Li, S., Lauri, A., Ziemann, M., Busch, A., Bhave, M., and Zachgo, S. (2009). Nuclear activity of ROXY1, a glutaredoxin interacting with TGA factors, is required for petal development in Arabidopsis thaliana. Plant Cell 21: 429–441.
The petal phenotype of the three roxy1 alleles (roxy1-1, -2, and -3) was analyzed in detail by Xing et al. (2005). ROXY1, a member of the plant glutaredoxin family, is required for petal development in Arabidopsis thaliana (Xing et al., 2005). All three alleles similarly affect petal initiation with flowers forming only two and five petals on average. In Li et al. (2009), the formation of two and five versus four petals was therefore used as a qualitative trait marker for the categorization of flowers into roxy1-like versus wild-type-like phenotypes. As stated in the article, we presented a number of “typical” and “representative” flower images. However, some of the images were reused without explicit acknowledgment and the legends therefore may be misleading. In addition, an inappropriately duplicated image was shown as a negative control in Figure 2. The details and corrections are described below.
Figure 2.
ROXY1 Interacts with TGA Factors in the Nuclei of Transiently Transformed N. benthamiana Leaves.
The BiFC technique was employed to investigate ROXY1 interactions with TGA factors in planta. The N terminus of YFP (YN) was cloned in-frame upstream of ROXY1. The C terminus of YFP (YC) was cloned in-frame upstream of TGA2, TGA3, TGA7, and PAN individually. Constructs were pairwise transiently expressed in N. benthamiana leaves. Reconstitution of YFP fluorescence was examined by confocal microscopy 3 to 5 d after transient coexpression of protein pairs, and representative pictures are shown. Yellow fluorescence in the nucleus was detected for interactions of ROXY1 with PAN, TGA2, TGA3, and TGA7, respectively. As a negative control, coexpression of YN-ROXY1 with nonfused YC failed to reconstitute a fluorescent YFP chromophore. Bars = 50 μm.
Figure 2: The image for the negative control corresponding to YN-ROXY1/YC shown in bottom left was inappropriately duplicated from the bright-field image shown in upper right corresponding to YN-ROX1/YC-PAN, without the fluorescent overlay. A correction for the negative control image corresponding to YN-ROXY1/YC was previously published in March 2014. Original and corrected versions of Figure 2 are shown. The figure legend is unchanged from the original.
Figure 6: Panel A (upper row, left) shows an image of roxy1-3 that was originally published in Figure 1C of Xing et al. (2005) instead of an image of roxy1-2 as indicated. Panel B shows an image of a roxy1-like flower phenotype that was duplicated from Figure 1B, bottom left, and flipped horizontally.
Figure 7: A wild-type-like flower image of roxy1-2 complemented with ROXY1pro:ROXY1 (Figure 3D, upper left) was reused in Figure 7 (upper row, left) to represent the wild-type-like flower phenotype observed in PAN-SRDX lines.
Figure 7.
Petal Phenotypes Induced by the Chimeric PAN Repressor.
To overcome functional redundancy of TGA factors, PAN was fused to the EAR-motif repression domain (SRDX). Ectopic expression of PANSRDX induced severe defects during flower development (500 flowers, 10 flowers from 50 T1 plants, were examined). Floral phenotypes of 35Spro:PANSRDX T1 transgenic plants grouping into four distinct classes are shown.
(A) Tetramerous wild-type-like flowers with four normal petals (10.6%).
(B) Pentamerous flowers with five normal petals resembling those of the single pan mutant (19.0%).
(C) and (D) Tetramerous flowers with normal, smaller, or folded petals resembled those of the single roxy1-2 mutant (19.6%). The majority of analyzed flowers was pentamerous (50.8%) and developed normal but also smaller (E) or folded petals (F), thus resembling those of the roxy1-2 pan double mutant. Abnormal petals, such as smaller or folded ones, are marked by arrows.
The image shown in (A) was duplicated from Figure 3D, upper left.
The legends to Figure 6 and Figure 7 have been amended accordingly, as shown below; added text is shown in bold.
Figure 6.
Interaction between ROXY1 and PAN.
(A) and (B) show typical petal phenotypes of roxy1-3 and roxy1-2 mutants, where petals remain often smaller or folded. The roxy1-2 pan double mutant (D) to (F) develops pentamerous flowers resembling those of the pan single mutant (C). Additionally, later petal morphogenesis is affected in double mutants that also form smaller (D) or folded petals in (D) to (F), thus resembling later roxy1-2 petal differentiation.
The image shown in (A) is of a roxy1-3 mutant published in Xing et al. (2005), Figure 1C. The image shown in (B) was duplicated from Figure 1B, lower left, flipped horizontally.
We regret these errors and apologize for any inconvenience to readers. To our knowledge, there are no other instances of reuse or mislabeling of images or inappropriate data or image manipulation in this article. Overall, we have faith in these data and to the best of our knowledge the above shortcomings do not compromise any of the conclusions drawn.
All authors are in agreement with this correction, with the exception of first author Shutian Li, who is no longer working in the field and we were unable to contact.
Footnotes
Articles can be viewed without a subscription.
Editor’s note: The corrected figures and accompanying text were reviewed by members of The Plant Cell editorial board based on the information provided by the authors. The authors are responsible for providing a complete listing and accurate explanations for all known errors or instances of inappropriate data handling or image manipulation associated with the original publication.
References
- Xing S., Rosso M.G., and Zachgo S. (2005). ROXY1, a member of the plant glutaredoxin family, is required for petal development in Arabidopsis thaliana. Development 132: 1555–1565. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]



