Table 2.
Characteristics of the selected studies
Author, country | Methodology | Population | n | Age | Control/Intervention |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Amirnovin et al.,(8) United States |
Foresight before and after intervention | Children admitted to the pediatric cardiac ICU who received opioid infusions ≥7 days | 119 | < 21 years (mean 10 months) |
Control: weaning at medical
discretion Intervention: protocolized weaning |
Bowens et al.,(19) United States |
Prospective, double-blind, randomized | Children admitted to the pediatric ICU with ≥ 5 days of fentanyl infusion | 68 | > 28 days to < 18 years (mean 4.4 months) | Control: protocolized management of
WS in “low doses” (according to weight) of
methadone Intervention: protocolized management of WS using “high-dose” methadone (according to fentanyl infusion rate) |
Garisto et al.,(20) Italy |
Randomized clinical trial | Children admitted to the pediatric ICU with congenital heart disease | 48 | > 28 days to < 24 months (mean 5.5 months) | Control: use of opioids and
benzodiazepines alone Intervention: use of benzodiazepines and opioids with dexmedetomidine |
Hünseler et al.,(21) Germany |
Prospective, double-blind, randomized controlled trial |
Children admitted to the pediatric ICU on MV for more than 3 days and on midazolam and fentanyl | 219 | NB with GA > 37 weeks up to 2
years (mean 10 months) |
Control: patients received clonidine
infusion Intervention: patients received a placebo infusion |
Tiacharoen et al.,(22) Thailand |
Open, randomized and controlled study | Children who received intravenous sedatives or analgesics for ≥ 5 days | 30 | > 1 month and < 18 years (mean 20.76 months) | Control: weaning at medical
discretion Intervention: weaning was protocolized through risk assessment for the development of WS |
Gaillard-Le Roux et al.,(23) França |
Prospective, before and after | Children admitted to the pediatric ICU | 194 | > 28 days to < 18 years (mean 6.6 months) | Control: weaning at medical discretion |
Sanchez-Pinto et al.,(24) Estados Unidos |
Prospective pre- and post-intervention | Children admitted to the pediatric ICU who received scheduled opioids for ≥ 7 days | 107 | < 21 years (mean 26.4 months) |
Control: weaning at medical
discretion Intervention: protocolized weaning |
Geven et al.,(25) Holanda |
Retrospective observational | Children admitted to the pediatric ICU who used benzodiazepines and opioids for 48 hours continuously | 102 | < 18 years (mean 14 months) |
Observation of patients weaned on dexmedetomidine after use of benzodiazepines and opioids |
Sperotto F, et al.,(26) Italia |
Observational prospective | Patients < 18 years of age who received dexmedetomidine for a period greater than or equal to 24 hours | 163 | < 18 years (mean 13 months) |
Observation of patients before and after 24 hours of dexmedetomidine infusion |
van der Vossen et al.,(27) Holanda |
Retrospective cohort | Children admitted to the pediatric ICU | 73 | < 18 years (mean 63.3 months) |
Control: evaluation of patients
before conversion from midazolam to
lorazepam Intervention: evaluation of patients 48 hours after conversion |
Sanavia et al,(28) Espanha |
Observational prospective | Children admitted to the pediatric ICU who received continuous infusions of sedatives and analgesics for > 4 days | 100 | > 1 month to 16 years (mean 8 months) | Observation of patients using medication rotation protocol |
Berrens et al.,(29) Estados Unidos |
Retrospective study | Children admitted to the pediatric ICU | 50 | > 1 month to < 18 years (mean 24 months) | Observation of patients weaned on clonidine compared to patients weaned on dexmedetomidine alone |
ICU - intensive care unit; WS - withdrawal syndrome; NB - newborn; GA - gestational age.