Skip to main content
. 2023 Feb 23;14:1121209. doi: 10.3389/fpls.2023.1121209

Table 1.

Application of CRISPR/Cas9 technology in tomato improvement for plant architecture, flower, fruit and biotic/abiotic stress resistance-related traits.

Trait Genotype Target gene Gene ID CRISPR
(DNA repair)
Transformation Genome editing effects References
Plant architecture, flower and fruit traits
Plant architecture, lycopene, fruit weight, size, number S. pimpinellifolium SP, O,
MULT,
FAS
FW2.2, CNR,
CycB
Solyc06g074350,
Solyc02g085500,
Solyc02g077390, Solyc11g071380,
Solyc02g077920
Solyc04g040190
Cas9
(knockout)
Agrobacterium Determinate growth habit (SP), increased fruit size (FAS), shape (O), number (MULT), fruit weight (FW2.2), and very high lycopene (CycB) content Zsögön et al., 2018
Inflorescence, fruit size, weight, yield M82,
S. pimpinellifolium
WUS/LC,
CLV3/FAS
SP,
S
Solyc02g083950,Solyc11g071380,
Solyc06g074350,
Solyc02g077390
Cas9
(knockout)
Agrobacterium Meristem size regulator (LC-FAS), increased compound inflorescence, locule number, fruit weight, size, and yield Rodríguez-Leal et al., 2017
Plant growth habit, fruit S. pimpinellifolium SP,
SP5G,
CLV3,
WUS,
GGP1
Solyc06g074350,
Solyc05g053850,
Solyc11g071380,
Solyc02g083950,
Solyc02g091510
Cas9
(knockout)
Agrobacterium Determinate growth habit, compact plants, synchronous fruit ripening and enlarged fruit size Li et al., 2018d
Plant growth habit, flower M82 SP5G Solyc05g053850 Cas9
(knockout)
Agrobacterium Rapid flowering, compact determinate growth habit and early yield Soyk et al., 2017
Plant growth habit Red Setter SP,
SP5G
Solyc06g074350,
Solyc05g053850
Cas9
(Knockin/RNPs)
Protoplast (PEG) Protoplast-mediated transformation protocols Liu et al., 2022
Plant regeneration S. peruvianum SGS3,
RDR6,
PR-1,
ProSys,
Mlo1
Solyc04g025300,
Solyc04g014870,Solyc08g075820,
Solyc09g006005,
Solyc05g051750,
Solyc04g049090
Cas9
(Knockin/RNPs)
Protoplast (PEG) No chromosomal changes or unintended genome editing sites, and heritable changes Lin et al., 2022a
Plant regeneration Micro-Tom AGO7 Solyc01g010970 Cas9
(CBEs/ABEs)
Protoplast
(PEG)
Successful application of cytosine base editors (CBEs) and adenine base editors (ABEs) in rice, tomato and poplar Sretenovic et al., 2021
Plant phenotype Micro-Tom PDS,
PIF4
Solyc03g123760,
Solyc07g043580
Cas9
(knockout)
Agrobacterium High frequencies of homozygous and biallelic albino mutants Pan et al., 2016
Plant phenotype Ailsa Craig and
Micro-Tom
PDS NM_001247166 Cas9
(knockout)
Agrobacterium Albino mutants Li et al., 2018c
Plant regeneration Red Setter,
Ailsa Craig, M82, Moneymaker
SP,
SP5G
Solyc06g074350,
Solyc05g053850
Cas9
(RNPs)
Protoplast (PEG-Ca2+) Improved protoplast isolation and shoot regeneration Liu et al., 2022
Plant regeneration Solanum spp. SHR,
SCR
Solyc02g092370, Solyc10g074680 Cas9
(knockout)
A.
rhizogenes
Hairy root transformation Ron et al., 2014
Dwarf plant Moneymaker PRO Solyc11g011260 Cas9
(knockout)
Agrobacterium Gibberellins-responsive dominant dwarf mutant with loss of function and deletion in DELLA allele Tomlinson et al., 2019
Leaf shape M82 AGO7 Solyc01g010970,
Solyc07g021170,
Solyc08g041770,
Solyc12g044760
Cas9
(knockout)
Agrobacterium Change in leaf shape from compound flat to needle like leaves Brooks et al., 2014
Leaf shape Micro-Tom DELLA,
ETR1
Solyc11g011260,
Solyc12g011330
Cas9
(base editing, Target-AID)
Agrobacterium Reduced serrated leaflets and insensitivity to ethylene Shimatani et al., 2017
Male sterility Micro-Tom Ms1035 ,
GSTAA
Solyc02g079810,
Solyc02g081340
Cas9
(knockout)
Agrobacterium Male-sterile line with a green hypocotyl or trichome density Liu et al., 2021a
Male sterility KS-13 MS10 Solyc02g079810 Cas9
(knockout)
Agrobacterium Male sterile line Jung et al., 2020
Male sterility Alisa Craig RBOH, RBOHE Solyc01g099620, Solyc07g042460 Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Male sterile line Dai et al., 2022
Male sterility Ailsa Craig AMS QDO73362.1 Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Non-viable pollens Bao et al., 2022
Male sterility Ailsa Craig CMT4 Solyc08g005400 Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Suppressed pollen tube growth Guo et al., 2022
Jointless fruit M82 J2 Solyc12g038510, Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Jointless inflorescence, large sepals Roldan et al., 2017
Leaf, flower, fruit shape M82 BOP1/2/3
(TMF)
Solyc04g040220,
Solyc10g079460,
Solyc10g079750
Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Defects in fruit shape and altered leaf Xu et al., 2016
Fruit size, locule number S. pimpinellifolium ENO Solyc03g117230 Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Increased fruit locule number, fruit size and yield Yuste-Lisbona et al., 2020
Fruit weight, number S. pimpinellifolium KLUH
(CYP78A family)
M9 SNP Cas9 (knock-out) Agrobacterium Increased fruit weight and decreased number of small fruits Li et al., 2022b
Fruit size Ailsa Craig SUN,
BZR1.7
Solyc10g079240,
Solyc10g076390
Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Elongated fruit shape Yu et al., 2022
Fruit size S. lycopersicum, S. pimpinellifolium TRM3/4/5,
OFP
Solyc07g008670, Solyc10g076180 Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Slightly flatter fruit Wu et al., 2018
Fruit ripening Micro-Tom MIR164A
(targets: NAM2, NAM3)
Solyc03g115850, Solyc06g069710 Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Accelerated fruit ripening Lin et al., 2022b
Fruit ripening Ailsa Craig RIN Solyc05g012020 Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Partial ripening and moderate red pigmentation Ito et al., 2015; Ito et al., 2017; Ito et al., 2020
Fruit ripening Ailsa Craig NOR,
CNR
Solyc10g006880
Solyc02g077920
Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Delayed ripening by 2-3 days Gao et al., 2019
Fruit ripening Moneyberg, Ailsa Craig AP2a,
NAC-NOR, FUL1,
FUL2
Solyc03g044300,
Solyc10g006880,
Solyc06g069430, Solyc03g114830
Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Early fruit ripening but not fully ripen Wang et al., 2019a
Fruit ripening Ailsa Craig PL,
PG2a, TBG4
Solyc03g111690,
Solyc10g080210, Solyc12g008840,
Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Influenced fruit firmness, weight and color Wang et al., 2019a
Fruit ripening Ailsa Craig NAM1 Solyc06g060230 Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Regulates fruit ripening Gao et al., 2021
Fruit ripening Moneyberg,
Ailsa Craig
FUL1,
FUL2
Solyc06g069430, Solyc03g114830 Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Independent/overlapping functions in fruit ripening Wang et al., 2019a
Fruit ripening Micro-Tom ORRM4 - Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Involved in RNA editing of transcripts Yang et al., 2017
Parthenocarpy Micro-Tom, Ailsa Craig IAA9 Solyc04g076850 Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Leaf shape changes and parthenocarpic Ueta et al., 2017
Parthenocarpy MP-1 AGL6 Solyc01g093960 Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Parthenocarpic fruit and heat stress tolerance Klap et al., 2017
Fruit flavor F6 (RILs) FLORAL4 Solyc04g063350 Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Increased phenylalanine volatile Tikunov et al., 2020
Lycopene lncRNA1459 KT963310,
KT963311
Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Reduced ethylene and lycopene Li et al., 2018a
Lycopene Ailsa Craig SGR1, LCY-E,
Blc,
LCY-B1, LCY-B2
DQ100158,
EU533951,
XM_010313794,
EF650013,
AF254793
Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Increased lycopene Li et al., 2018b
Lycopene S. pimpinellifolium CycB Solyc04g040190 Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium High lycopene content Zsögön et al., 2018
Carotenoid, chlorophyll, B. cinerea Moneymaker,
San Marzano
GF Solyc08g080090 Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium high carotenoids, chlorophylls and Botrytis cinerea resistance Gianoglio et al., 2022
Yellow fruit Red Setter Psy1,
CrtR-b2
Solyc03g031860,
Solyc03g007960
Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Yellow flesh color fruit D’Ambrosio et al., 2018
Carotenoid Periyakulam 1 (PKM1) CRTISO AF416727 Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Complete knockout of protein function Jayaraj et al., 2021
Pink fruit Inbred lines MYB12 Solyc01g079620 Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Pink color fruit Deng et al., 2018
Orange and yellow fruit Micro-Tom CRISTO,
PSY1
- Cas9 (knockin/geminiviral replicon) Agrobacterium High editing efficiency Dahan-Meir et al., 2018
Yellow fruit M82, S. pimpinellifolium PSY1 Solyc03g031860 Cas9
(knockin)
Agrobacterium Yellow fruit Hayut et al., 2017
Carotenoid, lycopene Micro-Tom DDB1, DET1,
CYC-B
Solyc02g021650,
Solyc01g056340,
Solyc06g074240
Cas9
(Target-AID base editing)
Agrobacterium Increased carotenoid, lycopene, and β-carotene content Hunziker et al. (2020)
Anthocyanin Micro-Tom ANT1 Solyc10g086260 Cas9 (Geminivirus replicon) Agrobacterium High anthocyanin content Cˇermák et al., 2015; Vu et al., 2020b
Anthocyanin Indigo Rose AN2,
ANT1, ANT1-
like,
R2R3-MYB TF AN2-like/Anthocyanin fruit (Aft)
Solyc10g086250, Solyc10g086260, Solyc10g086270,
Solyc10g086290
Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Decreased anthocyanin content Yan et al., 2020; Zhi et al., 2020
Anthocyanin Indigo Rose HY5 Solyc08g061130 Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Decreased anthocyanin Qiu et al., 2019
GABA Micro-Tom GAD2,
GAD3
B1Q3F1
FB1Q3F2
Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Increased GABA content Nonaka et al., 2017
GABA Ailsa Craig and
Micro-Tom
GABA-TP1, GABA-TP2,
GABA-TP3, CAT9,
SSADH
AY240229,
AY240230, AY240231,
XM_004248503,
NM_001246912
Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Increased GABA content Li et al., 2018c
Total soluble solid (TSS) M82 INVINH1,
VPE5
Solyc12g099200, Solyc12g095910 Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Increased glucose, fructose, and TSS contents Wang et al., 2021a
Sugar Suzukoma INVINH1 Solyc12g099200 Cas9 (knockout,
Target-AID base editing)
Agrobacterium High sugar content Kawaguchi et al., 2021
Vitamin D Moneymaker 7-DR2 Solyc06g074090 Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Increased 7-dehydrocholesterol (7-DHC) level Li et al., 2022a
Ascorbate Micro-Tom APX4 Solyc06g005150 Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Increased ascorbate content Do et al., 2022
Malate S. lycopersicum, S. pimpinellifolium, S.l. var cerasiforme TFM6,
ALMT
Solyc06g072910, Solyc06g072920 Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Reduced malate content Ye et al., 2017
Shelf-life M82 ALC FJ404469 Cas9 (knockin) Agrobacterium Extended shelf-life Yu et al., 2017
Fruit softening Micro-Tom PG solyc10g080210 Cas9 (knockout) A. rhizogenes Delayed fruit softening Nie et al., 2022
Biotic stress resistance
TYLCV Moneymaker CP, Rep
(virus gene)
- Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Resistance Tashkandi et al., 2018
TYLCV Moneymaker rgsCaM promoter - Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Efficiency of an inducible promoter Faal et al., 2020
TYLCV, Powdery mildew BN-86 Pelo,
Mlo1
Solyc04g009810,
Solyc04g049090
Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium High resistance Pramanik et al., 2021
ToMV Ailsa Craig DCL2b Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Resistance Wang et al., 2018
Bacterial speck (Pseudomonas syringae) Moneymaker JAZ2 Solyc12g009220 Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Resistance Ortigosa et al., 2019
Late blight (Phytophthora infestans) Alisa Craig MYBS2 Solyc04g008870 Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium High resistance Liu et al., 2021b
Powdery mildew (Oidium sp.) Moneymaker Mlo1 Solyc04g049090 Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Resistance Nekrasov et al., 2017
Powdery mildew Moneymaker PMR4 Solyc07g053980 Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Reduced resistance Martínez et al., 2020
Downy mildew FL8000 DMR6-1, DMR6-2 Solyc03g080190,
Solyc06g073080
Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium High resistance Thomazella et al., 2021
Multiple diseases FL8000 DMR6-1 Solyc03g080190 Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Disease resistance to P. syringae, P. capsici, and Xanthomonas spp. Thomazella et al., 2016
Fusarium wilt 76R, rmc - Solyc08g075770 Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Resistance Prihatna et al., 2018
Gray mold
(Botrytis cinerea)
Micro-Tom, Ailsa Craig MYC2, MAPK3 - Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Decreased disease resistance to B. cinerea Zhang et al., 2018; Shu et al., 2020
PVY, CMV Inbred line S8 eIF4E1
(host gene)
Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium PVY and CMV resistant mutants Atarashi et al., 2020
Abiotic stress tolerance
Multiple stresses Rubion GRXS14/15/16/17 Solyc02g082200, Solyc06g067960,
Solyc09g005620, Solyc02g078360
Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Increased tolerance to heat, chilling, drought, heavy metal toxicity and nutrient deficiency Kakeshpour et al., 2021
Drought Ailsa Craig NPR1 KX198701 Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Reduced drought tolerance Li et al., 2019
Drought Condine Red ALD1,
FMO1
Solyc11g044840,
Solyc07g04243
Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Increased drought tolerance Wang et al., 2021b
Drought Micro-Tom LBD40 Solyc02g085910 Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Increased drought tolerance Liu et al., 2020a
Drought Ailsa Craig MAPK3 AY261514 Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Reduced drought tolerance Wang et al., 2017
Heat Condine Red BZR1 Solyc04g079980 Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Reduced heat tolerance Yin et al., 2018
Heat Condine Red CPK28,
APX2
Solyc02g083850, Solyc06g005150 Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Improved thermotolerance Hu et al., 2021
Heat MP-1 AGL6 Solyc01g093960 Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Seedless fruit under heat stress Klap et al., 2017
Cold Ailsa Craig CBF1 AAS77820 Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Reduced chilling tolerance Li et al., 2018e
Salinity S. lycopersicum, S. pimpinellifolium HAK20, SOS1 Solyc04g008450, Solyc11g044540 Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Increased salt sensitivity Wang et al., 2020; Wang et al., 2021c
Salinity Hongkwang HKT1;2
RAD51/54
Solyc07g017540,
Solyc04g056400
Cas12a/
LbCpf1
(Geminivirus replicon)
Agrobacterium Increased salt tolerance Vu et al., 2020b
Salinity Hongkwang HyPRP1 Solyc12g009650 Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Increased salt tolerance Tran et al., 2021
C-N metabolism Micro-Tom SBPase Solyc05g052600 Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Optimal growth, carbon assimilation and nitrogen metabolism Ding et al., 2018
Phosphate transporter Micro-Tom PHO1;1,
PHO1;2,
PHO1;3,
PHO1;4, PHO1;5,
PHO1;6
Solyc09g090360
Solyc08g068240, Solyc05g010060,
Solyc05g013180, Solyc02g088220, Solyc02g088230
Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium High anthocyanin and phosphate content Zhao et al., 2019
Herbicide resistance WVA106 ALS Solyc03g044330 Cas9
(base editing)
Agrobacterium Resistance (Chlorsulfuron) Veillet et al., 2019
Herbicide resistance Micro-Tom PDS,
ALS,
EPSPS
Solyc03g123760,
Solyc06g059880, Solyc03g044330,
Solyc01g091190
Cas9 (knockout) Agrobacterium Resistance Yang et al., 2022
Herbicide resistance ALS1,
ALS2,
ALS3
Solyc03g044330,
Solyc07g061940, Solyc06g059880
Cas9 (knockin) Agrobacterium Resistance (Chlorsulfuron) Danilo et al., 2019

7-DR2 (7-Dehydrocholesterol reductase), AGL6 (Agamous-like 6), AGO7 (Argonaute7), ALC (Alcobaca), ALD1 (AGD2-like defense response protein), ALMT (Al-activated malate transporter),ALS1 (Acetolactate synthase 1), AMS (Aborted microspores), AN2 (Anthocyanin2), ANT1 (Anthocyanin 1), AP2a (Apetala2a TF), APX2/4 (Ascorbate peroxidase2/4), Blc (Beta-lycopene cyclase),BOPs (Blade-on-petiole), BZR1 (Brassinazole-resistant 1), CRTISO (Carotenoid isomerise), CAT9 (Cationic amino acid transporter 9), CBF1 (C-repeat/dehydration responsive element binding factor1), CLV3 (Clavata3), CMT4 (Chromomethylase), CNR (SBP-box colorless non-ripening), CPK28 (Calcium-dependent protein kinase28), CP (Coat protein), CrtR-b2 (Beta-carotene hydroxylase 2),CRTISO (Central role of carotenoid isomerase), CYC-B/CycB (Lycopene beta cyclase), DDB1 (DNA damage UV binding protein 1), DELLA (Aspartic acid–glutamic acid–leucine–leucine–alanine),DCL2b (Dicer-like 2b), DET1 (Deetiolated1), DMR6 (Downy mildew resistance 6), EJ2 (Enhancer-of-jointless2), ENO (Excessive number of floral organs), EPSPS (5-Enolpyruvylshikimate-3-phosphate synthase), ETR1 (Ethylene receptor 1), FASCIATED (FAS), FMO1 (Flavin-dependent monooxygenase), FUL1/2 (Fruitfull), GABA-TP1 (Pyruvate-dependent g-aminobutyric acidtransaminase 1), GAD2 (Glutamate decarboxylase 2), GAD3 (Glutamate decarboxylase 3), GF (Greenflesh/Staygreen), GGP1 (GDP-l-galactose phosphorylase1), GRXS (CGFS-type glutaredoxin),GSTAA (Glutathione S-transferase), HAK20 (High-affinity K+ 20), HKT1;2 (High-affinity potassium transporter 1;2), HY5 (elongated hypocotyl5), HyPRP1 (Hybrid proline-rich protein 1), IAA9(Auxin-induced 9), INVINH1 (Invertase inhibitor 1), J2 (Jointless-2), JAZ2 (Jasmonate zim domain), LBD40 (Lateral organ boundaries domain40), LOCULE NUMBER (LC), LCY-B1 (Lycopene bcyclase1), LCY-B2 (Lycopene b-cyclase 2), LCY-E (Lycopene e-cyclase), LIN (Long inflorescence), MAPK3 (Mitogen activated protein kinase 3), MIR164A (MicroRNA164A), TFAM1/TFAM2(Mitochondrial transcription factor A), Mlo1 (Mildew resistance locus o 1), MS10 (Male sterile 10), Ms1035 (Male sterile 1035), MULT (Multiflora), MYBS2 (MYB transcription factor S2), MYC2(Basic helix–loop–helix transcription factor), NAC (NAM-ATAF-CUC), NAM1/2/3 (No apical meristem1/2/3), NAC-NOR (NAC TF non-ripening), NOR (Non-ripening), NOR-like1 (Non-ripeninglike1), NPR1 (Nonexpressor of pathogenesis-related gene 1), O (ovate), ORRM4 (organelle RNA recognition motif-containing protein4), PDS (Phytoene desaturase), OFP (OVATE family protein),PG (Polygalacturonase), PG2a (polygalacturonase 2a), PHO1 (Phosphate 1), PIF4 (Phytochrome interacting factor 4), PL (pectate lyase), PMR4 (Powdery mildew resistance 4), PR-1 (Pathogenesisrelatedprotein-1), PRO (Procera), ProSys (Prosystemin), PSY1 (Phytoene synthase 1), RAD51/54 (DNA repair and recombination protein51/54), RBOH/RBOHE (Respiratory burst oxidasehomolog), RDR6 (RNA ald1dependent RNA polymerase 6), REP (Replicase), RIN (Ripening inhibitor), RMC (Reduced mycorrhizal colonization), SBPase (Sedoheptulose-1,7-bisphosphatase), S(Compound inflorescence), SCR (Scarecrow), SHR (Shortroot), SGR1 (Stay-green 1), SGS3 (Suppressor of gene silencing 3), SOS1 (Salt overly sensitive 1), SP (Self pruning), SP5G (Self pruning 5G),SSADH (Succinate semialdehyde dehydrogenase), Target-AID (Target activation-induced cytidine deaminase), TBG4 (b-galactanase), TFM6 (Tomato fruit malate on chromosome6), TMF(Terminating flower), ToMV (Tomato Mosaic virus), TRM3/4/5 (TONNEAU1 Recruiting Motif3/4/5), VPE5 (Vacuolar processing enzyme5), and WUS (Wuschel).RNPs (ribonucleoproteins), PEG (polyethylene glycol), Target-AID (Target Activation Induced Cytidine Deaminase), NHEJ (Homologous-End-Joining), KO (gene knock-out), KI (gene knock-in), HDR (homology-directed repair), HR (homologous recombination), HKI (HR-based KI).