"AuthorDate","ID","treatname","treatID","N","time_wk","y","se","arm","narm","fupcount","fups"
"Gottesdiener 2002",1,"Placebo_0",1,60,0,7.062,0.222167472781301,1,6,1,5
"Gottesdiener 2002",1,"Etoricoxib_10",6,114,0,7.009,0.1605567531753,2,6,1,5
"Gottesdiener 2002",1,"Etoricoxib_30",7,102,0,6.756,0.169607033648865,3,6,1,5
"Gottesdiener 2002",1,"Etoricoxib_5",8,117,0,6.873,0.158410421316763,4,6,1,5
"Gottesdiener 2002",1,"Etoricoxib_60",9,112,0,6.686,0.161931979323571,5,6,1,5
"Gottesdiener 2002",1,"Etoricoxib_90",10,112,0,6.854,0.162028154956109,6,6,1,5
"Gottesdiener 2002",1,"Placebo_0",1,60,1,6.362,0.226717523759405,1,6,2,5
"Gottesdiener 2002",1,"Etoricoxib_10",6,114,1,5.599,0.162767074119291,2,6,2,5
"Gottesdiener 2002",1,"Etoricoxib_30",7,102,1,4.796,0.172270518519949,3,6,2,5
"Gottesdiener 2002",1,"Etoricoxib_5",8,117,1,5.823,0.160828660967787,4,6,2,5
"Gottesdiener 2002",1,"Etoricoxib_60",9,112,1,3.866,0.164339086026525,5,6,2,5
"Gottesdiener 2002",1,"Etoricoxib_90",10,112,1,4.134,0.164376932023332,6,6,2,5
"Gottesdiener 2002",1,"Placebo_0",1,60,2,6.262,0.232474372929781,1,6,3,5
"Gottesdiener 2002",1,"Etoricoxib_10",6,114,2,5.079,0.164771390022759,2,6,3,5
"Gottesdiener 2002",1,"Etoricoxib_30",7,102,2,4.416,0.174320535120769,3,6,3,5
"Gottesdiener 2002",1,"Etoricoxib_5",8,117,2,5.343,0.162608767361743,4,6,3,5
"Gottesdiener 2002",1,"Etoricoxib_60",9,112,2,3.616,0.166505665716349,5,6,3,5
"Gottesdiener 2002",1,"Etoricoxib_90",10,112,2,4.084,0.166374887669048,6,6,3,5
"Gottesdiener 2002",1,"Placebo_0",1,60,4,6.052,0.240122584965984,1,6,4,5
"Gottesdiener 2002",1,"Etoricoxib_10",6,114,4,5.239,0.168918785347991,2,6,4,5
"Gottesdiener 2002",1,"Etoricoxib_30",7,102,4,4.476,0.17798345293024,3,6,4,5
"Gottesdiener 2002",1,"Etoricoxib_5",8,117,4,5.203,0.166205767069358,4,6,4,5
"Gottesdiener 2002",1,"Etoricoxib_60",9,112,4,3.576,0.170279614848335,5,6,4,5
"Gottesdiener 2002",1,"Etoricoxib_90",10,112,4,3.914,0.169729693768737,6,6,4,5
"Gottesdiener 2002",1,"Placebo_0",1,60,6,5.902,0.247814100493077,1,6,5,5
"Gottesdiener 2002",1,"Etoricoxib_10",6,114,6,5.219,0.171993884900998,2,6,5,5
"Gottesdiener 2002",1,"Etoricoxib_30",7,102,6,4.106,0.182096300280985,3,6,5,5
"Gottesdiener 2002",1,"Etoricoxib_5",8,117,6,4.823,0.169299768558779,4,6,5,5
"Gottesdiener 2002",1,"Etoricoxib_60",9,112,6,3.406,0.173435172041771,5,6,5,5
"Gottesdiener 2002",1,"Etoricoxib_90",10,112,6,3.794,0.172886156021761,6,6,5,5
"Schnitzer 2005_2",2,"Placebo_0",1,104,0,6.6,0.165718134191766,1,6,1,5
"Schnitzer 2005_2",2,"Naproxcinod_1500",15,114,0,6.7,0.156409830534143,2,6,1,5
"Schnitzer 2005_2",2,"Naproxcinod_250",16,104,0,6.7,0.183368586354202,3,6,1,5
"Schnitzer 2005_2",2,"Naproxcinod_750",17,107,0,6.6,0.171112358561082,4,6,1,5
"Schnitzer 2005_2",2,"Naproxen_1000",18,117,0,6.5,0.159938556578274,5,6,1,5
"Schnitzer 2005_2",2,"Rofecoxib_25",22,98,0,6.5,0.169705627484771,6,6,1,5
"Schnitzer 2005_2",2,"Placebo_0",1,104,1,4.39,0.173905249337353,1,6,2,5
"Schnitzer 2005_2",2,"Naproxcinod_1500",15,114,1,3.43,0.164173104642886,2,6,2,5
"Schnitzer 2005_2",2,"Naproxcinod_250",16,104,1,4.55,0.172272982893994,3,6,2,5
"Schnitzer 2005_2",2,"Naproxcinod_750",17,107,1,3.33,0.169973920225238,4,6,2,5
"Schnitzer 2005_2",2,"Naproxen_1000",18,117,1,3.45,0.162438044792012,5,6,2,5
"Schnitzer 2005_2",2,"Rofecoxib_25",22,98,1,3.32,0.176585616696332,6,6,2,5
"Schnitzer 2005_2",2,"Placebo_0",1,104,2,4.41,0.177686409594662,1,6,3,5
"Schnitzer 2005_2",2,"Naproxcinod_1500",15,114,2,3.18,0.166454590588981,2,6,3,5
"Schnitzer 2005_2",2,"Naproxcinod_250",16,104,2,4.17,0.174108104008,3,6,3,5
"Schnitzer 2005_2",2,"Naproxcinod_750",17,107,2,2.95,0.171603615136058,4,6,3,5
"Schnitzer 2005_2",2,"Naproxen_1000",18,117,2,3,0.16392543997828,5,6,3,5
"Schnitzer 2005_2",2,"Rofecoxib_25",22,98,2,3.16,0.179397384895119,6,6,3,5
"Schnitzer 2005_2",2,"Placebo_0",1,104,4,4.05,0.183984363849695,1,6,4,5
"Schnitzer 2005_2",2,"Naproxcinod_1500",15,114,4,2.88,0.169746595918025,2,6,4,5
"Schnitzer 2005_2",2,"Naproxcinod_250",16,104,4,4.14,0.178154032012363,3,6,4,5
"Schnitzer 2005_2",2,"Naproxcinod_750",17,107,4,2.84,0.175414646040789,4,6,4,5
"Schnitzer 2005_2",2,"Naproxen_1000",18,117,4,2.76,0.167895231894081,5,6,4,5
"Schnitzer 2005_2",2,"Rofecoxib_25",22,98,4,2.97,0.183498123208213,6,6,4,5
"Schnitzer 2005_2",2,"Placebo_0",1,104,6,3.97,0.189528491640222,1,6,5,5
"Schnitzer 2005_2",2,"Naproxcinod_1500",15,114,6,2.73,0.17321633954174,2,6,5,5
"Schnitzer 2005_2",2,"Naproxcinod_250",16,104,6,3.99,0.181314120732742,3,6,5,5
"Schnitzer 2005_2",2,"Naproxcinod_750",17,107,6,2.79,0.178985008233165,4,6,5,5
"Schnitzer 2005_2",2,"Naproxen_1000",18,117,6,2.69,0.170611283043991,5,6,5,5
"Schnitzer 2005_2",2,"Rofecoxib_25",22,98,6,2.9,0.186259350679297,6,6,5,5
"Bensen 1999",3,"Placebo_0",1,203,0,5.40562,0.127436521271067,1,5,1,3
"Bensen 1999",3,"Celebrex_100",2,203,0,5.382295,0.127028197878709,2,5,1,3
"Bensen 1999",3,"Celebrex_200",3,197,0,5.26609,0.12930812791979,3,5,1,3
"Bensen 1999",3,"Celebrex_400",4,202,0,5.40562,0.127566081980992,4,5,1,3
"Bensen 1999",3,"Naproxen_1000",18,198,0,5.54508,0.12875035948772,5,5,1,3
"Bensen 1999",3,"Placebo_0",1,203,2,5.02021,0.139670618862376,1,5,2,3
"Bensen 1999",3,"Celebrex_100",2,203,2,4.3457485,0.130300804313681,2,5,2,3
"Bensen 1999",3,"Celebrex_200",3,197,2,3.82251,0.132309240255573,3,5,2,3
"Bensen 1999",3,"Celebrex_400",4,202,2,3.9621085,0.130724495481187,4,5,2,3
"Bensen 1999",3,"Naproxen_1000",18,198,2,4.1248255,0.131930685365367,5,5,2,3
"Bensen 1999",3,"Placebo_0",1,203,12,4.7208885,0.151251348567045,1,5,3,3
"Bensen 1999",3,"Celebrex_100",2,203,12,4.325553,0.14135801055325,2,5,3,3
"Bensen 1999",3,"Celebrex_200",3,197,12,3.720855,0.143254857100138,3,5,3,3
"Bensen 1999",3,"Celebrex_400",4,202,12,3.9650325,0.141764226468071,4,5,3,3
"Bensen 1999",3,"Naproxen_1000",18,198,12,4.267348,0.143136256318841,5,5,3,3
"DeLemos 2011",4,"Placebo_0",1,200,0,6.016,0.146371103705615,1,5,1,7
"DeLemos 2011",4,"Celebrex_200",3,202,0,5.738,0.135231448097162,2,5,1,7
"DeLemos 2011",4,"Tramadol_100",23,201,0,5.968,0.142903021772952,3,5,1,7
"DeLemos 2011",4,"Tramadol_200",24,199,0,6.058,0.136246967602602,4,5,1,7
"DeLemos 2011",4,"Tramadol_300",25,199,0,6.124,0.152125906594789,5,5,1,7
"DeLemos 2011",4,"Placebo_0",1,200,1,4.660234,0.141748899128343,1,5,2,7
"DeLemos 2011",4,"Celebrex_200",3,202,1,3.746574,0.139736935110452,2,5,2,7
"DeLemos 2011",4,"Tramadol_100",23,201,1,4.701114,0.140131241044599,3,5,2,7
"DeLemos 2011",4,"Tramadol_200",24,199,1,4.3466,0.140611104231362,4,5,2,7
"DeLemos 2011",4,"Tramadol_300",25,199,1,4.332964,0.141135040486669,5,5,2,7
"DeLemos 2011",4,"Placebo_0",1,200,2,4.265908,0.144235597065886,1,5,3,7
"DeLemos 2011",4,"Celebrex_200",3,202,2,3.284066,0.141283809671255,2,5,3,7
"DeLemos 2011",4,"Tramadol_100",23,201,2,4.11591,0.141498646470756,3,5,3,7
"DeLemos 2011",4,"Tramadol_200",24,199,2,3.993182,0.142389438794714,4,5,3,7
"DeLemos 2011",4,"Tramadol_300",25,199,2,3.693184,0.142336572529141,5,5,3,7
"DeLemos 2011",4,"Placebo_0",1,200,3,3.980672,0.146623777939637,1,5,4,7
"DeLemos 2011",4,"Celebrex_200",3,202,3,2.930678,0.142552464448954,2,5,4,7
"DeLemos 2011",4,"Tramadol_100",23,201,3,3.667038,0.143014206914787,3,5,4,7
"DeLemos 2011",4,"Tramadol_200",24,199,3,3.762492,0.143902734253991,4,5,4,7
"DeLemos 2011",4,"Tramadol_300",25,199,3,3.230648,0.143835000269422,5,5,4,7
"DeLemos 2011",4,"Placebo_0",1,200,6,3.643174,0.153073317227181,1,5,5,7
"DeLemos 2011",4,"Celebrex_200",3,202,6,2.511332,0.146276500909911,2,5,5,7
"DeLemos 2011",4,"Tramadol_100",23,201,6,3.479538,0.14674325031644,3,5,5,7
"DeLemos 2011",4,"Tramadol_200",24,199,6,3.302266,0.147278546020098,4,5,5,7
"DeLemos 2011",4,"Tramadol_300",25,199,6,2.879542,0.147536659794733,5,5,5,7
"DeLemos 2011",4,"Placebo_0",1,200,9,3.29204,0.158092055404197,1,5,6,7
"DeLemos 2011",4,"Celebrex_200",3,202,9,2.55568,0.149163264958541,2,5,6,7
"DeLemos 2011",4,"Tramadol_100",23,201,9,3.605646,0.149990975160941,3,5,6,7
"DeLemos 2011",4,"Tramadol_200",24,199,9,3.223858,0.150775579152354,4,5,6,7
"DeLemos 2011",4,"Tramadol_300",25,199,9,2.828406,0.150643883208871,5,5,6,7
"DeLemos 2011",4,"Placebo_0",1,200,12,3.268146,0.162795358675804,1,5,7,7
"DeLemos 2011",4,"Celebrex_200",3,202,12,2.545424,0.152021780643981,2,5,7,7
"DeLemos 2011",4,"Tramadol_100",23,201,12,3.349994,0.152578528019132,3,5,7,7
"DeLemos 2011",4,"Tramadol_200",24,199,12,3.240874,0.15337053974826,4,5,7,7
"DeLemos 2011",4,"Tramadol_300",25,199,12,2.77724,0.153252198829557,5,5,7,7
"Gana 2006",5,"Placebo_0",1,205,0,6.118,0.132981128314528,1,5,1,7
"Gana 2006",5,"Tramadol_100",23,202,0,6.164,0.139734472383436,2,5,1,7
"Gana 2006",5,"Tramadol_200",24,201,0,6.304,0.130347869810669,3,5,1,7
"Gana 2006",5,"Tramadol_300",25,201,0,5.932,0.135849565614366,4,5,1,7
"Gana 2006",5,"Tramadol_400",26,202,0,5.96,0.131854179882457,5,5,1,7
"Gana 2006",5,"Placebo_0",1,205,1,5.278,0.133683252585521,1,5,2,7
"Gana 2006",5,"Tramadol_100",23,202,1,5.026,0.133453507215488,2,5,2,7
"Gana 2006",5,"Tramadol_200",24,201,1,5.03,0.133796054462964,3,5,2,7
"Gana 2006",5,"Tramadol_300",25,201,1,4.534,0.133811256762045,4,5,2,7
"Gana 2006",5,"Tramadol_400",26,202,1,4.678,0.13349877353724,5,5,2,7
"Gana 2006",5,"Placebo_0",1,205,2,4.846,0.136453205538565,1,5,3,7
"Gana 2006",5,"Tramadol_100",23,202,2,4.666,0.134941270162399,2,5,3,7
"Gana 2006",5,"Tramadol_200",24,201,2,4.498,0.135358771769523,3,5,3,7
"Gana 2006",5,"Tramadol_300",25,201,2,4.076,0.13543190012515,4,5,3,7
"Gana 2006",5,"Tramadol_400",26,202,2,4.23,0.135042626546916,5,5,3,7
"Gana 2006",5,"Placebo_0",1,205,3,4.746,0.1387323591767,1,5,4,7
"Gana 2006",5,"Tramadol_100",23,202,3,4.446,0.136295607243554,2,5,4,7
"Gana 2006",5,"Tramadol_200",24,201,3,4.3,0.136975460635036,3,5,4,7
"Gana 2006",5,"Tramadol_300",25,201,3,3.92,0.136606264390349,4,5,4,7
"Gana 2006",5,"Tramadol_400",26,202,3,3.898,0.136453941084421,5,5,4,7
"Gana 2006",5,"Placebo_0",1,205,6,4.576,0.145035666086665,1,5,5,7
"Gana 2006",5,"Tramadol_100",23,202,6,4.114,0.14008222551059,2,5,5,7
"Gana 2006",5,"Tramadol_200",24,201,6,4.172,0.140475978779383,3,5,5,7
"Gana 2006",5,"Tramadol_300",25,201,6,3.79,0.140325510210058,4,5,5,7
"Gana 2006",5,"Tramadol_400",26,202,6,3.7,0.139946086680131,5,5,5,7
"Gana 2006",5,"Placebo_0",1,205,9,4.604,0.149961086113941,1,5,6,7
"Gana 2006",5,"Tramadol_100",23,202,9,4.052,0.143244152576179,2,5,6,7
"Gana 2006",5,"Tramadol_200",24,201,9,4.154,0.143522373224311,3,5,6,7
"Gana 2006",5,"Tramadol_300",25,201,9,3.862,0.143786468013823,4,5,6,7
"Gana 2006",5,"Tramadol_400",26,202,9,3.708,0.14305671075246,5,5,6,7
"Gana 2006",5,"Placebo_0",1,205,12,4.634,0.154511151930352,1,5,7,7
"Gana 2006",5,"Tramadol_100",23,202,12,4.02,0.145987546962185,2,5,7,7
"Gana 2006",5,"Tramadol_200",24,201,12,4.074,0.14613322817965,3,5,7,7
"Gana 2006",5,"Tramadol_300",25,201,12,3.854,0.146247785644042,4,5,7,7
"Gana 2006",5,"Tramadol_400",26,202,12,3.804,0.14586527334649,5,5,7,7
"Kivitz 2001",6,"Placebo_0",1,217,0,5.296405,0.113659846878934,1,5,1,3
"Kivitz 2001",6,"Celebrex_100",2,216,0,5.24401,0.113720824304034,2,5,1,3
"Kivitz 2001",6,"Celebrex_200",3,207,0,5.30389,0.115951753425319,3,5,1,3
"Kivitz 2001",6,"Celebrex_400",4,213,0,5.41617,0.114324102244155,4,5,1,3
"Kivitz 2001",6,"Naproxen_1000",18,207,0,5.266465,0.115876657990354,5,5,1,3
"Kivitz 2001",6,"Placebo_0",1,217,2,4.997006,0.124907338927592,1,5,2,3
"Kivitz 2001",6,"Celebrex_100",2,216,2,4.3982035,0.15003124674547,2,5,2,3
"Kivitz 2001",6,"Celebrex_200",3,207,2,4.046407,0.119365956069512,3,5,2,3
"Kivitz 2001",6,"Celebrex_400",4,213,2,4.1362275,0.117737600242718,4,5,2,3
"Kivitz 2001",6,"Naproxen_1000",18,207,2,3.8967065,0.0799305253885453,5,5,2,3
"Kivitz 2001",6,"Placebo_0",1,217,12,4.862275,0.144933243810005,1,5,3,3
"Kivitz 2001",6,"Celebrex_100",2,216,12,4.495509,0.15003124674547,2,5,3,3
"Kivitz 2001",6,"Celebrex_200",3,207,12,4.255988,0.130130623414418,3,5,3,3
"Kivitz 2001",6,"Celebrex_400",4,213,12,4.2485025,0.128242716832299,4,5,3,3
"Kivitz 2001",6,"Naproxen_1000",18,207,12,3.994012,0.0900087220679706,5,5,3,3
"Kivitz 2002",7,"Placebo_0",1,205,0,5.4,0.119932279123531,1,5,1,4
"Kivitz 2002",7,"Naproxen_1000",18,204,0,5.35,0.120117429145081,2,5,1,4
"Kivitz 2002",7,"Valdecoxib_10",27,205,0,5.5,0.119881673205454,3,5,1,4
"Kivitz 2002",7,"Valdecoxib_20",28,201,0,5.35,0.120957158568864,4,5,1,4
"Kivitz 2002",7,"Valdecoxib_5",29,201,0,5.4,0.121072910617065,5,5,1,4
"Kivitz 2002",7,"Placebo_0",1,205,2,4.45,0.125343482935942,1,5,2,4
"Kivitz 2002",7,"Naproxen_1000",18,204,2,3.95,0.123083831351647,2,5,2,4
"Kivitz 2002",7,"Valdecoxib_10",27,205,2,3.95,0.123028622306505,3,5,2,4
"Kivitz 2002",7,"Valdecoxib_20",28,201,2,3.9,0.124569266652862,4,5,2,4
"Kivitz 2002",7,"Valdecoxib_5",29,201,2,4.1,0.124079559093496,5,5,2,4
"Kivitz 2002",7,"Placebo_0",1,205,6,4.2,0.133972713197904,1,5,3,4
"Kivitz 2002",7,"Naproxen_1000",18,204,6,3.8,0.128401844540531,2,5,3,4
"Kivitz 2002",7,"Valdecoxib_10",27,205,6,3.95,0.127922571751738,3,5,3,4
"Kivitz 2002",7,"Valdecoxib_20",28,201,6,3.7,0.129300716665195,4,5,3,4
"Kivitz 2002",7,"Valdecoxib_5",29,201,6,3.85,0.129459328277433,5,5,3,4
"Kivitz 2002",7,"Placebo_0",1,205,12,4.15,0.143643070233946,1,5,4,4
"Kivitz 2002",7,"Naproxen_1000",18,204,12,3.7,0.134276510026265,2,5,4,4
"Kivitz 2002",7,"Valdecoxib_10",27,205,12,3.95,0.133783171855759,3,5,4,4
"Kivitz 2002",7,"Valdecoxib_20",28,201,12,3.7,0.135165361983946,4,5,4,4
"Kivitz 2002",7,"Valdecoxib_5",29,201,12,3.8,0.135437718052169,5,5,4,4
"Fishman 2007",8,"Placebo_0",1,224,0,6.014,0.118663991409116,1,4,1,2
"Fishman 2007",8,"Tramadol_100",23,103,0,5.756,0.155287894238693,2,4,1,2
"Fishman 2007",8,"Tramadol_200",24,107,0,5.676,0.157964742310061,3,4,1,2
"Fishman 2007",8,"Tramadol_300",25,105,0,6.288,0.189519794166605,4,4,1,2
"Fishman 2007",8,"Placebo_0",1,224,12,4.071478,0.138160273363673,1,4,2,2
"Fishman 2007",8,"Tramadol_100",23,103,12,3.361504,0.190214172399667,2,4,2,2
"Fishman 2007",8,"Tramadol_200",24,107,12,3.246672,0.187480088910286,3,4,2,2
"Fishman 2007",8,"Tramadol_300",25,105,12,3.39552,0.188484146949439,4,4,2,2
"Fleischmann 2005",9,"Placebo_0",1,231,0,4.95,0.108562029668362,1,4,1,3
"Fleischmann 2005",9,"Celebrex_200",3,444,0,5.15,0.0792546926453337,2,4,1,3
"Fleischmann 2005",9,"Lumiracoxib_200",12,462,0,5.15,0.0753692210422761,3,4,1,3
"Fleischmann 2005",9,"Lumiracoxib_400",13,463,0,4.95,0.0785409606854893,4,4,1,3
"Fleischmann 2005",9,"Placebo_0",1,231,2,4.15,0.114492079602666,1,4,2,3
"Fleischmann 2005",9,"Celebrex_200",3,444,2,3.7,0.0810675138160701,2,4,2,3
"Fleischmann 2005",9,"Lumiracoxib_200",12,462,2,3.6,0.0796960366210982,3,4,2,3
"Fleischmann 2005",9,"Lumiracoxib_400",13,463,2,3.4,0.0795272556148059,4,4,2,3
"Fleischmann 2005",9,"Placebo_0",1,231,13,3.8,0.132922760558577,1,4,3,3
"Fleischmann 2005",9,"Celebrex_200",3,444,13,3.4,0.0889745978131693,2,4,3,3
"Fleischmann 2005",9,"Lumiracoxib_200",12,462,13,3.3,0.0872649876966427,3,4,3,3
"Fleischmann 2005",9,"Lumiracoxib_400",13,463,13,3.1,0.087327276996685,4,4,3,3
"Lehmann 2005",10,"Placebo_0",1,424,0,4.9,0.0777028689885811,1,4,1,3
"Lehmann 2005",10,"Celebrex_200",3,420,0,5.1,0.0788039308905941,2,4,1,3
"Lehmann 2005",10,"Lumiracoxib_100",11,420,0,4.95,0.0788039308905941,3,4,1,3
"Lehmann 2005",10,"Lumiracoxib_200",12,420,0,4.95,0.0778280308176455,4,4,1,3
"Lehmann 2005",10,"Placebo_0",1,424,2,4.35,0.0823748972943162,1,4,2,3
"Lehmann 2005",10,"Celebrex_200",3,420,2,3.85,0.0811620643502406,2,4,2,3
"Lehmann 2005",10,"Lumiracoxib_100",11,420,2,3.75,0.0812425042710176,3,4,2,3
"Lehmann 2005",10,"Lumiracoxib_200",12,420,2,3.9,0.0811261208924162,4,4,2,3
"Lehmann 2005",10,"Placebo_0",1,424,13,3.65,0.095893956210767,1,4,3,3
"Lehmann 2005",10,"Celebrex_200",3,420,13,3.4,0.0892381069325707,2,4,3,3
"Lehmann 2005",10,"Lumiracoxib_100",11,420,13,3.25,0.0892313345419357,3,4,3,3
"Lehmann 2005",10,"Lumiracoxib_200",12,420,13,3.35,0.0892089570542608,4,4,3,3
"Schnitzer 2010",11,"Placebo_0",1,221,0,7.215,0.106490830017556,1,4,1,4
"Schnitzer 2010",11,"Naproxcinod_1500",15,230,0,7.316,0.098445504677991,2,4,1,4
"Schnitzer 2010",11,"Naproxcinod_750",17,240,0,7.358,0.0992774731077835,3,4,1,4
"Schnitzer 2010",11,"Naproxen_1000",18,227,0,7.101,0.114007753233527,4,4,1,4
"Schnitzer 2010",11,"Placebo_0",1,221,2,5.265,0.113196204511658,1,4,2,4
"Schnitzer 2010",11,"Naproxcinod_1500",15,230,2,4.016,0.109189954524449,2,4,2,4
"Schnitzer 2010",11,"Naproxcinod_750",17,240,2,4.628,0.106661450315243,3,4,2,4
"Schnitzer 2010",11,"Naproxen_1000",18,227,2,3.871,0.109968047212899,4,4,2,4
"Schnitzer 2010",11,"Placebo_0",1,221,6,4.945,0.121366236752763,1,4,3,4
"Schnitzer 2010",11,"Naproxcinod_1500",15,230,6,3.546,0.113745481103586,2,4,3,4
"Schnitzer 2010",11,"Naproxcinod_750",17,240,6,4.118,0.111330919569028,3,4,3,4
"Schnitzer 2010",11,"Naproxen_1000",18,227,6,3.551,0.11460991466006,4,4,3,4
"Schnitzer 2010",11,"Placebo_0",1,221,13,4.655,0.132169567708294,1,4,4,4
"Schnitzer 2010",11,"Naproxcinod_1500",15,230,13,3.596,0.119988005302951,2,4,4,4
"Schnitzer 2010",11,"Naproxcinod_750",17,240,13,3.918,0.117412856256964,3,4,4,4
"Schnitzer 2010",11,"Naproxen_1000",18,227,13,3.331,0.120449077944249,4,4,4,4
"Sheldon 2005",12,"Placebo_0",1,382,0,5.5,0.0739326317089661,1,4,1,2
"Sheldon 2005",12,"Celebrex_200",3,393,0,5.4,0.0817181901134616,2,4,1,2
"Sheldon 2005",12,"Lumiracoxib_100",11,391,0,5.4,0.0781340084320348,3,4,1,2
"Sheldon 2005",12,"Lumiracoxib_NA",14,385,0,5.4,0.0807790798428637,4,4,1,2
"Sheldon 2005",12,"Placebo_0",1,382,13,4.35,0.0985695904039275,1,4,2,2
"Sheldon 2005",12,"Celebrex_200",3,393,13,3.7,0.0898689945877109,2,4,2,2
"Sheldon 2005",12,"Lumiracoxib_100",11,391,13,3.6,0.0902264234934038,3,4,2,2
"Sheldon 2005",12,"Lumiracoxib_NA",14,385,13,3.55,0.0906582366922373,4,4,2,2
"Tannenbaum 2004",13,"Placebo_0",1,243,0,5.15,0.0962250448649376,1,4,1,3
"Tannenbaum 2004",13,"Celebrex_200",3,481,0,5.05,0.0752335241769463,2,4,1,3
"Tannenbaum 2004",13,"Lumiracoxib_200",12,487,0,5.05,0.0770343532530054,3,4,1,3
"Tannenbaum 2004",13,"Lumiracoxib_400",13,491,0,5,0.0744634575970765,4,4,1,3
"Tannenbaum 2004",13,"Placebo_0",1,243,2,4.45,0.110958769203244,1,4,2,3
"Tannenbaum 2004",13,"Celebrex_200",3,481,2,3.85,0.0772774649975577,2,4,2,3
"Tannenbaum 2004",13,"Lumiracoxib_200",12,487,2,3.75,0.0769867098714184,3,4,2,3
"Tannenbaum 2004",13,"Lumiracoxib_400",13,491,2,3.7,0.0764913036446752,4,4,2,3
"Tannenbaum 2004",13,"Placebo_0",1,243,13,3.95,0.128798151266342,1,4,3,3
"Tannenbaum 2004",13,"Celebrex_200",3,481,13,3.5,0.0848927895066419,2,4,3,3
"Tannenbaum 2004",13,"Lumiracoxib_200",12,487,13,3.45,0.0844281977333261,3,4,3,3
"Tannenbaum 2004",13,"Lumiracoxib_400",13,491,13,3.4,0.0841337073558211,4,4,3,3
"Baerwald 2010",14,"Placebo_0",1,331,0,6.548,0.0861356060430226,1,3,1,4
"Baerwald 2010",14,"Naproxcinod_1500",15,323,0,6.625,0.0900334923921203,2,3,1,4
"Baerwald 2010",14,"Naproxen_1000",18,156,0,6.399,0.127381946351947,3,3,1,4
"Baerwald 2010",14,"Placebo_0",1,331,2,5.398,0.0931736665206822,1,3,2,4
"Baerwald 2010",14,"Naproxcinod_1500",15,323,2,4.435,0.0925806940191813,2,3,2,4
"Baerwald 2010",14,"Naproxen_1000",18,156,2,4.029,0.133370857020846,3,3,2,4
"Baerwald 2010",14,"Placebo_0",1,331,6,4.968,0.0996924137062099,1,3,3,4
"Baerwald 2010",14,"Naproxcinod_1500",15,323,6,4.085,0.0964592899046187,2,3,3,4
"Baerwald 2010",14,"Naproxen_1000",18,156,6,3.719,0.138612179388742,3,3,3,4
"Baerwald 2010",14,"Placebo_0",1,331,13,4.751,0.108500341440244,1,3,4,4
"Baerwald 2010",14,"Naproxcinod_1500",15,323,13,4.044,0.101758946834314,2,3,4,4
"Baerwald 2010",14,"Naproxen_1000",18,156,13,3.968,0.146470690078306,3,3,4,4
"Bingham 2007a",15,"Placebo_0",1,127,0,6.66,0.14375175452541,1,3,1,5
"Bingham 2007a",15,"Celebrex_200",3,241,0,6.75,0.104997530103335,2,3,1,5
"Bingham 2007a",15,"Etoricoxib_30",7,231,0,6.74,0.106588174583483,3,3,1,5
"Bingham 2007a",15,"Placebo_0",1,127,2,5.9051225,0.152958121253667,1,3,2,5
"Bingham 2007a",15,"Celebrex_200",3,241,2,4.606352,0.108942597414506,2,3,2,5
"Bingham 2007a",15,"Etoricoxib_30",7,231,2,4.245301,0.111231714481553,3,3,2,5
"Bingham 2007a",15,"Placebo_0",1,127,4,5.597386,0.158787285595136,1,3,3,5
"Bingham 2007a",15,"Celebrex_200",3,241,4,4.270519,0.111338901421766,2,3,3,5
"Bingham 2007a",15,"Etoricoxib_30",7,231,4,4.021748,0.113862910757473,3,3,3,5
"Bingham 2007a",15,"Placebo_0",1,127,8,5.374769,0.168129451642036,1,3,4,5
"Bingham 2007a",15,"Celebrex_200",3,241,8,4.300451,0.115636673276891,2,3,4,5
"Bingham 2007a",15,"Etoricoxib_30",7,231,8,4.037578,0.118028623865028,3,3,4,5
"Bingham 2007a",15,"Placebo_0",1,127,12,5.124054,0.176210521735528,1,3,5,5
"Bingham 2007a",15,"Celebrex_200",3,241,12,4.274297,0.118957907835841,2,3,5,5
"Bingham 2007a",15,"Etoricoxib_30",7,231,12,3.899251,0.121569021358834,3,3,5,5
"Bingham 2007b",16,"Placebo_0",1,112,0,6.64,0.159689989846398,1,3,1,5
"Bingham 2007b",16,"Celebrex_200",3,246,0,6.73,0.119226845342844,2,3,1,5
"Bingham 2007b",16,"Etoricoxib_30",7,243,0,6.87,0.105206049052332,3,3,1,5
"Bingham 2007b",16,"Placebo_0",1,112,2,5.519577,0.171094727386572,1,3,2,5
"Bingham 2007b",16,"Celebrex_200",3,246,2,4.384345,0.113633339369385,2,3,2,5
"Bingham 2007b",16,"Etoricoxib_30",7,243,2,4.465766,0.114297876763262,3,3,2,5
"Bingham 2007b",16,"Placebo_0",1,112,4,5.097473,0.177583126503329,1,3,3,5
"Bingham 2007b",16,"Celebrex_200",3,246,4,4.137306,0.115842448684323,2,3,3,5
"Bingham 2007b",16,"Etoricoxib_30",7,243,4,4.233316,0.116724574022163,3,3,3,5
"Bingham 2007b",16,"Placebo_0",1,112,8,5.01188,0.18711207155905,1,3,4,5
"Bingham 2007b",16,"Celebrex_200",3,246,8,4.022573,0.12001322470123,2,3,4,5
"Bingham 2007b",16,"Etoricoxib_30",7,243,8,4.089368,0.120871605254306,3,3,4,5
"Bingham 2007b",16,"Placebo_0",1,112,12,4.999232,0.195695082084162,1,3,5,5
"Bingham 2007b",16,"Celebrex_200",3,246,12,3.936906,0.123545705071134,2,3,5,5
"Bingham 2007b",16,"Etoricoxib_30",7,243,12,4.091271,0.124338579470959,3,3,5,5
"Birbara 2006_1",17,"Placebo_0",1,78,0,6.85,0.192487095804581,1,3,1,4
"Birbara 2006_1",17,"Celebrex_200",3,157,0,6.83,0.135674770359496,2,3,1,4
"Birbara 2006_1",17,"Rofecoxib_12",20,160,0,7.05,0.125700536991693,3,3,1,4
"Birbara 2006_1",17,"Placebo_0",1,78,2,5.05,0.198257833264973,1,3,2,4
"Birbara 2006_1",17,"Celebrex_200",3,157,2,4.29,0.137356259406074,2,3,2,4
"Birbara 2006_1",17,"Rofecoxib_12",20,160,2,4.65,0.135815068797244,3,3,2,4
"Birbara 2006_1",17,"Placebo_0",1,78,4,4.9,0.205465351504898,1,3,3,4
"Birbara 2006_1",17,"Celebrex_200",3,157,4,4.09,0.140201330508638,2,3,3,4
"Birbara 2006_1",17,"Rofecoxib_12",20,160,4,4.36,0.139190608414837,3,3,3,4
"Birbara 2006_1",17,"Placebo_0",1,78,6,4.74,0.212107111756212,1,3,4,4
"Birbara 2006_1",17,"Celebrex_200",3,157,6,3.93,0.142851501671756,2,3,4,4
"Birbara 2006_1",17,"Rofecoxib_12",20,160,6,4.19,0.141634956164942,3,3,4,4
"Birbara 2006_2",18,"Placebo_0",1,85,0,6.87,0.190898802880417,1,3,1,4
"Birbara 2006_2",18,"Celebrex_200",3,169,0,6.68,0.133076923076923,2,3,1,4
"Birbara 2006_2",18,"Rofecoxib_12",20,159,0,6.7,0.126888253714903,3,3,1,4
"Birbara 2006_2",18,"Placebo_0",1,85,2,4.93,0.192545016775812,1,3,2,4
"Birbara 2006_2",18,"Celebrex_200",3,169,2,4.19,0.133775817128783,2,3,2,4
"Birbara 2006_2",18,"Rofecoxib_12",20,159,2,3.72,0.138379808347396,3,3,2,4
"Birbara 2006_2",18,"Placebo_0",1,85,4,4.76,0.198929258543521,1,3,3,4
"Birbara 2006_2",18,"Celebrex_200",3,169,4,3.7,0.137021045093306,2,3,3,4
"Birbara 2006_2",18,"Rofecoxib_12",20,159,4,3.72,0.141389843301123,3,3,3,4
"Birbara 2006_2",18,"Placebo_0",1,85,6,4.59,0.206275132682967,1,3,4,4
"Birbara 2006_2",18,"Celebrex_200",3,169,6,3.54,0.139556571428422,2,3,4,4
"Birbara 2006_2",18,"Rofecoxib_12",20,159,6,3.62,0.14410240094927,3,3,4,4
"Enrich 1999",19,"Placebo_0",1,72,0,6.003,0.201075217780176,1,3,1,5
"Enrich 1999",19,"Rofecoxib_125",21,74,0,5.944,0.199534064684237,2,3,1,5
"Enrich 1999",19,"Rofecoxib_25",22,73,0,6.436,0.199997368068792,3,3,1,5
"Enrich 1999",19,"Placebo_0",1,72,1,5.643,0.206850933673192,1,3,2,5
"Enrich 1999",19,"Rofecoxib_125",21,74,1,3.484,0.201589249943306,2,3,2,5
"Enrich 1999",19,"Rofecoxib_25",22,73,1,4.146,0.203560121178666,3,3,2,5
"Enrich 1999",19,"Placebo_0",1,72,2,5.273,0.209912968939132,1,3,3,5
"Enrich 1999",19,"Rofecoxib_125",21,74,2,3.014,0.203905762179728,2,3,3,5
"Enrich 1999",19,"Rofecoxib_25",22,73,2,3.646,0.205410853086949,3,3,3,5
"Enrich 1999",19,"Placebo_0",1,72,4,5.233,0.218506851514625,1,3,4,5
"Enrich 1999",19,"Rofecoxib_125",21,74,4,3.124,0.208495920219499,2,3,4,5
"Enrich 1999",19,"Rofecoxib_25",22,73,4,3.906,0.210371409166668,3,3,4,5
"Enrich 1999",19,"Placebo_0",1,72,6,5.123,0.225857664593222,1,3,5,5
"Enrich 1999",19,"Rofecoxib_125",21,74,6,2.824,0.212602079514655,2,3,5,5
"Enrich 1999",19,"Rofecoxib_25",22,73,6,3.576,0.214405330471512,3,3,5,5
"Leung 2002",20,"Placebo_0",1,56,0,6.87,0.209399183038385,1,3,1,5
"Leung 2002",20,"Etoricoxib_60",9,224,0,6.491,0.111982460361306,2,3,1,5
"Leung 2002",20,"Naproxen_1000",18,221,0,6.564,0.115228849611568,3,3,1,5
"Leung 2002",20,"Placebo_0",1,56,2,5.53,0.236276374339451,1,3,2,5
"Leung 2002",20,"Etoricoxib_60",9,224,2,4.041,0.115907107898446,2,3,2,5
"Leung 2002",20,"Naproxen_1000",18,221,2,3.974,0.116773607124078,3,3,2,5
"Leung 2002",20,"Placebo_0",1,56,4,5.4,0.245600400218157,1,3,3,5
"Leung 2002",20,"Etoricoxib_60",9,224,4,4.021,0.118577048759117,2,3,3,5
"Leung 2002",20,"Naproxen_1000",18,221,4,4.034,0.119148144514358,3,3,3,5
"Leung 2002",20,"Placebo_0",1,56,8,5.16,0.25982124158231,1,3,4,5
"Leung 2002",20,"Etoricoxib_60",9,224,8,3.901,0.122907118418672,2,3,4,5
"Leung 2002",20,"Naproxen_1000",18,221,8,4.034,0.123668692919525,3,3,4,5
"Leung 2002",20,"Placebo_0",1,56,12,5.34,0.270875386845488,1,3,5,5
"Leung 2002",20,"Etoricoxib_60",9,224,12,3.801,0.126524209664778,2,3,5,5
"Leung 2002",20,"Naproxen_1000",18,221,12,4.084,0.127151193277348,3,3,5,5
"Schnitzer 2011LUM",21,"Placebo_0",1,416,0,5.3,0.0732984055078963,1,3,1,4
"Schnitzer 2011LUM",21,"Celebrex_200",3,419,0,5.4,0.0727912633431587,2,3,1,4
"Schnitzer 2011LUM",21,"Lumiracoxib_100",11,427,0,5.4,0.0786392617555719,3,3,1,4
"Schnitzer 2011LUM",21,"Placebo_0",1,416,4,4.42,0.0835928187029689,1,3,2,4
"Schnitzer 2011LUM",21,"Celebrex_200",3,419,4,3.86,0.0806081277560427,2,3,2,4
"Schnitzer 2011LUM",21,"Lumiracoxib_100",11,427,4,3.88,0.0798147279487129,3,3,2,4
"Schnitzer 2011LUM",21,"Placebo_0",1,416,8,4.255,0.0889406791741855,1,3,3,4
"Schnitzer 2011LUM",21,"Celebrex_200",3,419,8,3.58,0.0835466451885252,2,3,3,4
"Schnitzer 2011LUM",21,"Lumiracoxib_100",11,427,8,3.585,0.0828460106405959,3,3,3,4
"Schnitzer 2011LUM",21,"Placebo_0",1,416,13,4.14,0.0940775993014026,1,3,4,4
"Schnitzer 2011LUM",21,"Celebrex_200",3,419,13,3.545,0.0867155017798435,2,3,4,4
"Schnitzer 2011LUM",21,"Lumiracoxib_100",11,427,13,3.585,0.0859106366613843,3,3,4,4
"Sowers 2005",22,"Celebrex_200",3,136,0,4.28,0.1900204323379,1,3,1,3
"Sowers 2005",22,"Naproxen_1000",18,128,0,4.8,0.190034947443885,2,3,1,3
"Sowers 2005",22,"Rofecoxib_25",22,132,0,4.85,0.190005761475644,3,3,1,3
"Sowers 2005",22,"Celebrex_200",3,136,6,2.97,0.1900204323379,1,3,2,3
"Sowers 2005",22,"Naproxen_1000",18,128,6,3.48,0.210010714012405,2,3,2,3
"Sowers 2005",22,"Rofecoxib_25",22,132,6,3.36,0.200015226693097,3,3,2,3
"Sowers 2005",22,"Celebrex_200",3,136,12,2.78,0.199967350276165,1,3,3,3
"Sowers 2005",22,"Naproxen_1000",18,128,12,3.34,0.239974363865185,2,3,3,3
"Sowers 2005",22,"Rofecoxib_25",22,132,12,3.18,0.220034157128002,3,3,3,3
"Williams 2001",23,"Placebo_0",1,243,0,5.3,0.100074046659535,1,3,1,2
"Williams 2001",23,"Celebrex_200",3,241,0,5.05,0.150088493951394,2,3,1,2
"Williams 2001",23,"Celebrex_200",3,231,0,5.05,0.150012986450827,3,3,1,2
"Williams 2001",23,"Placebo_0",1,243,6,4.4,0.100074046659535,1,3,2,2
"Williams 2001",23,"Celebrex_200",3,241,6,3.75,0.100166355405329,2,3,2,2
"Williams 2001",23,"Celebrex_200",3,231,6,3.6,0.100008657633885,3,3,2,2
"Chappell 2009",24,"Placebo_0",1,127,0,5.175,0.118018415752343,1,2,1,2
"Chappell 2009",24,"Duloxetine_90",5,123,0,5.12,0.111356199881428,2,2,1,2
"Chappell 2009",24,"Placebo_0",1,127,13,3.43,0.162550688630295,1,2,2,2
"Chappell 2009",24,"Duloxetine_90",5,123,13,2.985,0.151958763306692,2,2,2,2
"Chappell 2011",25,"Placebo_0",1,117,0,5.475,0.138675049056307,1,2,1,2
"Chappell 2011",25,"Duloxetine_90",5,107,0,5.49,0.160961625426103,2,2,1,2
"Chappell 2011",25,"Placebo_0",1,117,13,3.88,0.185271435006692,1,2,2,2
"Chappell 2011",25,"Duloxetine_90",5,107,13,3.18,0.179373643962556,2,2,2,2
"Clegg 2006",26,"Placebo_0",1,313,0,4.742,0.0838806393713225,1,2,1,2
"Clegg 2006",26,"Celebrex_200",3,318,0,4.698,0.0833307420980778,2,2,1,2
"Clegg 2006",26,"Placebo_0",1,313,24,3.02,0.127855799365183,1,2,2,2
"Clegg 2006",26,"Celebrex_200",3,318,24,2.714,0.121463248576337,2,2,2,2
"Markenson 2005",27,"Placebo_0",1,51,0,6.13,0.310022010603801,1,2,1,6
"Markenson 2005",27,"Oxycodone_44",19,56,0,6.31,0.279956150903265,2,2,1,6
"Markenson 2005",27,"Placebo_0",1,51,2.142,5.83,0.310022010603801,1,2,2,6
"Markenson 2005",27,"Oxycodone_44",19,56,2.142,4.83,0.279956150903265,2,2,2,6
"Markenson 2005",27,"Placebo_0",1,51,4.286,5.72,0.310022010603801,1,2,3,6
"Markenson 2005",27,"Oxycodone_44",19,56,4.286,5.02,0.279956150903265,2,2,3,6
"Markenson 2005",27,"Placebo_0",1,51,6.429,5.94,0.310022010603801,1,2,4,6
"Markenson 2005",27,"Oxycodone_44",19,56,6.429,4.76,0.279956150903265,2,2,4,6
"Markenson 2005",27,"Placebo_0",1,51,8.571,5.98,0.310022010603801,1,2,5,6
"Markenson 2005",27,"Oxycodone_44",19,56,8.571,4.72,0.279956150903265,2,2,5,6
"Markenson 2005",27,"Placebo_0",1,51,12.857,5.98,0.310022010603801,1,2,6,6
"Markenson 2005",27,"Oxycodone_44",19,56,12.857,4.94,0.279956150903265,2,2,6,6
"McKenna 2001",28,"Placebo_0",1,200,0,5.35,0.11667261889578,1,2,1,2
"McKenna 2001",28,"Celebrex_200",3,199,0,5.3,0.109876586776292,2,2,1,2
"McKenna 2001",28,"Placebo_0",1,200,6,5.35,0.128686843116638,1,2,2,2
"McKenna 2001",28,"Celebrex_200",3,199,6,5.3,0.123023321732128,2,2,2,2
"Puopolo 2007",29,"Placebo_0",1,109,0,6.466,0.163564910535422,1,2,1,5
"Puopolo 2007",29,"Etoricoxib_30",7,220,0,6.646,0.115445391312524,2,2,1,5
"Puopolo 2007",29,"Placebo_0",1,109,2,5.236,0.171484521732101,1,2,2,5
"Puopolo 2007",29,"Etoricoxib_30",7,220,2,4.416,0.118603370164155,2,2,2,5
"Puopolo 2007",29,"Placebo_0",1,109,4,5.186,0.177717655588923,1,2,3,5
"Puopolo 2007",29,"Etoricoxib_30",7,220,4,4.146,0.121234575544023,2,2,3,5
"Puopolo 2007",29,"Placebo_0",1,109,8,4.686,0.188790594905793,1,2,4,5
"Puopolo 2007",29,"Etoricoxib_30",7,220,8,3.646,0.1254400811252,2,2,4,5
"Puopolo 2007",29,"Placebo_0",1,109,12,4.716,0.195836847627648,1,2,5,5
"Puopolo 2007",29,"Etoricoxib_30",7,220,12,3.656,0.129056989143773,2,2,5,5
"Sawitzke 2010",30,"Placebo_0",1,131,0,4.79,0.149540872116525,1,2,1,5
"Sawitzke 2010",30,"Celebrex_200",3,142,0,4.66,0.144297903797015,2,2,1,5
"Sawitzke 2010",30,"Placebo_0",1,130,4,3.42,0.163286159962584,1,2,2,5
"Sawitzke 2010",30,"Celebrex_200",3,141,4,3.08,0.151705644595748,2,2,2,5
"Sawitzke 2010",30,"Placebo_0",1,120,8,3.08,0.179193145583724,1,2,3,5
"Sawitzke 2010",30,"Celebrex_200",3,136,8,2.63,0.159824179405772,2,2,3,5
"Sawitzke 2010",30,"Placebo_0",1,115,16,2.79,0.198648139658077,1,2,4,5
"Sawitzke 2010",30,"Celebrex_200",3,129,16,2.6,0.172770953719005,2,2,4,5
"Sawitzke 2010",30,"Placebo_0",1,115,24,2.7,0.209212154117014,1,2,5,5
"Sawitzke 2010",30,"Celebrex_200",3,123,24,2.14,0.182975879244213,2,2,5,5