Table 1.
List of included studies. The data of each randomized controlled trial is represented in the columns. NSCLC = Non-small cell lung cancer, ZA = Zoledronic Acid, SR-89 = Strontium-89, SC = Subcutaneous, IV = Intravenous, MBq = Megabecquerel.
| Authors | Year | Primary cancer | Time of treatment compared to the main therapy | Treatment | Population size for treatment (n) | Comparator | Population size for comparator (n) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Barrett-Lee, P[33] | 2014 | Breast cancer | During | ZA- 4 mg/ 4 weeks | 699 | Ibandronic acid- 50 mg daily | 705 |
| Broom, R. J [34] | 2015 | Renal cell carcinoma | Before | Everolimus and ZA - 4 mg/ 4 weeks | 15 | Everolimus- 10 mg daily | 15 |
| Choudhury, K. B [31] | 2011 | NSCLC + others | During | ZA − 4 mg/ 4 weeks | 60 | 1. Ibandronate- 6 mg/ 4 weeks 2. Pamidronate- 90 mg/ 4 weeks |
1. 65 2. 62 |
| Cleeland, C. S [76] | 2013 | Breast cancer | Before | ZA − 4mg/ 4 weeks + SC placebo | 1020 | Denosumab- 120 mg/ 4 weeks + IV placebo | 1026 |
| Fizazi, K [35] | 2011 | Prostate cancer | After | ZA − 4 mg/ 4 weeks + SC placebo | 951 | Denosumab- 120 mg/ 4 weeks + IV placebo | 950 |
| Francini, F [36] | 2011 | NSCLC | During | ZA − 4mg/ 4 weeks | 28 | Ibandronic acid- 50 mg/day | 27 |
| Henry, D [37] | 2014 | NSCLC | Before | ZA - 4 mg/ 4 weeks + SC placebo | 797 | Denosumab SC- 120 mg/ 4 weeks with placebo IV | 800 |
| Hilton, J. F [38] | 2018 | Breast cancer | After | ZA − 4 mg/ 4 weeks | 38 | Pamidronate | 35 |
| Jacobs, C [39] | 2016 | Breast cancer | During | ZA − 4 mg/ 4 weeks | 35 | Pamidronate | 38 |
| James, N [40] | 2016 | Prostate cancer | Before | Docetaxel, ZA − 4 mg/ 4 weeks | 188 | 1. Docetaxel- 75 mg/m2/ 3 weeks, 2. Docetaxel and ZA 3. Docetaxel + Sr-89. |
1. 191 2. 188 3. 190 |
| Kamba, T [41] | 2016 | Prostate cancer | Before | ZA − 4 mg/ 4 weeks with combined androgen blockade | 115 | 80 mg of bicalutamide orally once a day and subcutaneous luteinizing hormone–releasing hormone agonist every 4 or 12 weeks | 112 |
| Kohno, N [42] | 2005 | Breast cancer | During | ZA − 4 mg/ 4 weeks | 114 | Placebo | 114 |
| Martin, M [43] | 2012 | Breast cancer | Before | ZA − 4 mg/ 4 weeks + SC placebo | 1020 | Denosumab- 120 mg/ 4 weeks + IV placebo | 1026 |
| Murakami, H [44] | 2014 | NSCLC | After | ZA − 4 mg/ 4 weeks with Docetaxel | 50 | Docetaxel- 60 mg/m2 | 50 |
| Pan, Y [45] | 2014 | Prostate cancer | After | Docetaxel-based chemotherapy + ZA - 4 mg/ 3 weeks | 53 | Docetaxel-based chemotherapy- 75 mg/m2 of docetaxel for 21 days and placebo | 52 |
| Pandya, K. J [56] | 2010 | NSCLC | After | Docetaxel, Carboplatin and ZA − 4 mg/ 4 weeks | 64 | Docetaxel- 75 mg/m2 for 1 h and carboplatin- IV for 15 min | 64 |
| Price, N [32] | 1999 | NSCLC + others | Before | ZA - A. 4 mg / 3 weeks B. 8 mg/ 3 weeks; reduced to 4 mg/ 3 weeks |
A. 254 B. 265 |
Placebo | 247 |
| Rosen, L. S [46] | 2003 | Multiple myeloma and breast cancer | During | ZA - A. 4 mg/ 4 weeks B. 8 mg/ 4 weeks; later switched to 4 mg/ 4 weeks |
A. 564 B. 526 |
Pamidronate- 90 mg/ 3 or 4 weeks | 558 |
| Rosen, L. S [47] | 2004 | NSCLC + others | During | ZA - A. 4 mg/ 4 weeks B. 8 mg/ 4 weeks; later switched to 4 mg/ 4 weeks |
A. 257 B. 266 |
Placebo | 250 |
| Saad, F [48] | 2002 | Prostate cancer | During | ZA - A. 4 mg / 4 weeks B. 8 mg/ 4 weeks;later switched to 4 mg/ 4 weeks |
A. 214 B. 221 |
Placebo | 208 |
| Smith, M. R [50] | 2014 | Prostate cancer | Before | ZA − 4 mg/ 4 weeks | 323 | Placebo | 322 |
| Smith, M. R. [49] | 2015 | Prostate cancer | After | ZA − 4 mg/ 4 weeks | 951 | Denosumab- 120 mg/ 4 weeks | 950 |
| Stopeck, A.T [51] | 2010 | Breast cancer | During | ZA − 4 mg/ 4 weeks + SC placebo | 1020 | Denosumab- 120 mg/ 4 weeks + IV placebo | 1026 |
| Ueno, S [52] | 2013 | Prostate cancer | Before | ZA − 4 mg/ 4 weeks with combined androgen blockade | 29 | Combined androgen blockade − 80 mg/ day | 31 |
| Wang, F [53] | 2013 | Prostate cancer | Before | ZA − 4 mg/ 4 weeks | 69 | Clodronate- 1600 mg / day | 68 |
| Wang, Y [55] | 2013 | NSCLC | Before | Sr-89, 0.9 % sodium chloride and ZA − 4 mg/ 4 weeks | 45 | 1. ZA − 4 mg every 3/4 weeks 2. Sr-89–150 MBq of Sr-89 every 6 months 3. Chemotherapy |
1. 45 2. 45 3. 45 |
| Zaghloul, MS [54] | 2010 | Bladder cancer | After | ZA − 4 mg/ 4 weeks | 20 | Placebo | 20 |