Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2023 Nov 1.
Published in final edited form as: Med Image Anal. 2022 Sep 14;82:102615. doi: 10.1016/j.media.2022.102615

Table 3:

Quantitative evaluation results of the inter-patient (i.e., the JHU dataset) and the atlas-to-patient (i.e., the IXI dataset) brain MRI registration. Dice score and percentage of voxels with a non-positive Jacobian determinant (i.e., folded voxels) are evaluated for different methods. The bolded numbers denote the highest scores, while the italicized ones indicate the second highest.

Inter-patient MRI Atlas-to-patient MRI
Model DSC % of Jϕ0 DSC % of Jϕ0
Affine 0.572±0.166 - 0.386±0.195 -
SyN 0.729±0.127 <0.0001 0.645±0.152 <0.0001
NiftyReg 0.723±0.131 0.061±0.093 0.645±0.167 0.020±0.046
LDDMM 0.716±0.131 <0.0001 0.680±0.135 <0.0001
deedsBCV 0.719±0.130 0.253±0.110 0.733±0.126 0.147±0.050
VoxelMorph-1 0.718±0.134 0.426±0.231 0.729±0.129 1.590±0.339
VoxelMorph-2 0.723±0.132 0.389±0.222 0.732±0.123 1.522±0.336
VoxelMorph-diff 0.715±0.137 <0.0001 0.580±0.165 <0.0001
CycleMorph 0.719±0.134 0.231±0.168 0.737±0.123 1.719±0.382
MIDIR 0.710±0.132 <0.0001 0.742±0.128 <0.0001
ViT-V-Net 0.729±0.128 0.402±0.249 0.734±0.124 1.609±0.319
PVT 0.729±0.130 0.427±0.254 0.727±0.128 1.858±0.314
CoTr 0.725±0.131 0.415±0.258 0.735±0.135 1.292±0.342
nnFormer 0.729±0.128 0.399±0.234 0.747±0.135 1.595±0.358
TransMorph-Bayes 0.744±0.125 0.389±0.241 0.753±0.123 1.560±0.333
TransMorph-diff 0.730±0.129 <0.0001 0.594±0.163 <0.0001
TransMorph-bspl 0.740±0.123 <0.0001 0.761±0.122 <0.0001
TransMorph 0.745±0.125 0.396±0.240 0.754±0.124 1.579±0.328