Sensors |
Current approaches |
Future directions |
|
Mostly 2D single cameras |
Multiple 2D cameras |
|
Problems |
3D (depth) sensors |
|
Only 2D information |
Pressure mat sensors |
|
Occlusions |
Improvements |
|
|
3D information |
|
|
Less occlusions |
|
|
More information due to multi-sensory integration |
Data |
Current approaches |
Future directions |
|
Small datasets |
Collect more data |
|
Problems |
Make it publicly available |
|
Not enough data to employ deep learning methods |
Make use of home videos |
|
Not publicly available - no benchmarking possible |
Employ DL methods |
|
Incorrect or incomplete data in some cases, e.g., inaccurate outcome labelling due to lack of longitudinal studies, the inclusion of incorrect age-specificity cases, use of low-inter-rater agreement or small rater-group or lack of experienced raters in data labelling, disorders or gender misrepresentation |
Make use of transfer learning (e.g., Tan et al., 2018) |
|
|
Challenges |
|
|
Need to solve anonymisation issue (automated techniques for face detection and replacement can be applied) |
|
|
Development of methods which can cope with different light conditions, resolution, frame rate |
Body areas of interest |
Current approaches |
Future directions |
|
Mostly movement of arms, legs, head |
Hand, fingers, feet |
|
Problems |
Eye movement data |
|
Incomplete information of full-body movement |
Mimic |
|
|
Challenges |
|
|
Integration and analysis of multimodal information |
Motion tracking |
Current approaches |
Future directions |
|
Mostly in 2D space |
Full-body tracking in 3D using well-established methods in DL (e.g., DeepLabCut and OpenPose frameworks) |
|
Problems |
Challenges |
|
Only 2D information |
DL methods need to be adapted to infants |
|
|
|
Motion encoding |
Current approaches |
Future directions |
|
Conventional features based on: displacement, distance, velocity, acceleration, speed, and time |
Motion encoding using well-established methods from robotics: |
|
Problems |
Dynamic Movement Primitives (e.g., Ijspeert, Nakanishi, Hoffmann, Pastor, & Schaal, 2013), Gaussian Mixture Models (e.g., Calinon, 2016; Khansari Zadeh & Billard, 2011), Probabilistic Movement Primitives (Paraschos, Daniel, Peters, & Neumann, 2018) |
|
Only 2D features |
Learn features from expert knowledge during observation (e.g., Silva et al., 2018, 2019) |
|
|
Improvements |
|
|
3D features |
|
|
New motion encoding and features |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Classification algorithms |
Current approaches |
Future directions |
|
Conventional ML methods, e.g., SVM, Decision Trees, Neural |
Employ ANN, DL |
|
Networks, Hidden Markov Models |
Employ Interactive Machine Learning (learning with feedback) |
|
Supervised learning without feedback during learning |
Improvements |
|
|
Better models with more accurate predictions |
|
|
Challenges |
|
|
More data is needed |