Butyrate as a promising therapeutic target in cancer: From pathogenesis to clinic (Review)

Abstract

Cancer is one of the leading causes of mortality worldwide. The etiology of cancer has not been fully elucidated yet, and further enhancements are necessary to optimize therapeutic efficacy. Butyrate, a short-chain fatty acid, is generated through gut microbial fermentation of dietary fiber. Studies have unveiled the relevance of butyrate in malignant neoplasms, and a comprehensive understanding of its role in cancer is imperative for realizing its full potential in oncological treatment. Its full antineoplastic effects via the activation of G protein-coupled receptors and the inhibition of histone deacetylases have been also confirmed. However, the underlying mechanistic details remain unclear. The present study aimed to review the involvement of butyrate in carcinogenesis and its molecular mechanisms, with a particular emphasis on its association with the efficacy of tumor immunotherapy, as well as discussing relevant clinical studies on butyrate as a therapeutic target for neoplastic diseases to provide new insights into cancer treatment.

1. Introduction

The human gut contains ~100 trillion microorganisms (1), which form a complex community that influences host physiology, metabolism and responses to diseases by playing a pivotal role in food digestion, nutrient absorption and energy provision. Additionally, the gut microbiota helps to maintain immune system equilibrium and metabolic processes, acting as a protective barrier against pathogenic threats (2). Advancements in sequencing and histological technologies have expanded research beyond the gut microbiota's composition, and the focus has shifted toward recognizing the significance of gut microbiota-derived metabolites in regulating host processes. Among these metabolites, short-chain fatty acids (SCFAs) stand out as prominent end-products of human gut microbiota's metabolic activities. SCFAs profoundly affect various aspects of health, including gastrointestinal well-being, energy utilization, immune system functionality, inflammatory response and the gut-brain axis. Additionally, SCFAs have been linked to a broad spectrum of diseases, including cancer (3-6). A growing body of evidence supports the idea that increased dietary fiber intake can yield numerous beneficial effects, potentially including anticancer properties. This may be attributed to the increased production of SCFAs resulting from fiber fermentation. Conversely, a previous study has observed an ecological imbalance in SCFAs-producing bacteria within the gut microbiota of patients with non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) (7).

One of the most extensively researched SCFAs is butyrate, which is a four-carbon SCFA generated by gut microbiota through fermenting dietary fiber. Butyrate is a critical nutrient for the intestinal mucosa that impacts several physiological functions (8). Among all SCFAs, butyrate has physiological effects at the lowest effective concentration, regulating the host immune system and oxidative stress, and mainly influencing cellular energy metabolism and cell apoptosis through the activation of G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) and effective inhibition of histone deacetylases (HDACs) (9). Therefore, the present review focused on examining the impact of butyrate on cancer and understanding its key mechanisms by elucidating the importance of butyrate in the development and treatment of cancer with respect to immune regulation, inflammatory microenvironment, promotion of tumor cell apoptosis, enhancement of the effectiveness of tumor therapy and protection of the intestinal epithelial barrier function. Furthermore, the present review also summarized existing clinical studies with the aim of providing new approaches for clinical treatment.

2. Overview of the butyrate

The metabolic processes of gut microbiota are responsible for supplying the human organism with the required levels of butyrate (10). Following its synthesis, the majority of butyrate is promptly absorbed by the apical membrane of colonic cells, while a minor fraction is transported to the liver (Fig. 1). The synthesis of butyrate contributes to the provision of the necessary energy for proper physiological functioning in healthy individuals.

Figure 1.

Illustration of the pathways involved in the synthesis, absorption, and metabolism of butyrate. Glutarate, L-lysate, succinate and non-digestible carbohydrates are the four sources of butyrate that the gut bacteria use. It is absorbed and digested by the intestinal epithelial cells. Little amounts of butyrate enter the liver, where it regulates the metabolism of fatty acids.

Synthesis of butyrate

SCFAs are organic carboxylic acids that contain 1-6 carbon atoms and are the primary products of the fermentation of undigested carbohydrates such as resistant starch, oligosaccharides and non-starch polysaccharides utilized by gut microbiota in the colon (10,11). Butyrate is one of the main SCFAs, accounting for ~20% of the total SCFAs (12). It acts as an energy source for the intestinal mucosa, and it regulates cell proliferation and differentiation (13). In total, 225 candidate bacteria potentially producing butyric acid were identified, with the majority belonging to the Firmicutes, Actinobacteria, Bacteroidetes, Fusobacteria and Proteobacteria groups (14). Changes in diet, misuse of antibiotics, ingestion of probiotics and gastrointestinal inflammation infections may alter the ecology and composition of the gut microbiota, thus affecting the production of SCFAs (15,16). Oral administration of Lactobacillus plantarum for 4 weeks revealed an increase in probiotics such as Bifidobacterium, a decrease in conditionally pathogenic bacteria such as Vibrio vulnificus and a significant increase in the level of SCFAs in adults (17). In addition, the temperature and pH levels of the intestinal tract also affect the synthesis of SCFAs (18).

Transportation, absorption and metabolism of butyrate

SCFAs exist within the intestinal lumen as free anions (SCFA^-), exhibiting weak acidity and contributing to the reduction of colonic pH. The majority of SCFAs undergo absorption in the colon, and 5-10% are excreted in feces (19). The absorption of SCFAs by colonic epithelium is facilitated by four mechanisms: (i) Non-ionic diffusion (20); (ii) 1:1 exchange with intracellular bicarbonate (21); (iii) cellular entry through hydrogen-coupled monocarboxylate transporter; and (iv) cellular entry through sodium-coupled monocarboxylate transporter (SMCT) (22). Butyrate primarily functions as an energy substrate for intestinal epithelial cells, supplying ~70% of the energy requirements for colon cells (23). Downregulation of SMCT-1 expression within specific colorectal cancer (CRC) tissues results in reduced butyrate concentration or diminished butyrate uptake in colorectal tissues (24). Butyrate concentration varies in a biological gradient from the intestinal lumen to systemic circulation, reaching a maximum level of 100 mM in the cecum and proximal colon. However, the physiological significance of this change is currently unclear (25). Butyrate that is not utilized by enterocytes is transported by the portal vein to the liver and metabolized, where it mainly participates in gluconeogenesis, ketogenesis and triacylglycerol synthesis, and also exerts anti-inflammatory and antitumor effects through a variety of mechanisms (26).

Detection of butyrate

At present, the assessment of intestinal SCFAs production and bioavailability predominantly relies on indirect measurements, primarily through the quantification of SCFAs concentrations in fecal samples. The main SCFAs detected within feces include acetate, propionate and butyrate. Factors contributing to elevated SCFAs levels in feces include high-fiber diets, reduced colonic transit time and proliferation of SCFAs-producing microbiota (27). In recent years, gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS) has emerged as the prevalent methodology for SCFAs analysis. This technique leverages differences in the adsorption capacities of chromatographic columns for distinct SCFAs, enabling the direct assessment of the relative abundance of each SCFAs in a specimen. GC-MS offers a streamlined and expedited approach (28). Currently, multi-omics analysis is widely used, and the association between diseases and changes in the composition of gut microbiota and its metabolites can be revealed by analyzing the metagenomic and metabolomic differences in gut microbiota between patients.

3. Role of butyrate in tumorigenesis

Butyrate has an extensive and active regulatory effect on human health. In recent years, numerous studies have investigated the antitumor effects of butyrate (29). As a tumor suppressor, butyrate slows down tumor growth by impacting immune, tumor and healthy intestinal cells. The following section summarizes the role of butyrate in cancer (Fig. 2).

Figure 2.

The role of butyrate in tumorigenesis. SCFAs are produced by the intestinal microbiome in the fermentation of undigested food fiber, non-digestible carbohydrates, or resistant starch. Butyrate is one of the major SCFAs. The antitumor effect of butyrate is mainly reflected in four aspects: (A) Modulation of immune response; (B) Influences on the tumor inflammatory microenvironment; (C) Induction tumor cell apoptosis; (D) Enhancement of the immunotherapeutic effect and (E) Protection of the intestinal epithelial barrier function. SFCAs, short-chain fatty acids.

Modulation of immune response

Promoting antitumor intrinsic immunity

Innate immune cells, including macrophages, dendritic cells (DCs) and natural killer (NK) cells, act as the first line of defense against foreign pathogens. Butyrate plays a crucial role in enhancing innate immune responses by promoting cell differentiation. It boosts monocyte differentiation into macrophages, enhancing their antimicrobial and antitumor capabilities (30). In vivo, macrophage activation pathways include M1 and M2 activation. M1 activation yields potent immune effectors, while M2 macrophages dampen immune responses, supporting tissue remodeling and angiogenesis. It has been shown that butyrate suppresses the expression of genes linked to M2 macrophages, hence reducing M2 polarization in macrophages obtained from humans. Butyrate acid's impact on M2 macrophages reduces the colitis caused by exposure to dextran sulfate sodium in mice (31). DCs, which are proficient antigen-presenting cells, are more effective at inducing the transformation of naïve T cells into regulatory T cells (Tregs) when derived from high-fiber-fed mice (32). This is in consistency with the link between high-fiber diets, increased butyrate-producing bacteria and higher butyrate levels. A previous in vitro study revealed that butyrate enhances the activity of NK cells and contributed to the development of liver-resident NK cells (33).

Promoting antitumor adaptive immunity

Butyrate serves as a powerful modulator of adaptive immunity, inducing T cell differentiation and bolstering antibody production by B cells. Butyrate has the capacity to facilitate the differentiation of naïve T cells into Treg cells and stimulate the extra-thymic development of Treg (34). In vitro and in vivo interventions involving butyrate have demonstrated an increase in the count of peripheral blood Tregs, coupled with elevated levels of IL-10 (35,36). Furthermore, butyrate can directly augment the responses of antitumor CD8⁺ T cells (37). Elevated levels of circulating butyrate lead to an upregulation of chemokine ligand 20 expression in lung endothelial cells, subsequently attracting T helper (Th)17 cells to the lung, effectively inhibiting the progression of melanoma lung metastases (38). An increase in the population of IgA-secreting plasma cells in the intestinal tract of mice on a high-fiber diet has been observed to correlate with butyrate-facilitated B-cell class switching (39). It is also noteworthy that butyrate indirectly regulates B cells by influencing other immune cell types, and it has been revealed to increase the production of follicular helper T (Tfh) cells in vivo and in vitro. Tfh cells, in turn, promote the activation and differentiation of B cells into IgA-producing plasma cells (40).

Butyrate plays a pivotal role in regulating the immunological response, facilitating the development and recruitment of immune cells, maintaining immune homeostasis and serving as a crucial intermediary connecting the gut microbiota with the immune system. Furthermore, it is critical to consider the concentration of butyrate exposure to various immune cell types in the body in order to predict the outcome of the immunological response mediated by butyrate in vivo.

Influences on the tumor inflammatory microenvironment

Epidemiological research has demonstrated a clear association between chronic inflammation and ~20% of tumorigenesis (41). Tumor-associated inflammation is widely recognized as a fundamental biological hallmark of malignancies (42). Under normal physiological conditions, inflammation serves as a critical component of the host's immune defense against pathogens and facilitates the repair of damaged tissues (43). However, the prolonged presence of chronic inflammation, causing point mutations, deletions or rearrangements of cellular genes, can ultimately lead to the development of cancer (44). Epidemiological evidence supports the anti-inflammatory effects of SCFAs and indicates that a reduced concentration of SCFAs in fecal matter is associated with an increased incidence of inflammatory diseases and tumors (45). It is worth noting that the anti-inflammatory efficacy of SCFAs varies, with propionate and butyrate demonstrating equivalent effectiveness, while acetate exhibiting the least potency.

Inhibiting pro-inflammatory cytokines and chemokines

Butyrate, a primary anti-inflammatory SCFA, exhibits a multifaceted role in mitigating inflammation (46,47). It inhibits the production of pro-inflammatory cytokines and chemokines, such as IL-6, TNF-α and IL-17, which helps to prevent colon cancer (48,49). In monocytes and neutrophils, butyrate reduces the expression of pro-inflammatory factors, including TNF, IL-2, IL-6 and IL-8, while promoting IL-10 production (50-52). Additionally, butyrate enhances neutrophil cell chemotaxis and phagocytic activity, and regulates the production of reactive oxygen species (ROS) (53-55), collectively mitigating undesirable inflammatory responses (56). Furthermore, in the absence of tissue-damaging inflammation, butyrate strengthens host defenses. It induces mucin and anti-microbial peptide expression in the intestinal epithelium and stimulates IL-18 production by intestinal epithelial cells (57). Inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) incidence and intestinal inflammation are closely associated. Previous research indicates that intestinal butyrate and butyrate-producing bacteria are reduced both before and during the development of intestinal inflammation, and that intestinal inflammation in IBD animal models can be decreased by supplementing butyric acid (58).

Dual rule of inflammatory pathways and inflammasome

Butyrate possesses the ability to inhibit several crucial inflammatory signaling pathways, including the AKT and NF-κB p65 pathways, thereby ameliorating inflammatory responses (59). Additionally, butyrate has been observed to suppress inflammation by inhibiting the expression of cyclooxygenase-2 mRNA in colonic tissues (60). Notably, NLR family pyrin domain containing 3 (NLRP3) stands as the prominently studied inflammatory vesicle in SCFA research (61). Among SCFAs, butyrate exhibits the highest efficiency in the negative regulation of NLRP3, which effectively inhibits macrophage activation as well as the secretion of IL-1β and IL-18 (62). Activation of inflammatory vesicles plays distinct roles in both tumor development and treatment. Butyric acid introduces novel perspectives for tumor control by means of inhibiting inflammasome activation.

Butyrate plays a pivotal role in the regulation of inflammation. Previous investigations have acknowledged that butyrate assumes a dual function in inflammation regulation. This dual role implies that butyrate can exhibit pro-inflammatory characteristics. Notably, in healthy rats, butyrate has been observed to augment neutrophil migration to inflammatory sites (63). Experimental studies have shed light on the mechanism responsible for this paradox. Given that butyrate serves as a primary energy source for colon cells, its impact on cellular processes is concentration-dependent. At low concentrations (0.5 mM), butyrate is primarily utilized as an energy source by cells, with no discernible effect on HDAC activity. By contrast, at higher concentrations (5 mM), butyrate is known to function as an HDAC inhibitor (HDACI) (64).

Induction of tumor cell apoptosis

Numerous studies have demonstrated the inhibitory impact of butyrate on the proliferation of diverse in vitro cultured tumor cell lines, including colon, esophageal, lung, liver and breast cancer cells, while concurrently promoting tumor cell senescence and apoptosis (65-67). This effect exhibits a dose-dependent characteristic, with the extent of cellular suppression manifesting progressively with increasing butyrate concentrations (7). Due to its involvement in the organism's oxidative processes, butyric acid exerts a safeguarding influence on normal cells, thereby promoting cellular proliferation and reducing apoptosis. Conversely, within neoplastic cells, butyric acid exhibits an opposite role, suppressing cell proliferation, facilitating cell differentiation and stimulating apoptosis (7,67). A previous study has proposed a potential correlation between these phenomena and the inhibition of the Wnt/β-catenin pathway by butyrate (68). Nevertheless, it should be noted that butyric acid may reduce the proliferation of distinct tumor cell types via different signaling pathways and mechanisms. Consequently, it is necessary to differentiate between diverse tumor species and pathological subtypes.

Enhancement of the immunotherapeutic effect

Although the advent of tumor immunotherapy has revolutionized cancer treatment, immune checkpoint inhibitors (ICIs) exhibit limitations, with >50% of patients failing to respond to treatment. As a result, there is a pressing need for biomarker exploration to identify potential patients who could benefit from ICI therapy (69). Butyric acid, which has been linked to tumor immunotherapy efficacy, is produced by gut microbiota after breaking down dietary fiber, and enhances anti-programmed cell death protein 1 therapy through CD8⁺ T cell activation (70-73). Higher dietary fiber correlates with improved progression-free survival (PFS) in patients with melanoma treated with ICIs (74). Elevated fecal butyric acid levels are associated with extended PFS and sustained benefits in various solid tumors, such as lung cancer (75-77). This suggests that butyrate can predict tumor prognosis. Previous studies have reported that genes that modulate butyrate metabolism, which is related to butyric acid metabolism, can be used to evaluate the prognosis and drug sensitivity of patients with liver cancer (78). However, some clinical studies have indicated a negative correlation between blood butyric acid concentrations and the effectiveness of anti-cytotoxic T-lymphocyte associated protein 4 (CTLA-4) antibodies. This may be attributed to butyric acid counteracting the accumulation of tumor-specific and memory T cells, as well as CD80/CD86 expression upregulation in DCs induced by anti-CTLA-4 antibodies (79).

Protection of the intestinal epithelial barrier function

Intestinal epithelial cells primarily obtain their energy from butyrate, which also helps to maintain energy homeostasis and regular physiological functions of cells (80). The intestinal mucosal barrier comprises four components: (i) A mechanical barrier; (ii) a chemical barrier; (iii) an immune barrier; and (iv) a biological barrier. These components work collaboratively to prevent the intrusion of pathogenic bacteria. In addition to protecting the mucous layer by encouraging the production of mucin2, trefoil factor 3, and other chemicals, butyric acid can also increase the expression of tight junction protein, which improves the intestinal tract's mechanical barrier performance (81,82). Butyrate influences the chemical barrier by regulating the intestinal luminal pH (83), and safeguards the biological barrier by promoting the proliferation of probiotic bacteria and restraining pathogenic bacteria (84). Regarding the regulation of the immune barrier, butyrate upregulates the production of antimicrobial peptides, including LL-37 and CAP18, while also stimulating the release of IL-18 (85,86). It additionally hinders the production of pro-inflammatory substances (including NO, IL-6 and IL-12) by macrophages that are stimulated by lipopolysaccharide (LPS) (87); furthermore, butyrate inhibits LPS-induced maturation and metabolic reprogramming of human monocyte-derived DCs, which promotes the polarization of naive CD4⁺ T cells into IL-10-producing Tregs, while preventing their polarization into Th1 and Th17 cells (88,89).

By adding butyrate to the diet, one can considerably increase the relative levels of Lactobacillus and Faecalibacterium Prausnitzii to reduce the levels of the pro-inflammatory cytokines TNF-α and IL-6; increase zonula occludens-1 protein expression; promote intestinal barrier recovery; and improve intestinal epithelial cell barrier function. These actions not only prevent the development of CRC, but also significantly improve IBD symptoms and reduce the risk of cancer in patients with IBD. According to a previous study, pathological alterations in the gut did not precede changes in butyric acid levels in patients with IBD. Due to intrinsic alterations in gut microbiota produced by IL-15, there was a lower concentration of butyric acid in the intestinal lumen, which may increase the risk of more susceptible to IBD and CRC (90). These findings provide a theoretical basis for the therapeutic strategy of exogenous butyric acid supplementation. However, it should be noted that butyric acid does not improve existing barrier defects.

In conclusion, the aforementioned studies highlight the pivotal role of butyrate in tumor growth and cancer therapy. A decrease in fecal butyrate levels could potentially serve as a biomarker for both cancer therapeutic effect and prognosis. Currently, the mechanisms for effectively maximizing leveraging butyrate's anticancer properties remain unclear, and therefore, further in vivo and in vitro studies, alongside clinical validation, are imperative to address this matter.

4. Mechanisms of butyrate's biological functions in tumor

The molecular mechanisms governing the tumor-suppressive effects of SCFAs are markedly complex, which can be attributed to their multifaceted interactions with various signaling molecules expressed by colonic epithelial and immune cells (91). Previous research has revealed that butyric acid primarily exerts its anticancer properties through two distinct mechanisms: (i) Activation of cell-surface receptors (GPR41, GPR43 and GPR109A); and (ii) inhibition of HDACs in different cells.

Butyrate acts as a ligand of GPCRs

In animal models, butyrate exhibits anti-inflammatory effects by activating GPCRs (92). GPCRs, also known as free fatty acid receptors (FFARs), can be dose-dependently activated by free fatty acids and are critical drug targets (34). Key receptors involved in the anti-inflammatory and immunomodulatory effects of SCFAs are GPR41 (FFAR3), GPR43 (FFAR2) and GPR109A (hydroxycarboxylic acid receptor 2) (93). These receptors are found in various cell types, with GPR43 predominantly expressed in immune cells; GPR41 mainly expressed in pancreas, spleen and adipose tissue; and GPR109A highly expressed in intestinal epithelial cells, macrophages, monocytes and neutrophils (94-96). All SCFAs activate GPR43 and GPR41, but only butyrate activates GPR109A (97).

Butyrate exerts its anti-inflammatory and pro-immune effects primarily by activating GPCRs on immune and intestinal epithelial cells. For instance, butyric acid suppresses the expression of inducible nitric oxide synthase (iNOS), TNF-α, monocyte chemotactic protein-1, IL-6 and IL-; stimulates neutrophil migration; and modulates ROS production through the activation of GPR41 and GPR43 in macrophages, as well as GPR43 in neutrophils (98,99). Butyrate, via GPR43, promotes the production of IL-10 by microbiota antigen-specific Th1 cells (100). Additionally, butyrate induces the expansion of Tregs, and enhances the expression of IL-10 and IL-18 by activating GPR109A on macrophages and DCs (101,102). It is well-established that the breakdown of the intestinal mucosal barrier contributes to the development of CRC, and butyrate can enhance intestinal barrier function by activating GPCRs (103). On one hand, the combination of butyrate and GPR109A activates K⁺ outflow, leading to cell hyperpolarization. This activation, in turn, triggers the NLRP3 inflammasome, resulting in an increased production of IL-18 and the promotion of intestinal homeostasis (101,104). On the other hand, butyrate activates AMPK, facilitating tight junction assembly and stabilizing the intestinal environment. This occurs through the induction of hypoxia-inducing factor 1 by depleting O₂ levels (93). Additionally, butyrate plays a key role in the regulation of energy metabolism. By interacting with GPR43 and GPR41 receptors on the surface of intestinal endocrine L cells, butyrate promotes the secretion of glucagon-like peptide-1 and peptide tyrosine-tyrosine, which are essential for maintaining energy balance (105,106) (Fig. 3).

Figure 3.

Butyrate plays an anticancer role within the human body through the activation of GPCRs. Its primary mode of action involves the regulation of cytokine production and immune cell functionality, achieved primarily by the activation of GPCRs. This activation serves to bolster intestinal barrier function, strengthen the immune system, mitigate inflammation, govern energy metabolism, and impede the progression of tumors. GPCR, G protein-coupled receptor.

A partial overlap in the mechanisms through which butyric acid governs immune responses and inflammation within the context of GPR41, GPR43 and GPR109A exists (107). In general, GPCRs undergo phosphorylation, causing receptor internalization and desensitization. Activation of GPCRs subsequently triggers downstream signaling pathways, including MAPK, phospholipase C and NF-κB, alongside other cascades, thus promoting the secretion of chemokines and cytokines. GPCRs hold a pivotal role in the regulation of immunity and inflammation; the preservation of intestinal barrier integrity; and regulation of energy metabolism processes due to the diverse effects their transmitted signals exert on various cell types.

Inhibition of HDAC activity in cells

The level of histone acetylation is determined by the interplay between the functions of histone acetyltransferase, which promotes gene transcription, and HDAC, which inhibits it. HDAC is widely expressed in immune, endothelial and vascular smooth muscle cells, and its expression varies in different tumor cells (64). HDACIs were first developed as anticancer drugs. SCFAs, a type of natural HDACI, have been found to exhibit varying inhibitory efficiencies. Butyrate, in particular, has demonstrated the highest inhibitory efficiency (>80%), and its effective inhibitory concentration of HDAC is within the mM range (108,109). The following subsections summarize the genes whose expression is regulated by butyrate (Fig. 4).

Figure 4.

Butyrate exerts anticarcinogenic effects through effecting acetylation. The main types of genes affected by butyrate include: (A) tumor immunity-related genes; (B) tumor apoptosis-related genes; (C) cell cycle control-related genes; (D) tumor-related miRNA; (E) tumor cell metabolism-related genes. miRNA or miR, microRNA; HK, hexokinase.

Enhancement of the expression of immune cell-related genes

SCFA receptors are not significantly expressed in T or B cells; thus, the role of butyrate is more reliant on HDACI activity. Inhibition of HDAC by butyric acid in T cells increases the acetylation of p70 S6 kinase and the phosphorylation of ribosomal protein S6; activates mTOR and STAT3; and promotes the differentiation of T lymphocytes into effector T cells (such as Th1 and Th2 cells) (110,111). Butyrate also promotes the differentiation of T lymphocytes into Tregs, increases the expression of Foxp3 in Tregs, and enhances the stability and activity of Foxp3. This process simultaneously promotes IL-10 production by naïve T cells while inhibiting excessive inflammation and immune responses (36,112).The inhibitory effect of butyric acid on B-cell HDAC activity is dose-dependent, and results in the promotion of B-cell class switching and antibody secretion. Butyric acid upregulates the expression of plasma cell differentiation-related genes such as Aicda, Xbp, Irf4, Prdm1 and Sdc1, and enhances the generation of post-switch transcripts expressed by IgG3, IgG1, IgG2b, IgG2a and IgA (39,40). In other immune cells, butyric acid downregulates the activity of NF-κB, thereby inhibiting its nuclear translocation and increasing the levels of IκB, which serves to ameliorate the regulation of prolonged inflammation. Furthermore, butyric acid reduces NO production in macrophages and intestinal myofibroblasts by modulating the expression of iNOS through the inhibition of the JAK/STAT1 signaling pathway (113). Butyrate inhibits NLRP3 inflammatory vesicle activation, and modulates immune cell infiltration in the pancreas by increasing the acetylation of histone H3K9, H3K14, H3K18 and H3K27 sites (114).

Suppression of the expression of cell cycle-related genes

Cell cycle arrest is a key regulatory mechanism in tumor cell proliferation (115). Butyrate has been found to induce cell cycle arrest in the G0/G1 phase in a dose-dependent manner in vitro in numerous tumors, including colon, liver, lung and bladder cancer, and G1 phase arrest may be one of the mechanisms by which butyrate induces apoptosis (67). Butyrate alters the expression of certain genes that regulate the cell cycle and apoptosis by increasing the level of histone acetylation, such as p21^WAF1/CIP1, c-Myc, c-Myb, cyclin-dependent kinase (CDK) 6, cyclin D1 and cyclin D3, while this effect is not exhibited in other SCFAs (116). Butyrate upregulates p21 protein expression via the p53 and Sp1/Sp3 pathways, and p21 protein induces G1-phase arrest in tumor cells through loss of function upon binding to CDK/cyclin (117,118). In addition to directly inhibiting the expression of p21^WAF1/CIP1, butyrate inhibits the degradation of splicing factor, arginine/serine-rich 2 (SRSF2) through HDAC6 inhibition, which results in the accumulation of acetylated and non-phosphorylated forms of SRSF2, thus promoting the activation of p21^WAF1/CIP1 transcription (119). In addition, butyrate might further induce cell cycle arrest via the PI3K-Akt pathway, and thus cause cell death (120).

Suppression of the expression of apoptosis-related family genes

Butyrate was found to modulate the Bcl-2 family by disrupting the mitochondrial transmembrane potential, activating the caspase cascade amplification reaction and inducing apoptosis in tumor cells (121). Bcl-2 serves as the most important regulator of mitochondrial membrane permeability (MMP), which is localized at the outer membrane of mitochondria. Alterations in MMP lead to a decrease in mitochondrial transmembrane potential (ΔΨm). In the presence of butyrate, Bcl-2 expression is inhibited and the mitochondrial permeability transition pore opens, leading to a decrease in ΔΨm until it is lost, thus disrupting the structure of the inner and outer membranes, and ultimately disintegrating the mitochondrion (122,123). Subsequently, mitochondria release cytochrome c (Cyt c), which forms apoptotic vesicles alongside apoptotic protease activating factor-1 (Apaf-1) and caspase-9 in the presence of ATP, thus activating caspase-3, initiating a cascade reaction and inducing apoptosis in tumor cells (124,125). Furthermore, in breast cancer cells, butyrate-induced apoptosis is accompanied by elevated ROS levels and caspase activity (126). Such mechanism suggests that ROS can induce mitochondrial membrane damage, release Cyt c from damaged mitochondria, and enhance apoptosis via the Cyt c/caspase-3 pathway (127).

Regulation of the expression of tumor cell proliferation, migration and invasion-related non-coding RNAs (ncRNAs)

Butyrate, through the regulation of a complex molecular network that induces apoptosis, exerts inhibitory effects on tumor cell proliferation, invasion and metastasis. For example, 666 differentially expressed mRNAs and 30 differentially expressed long nc RNAs (lncRNAs) were involved in the inhibition of CRC by butyrate. By constructing protein-protein interaction network and competing endogenous RNA networks based on differentially expressed mRNAs and lncRNAs, a series of differentially expressed genes related to the prognosis of CRC were found (66). Butyrate-treated lymphoma cell lines demonstrated increased expression levels of microRNA (miRNA or miR)-101, miR-143 and miR-145, and these differential miRNAs were involved in migration, proliferation and apoptotic processes in lymphoma cells (128). Among the previous studies on the role of ncRNAs in butyrate on tumors, miRNA-related studies are the most extensive. miRNAs are typically 20 nucleotides in length, and they are processed by sequential shearing of precursor transcripts. miRNAs have emerged as important regulators of tumorigenesis, and some miRNAs are novel targets for HDACI. Butyrate, by targeting miRNAs, induces apoptosis, and inhibits tumor cell proliferation, migration and invasion, which is associated with the diverse roles of individual miRNAs within the organism (Table I) (129-134). The construction of RNA predictive molecular networks should be the focus of future research.

Table I.

Summary of miRNAs regulated by butyrate.

miRNAs	Cancer types	Expression	Molecular axis	Functions
miR-203	Colorectal cancer	Up	miR-203/NEDD9	Inhibit colorectal cancer cell proliferation and invasion
miR-17-92	Colorectal cancer	Down	miR-17-92 cluster	Inhibit colorectal cancer cell proliferation
miR-31	Breast cancer	Up	miR-31/Bmi-1	Inhibit breast cancer cell proliferation
miR-22	Liver cancer	Up	miR-22/SIRT-1	Promote liver cancer cell apoptosis
miR-200c	Colorectal cancer	Up	miR-200c/Bim-1	Inhibit breast cancer cell migration
miR-139-5p	Bladder cancer	Up	miR-139-5p/Bmi-1	Activate the MAPK/mTOR pathway. Trigger autophagy and ROS production

miRNA or miR, microRNA.

Regulation of the expression of metabolism-regulated genes

Butyrate inhibits glucose transporter protein 1 expression and promotes hexokinase activity, leading to improved mitochondrial function and oxidative metabolism in lung cancer cells (135). Additionally, butyrate reverses the Warburg effect by blocking the activation of the pyruvate dehydrogenase complex via sirtuin 3 (136).

In summary, butyrate plays an important role by inhibiting HDAC. Butyrate can be readily received by any cell type via SMCT-1 and subsequently inhibit HDAC (24), which is the basic of the butyrate's regulatory role in cells that exhibit low expression of GPCRs. In such cells, butyrate enhances target gene histone acetylation by inhibiting HDAC activity, thus changing chromatin from a dense repressive structure to a relaxed transcriptionally activated structure, which contributes to the binding of transcription factors such as STAT3 and Foxp3 to DNA and initiates gene transcription. The present study reviewed the extensive inhibitory impact of butyrate on HDAC without an in-depth exploration of specific HDAC subtypes. Subsequent studies should consider selectively targeting different HDAC subtypes to elucidate whether butyrate manifests its antitumor efficacy through particular HDAC subtypes.

5. Butyrate-based novel therapeutic strategies

Metabolites in gut bacteria interact with the host in complex ways to achieve multi-level homeostatic control, which has important implications for new therapeutic approaches based on metabolic bionics. Targeting butyrate to restore its abundance has the potential to become a novel strategy for treating tumors. Currently, the main interventions to modulate butyrate include optimizing diet, supplementing with Clostridium butyricum, implementing synergistic antitumor drug therapy and fecal microbiota transplantation (FMT).

Diet optimization

Adjuvant treatments for tumors often involve dietary supplementation with SCFAs. Fiber consumption alters the composition of gut microbiome to a greater extent than other dietary factors and increases the number of butyrate-producing bacteria (15). Direct butyrate supplementation (via capsules or enemas) differs from endogenous butyrate production that is not generated in discrete, punctuated boluses, but is rather coupled to fermentation, which is diurnal and rhythmic (137). Butyrate can selectively modulate gut bacteria. After the resistant starch diet was increased in rats, culturable Lactobacillus and Bifidobacterium were found to increase, while Enterobacterium decreased (138). While promising results have been observed in cellular and animal experiments, the efficacy in humans has been less consistent. Blindly increasing dietary fiber intake does not consistently yield desired outcomes. Clinical trials predominantly center on CRC, melanoma, breast cancer and gastric cancer. These studies investigate the connection between SCFAs, disease progression and prognosis, including the impact of resistant starch and probiotics on gut microbiota composition, SCFAs content and outcome of patients (Table II). However, these studies lack specificity regarding SCFAs types, and their objectives encompass diverse aspects such as treatment and prognosis. Variability in internal and external environments of individuals, timing, dosage and SCFAs sources may introduce bias into the results of note; clinical studies lack uniform criteria for evaluating effects, and challenges remain regarding assessing the impact of dietary fiber and supplementation of SCFAs.

Table II.

Examples of clinical trials exploring the clinical application of SCFAs.

ClinicalTrials.gov ID	Study title	Cancer type	Population	Primary purpose
NCT04700527	The Effects of SCFA Supplementation in Subjects Receiving Abdominopelvic RT: A Randomized Controlled Study	Urinary Cancer, Gynecological Cancer	122	Treatment
NCT05113485	UCLA Breast Cancer Survivor Health Promotion Research Study	Breast Cancer	30	Prevention
NCT04795180	Pilot Randomized Evaluation of Butyrate Irrigation Before Ileostomy Closure on the Colonic Mucosa in Rectal Cancer Patients (BUTYCLO)	Rectal cancer	45	Prevention
NCT04538482	Determining the structural-and Functional-level Effects of Diet-specific Interventions on the Gut-microbiota of a Diverse Sample of Southern United States Adults	Colorectal Cancer	112	Prevention
NCT02819960	Prevention of Irinotecan Induced Diarrhea by Probiotics: A Phase III Study	-	100	Prevention
NCT04807582	Determining the Magnitude of Early Steps of Fatty Acid Oxidation in Cerebral Metastases Using [18F]FPIA PET/MRI	Cancer Metastasis	24	Diagnosis
NCT04005742	The Biomarkers of Risk of Colorectal Cancer (BORICC) Follow-Up (BFU) Study (BFU)	Colorectal Cancer	47	Prevention
NCT03781778	Randomized, Controlled Trial of Resistant Starch in Stage I-Ill Colorectal Cancer Survivors Pilot Study: The Fiber for Health After Cancer Study	Colon Cancer, Rectal Cancer	10	Prevention
NCT05039060	A Modified Microbiota-Accessible Carbohydrates (MAC) Diet and Change of Gut Microbiota in Patients with Colorectal Cancer After Surgery: A Prospective, Open-label, Cross-over, Single Center Study	Colorectal Cancer	40	Treatment
NCT05205187	Multi-center and Multi-omics Mechanism Research of Gut Microbiota and Metabonomics in Borrmann Type IV Gastric Cancer	Stomach Cancer	450	Diagnosis
NCT03531606	The Effects of Mechnikov Probiotics on Symptom and Surgical Outcome After Anterior Resection of Colon Cancer; Double-blind, Randomized, Placebo-controlled Trial	Sigmoid Colon Cancer	68	Treatment
NCT04988841	Prospective randomized Clinical Trial Assessing the Tolerance and Clinical Benefit of fecal transplantation in patients with melanoma Treated With CTLA-4 and PD1 Inhibitors	Melanoma	60	Treatment

SFCAs, short-chain fatty acids.

Clostridium butyricum supplementation

Clostridium butyricum is an anaerobic bacterium classified as a probiotic due to its production of butyric acid (139). CBM588, a live bacterial product, includes Clostridium butyricum, which was originally identified by Chikaji Miyairi in 1933 in healthy human feces. This non-pathogenic and non-toxic bacterium has gained widespread use in Japan, Korea, China and Europe (140). Administration of CBM588 in combination with antitumor therapy may result in increased efficacy. A retrospective study revealed a significant and positive association between CBM588 and PFS and overall survival in patients with NSCLC receiving ICIs (141). The beneficial effect of CBM588 was even more pronounced in patients receiving antibiotic therapy (142). In an open, single-center study (NCT03829111), CBM588 significantly prolonged PFS in patients with metastatic renal cancer who had been treated with nivolumab-ipilimumab and increased the response rate to treatment (143). CBM588 exerts direct antitumor effects by inducing polymorphonuclear neutrophils in the bladder to release substantial quantities of apoptosis-inducing ligands, thus achieving antitumor effects (144). Moreover, CBM588 modulates the structure and composition of gut microbiota, leading to a lower incidence of colitis-associated colon cancer (145). These findings strongly support the hypothesis that CBM588 may be a safe and efficient treatment for oncological diseases. Clinical trials related to Clostridium butyricum and oncology therapy are summarized in Table III and additional information can be found in the ClinicalTrials. gov database.

Table III.

Examples of clinical trials exploring the clinical application of clostridium butyricum.

ClinicalTrials.gov ID	Study title	Cancer type	Drugs	Population	Primary purpose
NCT02771470	Intestinal Microflora in Lung Cancer After Chemotherapy	Lung cancer	Probiotics, containing Clostridium butyricum	41	Supportive care
NCT03922035	A Randomized Open Label Pilot Study of Clostridium Butyricum MIYAIRI 588 (CBM588) in Recipients of Allogeneic Hematopoietic Stem Cell Transplantation	Hematopoietic and Lymphoid Cell cancer	CBM588 Probiotic Strain	36	Supportive care
NCT02169388	Effects of Gut Microflora on the Immune and Nutritional Status of CRC Patients After Chemotherapy	Gastrointestinal Neoplasm, Colorectal Cancer	Probiotics, containing Clostridium butyricum	30	Supportive care
NCT03829111	Pilot Study to Evaluate the Biologic Effect of CBM588 in Combination with Nivolumab/Ipilimumab for Patients with Metastatic Renal Cell Carcinoma	Renal cell carcinoma	CBM588 Probiotic Strain	30	Treatment
NCT05122546	Pilot Study to Evaluate the Biologic Effect of CBM588 in Combination with Cabozantinib/Nivolumab for Patients with Metastatic Renal Cell Carcinoma	Renal Cell Carcinoma	CBM588 Probiotic Strain	30	Treatment
NCT05914389	Induction Chemotherapy Combined with Neoadjuvant Immunotherapy for MSS Colon Cancer: A Prospective Single-center Multi-arm Open-label Randomized Phase II Study	Colon Cancer	Clostridium butyricum	100	Supportive Care
NCT04688242	A Randomized, Phase 2 Study of Anal Dilatation Plus Probiotics Before Ileostomy Reduction for Low Anterior Resection Syndrome After Sphincter-preserving Proctectomy	-	Clostridium butyricum	164	Treatment
NCT05759741	Alterations of Gut Microbiome, Function and Its Intervention After Total Mesorectal Excision with Dysfunctioning Ileostomy for Mid-low Rectal Cancer	Rectal Cancer	CBM588 Probiotic Strain	64	Treatment

Adjuvant antitumor therapy

Butyrate has not shown side effects or drug toxicity in previous animal studies. However, its brief half-life and unpleasant odor render it unsuitable for direct use as a chemotherapeutic agent (146). Alternative viable strategies involve the utilization of oral butyrate analogs, derivatives, or administration techniques at nanometer level to enhance bioavailability and mitigate olfactory irritation (147,148). Furthermore, butyrate not only alleviates the side effects associated with conventional chemotherapeutic agents such as oxaliplatin, irinotecan and 5-fluorouracil (149-151), but it also enhances the efficacy of both chemotherapy and immunotherapy (128). This has increased the interest in research on butyrate as an adjuvant therapy. Notably, certain conventional drugs can act synergistically with oncological treatments by influencing the body's butyrate concentration. For example, metformin has been demonstrated to enhance the biosynthesis of butyrate while concurrently inhibiting the progression of CRC (152), while safranin has been observed to augment the prevalence of butyrate-producing bacterial strains such as Allobaculum, Butyricoccus and Phascolarctobacter. This augmentation contributes to the increased production of butyrate, which has proven efficacious in preventing the recurrence of colorectal adenoma (153). The identification of effective biomarkers offers a potential solution to the challenge of heterogeneous response rates observed in immunotherapy across different tumor types. Considering the non-invasive nature of fecal examination, butyrate is anticipated to serve as an independent predictor of immunotherapeutic response for a diverse spectrum of malignancies. This could encompass the successful stratification of responders and non-responders to immune checkpoint inhibition through metabolomics analyses, or as a therapeutic target for improving the efficacy of ICIs in the treatment of specific tumors. In order to produce more accurate pharmacokinetic, absorption, distribution and metabolic data, organoids can simulate human-specific metabolic pathways, cell interactions and tissue responses more effectively (154). In a study linking butyric acid to colon cancer organoids, butyrate enhanced the efficacy of radiotherapy while protecting the normal mucosa, thus minimizing the associated toxicity of radiotherapy. Butyrate significantly enhanced radiation-induced cell death and enhanced treatment effects compared with administration of radiation alone. Notably, butyrate did not increase radiation-induced cell death and improved regeneration capacity after irradiation in normal organoids (155,156). Butyrate can increase the uptake of serotonin by mouse ileal organoids and alleviate gastrointestinal reactions by providing energy to cancer patients given radiation therapy (157). In liver organoids, butyrate could reduce drug-induced hepatotoxicity by improve metabolic activation (158).

FMT

Another alternative that may promote the generation of butyric acid and combat cancer is FMT. FMT decreases the diversity of gut microbiota in patients with colon cancer and promotes the growth of gastrointestinal tumors in mice (159). Conversely, FMT in wild-type mice alleviates CRC induced by dextran sulfate sodium or azoxymethane (160). Restoring the intestinal flora disturbed by FOLFOX (5-fluorouracil, leucovorin and oxaliplatin) therapy in mice receiving healthy donor feces decreased diarrhea and intestinal mucosal inflammation (161). FMT offers a wide range of potential applications in tumor therapy because it is the most direct method of altering the microbiome and directly increasing the bacteria that produce butyrate. However, FMT has the potential to disperse hazardous bacteria. Certain FMT materials have been linked to the production of autoimmune disorders in animal studies due to their microbiome (162). Thus, FMT donors should undergo thorough screening, questioning regarding their family history and previous illness, as well as fecal testing for potential parasites in order to minimize these risks.

The role of butyrate in helping to develop personalized anticancer strategies cannot be overstated. However, each of the aforementioned therapeutic approaches necessitates meticulous evaluation within patient cohorts prior to their clinical implementation. This rigorous scrutiny will not only advance the current understandings of human pathophysiology but also increase the current knowledge about complex metabolite-target group interactions and therapeutic associations, and such insights are instrumental in the refinement of clinical treatment protocols.

6. Conclusion and future perspectives

Butyrate, as one of the important SCFAs, is a key metabolite linking dietary fiber and gut microbiota, and plays a key role in establishing and maintaining homeostasis in the intestinal internal environment. The majority of previous in vivo and ex vivo studies have demonstrated that butyrate can function as a crucial molecular signal of GPCRs, and as a substrate for HDAC inhibitors and acetyl coenzyme A to promote protein acetylation. Additionally, butyrate plays a role in inflammation, immunity and cell proliferation, and differentiation, thus affecting tumor development. Butyrate may serve as an independent predictor of immunotherapeutic response in various types of cancer and as a therapeutic target for improving the efficacy of ICI therapy.

There are certain limitations in the currently available studies on butyrate and tumors. Firstly, the majority of data originate from animal studies, in vitro assays and preclinical trials, rendering the evidence in human patients inconclusive. Consequently, the role of butyrate in human energy and substrate metabolism necessitates further validation. Currently, the majority of studies on butyrate and its association with tumors is predominantly focused on CRC; thus, its applicability to other cancer types remains obscure. In terms of clinical application, the mechanism of action, safety, tolerability and optimal beneficial dose of butyrate still need further research. Secondly, the production of butyrate is directly impacted by gut microbiota, and investigating strategies to regulate it could aid in the creation of tailored tumor treatments. In a broader sense, future endeavors should concentrate on manipulating the gut microbiome and/or metabolome to adjust intestinal microecology, which could induce strong antitumor effects. This field of research is currently under development and requires important advancements on various fronts. For example, sophisticated methods are necessary to decode complex flora and their metabolites, and it is crucial to expand techniques for the identification of metabolites from metabolomic data through the combination of macro-genomics, culturomics and synthetic biology technologies. These promising technologies are expected to provide safer and more practical approaches for tumor treatment, greatly reducing cost, increasing-effectiveness and benefiting patients.

Abbreviations

SCFA

short-chain fatty acid

GPCR

G protein-coupled receptor

HDAC

histone deacetylase

NSCLC

non-small cell lung cancer

CRC

colorectal cancer

SMCT

sodium-coupled monocarboxylate transporter

DC

dendritic cells

NK

natural killer cells

Treg

regulatory T cells

LPS

lipopolysaccharide

HDACI

HDAC inhibitor

lncRNA

long non-coding RNA

miRNA

microRNA

Cyt c

Cytochrome c

CDK

cyclin-dependent kinase

IBD

inflammatory bowel disease

FMT

fecal microbiota transplantation

Funding Statement

The present study was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (grant no. 82203056), the Natural Science Foundation of Liaoning (grant no. 2023-BS-167), the Science and Technology Talent Innovation Support Plan of Dalian (grant no. 2022RQ091) and the '1+X' program for Clinical Competency Enhancement-Clinical Research Incubation Project of the Second Hospital of Dalian Medical University (grant no. 2022LCYJYB01).

Availability of data and materials

Not applicable.

Authors' contributions

JS mainly collected the related studies and drafted the manuscript. JS, HS and YS prepared the figures. HS, DZ and SC helped to revise the manuscript. JC participated in the conception of the article. All authors read and approved the final version of the manuscript. Data authentication is not applicable.

Ethics approval and consent to participate

Not applicable.

Patient consent for publication

Not applicable.

Competing interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.