Skip to main content
The BMJ logoLink to The BMJ
. 1998 Nov 28;317(7171):1527.

Rationing

Introduce new category of prescription charges, “full cost medicines”

Peter Ramsay-Baggs 1
PMCID: PMC1114358  PMID: 9831600

Editor—In the wake of the controversies surrounding the approval of sildenafil citrate1,2 and orlistat3 perhaps the time has come for the introduction of a new category of NHS prescription drugs, “full cost medicines.” Such medicines would be prescribed by the patient’s general practitioner, but the patient would pay the full cost plus the dispensing fee. This system would have many advantages, including maintaining the relationship between the general practitioner and the patient, suppressing misuse of expensive and possibly recreational drugs, keeping down the cost of such medicines because of the purchasing power of the NHS, and educating patients about the cost of pharmaceutical products and thus potentially opening up the debate on rationing of health care.

This proposal is not as radical as it sounds. We already have a model for such a system in the provision of NHS dentistry, with patients being expected to pay the full cost of their treatment up to a maximum of £340. If this charge is acceptable for the maintenance of dental health surely around £5 is acceptable for the maintenance of sexual health.

Footnotes

omfs@compuserve.com

References

BMJ. 1998 Nov 28;317(7171):1527.

The word must be used and the government must give a stronger lead

Philip Gaskell 1

Editor—I applaud the BMJ’s consistency over time in proclaiming the need for the rationing debate to be more explicit1-1 and to involve the public, as has happened elsewhere. What we have so far failed to address is how the current government may be let off the hook it is stuck on through not being prepared to use the word “rationing.” As general practitioners contemplate involvement in primary care groups and local healthcare cooperatives they need political leadership. Those who still live in the comfort of being only patient’s advocate or hoping for further increases in health expenditure must face up to the reality that exists the world over in developed countries and persuade this government to share the responsibility for making choices and creating priorities as best we can, now.

I wish to retain my patients’ trust but need that sharing of responsibility with the government, purchasers, colleagues, and the public in a spirit of honest doubt and where there are few black and white decisions to be made.

Footnotes

administrator@GP70304.lothian-hb.scot.nhs.uk

References


Articles from BMJ : British Medical Journal are provided here courtesy of BMJ Publishing Group

RESOURCES