Table A2.
Selection | Comparability | Outcome | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Lead Author (Year) | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | Total |
Costa (2004) 10 | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | 8 |
Lerer (2004) 35 | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | 8 |
Choi (2010) 5 | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | 8 |
Lee (2011) 33 | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | 8 |
Park (2012) 45 | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | 8 |
Ohishi (2014) 42 | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | 9 |
MacFarlane (2017) 37 | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | 8 |
Goto (2019) 18 | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | 8 |
Liu (2020) 36 | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | 9 |
Kim (2020) 25 | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | 8 |
Hisashi (2022) 21 | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | 9 |
Yoon (2022) 51 | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | 8 |
Bin (2016) 3 | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | 9 |
Kim (2019) 29 | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | 8 |
Kim (2019) 28 | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | 9 |
Ding (2007) 14 | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | 9 |
Crema (2010) 11 | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | 8 |
Emmanuel (2016) 15 | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | 9 |
Teichtahl (2017) 48 | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | 9 |
Özdemir (2019) 43 | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | 8 |
Jeon (2021) 22 | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | 9 |
Kim (2020) 26 | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | ◊ | 8 |
a One diamond indicates 1 point. A maximum of 2 diamonds can be awarded for the “Selection” and “Outcome” categories (columns 1-4 and 6-8). A maximum of 2 diamonds can be awarded for “Comparability” (column 5). Newcastle-Ottawa Scale items: 1 = representativeness of exposed cohort; 2 = selection of nonexposed cohort; 3 = ascertainment of exposure; 4 = demonstration that outcome of interest was not present at start of study; 5 = comparability of cohorts based on basis of design or analysis; 6 = assessment of outcomes; 7 = follow-up long enough for outcomes to occur; 8 = adequacy of follow-up of cohorts.