Abstract
Study Objectives:
As in many other Low and Middle Income Countries (LMICs) around the world, sleep disorders in the Kyrgyz Republic remain mostly undiagnosed and untreated. This article aims to describe the current state of practice of sleep medicine in the Kyrgyz Republic from the perspective of local and international health care workers who are active in the field and to propose a strategy to challenge the status quo.
Methods:
We performed a policy analysis and interviewed local doctors working in the field.
Results:
We identified 3 major barriers to the practice of sleep medicine and namely education and training, financial constraints and infrastructure and equipment. We then propose a multistep strategy to improve the current situation based on 3 pillars: knowledge sharing, implementation research activities and policy changes.
Conclusions:
Despite being at its early days and facing major challenges, sleep health in the Kyrgyz Republic is being recognized as a priority by health care workers in the field and now requires attention at local and government level. Furthermore, north-south academic partnerships represent an effective tool for knowledge sharing and should be further incentivised.
Citation:
Cirri L, Bolotbek uulu A, Shakiev N, et al. Sleep medicine in the Kyrgyz Republic: past, present, and future. J Clin Sleep Med. 2024;20(7):1213–1216.
Keywords: sleep medicine, global health, low- and middle-income countries, non-communicable diseases
BRIEF SUMMARY
Current Knowledge/Study Rationale: Sleep medicine in the Kyrgyz Republic is an underdeveloped clinical specialty. Attitudes and knowledge of Kyrgyz physicians about sleep medicine have not been explored yet and challenges to the development of sleep medicine as a clinical specialty have not been reviewed.
Study Impact: We report our field experience and the results of interviewing local doctors. We describe barriers to the development of sleep medicine in the Kyrgyz Republic and formulate a multistep strategy for its future development.
INTRODUCTION
The Kyrgyz Republic (KR) is a low- and middle-income country landlocked in central Asia. It has a population of 6.8 million people and its gross domestic product per capita currently amounts to 1,607 United States Dollars per year.1 Until the country reached its independency in 1991, it was part of the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics and still maintains tight cultural and academic bonds with the neighboring Ex-Union of Soviet Socialist Republics countries of Kazakhstan, Tajikistan, and Uzbekistan.2 The KR is a young country with an average age of 28.3 years and a life expectancy at birth of 71.8 years.1,3 Despite the young age, obesity remains a serious problem among the adult population. In 2020, 41.3% of men and 34.3% of women were overweight, with 13.7% of women and 8.7% of men being significantly overweight.4 Ischemic heart disease and stroke are by far the 2 major causes of mortality.5
The KR finances its public health care system through general taxation and its health expenditure per capita is one of the lowest in the World Health Organization European Region.6,7 Due to limited financial resources, its health care system faces significant challenges, including inadequate infrastructure and equipment, lack of medications, and a shortage of qualified medical personnel. As a result, an increasing number of private medical institutions are emerging in the country to allow Kyrgyz patients to avoid the faults of the public system. As of December 31, 2021, there were 1,758 private health care organizations licensed in the KR, including 123 hospitals and 159 day hospitals. Voluntary health insurance is virtually nonexistent, and private spending is almost entirely in the form of out-of-pocket expenditure, including informal payments, accounting for 46.3% of the health expenditure in 2019.6
The distribution of health care workers in Kyrgyzstan is uneven, with significant disparities between regions, particularly in rural areas where shortages of both specialists and family doctors are common. In 2021, the highest concentrations of physicians were found in the capital, Bishkek, and the second major city, Osh, with 225 and 246 physicians per 100,000 people, respectively. On the other side, in rural areas, the number of physicians was as low as 70 per 100,000 population, equivalent to only 1 physician for every 1,429 people.6
There are currently 23 medical schools in the country, 6 of them are governmental institutions and 17 are private medical schools. The number of medical schools increased from 4 in 2010 to 23 in 2022, accompanied by an increase in the number of admitted students. Thanks to its affordable education and liberal immigration policies, in the last decade the KR has become a hub for medical education in Asia, attracting medical student from abroad, mostly from populous central and south Asian countries. In 2020–2021, there were overall 36,845 students (approximately 20,000 from abroad, mainly India and Pakistan) in undergraduate medical education. Annually approximately 4,200 medical students graduate.6
This article aims to describe the current state of practice of sleep medicine in the KR from the perspective of health care workers who are active in the field and to propose a strategy to challenge the status quo.
SLEEP MEDICINE IN THE KR
There is no published data on sleep health in the KR, neither at general not at specific population level.8 This fact collides with the clinical experience of Kyrgyz doctors, both in primary and in secondary care, who have been recognizing the relevance of sleep disorders in their daily practice for a while already.
To date, no postgraduate curriculum in sleep medicine is available and there is formally no sleep specialist in the country. Patients with suspected sleep disorders are treated by close specialties like neurology, psychiatry, and respiratory medicine. However, the latter are also a rare good as the KR faces a shortage of medical specialists. As an example, only about 50 specialists in adult respiratory medicine are currently practicing in the country, most of them in the major urban centers.
The only inpatient sleep lab in the whole country has been established in January 2022 and is located within the Department of Respiratory Medicine at the National Center of Cardiology and Internal Medicine, Teaching Hospital of the Kyrgyz State Medical Academy in Bishkek. It has a total of 2 beds, which are fully equipped with a polysomnography, donated by the University Hospital of Zurich, Switzerland. Other than this, there are only 3 privately owned facilities which offer home polygraphies, 2 of them based in Bishkek and 1 in Osh. Each of them is a monospecialty center and no multidisciplinary evaluations of sleep patients are offered. There is no availability of pediatric, surgical, and dental sleep specialists in the country.
Apart from 1 national protocol from the ministry of health about diagnostic criteria for sleep apnea,9 there are no clinical guidelines available on how to screen, diagnose, or treat patients with sleep disorders and the decision is left up to the treating physicians. International guidelines are rarely followed. Based on our clinical experience, hypnotic medications are widely prescribed as first line treatment instead of cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia.
The Swiss-Kyrgyz Research Initiative on Sleep Health (SKySH)
The SKySH is a North-South academic partnership established in 2022 from a group of researchers from Switzerland and the KR with a special interest in sleep medicine. The general scope of this collaboration is to foster implementation research activities in primary and secondary care in the KR to improve the diagnosis, management, and prognosis of patients suffering from sleep disorders and to build a robust platform for collaborative research with similar low-resource settings in central Asia. This program was established to address the lack of government-sponsored research activity in the field of sleep medicine and to advocate for better sleep care in the country. The Kyrgyz team is based at the National Center of Cardiology and Internal Medicine in Bishkek and the European team is based in Switzerland and the United Kingdom.
Knowledge and attitude of Kyrgyz physicians toward sleep medicine
Aiming to define research priorities and set up an agenda for the upcoming years, the SKySH team asked Kyrgyz physicians from different specialties to complete a questionnaire about their knowledge and attitudes toward sleep medicine. The questionnaire was administered online during the first Sleep Medicine Symposium organized by SKySH, which took place on December 17, 2022 in Bishkek.
Of the 61 physicians attending the symposium, 51 (84%) completed the survey. They were primary care doctors (33%) and specialists (67%). Ninety-two percent of participants knew what obstructive sleep apnea is, but only 70% of them knew how to diagnose it and only 44% knew how to treat it. Eight-nine percent of participants knew what insomnia is, but only 48% knew how to diagnose it and only 30% knew how to treat it (Figure 1). Sixty-seven percent of participants do not have the possibility to diagnose and treat sleep disorders in their medical facility and 98% of them would like to be able to refer sleep patients to a specialized center for diagnosis and treatment. Seventy-seven percent of interviewees stated that they did not receive sufficient training in sleep disorders from medical school and/or residency and 91% of them would like to receive additional training.
Figure 1. Kyrgyz physicians’ knowledge of 2 major sleep disorders.
OSA = obstructive sleep apnea.
In conclusion, Kyrgyz physicians know about the existence of sleep disorders, but lack knowledge about their screening, diagnosis, and treatment. Most importantly, however, they recognize the relevance of sleep medicine in their daily practice and are willing to receive additional training in this field.
BARRIERS TO THE PRACTICE OF SLEEP MEDICINE
We identified 3 barriers to the implementation of sleep medicine in the KR: education and training, financial constraints, and infrastructure and equipment.
Education and training
Both primary care and specialist doctors do not currently receive sufficient training in sleep medicine during their medical school and residency; even simple tools like screening questionnaires for sleep disorders are not in use. Moreover, patients and public are not aware of the health care consequences of untreated sleep disorders and tend not to seek medical help when suffering from sleep disturbances.
Financial constraints
The Kyrgyz public health service does not cover the cost to perform sleep studies nor to treat sleep disorders. An overnight respiratory polygraphy costs approximately 5,000 soms (approximately 56 United States dollars). In case a continuous positive airway pressure machine is needed, patients are obliged to buy the machine for a cost of 45,000–130,000 soms (approximately 500–1,450 United States dollars). These costs are entirely paid by patients out of their pockets and there is no reimbursement from the national health service. Many patients, whose average monthly salary in 2022 was 26,540 soms (approximately 297 United States dollars) cannot afford to pay for these costs and remain undiagnosed and/or untreated.
Infrastructure and equipment
There is currently a lack of sleep clinics in the country, with only 1 inpatient and 2 outpatient facilities, located in the capital city of Bishkek, and 1 outpatient facility in Osh. In other cities and rural centers there is a total lack of sleep facilities. Also, the availability of medical equipment like diagnostic polygraphies and polysomnographies and continuous positive airway pressure machines is limited. Most devices are imported from foreign companies and many of them are not registered medical devices in the country. Also, there is no infrastructure to follow up continuous positive airway pressure patients in the communities.
FUTURE PERSPECTIVES
SKySH proposes a multistep strategy to improve the current state of sleep medicine in the KR, based on 3 pillars: knowledge sharing, research activities, and advocating for policy changes.
Knowledge sharing
Education of Kyrgyz health care workers, including primary care physicians, should be the number one priority. Sleep medicine should become a compulsory subject in medical schools and a postgraduate training curriculum in sleep disorders should be established and recognized nationally. The SKySH has already started the implementation of an educational program that includes sleep medicine lectures for residents in respiratory medicine. The implementation of at least 1 compulsory short course on sleep medicine in medical schools’ curricula would have also a potential benefit to other central and south Asian countries as two-thirds of medical students in Kyrgyz universities come from abroad and will go back to practice in their home countries after graduation. The course should address the multidisciplinary of sleep medicine and raise awareness on the health care effects of untreated sleep disorders.
There also needs to be a patient and public involvement strategy in place to raise awareness on the importance of sleep for general health. This may include educational activities in public schools and a social media strategy. In addition, patient and public should be involved in any performed academic activity.
Furthermore, the establishment of international partnerships, especially with institutions from countries where sleep medicine is at a more advanced stage should be incentivized. Within this framework, the organization of international symposia and exchange opportunities abroad for Kyrgyz doctors and allied health professionals should be prioritized.
Research activities
Clinical research studies should be performed in the KR to assess the local burden of disease, understand local priorities, implement and evaluate tailored interventions. Till date, research activities relied on international partnerships and funds. Kyrgyz researchers who have been trained in these frameworks should now be financially incentivized to independently develop their research agenda.
Advocating for policy changes
Advocating for policy change at local, regional, and governmental level is a major necessity to improve sleep health in the country. Therefore, an independent sleep medical society should be established to protect and represent the interests of health care professionals working in sleep medicine. This should primarily advocate for policy changes regarding reimbursement of diagnostics and treatments and improve local technical infrastructure, including the import and regulation in the country of medical devices used to treat sleep disorders.
CONCLUSIONS
Sleep medicine in the KR is in its early days and faces major challenges. An international and interdisciplinary effort is needed to further develop sleep medicine in the country. Knowledge sharing through North-South partnerships, implementation research activities, and reimbursement strategies should be on the agenda of the local government.
DISCLOSURE STATEMENT
All authors have seen and approved this manuscript. The authors report no conflicts of interest.
REFERENCES
- 1. The World Bank . The World Bank in the Kyrgyz Republic. Overview ; 2022. https://www.worldbank.org/en/country/kyrgyzrepublic/overview . Accessed March 10, 2024.
- 2. Kyrgyzstan - the World Factbook [updated April 9, 2024]. https://www.cia.gov/the-world-factbook/countries/kyrgyzstan/ .
- 3. Demographic yearbook of the Kyrgyz Republic - Publications Archive - Statistics of the Kyrgyz Republic ; 2023. https://www.stat.kg/en/publications/demograficheskij-ezhegodnik-kyrgyzskoj-respubliki/ . Accessed March 10, 2024.
- 4. Morbidity and causes of mortality in women and men. Important figures and facts - Statistics of Kyrgyzstan ; 2021. https://www.stat.kg/ru/news/zabolevaemost-i-prichiny-smertnosti-zhenshin-i-muzhchin-vazhnye-cifry-i-fakty/ . Accessed March 10, 2024.
- 5. Kyrgyzstan data | World Health Organization ; 2019. https://data.who.int/countries/417 . Accessed March 10, 2024.
- 6. Kyrgyzstan . Kyrgyzstan: health system review ; 2022. https://www.who.int/kyrgyzstan/publications/i/item/kyrgyzstan–health-system-review . Accessed March 10, 2024.
- 7. World Health Organization (WHO) . Kyrgyzstan adopts new health strategy for 2019–2030 [January 23]. https://www.who.int/europe/news/item/23-01-2019-kyrgyzstan-adopts-new-health-strategy-for-2019-2030 ; 2019. .
- 8. Lim DC , Najafi A , Afifi L , et al . The need to promote sleep health in public health agendas across the globe . Lancet Public Health. 8 ( 10 ): e820 – e826 . [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 9. MedElement . Obstructive apnea syndrome ; 2024. https://rb.gy/3sodtk . Accessed March 10, 2024.

