Table 2.
3D CRT | IMRTNC | IMRTCO | VMAT | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
CTV | V95% | 99.8±0.4 | 99.5±0.6* | 99.5±0.6* | 99.5 ± 0.6* |
HI | 1.05±0.02 | 1.07±0.04* | 1.07±0.03* | 1.11±0.04*†‡ | |
CI | 1.56±0.27 | 1.42±0.32 | 1.44±0.30 | 1.60±0.32 | |
PTV | V95% | 98.5±1.4 | 96.3±2.0* | 96.5±1.5* | 96.4±1.8* |
HI | 1.05±0.02 | 1.08 ±0.05* | 1.07±0.04* | 1.12±0.02*†‡ | |
CI | 1.04±0.17 | 0.95±0.20 | 0.96±0.21 | 1.07±0.22†‡ | |
Skin | D10 cm3 (%) | 45.9±7.1 | 41.9±5. 9* | 43.8±6.5 | 46.3±7.42†‡ |
D1 cm3 (%) | 72.9±9.6 | 59.2±10.3* | 61.1±11.9* | 64.2±11.7*† | |
Dmax (%) | 86.5±6.7 | 73.7±11.5* | 74.3±12.1* | 76.3±12.5* | |
ILB | V20% (%) | 28.5±8.5 | 27.0±7.8* | 26.4±8.3* | 23.5±7.5*†‡ |
V50% (%) | 15.3±5.3 | 14.3±3.9 | 14.8±5.5 | 14.1±5.6*‡ | |
V100% (%) | 4.3±1.6 | 3.8±1.3* | 3.9±1.4 | 4.4±1.9†‡ | |
D1% (%) | 103.7±1.8 | 103.9±2.5* | 104.0±2.3* | 105.6±2.8* | |
Heart | D10cm3(%) | 2.5±1.7 | 1.8±1.6* | 1.6±1.4* | 1.3±1.1*†‡ |
CB | D10cm3 (%) | 1.0±0.5 | 0.7±0.3* | 0.8±0.3*† | 0.6±0.2*‡ |
ILL | D10cm3 (%) | 11.4±8.3 | 13.2±10.8 | 11.8±9.8 | 9.6±9.9† ‡ |
Ribs | Dmax (%) | 33.6±33.0 | 34.3±36.6 | 33.7±35.8 | 30.4±36.6†‡ |
Dose fall off | V50%/V100% of ILB | 3.7±0.8 | 3.9±0.8 | 4.0±1.1 | 3.3±0.8*† ‡ |
Delivery time (min) | 11.0±1.5 | 9.7±1.0* | 8.3±1.1*† | 7.0±1.0*†‡ |
p value < 0.05 compared to 3D CRT where p = the two-tailed paired t-test.
p value < 0.05 compared to IMRTNC.
p value < 0.05 compared to IMRTCO.