Skip to main content
. 2023 Feb 2;13(2):256. doi: 10.3390/brainsci13020256

Table 2.

Inclusion and exclusion criteria via PICOS.

PICOS Criteria Inclusion Criteria Exclusion Criteria
P (population)
  • Patients diagnosed with an anxiety or stress-related disorder using the DSM-5 classification system

  • Patients aged >18 years (adults)

  • Patients of any biological sex, ethno-racial, and gender identity

  • Patients not diagnosed with an anxiety or stress-related disorder according to the DSM-5 classification system

  • Patients aged < 18 years (children and adolescents)

I (intervention)
  • Breathwork interventions or techniques or exercises

  • Non-breathwork interventions or techniques or exercises

  • Breathwork interventions or techniques or exercises combined with movement (e.g., yoga or Pilates) or techniques (meditation or visualization)

  • Breathwork interventions or techniques or exercises combined with other interventions (dietary changes or supplementation, exercise, etc.)

O (outcome)
  • Study year, study design, study source/location, condition, number of patients, intervention type, intervention regimen, measures, cognitive outcomes, behavioral outcomes, and quality of life outcomes

  • Not applicable

S (study design)
  • Clinical trials

  • Controlled clinical trials

  • Non-randomized or randomized clinical trials

  • Articles published in the English language

  • Articles that do not include clinical trials, controlled clinical trials, or non-randomized or randomized clinical trials

  • Student dissertations or theses

  • Conference abstracts or articles

  • Methodology, protocol, or technical note papers

  • Reviews (narrative, systematic, scoping, or meta-analysis)

  • Editorials, commentaries, or opinion pieces

  • Case reports or case series

  • Articles without full texts

  • Articles not published in the English language