Abstract
Background and Aims
Despite concerns about the impact of rising sea levels and storm surge events on coastal ecosystems, there is remarkably little information on the response of terrestrial coastal plant species to seawater inundation. The aim of this study was to elucidate responses of a glycophyte (white clover, Trifolium repens) to short-duration soil flooding by seawater and recovery following leaching of salts.
Methods
Using plants cultivated from parent ecotypes collected from a natural soil salinity gradient, the impact of short-duration seawater soil flooding (8 or 24 h) on short-term changes in leaf salt ion and organic solute concentrations was examined, together with longer term impacts on plant growth (stolon elongation) and flowering.
Key Results
There was substantial Cl– and Na+ accumulation in leaves, especially for plants subjected to 24 h soil flooding with seawater, but no consistent variation linked to parent plant provenance. Proline and sucrose concentrations also increased in plants following seawater flooding of the soil. Plant growth and flowering were reduced by longer soil immersion times (seawater flooding followed by drainage and freshwater inputs), but plants originating from more saline soil responded less negatively than those from lower salinity soil.
Conclusions
The accumulation of proline and sucrose indicates a potential for solute accumulation as a response to the osmotic imbalance caused by salt ions, while variation in growth and flowering responses between ecotypes points to a natural adaptive capacity for tolerance of short-duration seawater soil flooding in T. repens. Consequently, it is suggested that selection for tolerant ecotypes is possible should the predicted increase in frequency of storm surge flooding events occur.
Keywords: Climate change, flooding, glycophyte, osmotic stress, salinity, saline soil waterlogging, salt ions, sea level rise, stress metabolites, storm surge, Trifolium repens, white clover
INTRODUCTION
A combination of sea level rise and the increased likelihood of storm surge events associated with anthropogenic climate change is likely to result in more frequent and severe episodes of salt water inundation into low-lying coastal vegetation (Nicholls and Cazenave, 2010; Martin et al., 2011; Zappa et al., 2013). Coastal habitats are both economically and ecologically important. Not only do they provide protection against the sea for urban areas and agro-ecosystems inland (Hanley et al., 2014), but they also offer refuge for many plant and animal species excluded by intensive agriculture (Rhymer et al., 2010; Fisher et al., 2011). Consequently the ecological response of these coastal habitats to seawater inundation may have important ramifications not only for conservation, but also for shoreline management.
The potential impact of storm surge events may be particularly acute for grazing marsh, sand dunes and coastal pasture since, unlike salt marshes, these ecosystems are not naturally susceptible to the periodic intrusion of seawater. Salt stress and inundation regimes are known to affect productivity and plant zonation in estuarine marsh/grassland transitions (Guo and Pennings, 2012; Janousek and Mayo, 2013), and also influence plant survival, growth and reproduction in freshwater macrophytes (Van Zandt and Mopper, 2002; Van Zandt et al., 2003; Middleton, 2009; Pathikonda et al., 2010). However, our understanding of the impact of salt stress on coastal mesophytes is limited to the effects of sea spray on cliff and strandline vegetation (Malloch et al., 1985; de Vos et al., 2010; Rogers and Wiser, 2010). This contrasts markedly with a rich literature documenting salinity tolerance in halophytes (Zhu, 2001; Flowers and Colmer, 2008; Wetson et al., 2012) and the impact of salinity on growth and yield of crop species (Munns and Tester, 2008; Flowers et al., 2010).
The tolerance of wetland plants to freshwater flooding has been studied extensively (see reviews by Bailey-Serres and Voesenek, 2008; Colmer and Voesenek, 2009), but knowledge of plant response to seawater flooding is limited (Colmer and Flowers, 2008; Bennett et al., 2009; Hanley et al., 2013), and for the most part focuses on how increased tidal flooding affects halophytes in salt marsh systems (e.g. Janousek and Mayo, 2013; Valentim et al., 2013). In addition to impeded gas exchange and chemically reduced compounds in flooded soils (Armstrong, 1979), flooding by seawater also imposes osmotic and ionic stresses; the osmotic stress limits the plant's ability to absorb water, and the ionic stress can result in toxicity through the accumulation of Na+ and Cl– in tissues (Munns and Tester, 2008). In order to cope with the challenge of salinity, the plant must prevent or alleviate damage caused by the high concentration of salt ions (Na+ and Cl–) and re-establish homeostatic function (e.g. for K+). Salt tolerance is often achieved by the accumulation of stress metabolites (e.g. compatible solutes) and the regulation of tissue ions to exclude or compartmentalize the potentially damaging Na+ and Cl–, but, even if successfully achieved, this can impose a cost on plant growth (Munns and Tester, 2008).
Any change in the frequency and severity of seawater flooding might therefore be expected to influence greatly the vegetation of low-lying coastal ecosystems. Nonetheless, our ability to predict the impact of anthropogenically induced changes in storm surge scenarios on coastal vegetation is limited by the paucity of information on how component species respond to salt water inundation (Hoggart et al., 2014; but see Redondo-Gómez et al., 2011; Hanley et al., 2013). Here we investigate how one common and economically important coastal grassland species, Trifolium repens, responded to simulated short-term seawater inundation of the soil. Although some coastal populations of this species have been shown to be relatively tolerant of salinity, all previous work has exposed plants to a range of salt concentrations imposed for several weeks (Ab-Skukor et al., 1988; Rogers et al., 1997), rather than looking at the effects of a simulated, short-duration seawater soil flooding event and subsequent recovery. Given the lack of information on plant response to salinity stress following storm surge events, our primary goal was to elucidate how exposure to a relatively short pulse of seawater soil flooding affected plant survival, immediate onward growth and flowering. In addition, as plant performance and response are probably influenced by the accumulation of salt ions and organic solutes (Flowers and Colmer, 2008; Munns and Tester, 2008), we investigated post-immersion changes in the tissue concentrations of Na+, Cl– and K+, and organic solutes (sugars, sugar alcohols and proline).
We also examined whether response to seawater immersion varied for plants cultivated from clonal fragments taken from a natural salinity gradient, since we hypothesized that natural adaptation for salt tolerance (Munns and Tester, 2008) would probably influence the response of T. repens plants to short-duration soil immersion in seawater. Environmental gradients across even small distances can facilitate the evolution of local ecotypes, i.e. genetically distinct populations adapted to local environmental conditions (Turesson, 1922). Population-specific variation in morphological or physiological responses to environmental factors such as climate are well known (Fernández-Pascual et al., 2013; Quilot-Turion et al., 2013), but our understanding of ecotype-specific variation in response to salinity stress is largely confined to halophytes (Huiskes et al., 1985; Blits and Gallagher, 1991; but see Ab-Skukor et al., 1988; Van Zandt et al., 2003). Ours is the first study to examine ecotypic variation in response to simulated seawater soil flooding in a terrestrial, coastal glycophyte.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Plant species, collection and cultivation
Naturally distributed throughout Europe, North Africa and Asia, Trifolium repens has been widely introduced elsewhere as a pasture forage plant (Grime et al., 2007). It is also a very common component of coastal grasslands and dune systems likely to be affected by sea level rise and storm surge events. In June 2011, we collected parent plants from grassland pasture at South Efford Marsh near Aveton Gifford, Devon, UK (50°18′14″N, 3°50′59″W). Plants were collected at locations approx. 25, 200 and 700 m away from the most southerly point of the site. At 25 m, seepage under the sea wall favoured the development of a semi-halophytic community (containing Puccinellia maritima and Spergularia media) as well as common pasture species such as T. repens and Agrostis stolonifera. At 200 m, the plant community was more typical of a terrestrial pasture (dominated by A. stolonifera and Ranunculus repens), and, at 700 m, the sward was dominated by similar species, but also including common pasture grasses such as Holcus lanatus and Cyanosurus cristatus. The variation in the plant community with distance from the sea wall suggested a salinity gradient (confirmed by electrical conductivity measurements of the soil – described below), with which to test the hypothesis that natural adaptation for salt tolerance would influence plant response to short-duration soil immersion in seawater.
In mid-June 2011 we sampled 12 individual plants per distance, collecting large, branched (approx. 100 mm diameter) fragments with multiple rooting points. All parent plants were at least 5 m apart and taken from distinct patches to reduce the likelihood of collecting from the same individual (Ab-Shukor et al., 1988). The plant fragments were transplanted into 110 × 110 × 120 mm plastic pots containing John Innes No. 2 potting compost and cultivated in a sheltered outdoor area. Three soil cores (10 cm depth, 5 cm diameter) per distance were also collected at random intervals to quantify soil electrical conductivity. Three 20 g sub-samples were taken from each core and mixed with 100 mL of deionized water on a rotational mixer to provide a 1:5 soil:water extract (British Standards Institution, 1997). An electrical conductivity reading was then obtained for each sub-sample using a WTW Cond 330i handheld conductivity meter with a WTW TetraCon 325 probe (Wissenschaftlich-Technische Werkstätten GmbH, Weilheim, Germany). One-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) was used to determine variation in soil electrical conductivity from these samples.
Experimental treatments
In November 2011 we removed ten stolons (about 20 mm long with one root node) from each of 12 parent ‘stock’ plants per distance group, and individually transplanted these into 70 × 70 × 80 mm pots containing John Innes No. 2 potting compost. Plants were subsequently grown in a naturally lit, heated greenhouse in Plymouth, UK (mean daily temperatures varying between 10·7 °C (±0·2) minimum and 26·3 °C (±0·6) maximum, with daily watering with tap water), until late April 2012.
On 24 April 2012, established ramets were selected such that each of 12 parent ‘stock’ plants was represented by up to six clones, each uniform in size and appearance. Clones were allocated to a different treatment group such that we aimed to subject two ramets from each parent ‘stock’ plant to the same soil immersion treatment with seawater collected from Plymouth Sound (electrical conductivity = 47·9 mS cm–1 at 23·8 °C) for 8 or 24 h, or they were retained as untreated controls. This arrangement ensured that genetic variation across all soil immersion treatments was minimized within all distance classes. However, due to some plants failing to establish, replication fell below the target of six clones per parent for the 200 and 700 m distance groups, affecting the number of replicates used in the onward growth and flowering experiment (see below). By immersing to pot level (in large plastic tubs), we simulated short-term soil waterlogging. Although we recognize that seawater inundation following a storm surge event would potentially also result in shoot submergence, our approach allowed us to focus on the effect of ionic imbalance in the root zone rather than the combined effects that could also arise if shoots experienced oxygen deficiency by submergence. In addition, while seawater flooding following storm surge events might also be expected to persist longer than 24 h, records from along the UK coast suggest that a 1 d long seawater flooding event is typical (Environment Agency, 2014).
Immediately after immersion in seawater, pots were allowed to drain fully before being arranged randomly on a wire mesh-topped bench inside the greenhouse; the wire mesh allowed free drainage and prevented cross-contamination of any leachates between pots.
Tissue ion and metabolite analyses
One fully expanded, non-senescent leaf was removed from each of 12 individual clones per ecotype per immersion treatment 2 d after soil immersion. These samples were frozen in liquid nitrogen and freeze-dried. Samples were then stored in sealed containers with desiccant in a freezer at –80 °C until analysis. These plants were then discarded.
Dried samples were digested in 5 mL of dilute (0·5 m) nitric acid while suspended on a shaker in dark conditions for 2 d at room temperature prior to determination of Na+ and K+ by flame photometry and of Cl– by chloridometry (Munns et al., 2010). This procedure was applied to four replicate leaf samples per soil immersion treatment/ecotype group (minimum sample mass = 26·7 mg). A reference tissue taken through the procedures confirmed the reliability of these measurements.
The remaining leaf samples were bulked (by adding two samples together) such that four replicate samples were created for each soil immersion treatment/ecotype group (minimum sample mass = 54·3 mg). Tissue metabolites were extracted from these using 5 % (w/v) perchloric acid, and neutralized extracts were analysed using high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) (Fan et al., 1993). Neutralized extracts were filtered (0·22 μm) and stored at –80 °C. The initial HPLC analysis of organic solutes (glycinebetaine, proline, prolinebetaine and trigonelline), soluble sugars (fructose, glucose and sucrose) and sugar alcohols (sorbitol, mannitol and pinitol) was adapted from Slimestad and Vågen (2006). The HPLC system (Waters, Milford, MA, USA) consisted of a 600E pump, 717plus autosampler and a 996 photo-diode array detector (PDA). As detection of fructose, glucose and sucrose with the PDA at 195 nm is very insensitive, an Alltech (Deerfield, IL, USA) evaporative light scattering detector (ELSD) was also used to improve sensitivity by a minimum of 100-fold. Separation was achieved at 22 ± 1·0 °C on a Prevail ES Carbohydrate column (250 × 4·6 mm i.d. with 5 μm packing; Alltech) using a gradient elution profile of acetonitrile (eluent A) and water (eluent B) at 1 mL min–1. Samples in the autoinjector were held at 10 °C, the ELSD drift tube was held at 85 °C and eluent nebulization was with high purity N2 gas at a flow rate of 2·6 L min–1.
Quantification was based on PDA peak area for organic solutes, and ELSD peak area for soluble sugars and sugar alcohols. Calibration curves were generated from peak area vs. the mass of standard analyte injected, with a linear relationship for the PDA and a power relationship for the ELSD output. A standard was analysed every ten samples to check for any instrument/detector drift. Retention times of standards were used to identify analytes in the sample extracts, with the PDA spectral data and peak purity used to confirm organic solutes. Typical sample injections were 20 μL and run time was 20 min per sample, with Empower™ 2 software (Waters) used for data acquisition and processing.
Due to the fact that pinitol co-eluted with fructose, a second HPLC approach was needed to separate and quantify these two analytes, and the method described by Naidu (1998) was followed. The Sugar-Pak column (300 × 6·5 mm i.d.) was held at 90 ± 0·5 °C and separation was achieved using a mobile phase of 2·5 mg L–1 Ca-EDTA at 0·6 mL min–1. Detection and quantification of pinitol was undertaken with the PDA as this offered good sensitivity as well as peak spectral and purity comparisons with the standards.
Following application of the Cochran test for homogeneity of variance, and (logN) data transformation where necessary (Underwood, 1997), the effect of immersion on tissue ion and solute concentrations was examined using a two-way ANOVA with ‘immersion time’ and ‘distance’ as factors, with the tests for an ‘immersion time’ × ‘distance’ interaction included to examine any evidence for distance-specific variation in response to immersion duration.
Plant survival, growth and flowering
Plants not used for chemical analysis were watered to capacity 48 h after salt water immersion (using tap water), and then every 2 d thereafter for a further 70 d (5 July 2012). Greenhouse air temperatures during this phase of the experiment were: 11·3 °C (±0·3) minimum and 29·9 °C (± 0·9) maximum. Due to some clones failing to establish before immersion, replication fell below the target of 12 plants for the 200 m (0 h = 9 plants, 8 h = 9 plants, 24 h = 8 plants) and 700 m (24 h = 11 plants) distance groups.
The numbers of inflorescences on each plant were monitored weekly, so that the total number of inflorescences produced per plant (‘flowering effort’) and the percentage of plants that produced open inflorescences (‘percentage flowering’) could be quantified at the end of the experiment. Elongation of a representative, randomly selected shoot on each plant, measured from a node marked with loosely tied cotton thread, was quantified at 14 and 42 d (‘stolon growth’). Plant mortality was recorded daily.
Subsequently, the effects of ‘immersion time’ and ‘distance’ on ‘flowering effort’ were examined using a two-way ANOVA with ‘immersion time’ and ‘distance’ as factors, with the tests for an ‘immersion time’ × ‘distance’ interaction included to examine any evidence for distance-specific variation in response to immersion duration. The effects of ‘immersion time’ and ‘distance’ on ‘stolon growth’ at 14 d were analysed in the same way. Data transformation of the 42 d ‘stolon growth’ data could not avoid deviations from normality and homogeneity of variance; therefore, Kruskal–Wallis tests were applied. Pearson's χ2 test was performed on ‘percentage flowering’ data to assess the effects of immersion within ‘distance’ groups, where assumptions of the statistical test were met.
In order to quantify the leaching of salts from the potting compost, four pots were randomly chosen from each soil immersion treatment, and water passing through was collected and its electrical conductivity measured, as described above, for 5 weeks.
RESULTS
Electrical conductivity of soil samples from transects
One-way ANOVA indicated significant variation in soil electrical conductivity (of 1:5 soil:water extract, EC1:5) between sample sites [F(2,27) = 39·61, P < 0·01]. Post-hoc SNK (Student–Newman–Keuls) comparisons revealed that soil electrical conductivity declined with distance from the sea wall embankment, with a mean EC1:5 of 6·96 (±1·35 s.e.) mS cm–1 at 25 m, 1·29 (±0·40 s.e.) mS cm–1 at 200 m and 0·19 (±0·02 s.e.) mS cm–1 at 700 m. We therefore conclude that soil salt concentrations were higher at 25 m due to probable seawater seepage through the sea wall and/or deposition of salts from sea spray.
Accumulation in leaves of salt ions and stress metabolites
There was substantial accumulation of Cl– and Na+ in leaves following soil immersion in seawater (Table 1). Post-hoc SNK tests showed that leaf tissue Cl– concentrations significantly increased following 24 h seawater immersion compared with both control and 8 h treatments, irrespective of the original parental distance from the sea wall. There was also a significant increase in Cl– concentrations in the 8 h treatments compared with control plants. A similar effect of ‘immersion time’ was evident for Na+, although there were also additional ‘distance’ and ‘immersion time’ × ‘distance’ effects. However, SNK tests indicated that these were a manifestation of relatively high leaf Na+ levels in 200 m control plants, and generally relatively low leaf Na+ levels in 25 m plants following soil immersion. There was no effect of ‘immersion time’ on K+ concentrations; the significant ‘distance’ effect denoted the inherently higher leaf K+ concentrations in plants cultivated from the 200 m parent population.
Table 1.
Ion concentrations (μmol g–1 d. wt) of leaf tissues taken from Trifolium repens plants 2 d after root zone immersion in seawater
| Distance (m) | Treatment | n | Chloride |
Potassium |
Sodium |
|||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mean | s.e. | Mean | s.e. | Mean | s.e. | |||
| 25 | Control | 4 | 134a | 12 | 476 | 41 | 216a | 18 |
| 8 h | 4 | 966b | 47 | 383 | 82 | 663b | 46 | |
| 24 h | 4 | 1261c | 233 | 502 | 81 | 1049c | 129 | |
| 200 | Control | 4 | 138a | 16 | 797 | 30 | 273a | 29 |
| 8 h | 4 | 1025b | 77 | 712 | 112 | 929b | 34 | |
| 24 h | 4 | 1598c | 67 | 693 | 76 | 1126c | 30 | |
| 700 | Control | 4 | 110a | 17 | 466 | 66 | 202a | 28 |
| 8 h | 4 | 1047b | 36 | 457 | 66 | 814b | 39 | |
| 24 h | 4 | 1805c | 59 | 518 | 20 | 1454c | 49 | |
| Results of two-way ANOVA | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Factor | Chloride |
Potassium |
Sodium |
|||
| F | P | F | P | F | P | |
| Distance (d.f. = 2,27) | 1·1 | 0·358 | 14·9 | <0·001 | 5·0 | 0·014 |
| Immersion time (d.f. = 2,27) | 471·0 | <0·001 | 0·7 | 0·498 | 289·6 | <0·001 |
| Interaction (d.f. = 4,27) | 2·3 | 0·084 | 0·5 | 0·753 | 3·2 | 0·027 |
Significant differences (post-hoc SNK tests, P < 0·05) between treatment means are denoted by different letters following two-way ANOVA showing how immersion time (0, 8 or 24 h) and parent plant location along a natural salinity gradient (25 m most saline, 700 m least saline; described in the Results) affected accumulation of Cl–, Na+ and K+.
We found detectable amounts of the amino acid proline, the sugars fructose, glucose and sucrose, and the sugar alcohol pinitol in leaf extracts (Table 2). Of these, proline and sucrose increased in all distance groups following soil immersion, but no other treatment-specific trends were located for organic solutes.
Table 2.
Organic solute concentrations (μmol g–1 d. wt) of leaf tissue taken from Trifolium repens plants 2 d after root zone immersion in seawater
| Distance (m) | Treatment | n | Proline |
Fructose |
Glucose |
Sucrose |
Pinitol |
|||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mean | s.e. | Mean | s.e. | Mean | s.e. | Mean | s.e. | Mean | s.e. | |||
| 25 m | Control | 4 | ND | – | 84 | 11 | 57 | 5 | 9a | 2 | 166 | 31 |
| 8 h | 4 | 14ab | 8 | 74 | 16 | 75 | 12 | 155b | 19 | 138 | 18 | |
| 24 h | 4 | 28b | 10 | 85 | 42 | 74 | 16 | 148b | 32 | 125 | 16 | |
| 200 m | Control | 4 | ND | – | 42 | 5 | 36 | 3 | 14a | 2 | 160 | 28 |
| 8 h | 4 | 16b | 3 | 68 | 12 | 63 | 8 | 54b | 10 | 148 | 13 | |
| 24 h | 4 | 45c | 5 | 30 | 9 | 45 | 6 | 61b | 9 | 163 | 8 | |
| 700 m | Control | 4 | ND | – | 77 | 33 | 55 | 15 | 21a | 7 | 137 | 11 |
| 8 h | 4 | 22b | 4 | 61 | 18 | 57 | 6 | 142b | 15 | 131 | 9 | |
| 24 h | 4 | 55c | 8 | 45 | 22 | 58 | 8 | 107b | 18 | 118 | 16 | |
| Results of two-way ANOVA | ||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Factor | Proline |
Fructose |
Glucose |
Sucrose |
Pinitol |
|||||
| F | P | F | P | F | P | F | P | F | P | |
| Immersion time (d.f. = 2,27) | 44·0 | <0·001 | 0·4 | 0·649 | 1·9 | 0·171 | 73·9 | <0·001 | 0·9 | 0·436 |
| Interaction (d.f. = 4,27) | 1·6 | 0·198 | 0·5 | 0·735 | 0·6 | 0·697 | 4·8 | 0·005 | 0·4 | 0·790 |
Significant differences (post-hoc SNK tests, P < 0·05) between treatment means for each solute are denoted by different letters following two-way ANOVA showing how immersion time (0, 8 or 24 h) and parent plant location along a natural salinity gradient (25 m most saline, 700 m least saline; described in the Results) affected solute accumulation.
ND denotes failure to detect any quantity above the detection limit, which were: proline [12 μmol g–1 dry matter (DM)], fructose (14 μmol g–1 DM), glucose (20 μmol g–1 DM), sucrose (6 μmol g–1 DM), and pinitol (36 μmol g–1 DM).
Plant survival, growth and flowering
Water collected from control plants remained at an average electrical conductivity (ECw) of 2·37 ± 0·03 mS cm–1. Leachates from pots immersed for 8 and 24 h recorded similar levels of ECw 2 d post-immersion (12·53 ± 3·28 and 11·05 ± 5·61 mS cm–1, respectively) and declined at a similar rate until 35 d. At this point, stabilization of ECw occurred in both treatments (Fig. 1).
Fig. 1.

Average electrical conductivity (mS cm–1) of water passing through pots (i.e. of collected leachates following watering) after seawater soil immersion for the durations of 0 (control), 8 and 24 h.
Only four plants died during the experiment; these were all in the 24 h seawater soil immersion treatment; three from the 700 m ecotype and one from the 200 m ecotype. All plants from the 25 m ecotype survived 24 h soil immersion. At 14 d after the short durations of soil flooding, ‘stolon growth’ was greatly reduced by ‘immersion’ for all distance groups [F(2,91) = 50·25, P < 0·01], with post-hoc SNK tests indicating the greatest reduction after 24 h soil immersion treatment (P < 0·01) (Fig. 2A). ‘Distance’ also had a significant effect on ‘stolon growth’ [F(2,91) = 3·40, P < 0·05], probably due to a generally greater stem growth of 200 m plants and much reduced growth of 700 m plants following soil immersion. There was no interaction between ‘immersion’ and ‘distance’ [F(4,89) = 1·78, P > 0·05]. The loss of cotton thread markers used to identify stolons reduced the effective replicate number (see Fig. 2B) at 42 d; nevertheless, the ‘immersion’ effect remained apparent [H(2) = 35·22, P < 0·01), but ‘distance’ had no significant effect on ‘stolon growth’, as average growth of 25 m plants increased to rates similar to 200 m plants [H(2) = 2·15, P > 0·05). However, average stolon growth of 700 m plants appeared to be much reduced even at 42 d after the longer duration (24 h) of soil immersion (Fig. 2B).
Fig. 2.
Mean stolon extension (mm ± s.e.) of Trifolium repens clones cultivated from parent plants from different locations along a natural salinity gradient (25 m is most saline, 700 m least saline; described in the Results) (A) 14 d and (B) 42 d after the root zones of plants were immersed in seawater.
While both ‘immersion’ [F(2,92) = 14·18, P < 0·01] and ‘distance’ [F(2,92) = 6·12, P < 0·01] had a significant effect on ‘flowering effort’ (Fig. 3), there was no interaction between ‘immersion’ and ‘distance’ [F(4,90) = 0·69, P > 0·05]. Post-hoc SNK tests revealed that the mean number of inflorescences per plant (‘flowering effort’) produced by the end of the experiment were reduced in both the 8 and 24 h soil immersion treatments (P < 0·01). The significant ‘distance’ effect could be explained by a greater number of inflorescences produced by the 200 and 700 m control plants compared with the 25 m control plants, suggesting that these populations naturally produce more flowers. However, ‘flowering effort’ in the 200 and 700 m plants was nonetheless greatly reduced by 24 h soil immersion. Similar patterns were observed for ‘percentage flowering’ (Fig. 4); 700 m plants produced more open flowers than plants in the groups collected at 200 and 25 m. Pearson's χ2 test revealed that ‘percentage flowering’ in the 25 m plants was reduced by soil immersion [χ2(36,2) = 16·94, P < 0·01]. Although the same test could not be performed on 200 and 700 m plants (>50 % of cells in the test matrix had expected values of <5), there was a trend for reduced flowering in both these distance groups following soil immersion.
Fig. 3.

The effects of immersion time on the mean (±s.e.) number of inflorescences (‘flowering effort’) produced by Trifolium repens clones cultivated from parent plants from different locations along a natural salinity gradient (25 m is most saline, 700 m least saline; described in the Results) 70 d after root zone immersion in sea water.
Fig. 4.

The effects of immersion time on the proportion of Trifolium repens plants that had flowered by 70 d after root zone immersion in sea water. Clonal fragments were cultivated from parents from different locations along a natural salinity gradient (25 m is most saline, 700 m least saline; described in the Results).
DISCUSSION
Our experiment to simulate the effects of transient saline soil waterlogging yielded consistent ecophysiological and plant performance responses; 2 d after soil immersion, all plants exhibited higher leaf concentrations of Na+ and Cl–, concentrations of some organic solutes significantly changed (e.g. sucrose and proline increased) and longer term plant growth and flowering potential were reduced. The fact that growth and flowering responses also varied according to the location of the parent plants along a natural salinity gradient, suggests that our study plants were displaying natural ecotypic variation to the short-duration salinity stress.
The accumulation of Na+ and Cl– in leaf tissues is commonly observed in salt-stressed plants which, in turn, leads to the accumulation of organic solutes to counter the resulting osmotic imbalance (Wyn Jones and Gorham, 2002; Flowers and Colmer, 2008). It was interesting to note, however, that despite having different growth and flowering responses to seawater soil immersion, the accumulation of Na+ and Cl– in leaf tissues did not vary for plants from different locations along the natural salinity gradient. Unlike Rogers et al. (1997) who documented that tolerance of T. repens to longer exposures to salinity was associated with ‘exclusion’ of Cl– from the shoot, the apparent salinity tolerance of plants we collected from the 25 m population could not be linked to differences in leaf ion concentrations (the trend in the present study for lower leaf Na+ and Cl– in ecotypes collected from closer to the sea wall was not statistically significant; Table 1). Moreover, in addition to regulation of leaf ion concentrations, other traits such as differences in ‘tissue tolerance’ can also influence overall plant salinity tolerance (Munns and Tester, 2008). Maintenance of tissue K+ concentration, which can decrease in plants exposed to excess Na+, to retain a favourable K+/Na+ ratio of the cytoplasm for enzyme functioning, is also of importance for salt tolerance (Maathuis and Amtmann, 1999), but for the short-term salinity exposures in the present experiment on T. repens there was no significant treatment effect on leaf K+ (Table 1). In addition to regulation of leaf ion concentrations, organic solutes that are compatible with enzymes and therefore accumulated in the cytoplasm are also of importance for adaptation to salinity (Flowers and Colmer, 2008; Munns and Tester, 2008). Organic solutes in plants can include various sugars, sugar alcohols, betaines and amino acids, many of which accumulate with increasing plant exposure to NaCl, but the types and concentrations vary in different species (Flowers and Colmer, 2008). Trifolium repens leaves contained constitutively high concentrations of pinitol, whereas proline and sucrose concentrations rose dramatically in the salt-stressed plants (Table 2). The increased organic solute accumulation is probably a response to provide the osmotic balance needed in the cytoplasm for Na+ and Cl– accumulation in the vacuole.
The reduction in plant growth reported here mirrors that of plants in salinized agricultural systems (Bennett et al., 2009; Flowers et al., 2010). Simulated seawater soil flooding not only reduced vegetative growth, measured here for T. repens as stolon growth, but had the added effect of causing reduced flowering potential. Exposure of the roots to seawater is expected to exert a negative effect on plant growth and reproductive allocation via ionic and osmotic stresses; salt stress impacts on cell division and photosynthesis as an osmotic imbalance leads to stomatal closure and reduced CO2 uptake and so less photosynthesis (Zhu, 2001). Therefore, greater stress will be exerted on plants enduring longer root immersion as Na+ and Cl– ions have more time to accumulate in leaf tissues (as was observed here for all plants subject to 24 h soil immersion when compared with the 8 h treatment). This is reflected by the greatest reduction in stolon growth and flowering potential of T. repens occurring as a result of 24 h seawater soil immersion despite the fact that salt levels in the growing media were roughly comparable for 8 and 24 h treatments after removal from seawater and subsequent leaching due to watering.
Growth and flowering responses to seawater soil immersion also varied according to the location of the parent plant along a natural salinity gradient. After 24 h of seawater soil immersion, stolon growth of 700 m plants was severely limited, while 25 and 200 m plants were less affected and seemed to return to similar rates of growth by 42 d. Similarly, although ‘flowering effort’ and the percentage of plants with flowering inflorescences were reduced for all distances, the effects were particularly marked for 700 m plants. Ecotype-specific variation in flowering as a consequence of long-term salinity exposure is well known for halophytes such as Aster tripolium (Gray et al., 1979) and Sporobolus virginicus (Blits and Gallagher, 1991), but ours is the first study to demonstrate this effect for a glycophyte from a natural salinity gradient when exposed to short-duration seawater soil flooding. Our results indicate that the 25 m and, to some degree, the 200 m ecotype, were resilient to transient seawater soil immersion presumably as a consequence of a local population adaptation to the higher soil salinity near to the sea wall embankment. Interestingly, a trade-off between salinity tolerance and reproductive allocation might be evident, as flowering potential in the 25 m ecotype was lower than in the 700 m population.
Plant adaptation to salinity has been shown for species in many hypersaline semi-arid/arid areas (Munns and Tester, 2008), but such local adaptation also occurs in coastal plant populations exposed to salt spray and long-term accumulation of salt ions in the soil (Lowry et al., 2009), including T. repens (Ab-Shukor et al., 1988; Rogers et al., 1997). Our study is considerably different, however, in that we applied a one-off, short-term, salinity pulse via soil flooding in an attempt to mirror seawater inundation in a storm surge event. Consequently, our plants experienced an immediate salinity shock followed by a gradual reduction of salt ions around the roots as fresh water diluted and leached salt from the potting media. In flooded ecosystems, the dissipation of salt ions over time may also allow plants to recover from the initial impact of ionic and osmotic stress, an effect likely to vary not only between plant species and ecotypes, but also with season and local weather conditions. The effects of seasonality and species identity remain to be elucidated, but we demonstrate here population-level variation in plant response to seawater soil flooding. Although an ecotype-specific response to salinity stress has been demonstrated at the regional scale for T. repens (Ab-Shukor et al., 1988), our study provides evidence for the presence of different salinity-tolerant ecotypes over relatively small distances within a single coastal site. If salinity-tolerant ecotypes are a widely distributed feature of coastal plant species, supra-littoral vegetation may be naturally buffered to some extent against predicted sea level rise and increased incidence of storm surge events over coming decades. The existence of flooding-tolerant ecotypes may also be important in developing salt-tolerant cultivars for use in saline soils (Ab-Shukor et al., 1988; Rogers et al., 1997; Bennett et al., 2009), and any coastal pastures susceptible to future episodes of seawater flooding.
Given the increased likelihood of storm surge events over the coming decades (Martin et al., 2011; Zappa et al., 2013), the international conservation importance of low-lying coastal vegetation and the role these areas play in coastal defence (Rhymer et al., 2010; Fisher et al., 2011; Hanley et al., 2014), a more detailed understanding of the structural and functional responses of coastal vegetation to periodic seawater flooding is particularly pressing. We demonstrate here that one common plant species component of many coastal grasslands and dune systems, T. repens, responds poorly to simulated seawater soil flooding, but that the response may be population, i.e. ecotype, specific and that the species consequently has an adaptive capacity to withstand short periods of soil inundation by seawater. Whether the likely increased selection pressure for plants resistant to seawater flooding impacts on other plant traits (e.g. growth, nitrogen-fixing capacity, anti-herbivore defence or reproductive potential), and thus the ecological role and economic value of this species, is worthy of future attention. In addition, the impact of short-duration seawater flooding on multispecies mixtures and subsequent community assembly and function could yield many useful insights into the likely responses of coastal vegetation to rising sea levels and the anticipated increased frequency and severity of saline flooding events.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We thank Jane Akerman, Simon Hoggart and John Quealy for technical assistance, and two anonymous referees for their comments on an earlier draft of this manuscript. The support of a University of Plymouth International Research, Networking and Collaboration Grant to M.E.H. and a University of Plymouth research studentship bursary to A.C.W. are gratefully acknowledged.
LITERATURE CITED
- Ab-Shukor NA, Kay QON, Stevens DP, Skibinski DOF. Salt tolerance in natural populations of Trifolium repens L. New Phytologist. 1988;109:483–490. [Google Scholar]
- Armstrong W. Aeration in higher plants. Advances in Botanical Research. 1979;7:225–332. [Google Scholar]
- Bailey-Serres J, Voesenek LACJ. Flooding stress: acclimations and genetic diversity. Annual Review of Plant Biology. 2008;59:313–339. doi: 10.1146/annurev.arplant.59.032607.092752. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Bennett SJ, Barrett-Lennard EG, Colmer TD. Salinity and waterlogging as constraints to saltland pasture production: a review. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment. 2009;129:349–360. [Google Scholar]
- Blits KC, Gallagher JL. Morphological and physiological responses to increased salinity in marsh and dune ecotypes of Sporobolus virginicus (L) Kunth. Oecologia. 1991;87:330–335. doi: 10.1007/BF00634587. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- British Standards Institution. Part 3: Chemical methods. London: British Standard 7755, British Standards Institution; 1997. [Google Scholar]
- Colmer TD, Flowers TJ. Flooding tolerance in halophytes. New Phytologist. 2008;179:964–974. doi: 10.1111/j.1469-8137.2008.02483.x. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Colmer TD, Voesenek LACJ. Flooding tolerance: suites of plant traits in variable environments. Functional Plant Biology. 2009;36:665–681. doi: 10.1071/FP09144. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Environment Agency UK. DataShare. 2014. Available from http://www.geostore.com/environment-agency/ Accessed 4 April 2014.
- Fan TWM, Colmer TD, Lane AN, Higashi RM. Determination of metabolites by 1H NMR and GC: analysis for organic osmolytes in crude tissue extracts. Annals of Biochemistry. 1993;214:260–271. doi: 10.1006/abio.1993.1486. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Fernández-Pascual E, Jiménez-Alfaro B, Caujapé-Castells J, Jaén-Molina R, Díaz TE. A local dormancy cline is related to the seed maturation environment, population genetic composition and climate. Annals of Botany. 2013;112:937–945. doi: 10.1093/aob/mct154. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Fisher B, Bradbury RB, Andrews JE, et al. Impacts of species-led conservation on ecosystem services of wetlands: understanding co-benefits and tradeoffs. Biodiversity Conservation. 2011;20:2461–2481. [Google Scholar]
- Flowers TJ, Colmer TD. Salinity tolerance in halophytes. New Phytologist. 2008;179:945–963. doi: 10.1111/j.1469-8137.2008.02531.x. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Flowers TJ, Gaur PM, Gowda CLL, et al. Salt sensitivity in chickpea. Plant, Cell and Environment. 2010;33:490–509. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-3040.2009.02051.x. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Gray AJ, Parsell RJ, Scott R. The genetic structure of plant populations in relation to the development of salt marshes. In: Jefferies RL, Davy AJ, editors. Ecological processes in coastal environments. Oxford: Blackwell; 1979. pp. 43–64. [Google Scholar]
- Grime JP, Hodgson JG, Hunt R. Comparative plant ecology. 2nd edn. Dalbeattie, UK: Castlepoint Press; 2007. [Google Scholar]
- Guo HY, Pennings SC. Mechanisms mediating plant distributions across estuarine landscapes in a low-latitude tidal estuary. Ecology. 2012;93:90–100. doi: 10.1890/11-0487.1. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Hanley ME, Yip PYS, Hoggart SPG, Bilton DT, Rundle SD, Thompson RC. Riding the storm: the response of Plantago lanceolata to simulated tidal flooding. Journal of Coastal Conservation. 2013;17:799–803. [Google Scholar]
- Hanley ME, Hoggart SPG, Simmonds DJ, et al. Shifting sands? Coastal protection by sand banks, beaches, and dunes. Coastal Engineering. 2014;87:136–146. [Google Scholar]
- Hoggart SPG, Hanley ME, Parker DJ, et al. The consequences of doing nothing: the effects of seawater flooding on coastal zones. Coastal Engineering. 2014;87:169–182. [Google Scholar]
- Huiskes AHL, van Soelen J, Markusse MM. Field studies on the variability of populations of Aster tripolium L. in relation to salt marsh zonation. Vegetatio. 1985;61:163–169. [Google Scholar]
- Janousek CN, Mayo C. Plant responses to increased inundation and salt exposure: interactive effects on tidal marsh productivity. Plant Ecology. 2013;214:917–928. [Google Scholar]
- Lowry DB, Hall MC, Salt DE, Willis JH. Genetic and physiological basis of adaptive salt tolerance divergence between coastal and inland Mimulus guttatus. New Phytologist. 2009;183:776–788. doi: 10.1111/j.1469-8137.2009.02901.x. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Malloch AJC, Bamidele JF, Scott AM. The phytosociology of British sea-cliff vegetation with special reference to the ecophysiology of some maritime cliff plants. Vegetatio. 1985;62:309–317. [Google Scholar]
- Martin J, Fackler PL, Nichols JD, et al. Structured decision making as a proactive approach to dealing with sea level rise in Florida. Climatic Change. 2011;107:185–202. [Google Scholar]
- Maathuis FJM, Amtmann A. K+ nutrition and Na+ toxicity: the basis of cellular K+/Na+ ratios. Annals of Botany. 1999;84:123–133. [Google Scholar]
- Middleton EA. Regeneration of coastal marsh vegetation impacted by hurricanes Katrina and Rita. Wetlands. 2009;29:54–65. [Google Scholar]
- Munns R, Tester M. Mechanisms of salt tolerance. Annual Review of Plant Biology. 2008;59:651–681. doi: 10.1146/annurev.arplant.59.032607.092911. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Munns R, Wallace PA, Teakle NL, Colmer TD. Measuring soluble ion concentrations (Na+, K+, Cl–) in salt-treated plants. Methods in Molecular Biology. 2010;639:371–382. doi: 10.1007/978-1-60761-702-0_23. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Naidu BP. Separation of sugars, polyols, proline analogues, and betaines in stressed plant extracts by high performance liquid chromatography and quantification by ultra violet detection. Australian Journal Plant Physiology. 1998;25:793–800. [Google Scholar]
- Nicholls RJ, Cazenave A. Sea-level rise and its impact on coastal zones. Science. 2010;328:1517–1520. doi: 10.1126/science.1185782. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Pathikonda S, Meerow A, He ZX, Mopper S. Salinity tolerance and genetic variability in freshwater and brackish Iris hexagona colonies. American Journal of Botany. 2010;97:1438–1443. doi: 10.3732/ajb.0900356. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Quilot-Turion B, Leppälä J, Leinonen PH, et al. Genetic changes in flowering and morphology in response to adaptation to a high-latitude environment in Arabidopsis lyrata. Annals of Botany. 2013;111:957–968. doi: 10.1093/aob/mct055. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Redondo-Gómez S, Andrades-Moreno L, Parra R, Mateos-Naranjo E, Sánchez-Lafuente AM. Factors influencing seed germination of Cyperus capitatus, inhabiting the moving sand dunes in southern Europe. Journal of Arid Environments. 2011;75:309–312. [Google Scholar]
- Rogers GM, Wiser SK. Environment, composition and conservation of coastal turfs of mainland New Zealand. New Zealand Journal of Botany. 2010;48:1–14. [Google Scholar]
- Rogers ME, Noble CL, Halloran GM, Nicolas ME. Selecting for salt tolerance in white clover (Trifolium repens): chloride ion exclusion and its heritability. New Phytologist. 1997;135:645–654. [Google Scholar]
- Rhymer CM, Robinson RA, Smart J, Whittingham MJ. Can ecosystem services be integrated with conservation? A case study of breeding waders on grassland. Ibis. 2010;152:698–712. [Google Scholar]
- Slimestad R, Vågen IM. Thermal stability of glucose and other sugar aldoses in normal phase high performance liquid chromatography. Journal of Chromatography A. 2006;1118:281–284. doi: 10.1016/j.chroma.2006.04.087. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Turesson G. The genotypical response of the plant species to the habitat. Hereditas. 1922;3:211–350. [Google Scholar]
- Underwood AJ. Experiments in ecology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 1997. [Google Scholar]
- Valentim JM, Vaz N, Silva H, Duarte B, Caçador I, Dias JM. Tagus estuary and Ria de Aveiro Salt marsh dynamics and the impact of sea level rise. Estuarine, Coastal and Shelf Science. 2013;130:138–151. [Google Scholar]
- Van Zandt PA, Mopper S. Delayed and carry-over effects of salinity on flowering in Iris hexagona (Iridaceae) American Journal of Botany. 2002;89:1847–1851. doi: 10.3732/ajb.89.11.1847. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Van Zandt PA, Tobler MA, Mouton E, Hasenstein KH, Mopper S. Positive and negative consequences of salinity stress for the growth and reproduction of the clonal plant, Iris hexagona. Journal of Ecology. 2003;91:837–846. [Google Scholar]
- de Vos AC, Broekman R, Groot MP, Rozema J. Ecophysiological response of Crambe maritima to airborne and soil-borne salinity. Annals of Botany. 2010;105:925–938. doi: 10.1093/aob/mcq072. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Wetson AM, Zoerb C, John EA, Flowers TJ. High phenotypic plasticity of Suaeda maritima observed under hypoxic conditions in relation to its physiological basis. Annals of Botany. 2012;109:1027–1036. doi: 10.1093/aob/mcs014. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Wyn Jones G, Gorham J. Intra- and inter-celluar compartments of ions. In: Läuchli A, Lüttge U, editors. Salinity: environment–plant–molecules. Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Kluwer; 2002. pp. 159–180. [Google Scholar]
- Zappa G, Shaffrey LC, Hodges KI, Sansom PG, Stephenson DB. A multi-model assessment of future projections of North Atlantic and European extratropical cyclones in the CMIP5 climate models. Journal of Climate. 2013;26:5846–5862. [Google Scholar]
- Zhu J-K. Plant salt tolerance. Trends in Plant Science. 2001;6:66–71. doi: 10.1016/s1360-1385(00)01838-0. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]

