Methods | Allocation: randomised, sealed envelopes, stratified by previous contacts with psychiatric services. Blindness: double; blinding tested +3 = no blinding, −3 = perfect blinding: mean 1.95. N=87. Follow up: 3 months. Analysis: ITT. |
|
Participants | Diagnosis: schizophrenia (38), mood disorders (32), neurotic (25), other (5). Personality disordered 50 (ICD-10), 35 (PAS)**. History: 51% previous psychiatric contact. N=100*. Age: median 32. Sex: 40 M, 60 F. Setting: inner city. |
|
Interventions | 1. Community focused multidisciplinary team, open referral, in-home assessments, collaboration maintained with already involved agencies, clinical decisions by team consensus. N=48 2. Standard hospital treatment : usually outpatient clinic assessments with occasional home visits. N=52 |
|
Outcomes | Death. Leaving study early. Satisfaction with care (Satisfaction with Service Questionnaire, displayed as not very satisfied with care). Hospital admission. Duration of hospital care. Team utilisation (mean visits). Social functioning/networks (Network Schedule, SFQ). Police contacts. Unable to use - Psychiatric symptoms: BAS, MADRAS (no SD). |
|
Notes | *Randomisation at point of referral to psychiatric emergency services (A&E presentations, urgent GP or social work referrals), not currently in contact with psychiatric services Additional diagnosis of personality disorder made & data presented on this subgroup. 2 ’natural cause’ deaths subtracted from original number randomised. **Data relating to those with personality disorder presented in separate comparison |
|
Risk of bias | ||
Item | Authors’ judgement | Description |
Allocation concealment? | Yes | A - Adequate |