Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2015 Apr 1.
Published in final edited form as: Radiology. 2014 Oct 15;275(1):245–254. doi: 10.1148/radiol.14140973

Table 2.

Bland Altman limits of agreement (LA) for comparison of spiral 4D flow, Cartesian 4D flow (both assessed in upper abdominal vessels) and cine 2D phase contrast (assessed in the portal vein). Limits of agreement for inter-observer reproducibility are also given.

Flow Area Vavg Vpeak

ALL VESSELS Inter-technique Spiral 4D vs. Cartesian 4D Mean −2.6 −0.10 −0.4 −1.5
LA −11.8/6.6 −0.66/0.45 −7.7/6.9 −27.2/24.3

Inter-observer Cartesian 4D Mean −0.7 −0.02 −0.4 −1.4
LA −8.7/7.3 −0.44/0.40 −6.2/5.4 −36.1/33.2

Spiral 4D Mean −0.9 −0.02 −0.8 −1.2
LA −7.2/5.4 −0.60/0.57 −5.7/4.1 −23.8/21.3

PORTAL VEIN Inter-technique Spiral 4D vs. Cartesian 4D Mean −1.8 −0.15 −0.3 −0.1
LA −11.8/8.2 −0.94/0.65 −6.1/5.5 −8.9/8.8

Cartesian 4D vs. cine 2D Mean 2.1 −0.59 3.4 8.2
LA −10.6/14.6 −1.55/0.38 −3.3/10.0 −0.4/16.8

Spiral 4D vs. cine 2D Mean 0.2 −0.73 3.1 8.1
LA −8.8/9.3 −1.51/0.04 −0.6/6.8 2.3/14.0

Inter-observer Cartesian 4D Mean 0.2 −0.03 0.2 −0.1
LA −3.5/3.9 −0.34/0.29 −3.3/3.6 −4.7/4.6

Spiral 4D Mean −1.1 −0.12 −0.2 0.2
LA −5.1/2.8 −0.79/0.56 −1.8/1.3 −1.6/2.1

Cine 2D Mean −0.6 0.11 −0.6 −0.3
LA −5.2/4.1 −0.26/0.49 −3.4/2.2 −2.1/1.4

Area: time-averaged vessel area in cm2; Flow: time-averaged total flow in mL/s; HV: hepatic vein; IVC: inferior vena cava; LA: limits of agreement; SMA: superior mesenteric artery; SMV: superior mesenteric vein; Vavg: time-averaged through-plane velocity in cm/s; Vpeak: peak through-plane velocity in cm/s