Skip to main content
EPA Author Manuscripts logoLink to EPA Author Manuscripts
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2023 Dec 1.
Published in final edited form as: Wetl Ecol Manag. 2022 Dec 1;30(6):1291–1302. doi: 10.1007/s11273-022-09891-3

Open SESAME: A Social-Ecological Systems framework for collaborative Adaptive Management and Engagement in coastal restoration and climate adaptation

Kate Mulvaney 1,*, Suzanne Ayvazian 1, Caitlin Chaffee 2, Cathleen Wigand 1, Katherine Canfield 1, Mary Schoell 1,2
PMCID: PMC9836390  NIHMSID: NIHMS1856662  PMID: 36643969

Abstract

The successful implementation and sustainability of many marsh restoration efforts, including coastal adaptation to buffer inundation and mitigate sea level rise, often hinges upon support from surrounding human communities. Yet, stakeholder engagement in these projects remains relatively undervalued and underutilized. We present the Social-Ecological Systems, Adaptive Management, and Engagement (SESAME) framework that provides reciprocal connections between the human and ecological components of restoration efforts and the resulting management and engagement needs. We built and describe this framework through discussion of two case studies of coastal restoration efforts in southern New England salt marshes. The first case study focuses on the use of sediment placement to increase the elevation of the surface of a drowning marsh in Rhode Island as an interim measure to protect against sea level rise. The second case study describes the use of living shorelines for erosion mitigation on a salt marsh in Massachusetts. These cases included significant partner and stakeholder engagement and provided important lessons learned for practical implementation of the SESAME framework. Valuable lessons included the need for engagement throughout the entirety of the process, specific clarification of roles within the restoration efforts, and flexibility in implementation and goal setting.

Keywords: adaptive management, ecological restoration, living shorelines, sediment placement, social-ecological systems, stakeholder engagement

Introduction

Here we highlight the importance of the social components of restoration efforts through a Social-Ecological Systems, Adaptive Management and Engagement (SESAME) framework built from previous work by Bierbaum et al. (2013) and the National Research Council (2011) and the experiences of two coastal marsh restoration projects. Adaptive management that intentionally sets targets and goals, iteratively monitors whether these targets and goals are met, and enables revisions of strategies, has long been a key methodology in wetland restorations and other environmental management (Williams, 2011). The implementation of “collaborative adaptive management” that actively engages a range of stakeholders throughout the process is often critical for the success of restoration projects (Maher et al. 2021; Perry et al. 2020; Bierbaum et al. 2013; SER 2004). Because of this importance, more recently and often less formally, there is an increasing effort to manage restoration efforts as social-ecological systems with an understanding that the resilience of environmental resources hinges upon the integration between ecological restoration and engagement with stakeholders (Convention on Biodiversity 2022; Kibler et al. 2018; Geist and Galatowitsch 1999; Gunderson 1999). A critical component of restoration and adaptive management in an integrated social-ecological system is the engagement of various stakeholders and partners throughout the process (Maher et al. 2021; Olsson et al. 2004).

We report the approaches for the collaborative adaptive management of two restoration projects (sediment placement and living shoreline) through a social-ecological systems lens, with a particular focus on their stakeholder engagement and lessons learned for use in future restoration efforts.

Methods

Our interdisciplinary team of social scientists, restoration practitioners, and coastal ecologists reviewed existing social-ecological systems, restoration, climate adaptation and adaptive management literature for stakeholder engagement and social components within their respective frameworks. We synthesized critical concepts and analyzed these within the context of two case studies to build an applied framework for the integration of engagement and adaptive practices, which incorporate both social and ecological components. This resulted in a formalized structure for the SESAME framework built from and expanding upon the Bierbaum et al. (2013) and National Research Council (2011) frameworks as overlaid with the experiences in two restoration projects. The SESAME framework builds from the primarily ecological components of Bierbaum et al. (2013) and National Research Council (2011) to incorporate social components more explicitly throughout the adaptive management cycle. In addition to active consideration of social components within a restoration project, our framework also builds in the importance of capturing lessons of success related to social goals alongside successfully meeting ecological goals to improve future restoration efforts.

Social-Ecological Systems, Adaptive Management, and Engagement (SESAME) Framework

There is increasing recognition of the need to collaborate in environmental restoration with partners such as NGOs and local community groups, and to diversify engagement approaches with the broader set of stakeholders throughout the adaptive management process (i.e., adaptive co-management or collaborative adaptive management; Susskind et al. 2012, Armitage et al. 2009, Olsson et al. 2004). Butler et al. (2015) outlined the need for partners’ active involvement in implementation as well as the planning phase of restoration efforts. Armitage et al. (2009) highlight the value of adaptive co-management to understand and ultimately respond to stressors in social-ecological systems. In the SESAME framework (Figure 1), while there is often a project lead, stakeholder and partner engagement efforts are essential throughout all phases of the process. These efforts may vary in intensity, duration, and people or organizations involved, but we contend that the success of many restoration efforts requires this collaborative adaptive management. Here, “partners” refers to entities directly involved in a project, while the term “stakeholder” is inclusive of partners and has a broader meaning to include the general public, those directly impacted, technical experts, decision makers, funders, and more. Stakeholders and partners can range from restoration experts in organizations that have worked together for decades to community members whose property borders management sites. It is particularly important to engage populations that have been historically marginalized in environmental management or those who may be directly affected by project outcomes (Douglas et al. 2012).

Figure 1. Social-Ecological Systems, Adaptive Management, and Engagement (SESAME) Framework.

Figure 1.

In the marsh restoration process, there are important opportunities for stakeholder engagement throughout the adaptive management effort from the development of social-ecological system goals and planning to project implementation through monitoring and evaluation. There is also a need throughout the process for monitoring of the social and ecological components to address concerns and enable flexibility for meeting goals. In addition to the importance of monitoring and evaluation to enable adaptations within a project (farthest left circle), there is also a need for reflecting back upon projects to identify social and ecological successes and barriers for the restoration to inform future restoration efforts (subsequent circles offshooting from the first).

Stakeholder engagement is often advocated for in environmental decision making, including ecological restoration efforts, to improve outcomes through information and localized knowledge that stakeholders and partners bring to the process (Maher et al. 2021; Kearney et al. 2007; Beierle and Cayford 2002). It can also build trust and increase acceptance from those who may be affected by management and restoration actions (Armitage et al. 2009; Kearney et al. 2007). Approaches to “stakeholder engagement” range from one-directional communication that informs the public of a decision to empowering stakeholders to make final decisions, with many variations in between that can include consultation, involvement, and collaboration (Conrad et al. 2011; IAP2 2019).

One key to collaborative adaptive management of social-ecological systems is iterative learning and flexible decision making (Olsson et al. 2004; Williams 2011) to deal with the social and ecological uncertainty of restoration efforts within a project and to identify best practices and lessons learned for future application. This often results in necessary adaptations and adjustments to the restoration approach. For example, the baseline monitoring may be motivated by interest from a local community group and its data can be used to set ecological and social goals for the restoration. However, during implementation, additional monitoring or a new stakeholder may identify a previously unidentified concern that call for project adjustments and new goals. The process is not linear and depends heavily on iterative learning to develop best practices for meeting the project goals and future efforts.

In collaborative adaptive management, restoration practitioners, partners, and stakeholders work together to develop the social-ecological system goals and desired outcomes and plan for a restoration effort. Social-ecological system goals include both ecological targets (e.g., number of hectares restored to saline condition or number of plant species observed) and social targets (e.g., bird watching increases at the site or there is reduced flooding of abutting properties). These are often built from the experiences, priorities, and expertise of stakeholders engaged in the process and can reflect a breadth of objectives which may have different levels of subjective importance, including possibly competing overall objectives (Neckles et al. 2015; Williams 2011; Hobbs 2007). Shared goals and objectives can help set targets, guide decision making, allow for improved evaluation that permits project adjustments (Susskind et al. 2012; Hobbs 2007), as well as clarify assumptions and set realistic expectations for what a restoration project will accomplish (Jackson et al. 1995).

The restoration is implemented to meet those targets, objectives, and goals. Implementing plans requires partners and stakeholders to make decisions on siting, methodology, timing, costs, and risks. In these decisions, there are opportunities for deliberative consensus building that can also include conflicts. Implementing a suite of participation and collaboration tools can help increase the success of these efforts by inviting additional expertise, better addressing challenges, and reducing and/or addressing conflicts (Susskind et al. 2012).

Establishing affordable and tenable monitoring and evaluation of restoration efforts is critical for maintaining restored social-ecological systems, understanding the success of restoration projects, and for learning from past ventures (Hiatt et al. 2019, Williams 2011). Individual sites and reference areas often need to be monitored prior to implementing restoration to establish baseline conditions and after implementation to determine if targets are met and decide if adjustments are needed. This iterative process allows stakeholders to evaluate the overall performance of the restoration in meeting both social and ecological goals and to improve future work (Downs and Kondolf 2002). Assessment and monitoring the success of restoration efforts, including social outcomes, is relatively rare but increasing (Wortley et al. 2013). Maintaining such monitoring and evaluation is challenging because of financial, institutional, and logistical limitations (Leslie et al. 2015). Long-term monitoring of both ecological and social impacts is needed (e.g., Konisky 2006, Hiatt et al. 2019, Smith et al. 2021) to learn from the implementation of completed restoration projects or to adapt practices, but these evaluations require a resource commitment that often extends beyond the project’s primary focus and remain under-investigated. Long-term monitoring would also help identify necessary interventions or management efforts needed to maintain the restoration’s objectives.

SESAME Case Studies

Here, we describe the two different restoration projects from southern New England, USA, through the lens of the SESAME framework: a sediment placement project in Ninigret Pond, Rhode Island (Table 1), and a living shoreline project on Martha’s Vineyard, Massachusetts (see Table 1 and Josephs and Humphries (2018) for project details). The Ninigret Pond project was largely successful, and its success was built upon through subsequent restoration efforts in other marshes. The Martha’s Vineyard project had some success in preventing erosion, but also suffered from a number of partner and environmental challenges in the process. We provide information on the specific components of the social-ecological system 1) social-ecological goals and planning, 2) restoration implementation, and 3) monitoring and evaluation, as well as describe the needed adjustments and stakeholder engagement for those three components.

Table 1. Two Restoration Pilot Projects.

Insights from these two restoration efforts were used as the foundation for the development of the SESAME model.

Location Ninigret Pond, Charlestown, RI, USA Sengekontacket Pond, Oak Bluffs, MA, USA
Stakeholder & Partner Engagement Primary Project Partners RI Coastal Resources Management Council (CRMC, project lead), U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Town of Charlestown, Save The Bay- Narragansett Bay, Salt Ponds Coalition Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), Oak Bluffs and Edgartown Shellfish Departments, Felix Neck Wildlife Sanctuary- Mass Audubon, University of Rhode Island
Monitoring Partners CRMC, Save The Bay, EPA, Narragansett Bay National Estuarine Research Reserve, the University of Rhode Island’s Environmental Data Center, Rhode Island Natural History Survey EPA, Shellfish Constables and staff from the Oak Bluffs and Edgartown Massachusetts Shellfish Departments, Felix Neck Wildlife Sanctuary-Mass Audubon, Martha’s Vineyard Shellfish Group, Friends of Sengekontacket Pond intern
Other Stakeholders Local marina users, aquaculturists Friends of Sengekontacket Pond, Audubon visitors and students in educational programs, recreational boaters, recreational and commercial shellfishers
Key Stakeholder Engagement Actions -municipal and local NGO staff included as primary project partners
-presentations to local board and town council
-community outreach by NGO partner
-letters of support solicited from community members and businesses for funding proposal
-public media articles and an EPA blog about the project
-informational signage about living shorelines and project goals at Felix Neck Wildlife Sanctuary
-presentations to the Martha’s Vineyard Conservation Commission and the Felix Neck Audubon Sanctuary staff and volunteers
Goals & Planning Ecological and Social Goals -restore degraded marsh
-build salt marsh resiliency
-dredge salt pond for recreational and navigational use
-prevent erosion and restore eroded marsh area
-investigate the utility of living shorelines for nitrogen mitigation
- maintain salt marsh wildlife and bird habitat for Audubon visitors and students in educational programs
Implement Restoration Restoration Sediment Placement Living Shoreline
Monitor & Evaluate Monitoring Efforts Ecological parameters included: accretion and elevation, vegetation density and height, species community composition, nekton, soil characteristics, water levels
No social parameters were included.
Ecological parameters included: elevation; accretion; vegetation density, diversity, length of dominant species; nekton abundance and biomass; soil and water chemistry; denitrification enzyme activity (DEA) Social parameters included: human attitudes, preferences, environmental values
Adapt & Adjust Important Project Adaptations -adjustment of project design to meet community goals
-re-structuring of contract bid process to ensure completion of restoration goals
-replacement of coir logs and modifications to coir log design as a result of storm damage
-sand amendments and vegetation plantings
Project Outcome to Date Targeted elevations were attained at the restored marsh. Basin and channel were successfully dredged, the trajectory of high marsh graminoid cover was trending higher than the drowning control. Nekton density, bird abundance, and bird community structure appear to be unaffected by sediment placement in the short-term. Soil characteristics still reflect dredged materials and may take decades to reach equivalency of reference salt marshes. Outcomes of this project in Ninigret were used to leverage funding for a separate sediment placement project. Partners and stakeholders succeeded in organizing, designing, and implementing all components of the living shoreline restoration. Alterations to the coir log design were necessary as a result of severe weather events. Two years of shoreline monitoring yielded no significant change in marsh elevation or lateral erosion rates in living shoreline areas compared to control sites. Denitrification rates were higher at living shoreline sites but did not increase over time. Long-term monitoring of the performance of the living shoreline restoration to prevent further marsh edge erosion and remove nutrients was not possible by the project partners. Positive social outcomes were documented in relation to user support of the restoration.

Case Study 1: Sediment Placement in Ninigret Pond, Rhode Island

Ninigret Pond marsh is a back-barrier salt marsh adjacent to a constructed breachway in Charlestown, Rhode Island, that exhibited areas of prolonged flooding, vegetation die-off, and marsh edge erosion compared to reference marshes, resulting from accelerated sea level rise (Figure 2a). Project partners used an adaptive management approach to guide restoration efforts focusing on the entire social-ecological system. In 2014, they convened a project team to set goals and design an experimental approach to monitor and learn about sediment placement as a practice for enhancing degraded marshes and building salt marsh resiliency (related methods outlined in Perry et al. 2020). The project team consisted of stakeholders from federal and state agencies, environmental non-governmental organizations (NGOs), and the town of Charlestown (see Table 1). The town and the watershed organization represented the interests of the pond’s users and residents. Additional outreach was ad hoc, sometimes prompted by regulatory requirements (e.g. NHPA Section 106 tribal consultations, public comment periods, town council approval process).

Figure 2. The two case study sites.

Figure 2.

A) Project partners at the sediment placement restoration site at Ninigret Pond, Rhode Island, USA. B) Coconut fiber ‘coir logs’ were installed to break up incoming wave energy to protect the shoreline from further erosion on Martha’s Vineyard, Massachusetts, USA with assistance of partners and stakeholders.

Social-Ecological System Goals and Planning

The Rhode Island Coastal Resources Management Council (CRMC) and partners identified two ecological restoration goals (restore degraded marsh and build coastal resiliency) and a community goal (dredge Ninigret Pond) for a marsh elevation enhancement project (Table 1). These goals targeted the aspects of the pond that tracked with statewide trends of marsh loss and loss of high marsh habitat, with more than 30 percent permanent vegetation die-off and ponding at the site. The placement of dredged sediment on the marsh surface to increase elevation was an innovative climate adaptation technique to increase salt marsh resilience to impacts from sea level rise and allow for the recovery of the degraded marsh (Raposa et al. 2017). The technique had not yet been piloted in New England but had proven effective in increasing salt marsh vegetation cover, plant height and plant biomass in other regions (Ray 2007). The community goal was a social one and reflected the desire of the Town of Charlestown to maintain the previously dredged sedimentation basins and channel for boating access and improved water circulation. This community goal was communicated previously to CRMC by the Town and NGOs and was one of the reasons Ninigret Pond was chosen as the project site. The site’s degraded marsh condition and location adjacent to a previously permitted dredge area that could serve as a sediment source made it a logical candidate for testing this new climate adaptation methodology.

Project partners developed a funding proposal and identified roles: CRMC was the project lead and funding applicant; Save The Bay (NGO) was the lead for maintenance, planting, and monitoring; the Town was the state and federal permit applicant; and the Salt Ponds Coalition (NGO) served as the primary vehicle for community outreach and obtained numerous letters of support for the funding proposal from community members and local businesses. A more detailed conceptual design was developed in coordination with the project team and iterations were reviewed with the contracted engineering consultant at several team meetings. The main consideration for the design was balancing the volume of material to be dredged to meet the social goal with the amount needed to achieve the marsh enhancement design.

Implementation

Project implementation occurred from November 2016 to March 2017. During implementation of the project, CRMC served as lead for construction oversight of the contractor, conducting frequent site visits and communicating with the contractor as the project progressed. Representatives from the town visited the project frequently and offered feedback on the dredging component of the project. In the project, approximately 30,000 cubic yards of dredged material were placed on approximately 20 acres of marsh for a total cost of about $1.6 million (USD). Costs included design, engineering, permitting, and construction. After the initial dredging and placement phase was completed by the contractor, the CRMC relied heavily on project partner Save The Bay to coordinate the volunteer planting effort and make corrections to site grades and drainage. This organizational and personnel support continued through 2018, and was vital to the success of the project after the contractor had left the site.

Monitoring and Evaluation

In addition to the project design, a comprehensive monitoring plan was developed in coordination by several partners. The plan highlighted the key questions necessary to evaluate the effectiveness of the sediment placement technique. Parameters monitored included vegetation, nekton, birds, soils, water levels, accretion, and elevation. The monitoring plan included a control site at a nearby National Wildlife Refuge so that measurements could be taken before and after sediment placement at both the control and impact sites. Monitoring began in 2016 and has continued through 2021. Monitoring post-sediment placement showed that target elevations for optimal growth of the desired high marsh plants were attained. The added sediment increased the elevation capital and resiliency of the restored marsh to accelerated sea level rise. Dredging of the basin and channel should allow improved boating access and water circulation. Monitoring recorded rapid re-vegetation of bare areas on the restored marsh and by the third year after sediment placement the trajectory of high marsh graminoid cover was trending higher than the drowning control. Nekton density, bird abundance, and bird community structure appeared to be unaffected by sediment placement in the short-term. Soil characteristics (percent organic matter, bulk density) reflected soil characteristics of the dredged sandy sediments and may take decades to reach equivalency of reference salt marshes (similar to Konisky et al. 2006). There was no formalized monitoring of social indicators for this project to identify if boat passage was able to continue or expand or if there has been an increase in recreation, etc.

Based on the success of the Ninigret climate adaptation project, CRMC was able to apply for additional federal funding with considerable financial support from the Town of Charlestown to implement a second sediment placement project on an adjacent marsh system (Perry et al. 2020). Additionally, a number of partners developed a longer-term monitoring plan for Ninigret, which ensured continuity of the monitoring efforts and the ability to evaluate longer-term success of the restoration. Availability of resources (i.e., funds, personnel time, volunteer efforts) will dictate whether longer-term monitoring continues into the future beyond the scope of the funded project.

Case Study 2: Living Shoreline on Martha’s Vineyard, Massachusetts

Fringing salt marsh habitat at Mass Audubon Felix Neck Wildlife Sanctuary (“Felix Neck”) on Sengekontacket Pond (Martha’s Vineyard, Massachusetts) experienced overwhelming vegetation loss and erosion following Superstorm Sandy in 2012, which prompted a request by the Felix Neck Wildlife Sanctuary and Oak Bluffs Shellfish Department to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) for assistance with stabilizing the shoreline. Additionally, concerns were raised about nutrient enrichment, which has largely been attributed to wastewater from private septic systems (Massachusetts Estuaries Report, 2015), and a Total Maximum Daily Load (TMDL) was issued for the Sengekontacket Pond embayment in 2009. Together these partners formed a project team along with stakeholders from local environmental groups and restoration consultants to design a living shoreline that would stabilize and protect the current marsh edge against further erosion and address excess nutrients in the pond.

Social-Ecological Systems Goals and Planning

An initial meeting was convened with partners and a broad stakeholder group (Table 1) to discuss concerns about the vulnerability of the salt marsh and to explore the best available techniques to restore and stabilize the habitat. Stakeholders shared their concerns about Sengekontacket Pond’s northeasterly exposure, which made the salt marsh particularly vulnerable to the increasing frequency and severity of storm activity and sea level rise. They shared their observations following Superstorm Sandy in 2012, where in some areas up to 10 feet of marsh had been carved away, with disconnected clumps remaining in the shallows. The EPA supplemented these discussions with maps quantifying vegetation loss from 2005-2014, as well as historic aerial images of the marsh from 1951, 1969, and 1985. Several factors determined the restoration approach. Partners examined restoration literature (NOAA 2015; PDE 2013; Miller et al. 2015) and consulted with restoration experts to discuss the feasibility of a living shoreline as a nature-based restoration technique. Additionally, the State of Massachusetts’ restoration policies and the Felix Neck Sanctuary’s restriction on the types of materials that could be used to construct the living shoreline shaped the design requirements.

Collectively, partners determined that the ecological goals of the living shoreline restoration were to stabilize and protect the current marsh edge and to evaluate the ways in which a living shoreline could mitigate excess nitrogen in the pond (similar to findings by Chambers et al. 2021 and Onorevole et al. 2018). The social goals were to maintain wildlife habitat and continue to provide educational opportunities for naturalists and local school students visiting Felix Neck. The roles and responsibilities of each partner in the restoration effort were considered during planning. The EPA was the lead partner for the design, implementation, and monitoring of the project. The University of Rhode Island (URI) planned a social-ecological survey to examine stakeholder sentiment and support (Josephs and Humphries 2018). To expedite the start of the restoration project, the Edgartown Shellfish Department prepared the permit for the construction of a living shoreline to the Town of Edgartown. Funds were secured from the towns of Oak Bluffs and Edgartown, Felix Neck Audubon Sanctuary, and EPA. Each of the partners pledged personnel support for the implementation and monitoring of the project, from baseline data collection through the end of the restoration project.

Implementation

The main stakeholders/partners conducted initial site visits to ground truth the potential sites and discuss the living shoreline design, which led to installation during the summer of 2016. For installation, approximately 80 coir logs were used to construct three living shoreline sites along the marsh. In addition, three unaltered areas of shoreline were delineated and served as companion control sites to the living shorelines. Installing the living shorelines required the assistance of 10 to 15 stakeholders during each site installation. Personnel from multiple partner organizations provided input and effort into the construction of the sites, along with stakeholders from the Friends of the Sengekontacket Pond and interested volunteers from the island. Partners and stakeholders also constructed approximately 1000 shell bags from coir material, which were filled with cured oyster, scallop, and clam shells and added along the sides of the coir logs and to undercut areas of the marsh to add stability to the design (Figure 2b). This approach was chosen based on best practices from the living shoreline literature and modified to meet partner requirements that all materials were bio-based. Partner collaboration enabled the recruitment of the large number of volunteers needed for project installation and repair. Also, stakeholder coordination enabled the project to proceed more quickly than would be expected in a less collaborative project.

Adaptive management tactics were required to maintain both the restoration goals as well as the scientific rigor of the experimental design. Repairs and adjustments were made to the coir logs and shell bags over time as they received damage from severe and episodic weather events. Replacement coir logs had a covering with a smaller mesh size making them more resilient, less prone to failure, and a better choice for future restorations. During the summer of 2017, 25 cubic yards of sand were brought in to backfill the living shoreline, and Spartina alterniflora plugs were planted into the sand to provide further stabilization. Project stakeholders were involved in each of these restoration implementation activities. Application for permitting this restoration was registered by one of the partners well in advance of the beginning of the project. It was not clear that approval would have been received for a design using a hybrid approach of hardened and natural fiber structures, as this salt marsh site is situated within a shallow salt pond where multiple user groups participate in recreational activities such as kayaking, wind surfing, and fishing. However, in addition to the use of replacement coir logs with tighter mesh, this project would have benefitted from the use of a hybrid bio-based structure such as oyster castles to attenuate wave energy to extend the durability and effectiveness of the coir logs and protect the shoreline against severe winter storms.

Project success was affected by a failure of the logs to maintain their structure and function through repeated storms and fatigue on the part of some partners, stakeholders, and volunteers to repeatedly repair damage. However, each of these issues created opportunities to work collaboratively to identify solutions.

Monitoring and Evaluation

Project partners developed a monitoring plan to measure the living shoreline’s ability to stabilize the shoreline, remove nutrients, and provide wildlife habitat. Beginning immediately following the living shoreline installation in 2016, elevation, water quality, vegetation, nekton, and soil metrics were measured seasonally at the treatment and control sites through 2018 (similar to Whalen et al. 2011). Monitoring events also created citizen science opportunities to help with data collection and learn about the salt marsh, which contributed to the social goal of providing educational experiences for naturalists and visitors of Felix Neck. During the 2016 summer season, partners conducted surveys with visitors to Felix Neck and other stakeholders (permanent and summer residents of Martha’s Vineyard, tourists, fishers, and boaters) to assess support for the restoration (full details of this study are available in Josephs and Humphries 2018).

Many of the monitoring metrics were labor intensive, requiring both field and laboratory components. The enthusiastic initial willingness to contribute to monitoring from stakeholders during 2016 waned during the second (2017) and third (2018) years. While the partners worked tirelessly to maintain the stakeholders’ interest, the project was time intensive and priorities shifted over time. One challenge was that some of the stakeholders involved in monitoring were volunteers. After preliminary analyses of the 2016 and 2017 data, the scope of sampling was reduced during 2018 to reflect only the most important measures and reduce the intensity of the data collection. Intentional effort was put into communicating the results from the research at a variety of venues including semi-regular meetings with core partners, an EPA blog post, local newspaper articles, scientific meetings, Massachusetts Audubon Society Naturalist Day, and presentations to Felix Neck Audubon Sanctuary staff meetings and the Martha’s Vineyard Conservation Commission. Josephs and Humphries’ (2018) findings from interviews across a wide spectrum of stakeholders indicated that support for this restoration initiative was greatest among those that understood the goals and aims of the project.

This project provided lessons learned on the success of the living shoreline as a restoration technique. Using the three years of monitoring available to assess the success of the living shoreline as a shoreline stabilization and nutrient mitigation technique, neither the living shoreline nor control salt marsh sites demonstrated a significant change in shoreline position or elevation. Additionally, nutrient removal appeared to be higher in the living shorelines throughout the study, but it did not increase significantly over this short timeframe. Longer-term monitoring may have yielded more informative results.

Applying actions that are contained within the framework, most notably stakeholder engagement, active monitoring, a systems perspective, and a willingness to be iterative for both goals and implementation is what allowed the team to identify solutions. The project could not have been completed without the collaborative efforts of partners and stakeholders. While communication between partners and stakeholders occurred at all phases of the project, the process would have benefitted from a coordinator with the primary responsibilities of carrying out strategic planning, communications, goal setting, and assessing needs and commitment capacities of partners and stakeholders. This also could have resulted in designing a procedure for continued long-term monitoring at the sites and earlier communication and decision making about the options for restoration materials.

Conclusions

Both case studies used to develop the SESAME framework incorporated stakeholder engagement through their planning and implementation reflecting aspects of collaborative adaptive management. In both projects, and in other related restoration efforts, because of limited staff capacity of the lead agencies, it would have been impossible to implement projects of their scope and scale without the assistance of other organizations and without community support. Including multiple partners and stakeholders in the process helped to ensure that social as well as ecological project goals would be achieved. Both projects also needed strong relationships with the partners and stakeholders to allow for adaptive implementation of the physical restoration efforts. These projects could have benefited from research guides and brochures designed for the partners and their stakeholders, as well as a communication plan to keep the network of volunteers more actively involved in this project, and to educate the public about the need for and benefit of restoration and coastal resiliency. Reflecting critically through a SESAME framework lens that actively considers both social and ecological aspects of a restoration project throughout the entirety of the process can provide important lessons for future work.

Although stakeholder engagement is often referenced by restoration practitioners as critical to successful project implementation, there is very little documentation on best practices or monitoring of social goals (e.g., Josephs and Humphries, 2018). Here we rely on two restoration projects in the northeast to help build the SESAME framework, although components of this framework are also consistent with other related restoration efforts. Incorporating and learning from both the social and ecological aspects of restoration allow us to better implement future projects that are equipped to address the social and ecological complexities associated with managing coastal habitats and communities in the Anthropocene, a time when coastal communities are threatened by climate change and other anthropogenic stressors. In particular, we highlight the value and challenges of an intentional and thorough stakeholder engagement process throughout the restoration process. The lessons learned from both the social and ecological perspectives of the projects support a framework that better addresses both social and ecological goals and engages partners and other stakeholders throughout a restoration project and for future efforts. The coastal restoration community in southern New England has a long history of collaboration which enables a better SESAME approach into the future if we take the opportunity to monitor, address, and learn from both the social and the ecological components of the restoration process.

Acknowledgments

We are grateful to the three anonymous reviewers of this manuscript as well as Casey Tremper, Mary Clare Hano, Rick McKinney, Marnita Chintala, and Wayne Munns for earlier reviews. The views expressed in this article are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent the views or policies of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. This contribution is identified by tracking number ORD-043859 of the Atlantic Coastal Environmental Sciences Division, Center for Environmental Measurement and Modeling, Office of Research and Development, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. The EPA does not endorse any commercial products, services, or enterprises. The Ninigret project was funded through the Hurricane Sandy Coastal Resiliency Competitive Grant Program NFWF Grant 41739.

Conflicts of Interest:

Mulvaney, Wigand, Ayvazian, and Canfield have all been U.S. Environmental Protection Agency employees for the duration of their work on this research. Chaffee initially contributed to this work when employed by the Rhode Island Coastal Resources Management Council and now when employed by the Narragansett Bay National Research Reserve. Schoell initially contributed to this work as an ORAU Contractor with the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and now as a NOAA Digital Coast Fellow with the National Estuarine Research Reserves. The Ninigret project was funded through the Hurricane Sandy Coastal Resiliency Competitive Grant Program NFWF Grant 41739.

Data Availability

Data sharing not applicable to this article as no datasets were generated or analyzed during the current study.

Literature Cited

  1. Armitage DR, Plummer R, Berkes F, et al. (2009) Adaptive co-management for social-ecological complexity. Front Ecol Environ. 7:95–102. 10.1890/070089 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
  2. Beierle TC, Cayford J (2002) Democracy in Practice: Public Participation in Environmental Decisions. Resources for the Future, Washington, DC. [Google Scholar]
  3. Bierbaum R, Smith JB, Lee A, et al. (2013) A comprehensive review of climate adaptation in the United States: more than before, but less than needed. Mitig Adapt Strateg Glob Change 18:361–406. 10.1007/s11027-012-9423-1 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
  4. Butler WH, Monroe A, McCaffrey S (2015) Collaborative implementation for ecological restoration on US public lands: implications for legal context, accountability, and adaptive management. Environ Manage. 55: 564–577. DOI 10.1007/s00267-014-0430-8 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  5. Chambers RM, Gorsky AL, Isdell RE, Mitchell MM, Bilkovic DM (2021). Comparison of nutrient accrual in constructed living shoreline and natural fringing marshes. Ocean Coast Manage. 199: 105401. 10.1016/j.ocecoaman.2020.105401 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
  6. Conrad E, Cassar LF, Christie M, Fazey I (2011) Hearing but not listening? A participatory assessment of public participation in planning. Environ Plann C. 29:761–782. doi: 10.1068/c10137 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
  7. Convention on Biodiversity (2022) Ecosystem Approach Principles. https://www.cbd.int/ecosystem/principles.shtml Accessed: March 18, 2022 [Google Scholar]
  8. Douglas EM, Kirshen PH, Paolisso M, Watson C, Wiggin J, Enrici A, Ruth M (2012) Coastal flooding, climate change and environmental justice: identifying obstacles and incentives for adaptation in two metropolitan Boston Massachusetts communities. Mitig Adapt Strateg Glob Change 17:537–562. 10.1007/s11027-011-9340-8 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
  9. Downs PW, Kondolf GM (2002) Post-project appraisals in adaptive management of river channel restoration. Environ Manage 29:477–496. 10.1007/s00267-001-0035-X [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  10. Geist C and Galatowitsch SM (1999) Reciprocal model for meeting ecological and human needs in restoration projects. Conservation Biology 13:970–979. [Google Scholar]
  11. Gunderson L (1999) Resilience, flexibility and adaptive management—Antidote to spurious certitude? Conserv Ecol 3:7. http://www.jstor.org/stable/26271703 [Google Scholar]
  12. Hiatt D, Serbesoff-King K, Lieurance D, Gordon DR, Flory SL (2019) Allocation of invasive plant management expenditures for conservation: Lessons from Florida, USA. Conserv Sci Prac 1:e51 DOI: 10.1111/csp2.51 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
  13. Hobbs RJ (2007) Setting effective and realistic restoration goals: key directions for research. Restor Ecol. 15:354–357. 10.1111/j.1526-100X.2007.00225.x [DOI] [Google Scholar]
  14. IAP2 (International Association for Public Participation) (2019) IAP2 Spectrum of Public Participation. [online]: www.iap2.org/resource/resmgr/pillars/Spectrum_8.5x11_Print.pdf Accessed: 3 November 2021 [Google Scholar]
  15. Jackson LL, Lopoukhine N, Hillyard D (1995) Ecological restoration: a definition and comments. Restor Ecol. 3:71–75. 10.1111/j.1526-100X.1995.tb00079.x [DOI] [Google Scholar]
  16. Josephs LI, Humphries AT (2018) Identifying social factors that undermine support for nature-based coastal management. J Environ Manage. 212:32–38. 10.1016/j.jenvman.2018.01.085 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  17. Kearney J, Berkes F, Charles A, Pinkerton E, Wiber M (2007) The role of participatory governance and community-based management in integrated coastal and ocean management. Coast Manage. 35:79–104. 10.1080/10.1080/08920750600970511 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
  18. Kibler KM, Cook G, Chambers LG, et al. (2018) Integrating sense of place into ecosystem restoration: a novel approach to achieve synergistic social-ecological impact. Ecol Soc. 23:25. 10.5751/ES-10542-230425 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
  19. Kirwan ML, Megonigal P (2013) Tidal wetland stability in the face of human impacts and sea-level rise. Nature. 504:53–60. 10.1038/nature12856 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  20. Konisky RA, Burdick DM, Dionne M, Neckles HA (2006). A regional assessment of salt marsh restoration and monitoring in the Gulf of Maine. Restor Ecol 14: 516–525. [Google Scholar]
  21. Leslie H et al. (2015) Operationalizing the social-ecological systems framework to assess sustainability. Proceed Natl Acad Sci 112: 5979–5984. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  22. Maher N, Salazar C, Fournier A (2021) Advancing salt marsh restoration for coastal resilience: a learning exchange. Wetlands Ecol Manage. 10.1007/s11273-021-09841-5 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
  23. Miller JK, Rella A, Williams A, Sproule E (2015) Living shorelines engineering guidelines. Stevens Institute of Technology. [Google Scholar]
  24. National Research Council (2011) America’s Climate Choices. National Academies Press, Washington, DC. [Google Scholar]
  25. Neckles HA, Lyons JE, Guntenspergen GR, Shriver WG, Adamowicz SC (2015) Use of structured decision making to identify monitoring variables and management priorities for salt marsh ecosystems. Estuaries Coast. 38:1215–1232. 10.1007/s12237-014-9822-5 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
  26. Olsson P, Folke C, Berkes F (2004) Adaptive co-management for building resilience in social-ecological systems. Environ Manage. 34:75–90. DOI: 10.1007/s00267-003-0101-7 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  27. Onorevole KM, Thompson SP, Piehler MF (2018) Living shorelines enhance nitrogen removal capacity over time. Ecol Eng. 120: 238–248. DOI: 10.1016/j.ecoleng.2018.05.017 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
  28. PDE (Partnership for the Delaware Estuary) (2013) Living Shorelines in the Delaware Estuary: Best Practices from Lessons Learned and Information Collected by the Partnership for the Delaware Estuary and the Haskin Shellfish Research Laboratory, 2008-2012. PDE Report No. 13–04 [Google Scholar]
  29. Perry DC, Chaffee C, Wigand C, Thornber C (2020) Implementing adaptive management into a climate change adaptation strategy for a drowning New England salt marsh. J Environ Manage. 270:110928. 10.1016/j.jenvman.2020.110928 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  30. Raposa KB, Weber RL, Cole Ekberg M, Ferguson W (2017) Vegetation dynamics in Rhode Island salt marshes during a period of accelerating sea level rise and extreme sea level events. Estuaries Coast. 40:640–650. DOI 10.1007/s12237-015-0018-4 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
  31. Ray GL (2007) Thin layer placement of dredged material on coastal wetlands: a review of the technical and scientific literature. U.S. Army Corps of Engineers ERDC/EL TN-07-1 [Google Scholar]
  32. SER (Society for Ecological Restoration International Science and Policy Working Group) (2004) The SER International Primer on Ecological Restoration. Society for Ecological Restoration International: Tucson [Google Scholar]
  33. Smith RS, Lusk B, Castorani MCN (2022) Restored oyster reefs match multiple functions of natural reefs within a decade. Conserv Lett. E12883 DOI: 10.1111/conl.12883 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
  34. Susskind L, Camacho AE, Schenk T (2012) A critical assessment of collaborative adaptive management in practice. J Appl Ecol. 49:47–51. 10.1111/j.1365-2664.2011.02070.x [DOI] [Google Scholar]
  35. Watson EB, Raposa KB, Carey JC, Wigand C, Warren RS (2017) Anthropocene survival of southern New England's salt marshes. Estuaries Coast. 40:617–625. DOI 10.1007/s12237-016-0166-1 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  36. Whalen L, Kreeger D, Bushek D, Moody J, Padeletti A (2011) Practitioner’s Guide to Shellfish-Based Living Shorelines for Salt Marsh Erosion Control and Environmental Enhancement in the Mid-Atlantic Partnership for the Delaware Estuary. [Google Scholar]
  37. Williams BK (2011) Adaptive management of natural resources—framework and issues. J Environ Manage 92:1346–1353. 10.1016/j.jenvman.2010.10.041 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  38. Wortley L, Hero JM, Howes M (2013) Evaluating ecological restoration success: a review of the literature. Restor Ecol. 21:537–543. 10.1111/rec.12028 [DOI] [Google Scholar]

Associated Data

This section collects any data citations, data availability statements, or supplementary materials included in this article.

Data Availability Statement

Data sharing not applicable to this article as no datasets were generated or analyzed during the current study.

RESOURCES