Methods | Allocation: randomised, sealed envelopes. Blindness: single (researchers). Follow up: 12 months. |
|
Participants | Diagnosis: schizophrenia (86), bipolar affective disorder (20), depressive disorder (24), other (25) (DSM-III, ICD-10, OPCRIT). History: >1 admission in last 3 years. N=155*. Age: range 16-65 years. Setting: urban. |
|
Interventions | 1. ’Community team’: multidisciplinary community based team, treatment at home\other appropriate setting. N=82 2. Standard hospital treatment: care plans & reviews organised from hospital base. N=73 |
|
Outcomes | Death**. Hospital admission. Leaving the study early. Days in hospital. Police contacts. Unable to use - Mental state: BAS, CPRS, HADS, MADRAS (no SD). Social Function: SFQ(no SD). Global assessment: GAF (no SD). Costs of care. (no usable data). |
|
Notes | * Randomisation at point of discharge from hospital. ** 1 accidental death considered ’suspicious circumstances’ for this review. Contact reviewer = trial author. No data collected on patient satisfaction. |
|
Risk of bias | ||
Item | Authors’ judgement | Description |
Allocation concealment? | Unclear | B - Unclear |
General
F1 psychosis = Medical Subject Heading Codes.
ICD-10 = 10th revision of the International Classification of Diseases.
OPD = Out patient department.
SCL - Syndrome Check List
SCALES
Mental state
BAS = Brief Rating Scale for Anxiety.
BPRS = Brief Psychiatric Rating Scale.
CPRS = Comprehensive Psychpathological Rating Scale.
MADRAS = Montgomery and Asberg Depression Rating Scale.
OPCRIT = Operational Criterea for diagnosing Severe Mental Illness.
PEF = Psychiatric Evaluation Form.
PSE = Present State Examination (to measure clinical symptoms).
Family buden
FEF = Family Evaluation Form. Functioning
GAF = Global Assessment of Functioning
HSRS = Health Sickness Rating Scale (to measure a persons functioning).
PEF = Psychiatric Evaluation Form.
SFQ = Social Functioning Questionaire.
SFS = Social Functioning Schedule.