Table 10.

Case library details

Number	Date	Case	Outcome	Place	Hospital rank
C1	2019.12.24	Civil Aviation General Hospital Patient’s family suspected physician of repeatedly refusing examination and treatment results. The patient’s son was dissatisfied and killed the physician using a knife.	Physician died	Beijing	Tertiary hospital
C2	2019.12.29	Chang’an Hospital The nurse prevented a man who took their child to the emergency department to see a doctor from queue jumping. During skin testing, the child cried and the parents beat the nurse as they believe the nurse was acting in retaliation.	Nurse sustained injuries	Xian City, Shanxi Province	Tertiary hospital
C3	2020.1.1	Peking University People’s Hospital Patient’s family was dissatisfied that they were prevented from jumping in line and claimed to cut the physician.	No casualties	Beijing	Tertiary hospital
C4	2020.1.1	Second Hospital of Shanxi Medical University The emergency attendant was stabbed by a drunken patient’s companion.	Nurse sustained injuries	Taiyuan City, Shanxi Province	Tertiary hospital
C5	2020.1.10	Sichuan Provincial People’s Hospital Patient was anxious to leave the hospital while her medical insurance was not reviewed and did not meet the discharge conditions. The patient believed that the physician deliberately created difficulties and neglected them. As a result, her husband attacked the physician.	Physician sustained injuries	Chengdu City, Sichuan Province	Tertiary hospital
C6	2020.1.16	Zhangqiu District Maternal and Child Health Hospital Patient’s parents were dissatisfied with the routine withdrawal of infusion pillows and decided to insult and beat the nurse.	Nurse sustained injuries	Jinan City, Shandong Province	Tertiary hospital
C7	2020.1.17	Hejiang People’s Hospital Patient’s family threatened to kill the physician if they failed to resuscitate the patient. The patient, who had massive myocardial infarction, died and the patient’s husband, sister and son, beat the physicians.	Three physicians sustained injuries	Luzhou City, Sichuan Province	Tertiary hospital
C8	2020.1.19	Jingmen No.1 People’s Hospital Patient’s family questioned the physician’s treatment process after the patient died in a car accident. Subsequently, they beat the physician and forced them to kneel.	Physician sustained injuries	Jingmen City, Hubei Province	Tertiary hospital
C9	2020.1.20	Beijing Chao Yang Hospital Patient resented their physician and took revenge using a knife as their eye examination results did not meet their expectations.	Two physicians sustained injuries	Beijing	Tertiary hospital
C10	2020.1.29	Wuhan Fourth Hospital Patient’s family clashed with the hospital due to transfer. The patient died during the night and, as a result, the patient’s son-in-law was sad and beat the medical staff.	Nurse and physician sustained injuries	Wuhan City, Hubei Province	Tertiary hospital
C11	2020.2.1	Xinyu People’s Hospital Patient’s son believed that the physician did not diagnose and treat the patient in time and repeatedly accused the physician for no reason. This caused disturbance to normal order in the hospital.	No casualties	Xinyu City, Jiangxi Province	Tertiary hospital
C12	2020.2.6	Caoyankou Health Center The physician reminded the patient’s son who came to visit the patient after drinking to wear a mask and stopped them from smoking in the oxygen treatment ward. The patient’s son became dissatisfied and beat the physicians.	Two physicians sustained injuries	Yancheng City, Jiangsu Province	First-level hospital
C13	2020.3.2	Shangdu County People’s Hospital Drunken patients repeatedly molested and beat the female healthcare workers when receiving medical treatment.	Medical worker sustained injuries	Wulanchabu City, Neimenggu Province	Secondary hospital
C14	2020.3.7	Shengjing Hospital of China Medical University During the patient’s rescue from a traffic accident, the patient’s husband argued with the physician and beat them due to nursing problems.	Physician sustained injuries	Shenyang City, Liaoning Province	Tertiary hospital
C15	2020.3.27	Hanchuan People’s Hospital Two COVID-19 rehabilitation patients disputed with a physician and injured them due to the long wait time.	Physician sustained injuries	Hanchuan City, Hubei Province	Tertiary hospital
C16	2020.4.1	Guangzhou Eighth People’s Hospital A foreign patient diagnosed with COVID-19 ignored the nurse’s notification about the blood test and tried to follow the nurse to forcibly leave the isolation ward. The patient was stopped by the nurse and, as a result, pushed the nurse down and bit them.	Nurse sustained injuries	Guangzhou City, Guangdong Province	Tertiary hospital
C17	2020.4.29	Peking University Third Hospital Yanqing Hospital Patient asked to be discharged after completing hospital procedures. Considering the physical condition of the pregnant woman, the physician refused stating that the patient required further observation. The patient’s husband became dissatisfied and yelled and beat the physician.	Physician sustained injuries	Beijing	Secondary hospital
C18	2020.5.25	Beijing Yanhua Hospital Patient had a dispute with the physician on duty due to the order of treatment and hurt the physician.	Physician sustained injuries	Beijing	Tertiary hospital
C19	2020.5.28	Peking University First Hospital Patient’s family was dissatisfied with the operation arrangements and injured the physician that communicated with them.	Physician sustained injuries	Beijing	Tertiary hospital
C20	2020.6.22	The First Affiliated Hospital of Zhengzhou University Patient believed that their disease was caused by the improper diagnosis and treatment by the physician and complained that the disease was not cured. The contradiction remained unsolved and the patient took revenge on the physician using a knife.	Two physicians sustained injuries	Zhengzhou City, Henan Province	Tertiary hospital