AnimaliaORDOFAMILIADerkarabetianShahanStarrettJamesTsurusakiNobuoUbickDarrellCastilloStephanieHedinMarshalA stable phylogenomic classification of Travunioidea (Arachnida, Opiliones, Laniatores) based on sequence capture of ultraconserved elementsZookeys2852018201876013610.3897/zookeys.760.24937 CLADONYCHIIDAE Hadži, 1935Type genus.

Erebomaster Briggs, 1969.

Type species.

Erebomaster flavescens Cope, 1872.

Diagnosis.

Some taxa have not been examined for the relevant characters, but tentative diagnostic characters may be found in the intestinal complex (Suppl. material 2: Figure 2). All Cladonychiidae that have been examined show a 2–3 branched, elongate, and triangular D1, and elongate OD3. In the Pacific Northwest of North America, cladonychiids are broadly sympatric with the Cryptomastridae and Paranonychidae. The above intestinal characteristics differentiate them from Cryptomastridae, which possess a relatively short and stout OD3, and the Paranonychidae, which possess a simple unbranched D1 (Suppl. material 2: Figure 2). The European taxa can be diagnosed from Travuniidae based on male genital morphology (Figure 7): travuniids have a widened and flattened glans with lateral wing-like extensions; the glans and shaft are undivided in Travunia and Dinaria. The penis musculature is restricted to the base in Holoscotolemon and Peltonychia, while the musculature of Trojanella is restricted to the apical portion of the shaft and glans.

Representative penis morphology of Travunioidea. Clockwise from left: Trojanella serbica redrawn from Karaman (2005), Travunia hofferi redrawn from Karaman (2005), Cryptomaster behemoth adapted from Starrett et al. (2016), Holoscotolemon jaqueti redrawn from Martens (1978), Briggsus hamatus, Yuria pulcra, Paranonychus brunneus, Metanonychus setulus navarrus, Nippononychus japonicus redrawn from Suzuki (1975), Kaolinonychus coreanus coreanus redrawn from Suzuki (1975), Izunonychus ohruii, Zuma acuta. All Travuniidae and Cladonychiidae are drawn in ventral view; Cryptomastridae, Yuria, and Paranonychidae drawn in lateral. For simplicity, not all travunioid genera are included.

Included genera and species.

Erebomaster (Figure 1B). Erebomaster is found in the eastern United States, and currently includes three species: E. flavescens Cope, 1872 with two subspecies E. f. flavescens from Wyandotte Cave in Indiana and E. f. coecus (Packard, 1888) from Carter Cave in Kentucky; E. weyerensis (Packard, 1888) from caves in West Virginia; and the relatively widespread E. acanthinus (Crosby & Bishop, 1924) with a distribution along and west of the Appalachian Mountains. A revision of Erebomaster taxa is needed.

Theromaster (Figure 1A). Consisting of two described species found in the eastern United States: T. brunneus (Banks, 1902) is relatively widespread in the southern Appalachian Mountains; T. archeri (Goodnight & Goodnight, 1942) from caves in Alabama.

Speleonychia (Figure 1I). A monotypic genus, Speleonychia sengeri Briggs, 1974 is a highly troglomorphic species restricted to lava tubes near Mt. Adams, in south-central Washington.

Briggsus (Figure 1G). The genus and all species were originally described by Briggs (1971b) as Pentanychus; Özdikmen and Demir (2008) provided the replacement name. This genus consists of five described species all restricted to the moist coastal forests (>50 inches yearly rainfall) of Oregon and Washington in the Pacific Northwest: B. bilobatus (Briggs, 1971), B. clavatus (Briggs, 1971), B. flavescens (Briggs, 1971), B. hamatus (Briggs, 1971), and B. pacificus (Briggs, 1971).

Isolachus (Figure 1H). A monotypic genus, Isolachus spinosus Briggs, 1971 is restricted to northwest Oregon and southwest Washington.

Holoscotolemon (Figure 1D). A European genus with eight species. Six species are restricted to the Alps, primarily from Italy and Austria: H. unicolor Roewer, 1915; H. lessiniensis Martens, 1978; H. oreophilus Martens, 1978; H. franzinii Tedeschi & Sciaky, 1994; H. monzinii Tedeschi & Sciaky, 1994; and H. naturae Tedeschi & Sciaky, 1994. H. querilhaci (Lucas, 1864) is found in the Pyrenees of southern France and H. jaqueti (Corti, 1905) is recorded from eastern Europe in Romania, Ukraine, and former Yugoslavia.

Peltonychia (Figure 1E). A genus with a long history, Peltonychia includes the first described travunioid species, P. leprieurii. This genus of eight species is almost entirely known only from caves in central Europe throughout the Pyrenees and Alps (Suppl. material 2: Figure 3). Peltonychia leprieurii is found in the Alps of northern Italy. Peltonychia clavigera, P. navarica (Simon, 1879), P. piochardi (Simon, 1872), and P. sarea (Roewer, 1935) are all found in the Pyrenees of northern Spain and southern France. P. gabria Roewer, 1935 is recorded from Trieste, Italy; P. postumicola (Roewer, 1935) is recorded from eastern Italy and western Slovenia; and P. tenuis Roewer, 1935 is recorded from northern Slovenia. Records from Trieste, Italy and Slovenia are conclusively shown to be in error, and P. postumicola and P. tenuis are morphologically similar to P. clavigera (Novak and Gruber 2000). As such, it is unclear how many actual species are included.

Arbasus. A monotypic genus, the highly troglomorphic Arbasus caecus (Simon, 1911) is only known from Grotte de Pène Blanque in the Pyrenees of southern France.

Buemarinoa. A monotypic genus, the highly troglomorphic Buemarinoa patrizii Roewer, 1956 is only known from the Grotte del Bue Marino in Sardinia, Italy.

Proholoscotolemon Ubick & Dunlop, 2005. A monotypic genus, P. nemastomoides (Koch & Berendt, 1854) is known from specimens preserved in Baltic amber. The specimens were redescribed by Ubick and Dunlop (2005) and based on morphological similarity and geography it is interpreted as the ancestor of, or sister group to, Holoscotolemon.

Remarks.

Peltonychia is polyphyletic, in some cases with strong support (Figure 5). The sampled species are from two separate geographic regions: P. clavigera from the Pyrenees of northern Spain and southern France, and P. leprieurii from the Alps of northern Italy. Accounting for the locality errors in Italy and Slovenia mentioned above, Peltonychia is geographically split into two regions: P. leprieurii in northern Italy, and the remaining species in the Pyrenees. The male genitalia of four species of Peltonychia have been examined: P. leprieurii, P. clavigera, P. gabria, and P. postumicola. Based on these genitalic drawings (Chemini 1985, Martens 1978, Thaler 1996), it is obvious that P. leprieurii is very divergent from the other three Peltonychia, which are very similar (Suppl. material 2: Figure 3). This concordance between geography, genital morphology, and our phylogenomic analyses support the separation of Peltonychia into two genera. However, we refrain from formally making this taxonomic change until all relevant species can be studied.

The sister relationship of Speleonychia to the traditional Briggsinae (Briggsus + Isolachus) is not surprising given the close geographic proximity of these genera and shared presence of a free ninth tergite and lateral sclerites. The distinct generic status of Arbasus and Buemarinoa has been doubted (Kury and Mendes 2007). The morphological distinction between Arbasus and Buemarinoa is minimal and entirely based on tarsal segmentation (Kury and Mendes 2007), which is typical of the “Roewerian classification” system that resulted in taxa being over split based on irrelevant characters (e.g., Kury et al. 2014, Kury and Pérez-González 2015). Aside from the original descriptions with basic drawings (Roewer 1935, 1956), virtually no taxonomic work has been conducted on Arbasus and Buemarinoa. However, Kury and Mendes (2007) note that they “both look superficially like Hadziani [=Peltonychia], but with clear troglomorphic traits…”, and their inclusion in Cladonychiidae here seems justified.

Figures

Data type: molecular data

Explanation note:

Figure 1. Outgroup relationships for the 70% dataset. Nodes are fully supported (e.g., 100 bootstrap, 1.0 posterior probability, etc.) unless otherwise indicated. RAxML tree manually rooted according to BEAST topology. Asterisk in ASTRAL tree indicates node not given support values by default.

Figure 2. Representative midgut morphology. Only the right half of the midgut is illustrated. Drawings for Triaenonychoidea (Synthetonychia), Grassatores (Discocyrtus), Cladonychiidae, and Paranonychidae redrawn from Dumitrescu (1975, 1976). Abbreviations: D1 = diverticulum 1; OD2 = opisthosomal diverticula 2; OD3 = opisthosomal diverticula 3.

Figure 3. Representative genital morphology and distribution of Peltonychia in Europe. Records from Slovenia and Trieste, Italy (red) are in error. Genitalia from left to right: P. clavigera, redrawn from Thaler (1996); P. leprieurii, redrawn from Chemini (1985); P. gabria, redrawn from Martens (1978).

Figure 4. SEM penis morphology of Yuria and Paranonychidae. Scale bars 500 mm.

This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.Shahan Derkarabetian, James Starrett, Nobuo Tsurusaki, Darrell Ubick, Stephanie Castillo Marshal Hedin

Geographic distribution of travunioid genera. Colors correspond to classification proposed in this study. Abbreviations: wNA = western North America, eNA = eastern North America, EUR = central and southern Europe, JPN/KOR = Japan and South Korea.

Photographs of live travunioid harvestmen. A Theromaster brunneus B Erebomaster sp. C Cryptomaster leviathan D Holoscotolemon lessiniense E Peltonychia leprieurii F Trojanella serbica G Briggsus sp. H Isolachus spinosus I Speleonychia sengeri J Yuria pulcra K Paranonychus brunneus L Sclerobunus nondimorphicus M Metanippononychus sp. N Zuma acuta O Kainonychus akamai. All photos by MH, except D, E (courtesy of and copyright A. Schönhofer), and F (courtesy of and copyright I. Karaman).

Phylogenetic relationships among major laniatorean lineages. Lower phylogenies correspond to results presented in this study. Nodes are fully supported (100% bootstrap or 1.0 posterior probability), unless indicated otherwise. Numbers in lower left phylogeny correspond to support values from 50% RAxML concatenated (top), and from 70% RAxML partitioned (bottom) analyses. Numbers in ASTRAL phylogeny based on 50% (top) and 70% (bottom) matrices.

Phylogenomic relationships among travunioid genera. Left: 70% SVDQuartets. Right: 70% ASTRAL. Nodes are fully supported (100% bootstrap), unless indicated.

DumitrescuDO (1975) Contribution a l’étude morphologique de l’appareil digestif (intestin moyen) des opilions. Proceedings of the 6th International Arachnology Congress, Amsterdam IV, April 1974. Vrije Universiteit at Amsterdam, 150–155. DumitrescuDO (1976) Recherches morphologiques sur l’appareil digestif (intestin moyen) des Gonyleptomorphi (Arachnida, Opilionida). Travaux du Muséum d’Histoire naturelle (Grigore Antipa) 17: 1730. ThalerK (1996) Neue Funde europäischer Krallenweberknechte. Berichte des naturwissenschaftlichen-medizinischen Verein Innsbruck 83: 135148. CheminiC (1985) Descrizione del maschio di Peltonychia leprieuri (Lucas) e ridescrizione di Mitostoma orobicum (Caporiacco) (Arachnida, Opiliones). Bollettino della Societá Entomologica Italiana 117: 7275. MartensJ (1978) Spinnentiere, Arachnida: Weberknechte, Opiliones. VEB Gustav Fischer Verlag, 464 pp. KaramanIM (2005) Trojanella serbica gen. n., sp. n., a remarkable new troglobitic travunioid (Opiliones, Laniatores, Travunioidea). Revue Suisse de Zoologie 112: 439456.https://doi.org/10.5962/bhl.part.80308 StarrettJDerkarabetianSRichartCHCabreroAHedinM (2016) A new monster from southwest Oregon forests: Cryptomaster behemoth sp. n. (Opiliones, Laniatores, Travunioidea). ZooKeys 555: 1135. https://doi.org/10.3897/zookeys.555.6274 BriggsTS (1971b) The harvestmen of family Triaenonychidae in North America (Opiliones). Occasional Papers of the California Academy of Sciences 90: 143. ÖzdikmenHDemirH (2008) New family and genus names, Briggsidae nom. nov. and Briggsus nom nov., for the harvestmen (Opiliones: Laniatores). Munis Entomology and Zoology 3: 174176. NovakTGruberJ (2000) Remarks on published data on harvestmen (Arachnida: Opiliones) from Slovenia. Annales, (Koper) Series Historia Naturalis 10: 281308. UbickDDunlopJA (2005) On the placement of the Baltic amber harvestman Gonyleptes nemastomoides Koch & Berendt, 1854, with notes on the phylogeny of Cladonychiidae (Opiliones, Laniatores, Travunioidea). Mitteilungen aus dem Museum für Naturkunde zu Berlin, Geowissenschaftliche Reihe 8: 7582. https://doi.org/10.1002/mmng.200410005 KuryABMendesAC (2007) Taxonomic status of the European genera of Travuniidae (Arachnida, Opiliones, Laniatores). Munis Entomology & Zoology 2: 114. KuryABMendesACSouzaDR (2014) World Checklist of Opiliones species (Arachnida). Part 1: LaniatoresTravunioidea and Triaenonychoidea. Biodiversity Data Journal 2: e4094. https://doi.org/10.3897/BDJ.2.e4094 KuryABPérez-GonzálezA (2015) A companion to Part 2 of the World Checklist of Opiliones species (Arachnida): LaniatoresSamooidea, Zalmoxoidea and Grassatores incertae sedis. Biodiversity Data Journal 3: e6663. https://doi.org/10.3897/BDJ.3.e6663 RoewerCF (1935) Opiliones. Fünfte Serie, zugleich eine Revision aller bisher bekannten europäischen Laniatores. Biospeologica. LXII. Archives de Zoologie Expérimentale et Générale, Paris 78: 196. RoewerCF (1956) Cavernicole Arachniden aus Sardinien II. Fragmenta Entomologica, Roma 2: 97104.