TABLE 2.
Model | Trail | SP (%) | SN (%) | ACC (%) | PRE (%) | F1 score (%) | AUC (%) | MCC (%) | Kappa (%) | Time (s) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Decision tree | NT vs. PHT | 84.44 | 70.88 | 72.83 | 72.89 | 72.85 | 72.65 | 45.22 | 45.22 | 0.23 |
NT vs. HT | 80.39 | 79.60 | 79.93 | 80.30 | 80.02 | 79.99 | 59.49 | 59.34 | 0.28 | |
(NT + PHT) vs. HT | 96.26 | 65.88 | 80.41 | 80.41 | 80.41 | 76.07 | 52.14 | 52.14 | 0.57 | |
AdaBoost | NT vs. PHT | 78.74 | 71.58 | 75.51 | 75.47 | 75.48 | 75.16 | 50.44 | 50.43 | 1.64 |
NT vs. HT | 88.22 | 75.29 | 82.75 | 82.73 | 82.64 | 81.76 | 64.44 | 64.25 | 1.59 | |
(NT + PHT) vs. HT | 92.26 | 60.39 | 83.11 | 82.56 | 82.48 | 76.33 | 56.73 | 56.06 | 2.47 | |
GBDT | NT vs. PHT | 83.62 | 77.54 | 80.88 | 80.86 | 80.86 | 80.58 | 61.32 | 61.30 | 7.24 |
NT vs. HT | 93.10 | 82.35 | 88.58 | 88.62 | 88.48 | 87.73 | 76.50 | 76.30 | 6.79 | |
(NT + PHT) vs. HT | 96.37 | 66.27 | 87.72 | 87.75 | 87.15 | 81.32 | 68.85 | 67.63 | 11.30 | |
Random forest | NT vs. PHT | 84.20 | 76.14 | 80.57 | 80.54 | 80.52 | 80.17 | 60.64 | 60.59 | 1.30 |
NT vs. HT | 93.68 | 83.14 | 89.22 | 89.30 | 89.15 | 88.41 | 77.87 | 77.67 | 1.48 | |
(NT + PHT) vs. HT | 96.84 | 61.57 | 86.71 | 86.93 | 85.90 | 79.20 | 66.15 | 64.28 | 2.49 | |
XgBoost | NT vs. PHT | 85.34 | 78.95 | 82.46 | 82.44 | 82.44 | 82.15 | 64.50 | 64.48 | 1.34 |
NT vs. HT | 93.68 | 87.84 | 91.21 | 91.21 | 91.19 | 90.76 | 81.95 | 81.91 | 1.09 | |
(NT + PHT) vs. HT | 95.73 | 74.90 | 89.75 | 89.63 | 89.50 | 85.32 | 74.26 | 73.84 | 2.02 | |
LightGBM | NT vs. PHT | 85.92 | 80.70 | 83.57 | 83.55 | 83.55 | 83.31 | 66.76 | 66.75 | 0.87 |
NT vs. HT | 94.25 | 87.84 | 91.54 | 91.55 | 91.51 | 91.05 | 82.63 | 82.57 | 0.81 | |
(NT + PHT) vs. HT | 96.27 | 74.12 | 89.98 | 89.92 | 89.68 | 85.24 | 74.80 | 74.22 | 1.13 |