Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2019 Apr 25.
Published in final edited form as: Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2018 Apr 25;4:CD007105. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD007105.pub3
Study ID Regional
technique
Timing of
intervention
Adjuvants Outcomes Continuous Follow-up
(month)
Breast cancer surgery
Albi-Feldzer 2013 Wound instillation and intervertebral block Postincision, single shot vs placebo None Pain/no pain Brief Pain Index 3, 6 and 12 months
Baudry 2008 Local Infiltration Single shot, postincision vs control None Pain/no pain McGill results not reported 18 months
Besic 2014 Local Infiltration Postincision, continuous post-op vs control None Pain/no pain None 3 months
Fassoulaki 2000 Topical application Preincision, continuous post-op vs placebo Propoxyphene Pain/no pain Verbal Intensity Scale 3 months
Fassoulaki 2001 Brachial plexus block Postincision, single shot vs placebo Mexiletine, propoxyphene Pain/no pain VAS 3 months
Fassoulaki 2005 Topical application Postincision, continuous postop vs control Gabapentin Pain/no pain Analgesic consumption 6 months
Gacio 2016 Paravertebral block Single shot, preincision vs control Parecoxib, fentanyl, morphine, and adrenaline Pain/no pain None 6 months
Grigoras 2012 IV lidocaine Preincision, continuous intra-op vs placebo None Pain/no pain Short-form McGill Pain Questionnaire 3 months
Ibarra 2011 Single shot, paravertebral block Single shot, preincision vs control None Myofascial, phantom or neuropathic pain None 3 and 5 months
Kairaluoma 2006 Single shot, paravertebral block Single shot, preincision vs control None NRS > 3 Analgesic consumption 12 months
Karmakar 2014 Thoracic paravertebral block Single shot, preincision vs pre incision, continuous vs control Epinephrine Pain/no pain VRS 3 and 6 months
Lam 2015 Paravertebral block Not specified None Pain/no pain None 6 months
Lee 2013 Paravertebral block Preincision, continuous intra-op and post-op vs control Pregabalin Pain/no pain Short-form McGill Pain Questionnaire 3 months
Micha 2012 Local infiltration with brachial plexus and interscalene block Postincision, single shot vs placebo None DN4 None 6 months
Strazisar 2012 Local infiltration Postincision, continuous post-op vs control None Pain/no pain None 3 months
Strazisar 2014 Local infiltration Postincision, continuous post-op vs control None Pain/no pain None 3 months
Tecirli 2014 Intercostal nerve block Postincision, single shot vs control None DN4 VAS 3 months
Terkawi 2015b IV lidocaine Preincision, continuous intra-op and post-op vs placebo None Pain/no pain VAS 6 months
Caesarean section
Bollag 2012 Transversus abdominis plane block Single shot, post-op vs placebo Clonidine None Short form McGill Pain Questionnaire 3, 6 and 12 months
Lavand’homme 2007 Wound irrigation Preincision, continuous post-op vs control None Pain/no pain Analgesic consumption 6 months
Loane 2012 Transversus abdominis plane block Postincision, single shot vs placebo None Pain/no pain None 3 months
McKeen 2014 Transversus abdominis plane block Postincision, single shot vs placebo None None SF-36 6 months
Shahin 2010 Peritoneal instillation Postincision, single shot vs placebo None Pain/no pain NRS 8 months
Singh 2013 Transversus abdominis plane block Postincision, single shot vs placebo None None NRS 3 months
Iliac crest bone graft
Barkhuysen 2010 Local infiltration Postincision, single shot vs control Epinephrine Pain/no pain None 1 Year
Gundes 2000 Wound instillation Postincision, single shot vs placebo None Pain and dysaesthesia vs none None 3 months
Singh 2007 Wound irrigation Postincision, continuous post-op vs control None Pain/no pain VAS, pain frequency, functional activity score, overall satisfaction 4.7 years
Prostatectomy
Brown 2004 Spinal Preincision, continuous intra-op vs placebo Clonidine Pain/no pain Numerical Pain Scale, SF-36 3 months
Gupta 2006 Epidural Continuos, post-op vs placebo Adrenaline None SF-36 3 months
Thoracatomy
Can 2013 Epidural Single shot, preincision vs preincision, continuous vs control None Pain/no pain VAS, patient satisfaction 6 months
Comez 2015 Epidural Preincision, continuous intra-op vs control Dexketoprofen, morphine, and fentanyl Pain/no pain VAS 3 and 6 months
Ju 2008 Epidural Preincision and post-op vs control None Pain/no pain Allodynia 12 months
Katz 1996 Intercostal nerve block Single shot, postincision vs control None Pain/no pain VRS, analgesic consumption 18 months
Liu 2015 Wound irrigation Postincision, continuous post-op vs control Fentanyl Pain/no pain None 3 months
Lu 2008 Epidural Preincision vs post-op vs control None Pain/no pain None 6 months
Senturk 2002 Epidural Preincision vs post-op vs control None Pain/no pain NRS, pain affecting daily living 6 months
Vaginal hysterectomy
Purwar 2015 Spinal Single shot, preincision vs control Fentanyl None VAS, SF-36 3 months
Sprung 2006 Spinal Single shot, preincision vs control Clonidine None NRS, SF-36 3 months
Abdominal hysterectomy
Wodlin 2011 Spinal Single shot, preincision vs control None None SF-36 6 months

DN4: Douleur Neuropathique 4, a pain questionnaire; NRS: numerical rating scale; SF-36: Short Form Health Survey; VAS: visual analogue scale; VRS: verbal rating scale