Table 1.
Article | Number of Patients | Subsite | Imaging | Analyzed Endpoint | Statistical Findings | Conclusion |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Segmentation | ||||||
C. Parmar et al. Robust Radiomics Feature Quantification Using Semiautomatic Volumetric Segmentation [15] | 20 | Lung NSCLC | CT | Segmentation | 56 3D radiomic features, quantifying phenotypic differences based on tumor intensity, shape and texture | Radiomic features extracted from 3D slicer segmentations had significantly higher reproducibility, were more robust and overlapping with the feature ranges extracted from manual contouring. |
Kuhl, C.K.; Truhn, D. The Long Route to Standardized Radiomics: Unraveling the Knot from the End [16] | 51 | Soft-tissue sarcoma | CT, MRI and PET | Segmentation | 169 preselected features | 167 features demonstrated good to excellent reproducibility and 71 were reproducible after a comprehensive inter- and intra-CT image acquisition analysis. |
Gitto, S. et al. Effects of Interobserver Variability on 2D and 3D CT- and MRI-Based Texture Feature Reproducibility of Cartilaginous Bone Tumors [17] | 30 | Bone tumors | CT and MRI | Segmentation | 783 and 1132 features were extracted | The features extracted were reproducible. 3D and 2D MRI-based texture analyses provided similar rates of stable features. |
Huan Yu et al. Coregistered FDG PET/CT-Based Textural Characterization of Head and Neck Cancer for Radiation Treatment Planning [18] | 40 | Head and neck cancer and lung cancer |
F-FDG PET and CT | Segmentation | Texture features | Gray-tone difference matrices (NGTDM) (PET coarseness, PET contrast and CT coarseness) provided good discrimination performance. |
Yu, H. et al. Automated Radiation Targeting in Head-and-Neck Cancer Using Region-Based Texture Analysis of PET and CT Images [19] | 10 | Head and neck cancer | F-FDG PET and CT | Segmentation | Co-registered multimodality pattern analysis segmentation system (COMPASS) | Tumor delineation was similar to those of the radiation oncologists. |
Characterization | ||||||
Buch, K. et al. Using Texture Analysis to Determine Human Papillomavirus Status of Oropharyngeal Squamous Cell Carcinomas on CT [20] | 40 | Oropharyngeal carcinoma | CT | Characterization | A t-test evaluated differences in 42 texture features between HPV-positive and -negative carcinoma | There are statistically significant differences in some texture features between human-papillomavirus-positive and human-papillomavirus-negative oropharyngeal tumors. |
Fujita, A et al. Difference Between HPV-Positive and HPV-Negative Non-Oropharyngeal Head and Neck Cancer [21] | 46 | Oral cavity, larynx and hypopharynx cancer |
CT | Characterization | Texture analysis program extracted 42 texture features | 16 texture parameters showed significant differences in relation to HPV status. |
Vallieres, M. et al. FDG-PET Image-Derived Features Can Determine HPV Status in Head-and-Neck Cancer [22] | 67 | Hypopharynx | FDG-PET | Characterization | Six texture features, two SUV measures and three shape features were extracted, and logistic regression and support vector machine were performed | It is possible to predict HPV status and treatment failure in HNSCC using a combination of FDG-PET texture and morphological features. |
Payabvash, S. et al. Differentiation of lymphomatous, metastatic, and non-malignant lymphadenopathy in the neck with quantitative diffusion-weighted imaging: Systematic review and meta-analysis [23] | Review (27 studies and 1165 patients) | Neck lymph nodes | MRI (Diffusion Weighted Imaging, DWI) | Characterization | Random-effects models, pooled diagnostic odds ratio (DOR), summary receiver operating characteristics (sROC), area under the curve (AUC) were determined |
Quantitative valuation of ADC can help with differentiation of cervical lymph nodes. Lower ADC values are linked to malignancy and HPV positive status. |
Payabvash, S. et al. Quantitative diffusion magnetic resonance imaging for prediction of human papillomavirus status in head and neck squamous-cell carcinoma: A systematic review and meta-analysis [24] | Review (5 studies and 264 patients) | HNSCC | MRI (DWI) | Characterization | Meta-analysis | HPV-positive HNSCC primary lesions have lower ADC. |
Marzi, S.et al. Multifactorial Model Based on DWI-Radiomics to Determine HPV Status in Oropharyngeal Squamous Cell Carcinoma [25] | 144 | Oropharyngeal carcinoma | MRI (DWI) | Characterization | Different families of machine-learning (ML) algorithms and five-fold cross-validation | DWI-based radiomics can help in differentiating HPV-positive from HPV-negative patients. |
Suh, C.H. et al. Oropharyngeal squamous cell carcinoma: Radiomic machine-learning classifiers from multiparametric MR images for determination of HPV infection status [26] | 60 | Oropharyngeal carcinoma | MRI | Characterization | 1618 quantitative features extraction, features selection, three machine-learning classifiers (logistic regression, random forest and XG boost) | The highest diagnostic accuracies were achieved when using all sequences, and the difference was significant only when the combination did not include the ADC map. |
Sohn, B. et al. Machine Learning Based Radiomic HPV Phenotyping of Oropharyngeal SCC: A Feasibility Study Using MRI [27] | 62 | Oropharyngeal carcinoma | MRI | Characterization | 170 radiomic features | Six radiomic features with strong association with HPV status of SCC were selected using least absolute shrinkage and selection operator (LASSO). |
Aerts, H.J.W.L. et al. Decoding tumour phenotype by noninvasive imaging using a quantitative radiomics approach [28] | 1019 | Lung or head-and-neck cancer | CT | Characterization | 440 features | Some radiomic features had prognostic power associated with underlying gene expression patterns. |
Zwirner, K. et al. Radiogenomics in head and neck cancer: Correlation of radiomic heterogeneity and somatic mutations in TP53, FAT1 and KMT2D [29] | 20 | HNSCC | CT | Characterization | Radiomic features and genetic analysis | Somatic mutations in FAT1 and smaller primary tumor volumes were associated with reduced radiomic intra-tumor heterogeneity. |
Huang, C. et al. Development and validation of radiomic signatures of head and neck squamous cell carcinoma molecular features and subtypes [30] | 113 | HNSCC | CT | Characterization | 540 features, logistic regression, AUC | Quantitative image features can distinguish several molecular phenotypes. |
Zhu, Y. et al. Imaging-Genomic Study of Head and Neck Squamous Cell Carcinoma: Associations Between Radiomic Phenotypes and Genomic Mechanisms via Integration of The Cancer Genome Atlas and The Cancer Imaging Archive [31] | 126 | HNSCC | CT | Characterization | Linear regression and gene set enrichment analysis | Associations between genomic features and radiomic features |
Chen, R.-Y. et al.; Associations of Tumor PD-1 Ligands, Immunohistochemical Studies, and Textural Features in 18F-FDG PET in Squamous Cell Carcinoma of the Head and Neck [32] | 53 | HNSCC | 18F-FDG PET | Characterization | Associations of tumor PD-1 ligands, immunohistochemical studies and textural features | PD-L1 expressions were positively correlated with Ki-67 c-Met and p16. |
Brown, A.M. et al.; Multi-institutional validation of a novel textural analysis tool for preoperative stratification of suspected thyroid tumors on diffusion-weighted MRI [33] | Thyroid tumors | MRI (DWI) | Characterization | 21 textural features | Textural analysis (TA) could characterize thyroid nodules using diffusion-weighted MRI (DW-MRI). | |
Jansen, J.F. Texture analysis on parametric maps derived from dynamic contrast-enhanced magnetic resonance imaging in head and neck cancer [34] | 19 | HNSCC | Dynamic contrast enhanced (DCE)-MRI | Characterization | Image texture analysis was employed on maps of Ktrans and ve, generating two texture measures | Chemoradiation treatment in HNSCC significantly reduced the heterogeneity of tumors. |
Kim, S. et al. Prediction of Response to Chemoradiation Therapy in Squamous Cell Carcinomas of the Head and Neck Using Dynamic Contrast-Enhanced MR Imaging [35] | 33 | HNSCC | DCE-MRI | Characterization | The data were analyzed by using SSM for estimation of Ktrans, ve and τi | Pretreatment DCE-MR imaging can potentially be used for prediction of response to chemoradiation therapy. |
Shukla-Dave et al. Dynamic Contrast-Enhanced Magnetic Resonance Imaging as a Predictor of Outcome in Head-and-Neck Squamous Cell Carcinoma Patients with Nodal Metastases [36] | 64 | HNSCC | DCE-MRI | Characterization | DCE-MRI data were analyzed using the Tofts model | Important role of pretreatment DCE-MRI parameter K{sup trans} as a predictor of outcome |
Dang, M. et al.; MRI Texture Analysis Predicts p53 Status in Head and Neck Squamous Cell Carcinoma [37] | 16 | HNSCC | MRI | Characterization | Texture analysis | MR imaging texture analysis predicted p53 status. |
Staging | ||||||
Wang, F. et al. Radiomic Nomogram Improves Preoperative T Category Accuracy in Locally Advanced Laryngeal Carcinoma [38] | 211 | Laryngeal carcinoma | CT | Staging | 1390 radiomic features extracted and analyzed |
Eight features were found associated with preoperative T category. |
Ren, J. et al.; Magnetic resonance imaging based radiomics signature for the preoperative discrimination of stage I-II and III-IV head and neck squamous cell carcinoma [39] | 127 | HNSCC | MRI | Staging | Radiomics signatures were constructed with least absolute shrinkage and selection operator (LASSO) logistic regression and analyzed | Radiomics signature based on MRI could discriminate stage I–II from stage III–IV HNSCC. |
Romeo, V. et al. Prediction of Tumor Grade and Nodal Status in Oropharyngeal and Oral Cavity Squamous-cell Carcinoma Using a Radiomic Approach [40] | 40 | Oropharyngeal oral cavity carcinoma | CT | Staging | TA features | Tumor grade (TG) and nodal status (NS) could be predicted. |
Wang, H. et al.; Machine learning-based multiparametric MRI radiomics for predicting the aggressiveness of papillary thyroid carcinoma [41] | 120 | Papillary thyroid carcinoma | MRI | Staging | 1393 features | Aggressive and non-aggressive PTC could be distinguished preoperatively through machine-learning-based multiparametric MR imaging radiomics. |