In a decision that has stunned tobacco control advocates, the Victorian Court of Appeal in Australia has overturned an earlier ruling against British American Tobacco (BAT) that had awarded over $A700000 (£250000; $394000; €390000) in damages to a dying smoker.
The earlier ruling had dismissed BAT's defence because the company had destroyed thousands of potentially relevant documents (BMJ 2002;324: 934) .
On 6 December 2002 the Victorian Court of Appeal unanimously ruled in favour of BAT on all points of its appeal and ordered a new trial on behalf of Rolah McCabe. Ms McCabe died from lung cancer on 26 October 2002, but the executors of her estate continued the action.
In their decision, Court of Appeal Judges John Phillips, John Batt, and Peter Buchanan found that simply because BAT destroyed documents—and CDs on to which 30000 documents had been copied—did not justify the dismissal of its defence.
