1 are eligible, and those with CDR®+NACC-FTLD < 1 are included based on different inclusion criteria. The estimated number of eligible participants refers to the number of participants in the current dataset that meet the specified inclusion criteria. For each genetic group, we select a representative MRI and neuropsychological measures (displayed in the first column). Bolded cells indicate that the sample size estimates are less than or within 15 participants of the number eligible. All trial designs assume 1:1 randomization treatment vs. control, 10% attrition per year, and have a primary analysis of a change from baseline in the primary endpoint. Additional details of the assumptions underlying these simulations can be found in Table S9.

Abbreviations: CDR®+NACC-FTLD-SB/CDR: Clinical Dementia Rating Scale plus National Alzheimer’s Coordinating Center’s Frontotemporal Lobar Degeneration Module Sum of Boxes; NfL(log): Log-transformed plasma neurofilament light chain; MRI: magnetic resonance imaging; NP: Group-specific neuropsychological measure; Trails A/B: Trail Making Test, Parts A & B; MTL: Medial Temporal Lobe; MINT: Multilingual Naming Test; DA = Disease Age