Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2023 Jul 1.
Published in final edited form as: Mol Psychiatry. 2022 Oct 17;28(1):298–328. doi: 10.1038/s41380-022-01819-w

Table 5.

Assessment of reported exercise variables of frequency, intensity, time, and type (FITT) in a manner that would permit intervention replication and determination if intervention met public health physical activity guidelines.44

Trial Exercise Study Arm(s) Frequency Intensity Time Type Total FITT Criteria Reported Meet Current PA Guidelines (AEx|REx)
Randomized controlled trials of exercise as a monotherapy (Table 1)
Doyne et al., 198738 AEx 3
REx 2
Singh et al., 199720 PREx 4
Blumenthal et al., 199950 AEx 4
Dunn et al., 200521 AEx PHD-3d 2
AEx PHD-5d 2
AEx LD-3d 2
AEx LD-5d 2
Singh et al., 200522 HI-PREx 4
LO-REx 4
Blumenthal et al., 200723 AEx 4
Krogh et al., 201251 AEx 4
Randomized controlled trials of exercise as an adjunct to psychotherapy for major depression (Table 2)
Jacquart et al., 201452 Psych-Walk 2
Oertel-Knochel et al., 201453 AEx 4
Kerling et al., 201554 AEx 4
Randomized controlled trials of exercise as an adjunct to pharmacotherapy for major depression (exercise combined with pharmacotherapy as a treatment arm or all subjects on stable dose of pharmacotherapy) (Table 3)
Blumenthal et al., 199950 AEx 4
Pilu et al., 200755 PA 2
Mota-Pereira al., 201156 AEx 4
Danielsson et al., 201457 PA 3
Belvederi Murri et al., 201558 P-AEx 4
NP-AEx 4
Carneiro et al., 201559 AEx 3
Legrand & Neff, 201660 AEx 4
Salehi et al., 201661 AEx 4
Siqueira et al., 201662 AEx 2
Gujral et al., 201963 AEx 4
Moraes et al., 202064 PREx 4
NP-AEx 4
Randomized controlled trials of exercise as an adjunct to standard care for major depression (Table 4)
Martinsen et al., 198565 AEx 3
Veale et al., 199266
Study 1
AEx 2
Veale et al., 199266
Study 2
AEx 2
Knubben et al., 200767 AEx 4
Krogh et al., 200968 P-AEx 4
PREx 4
Doose et al., 201569 AEx 4
Hallgren et al., 201570 Ex 2
Schuch et al., 201571 AEx 2
Helgadóttir et al., 201672 Ex-Light 3
Ex-Mod 3
Ex-Vig 3
Olson et al., 201773 AEx 4
Buschert et al., 201974 AEx 2
Chau et al., 202075 Ex AEx 3-AEx
2-REx
AEx
REx REx
Haussleiter et al., 202076 Ex 2
La Rocque et al., 202177 AEx 2
Clinical trials examining the relationship of molecular mechanisms and clinical outcomes (Table 6)
Krogh et al., 2010161 P-AEx 4
PREx 4
Toups et al., 2011162 AEx 0
Krogh et al., 2012;51 AEx 4
Rethorst et al., 2013155 AEx 1
Krogh et al. 2014152 AEx 0
Krogh et al., 2014163 AEx 4
Schuch et al., 2014164 AEx 2
Salehi et al., 201661 AEx 4
Carniero et al., 2017117 AEx 3
Euteneuer et al., 2017153 Ex 2
Kerling et al., 2017165 AEx 3
Lavebratt et al., 2017154 Ex-Vig 3
Ex-Mod 3
Ex-Light 3
Rahman et al., 2017166 Ex 2
Gourgouvelis et al., 2018167 Ex
(AEx + REx)
4 AEx
REx
Szuhany & Otto, 2020138 Ex 1
Gerber et al., 2020168 Ex 4

PA = physical activity; AEx = aerobic exercise; REx = resistance exercise; PREx = progressive resistance exercise; PHD = public health dose; 3d = 3 days/week; 5d = 5days/week; HI = high intensity; LO = low intensity; Psych = psychotherapy; P-AEx = progressive aerobic exercise; NP-AEx = non-progressive aerobic exercise; Ex = exercise; Ex-Vig = exercise-vigorous intensity; Ex-Mod = exercise-moderate intensity; Ex-Light = exercise-light intensity

Assessment of FITT variables

Inline graphic / Inline graphic = sufficient/insufficient detail provided in manuscript to replicate the frequency (e.g. times per week), intensity (e.g., % heart rate reserve (AEx); % repetition maximum (REx), time (e.g., time spent exercising; time in target intensity zone), type (e.g. stationary cycling).

Assessment of intervention compliance with public health physical activity guidelines

Inline graphic = intervention required at least 150 minutes of moderate intensity AEx, or 75 minutes of vigorous intensity AEx, per week; and/or intervention required at least two days of REx (utilizing most muscle groups) per week.

Inline graphic = insufficient detail provided to determine total time and intensity; prescribed or reported time and intensity were below recommended thresholds.