Skip to main content
. 2023 Jan 26;7(3):414–423. doi: 10.1038/s41559-022-01975-w

Fig. 2. Conceptual overview of evolutionary responses to ancestral plasticity.

Fig. 2

When an ancestral population reaches a novel environment, an immediate PC moves the trait from an initial value of Lo in the old environment to Lp in the new environment. As populations adapt over time, a further EC shifts Lp to a new value of La. a, The evolutionary response to ancestral plasticity can be divided into three categories depending on the values of PC and EC. be, Cartoon representations of scenarios. Dashed line represents transition from ancestral to novel environment and associated trait shift, PC. b, Reinforcement occurs when the subsequent EC is in the same direction as PC. c, Overshooting occurs when PC has moved the trait value closer to the new optimum (that is, La is closer to Lp than Lo). In this scenario, EC is in the opposite direction to PC, but |EC| < 0.5 × |PC|. d,e, Reversion occurs when the optimum in the new habitat is nearer to the value of the unstressed ancestor in its home environment than the ancestor’s response (that is, La is closer to Lo than Lp), so EC is in the opposite direction to PC, but |EC| < 0.5 × |PC|. Reversion can include the restoration of the ancestral state in the old environment (|EC| = |PC|) (e) or move beyond this value in the opposite direction (|EC| >|PC|) (d). Reinforcement and overshooting suggest that ancestral plasticity was adaptive, whereas reversion indicates it was maladaptive.