Skip to main content
Wiley Open Access Collection logoLink to Wiley Open Access Collection
. 2024 May 6;89(5):2974–2990. doi: 10.1111/1750-3841.17033

Sensory, emotional, and appropriateness of plant‐ and meat‐based burgers

Giovanni Sogari 1,✉, Simona Grasso 2, Vincenzina Caputo 3, Miguel I Gómez 4, Cristina Mora 1, Joachim J Schouteten 5
PMCID: PMC13281143  PMID: 38711372

Abstract

Abstract

The plant‐based meat alternative market is experiencing rapid growth. However, whether this growth extends to mainstream consumers will depend on the sensory profile, emotional profile, and situational appropriateness of these products. This study provides a sensory comparison between two plant‐based burgers, one hybrid burger, and a conventional 100% ground beef burger. The sensory evaluation was carried out under blind and informed conditions using a between‐subject design. Participants (n = 177) were asked to rate the appearance, flavor, odor, and texture of each product and indicate their overall liking. In addition, 26 sensory terms were evaluated using the rate‐all‐that‐apply technique. The study also measured the emotional profile and the situational appropriateness elicited by each product using the check‐all‐that‐apply technique. The results showed that (a) in the blind condition, there were no significant differences observed in overall liking across the four burgers; (b) the plant‐based burger made with pea protein received the lowest overall liking score, and its evaluation was not positively influenced by product information disclosure; (c) providing product information influenced the perceived intensity of the attributes associated with meat; (d) discriminatory ability for emotions was higher in the informed condition; and (e) for the situational appropriateness, when prioritizing healthy eating, participants considered plant‐based burgers more suitable than the groundbeef burger.

Practical Application

Our results demonstrate that product descriptions could have an impact on consumer acceptance of different meat burger alternatives. In order to launch successfull meat alternatives, product developers and communication marketing specialists should consider the extent to which these alternatives resemble regular meat products in terms of their sensory and emotional profiles and context of use.

Keywords: consumers’ acceptance, hybrid meat, item‐by‐use (IBU), meat analogs, meat substitute

1. INTRODUCTION

The plant‐based meat alternatives industry is experiencing a continuous surge in popularity, primarily driven by the ongoing trend of reducing meat consumption (Cutroneo et al., 2022; OECD & FAO, 2020) and the increasing number of flexitarian consumers (Andreani et al., 2023; Boukid, 2021; Demartini et al., 2022). Recent advancements in plant‐based meat alternatives, also known as meat substitutes or analogs, are trying to replicate the sensory aspects of animal meat, including flavor, texture, odor, and appearance (Boukid, 2021; Giacalone et al., 2022).

These advancements have led to the development of various plant‐based products, including burger patties, nuggets, sausages, and meatballs (Andreani et al., 2023). Another notable innovation in the meat industry is the development of products containing both meat‐ and plant‐based ingredients, resulting in hybrid meat or blended meat analogs (Grasso & Jaworska, 2020). These products typically replace a portion of the meat, ranging from 20% to 50%, with plant‐based ingredients and can incorporate a combination of vegetables, spices, or single‐plant ingredients like mushrooms (Grasso & Jaworska, 2020).

Although the market for plant‐based foods like meat alternatives is expanding both in the retail and in the food service sectors (e.g., fast‐food chains) (Markets & Markets, 2020), the sensory appeal of these products plays a critical role in mainstream consumer acceptance (Grasso et al., 2022; Neville et al., 2017; Smetana et al., 2021; Sogari et al., 2023). Thus, there is a need for additional sensory and consumer research to gain a deeper understanding of the most valued aspects during the evaluation of these plant‐based and hybrid meat products. Past sensory studies on the topic investigated the role of disclosing information about the product by using a blind‐informed test. For instance, Grasso et al. (2022) showed a significant effect of the information disclosure about the product composition (e.g., “A burger made with …”) on consumers’ acceptance of plant‐based meat and hybrid burgers. In another recent study by Martin et al. (2021), the authors explored consumers’ preferences for a meat‐based product (pork sausage) and its vegetable protein‐based counterpart (plant‐based sausage) by using two levels of information (the packaging information only vs. additional information about the environmental and health benefits and risks of consuming these kinds of products). Their results showed that, when providing the packaging information only, consumer purchase intention leaned toward the pork sausage; however, using the packaging and additional information increased both the purchase intent and consumer willingness to pay for the plant‐based product. Our study aims to contribute to this line of research by providing a sensory comparison between two plant‐based burgers, a hybrid (blended meat–vegetable) burger, and a conventional 100% ground beef burger, under both blind and informed conditions.

During the sensory experiment, consumers were asked to indicate their overall liking as well as their liking of the appearance, flavor, odor, and texture of each product. A battery of rate‐all‐that‐apply (RATA) questions was also used to identify the sensory attributes that best characterize the four burgers. Moreover, our study incorporates measures of product‐elicited emotions and item‐by‐use (IBU) situational appropriateness, which are increasingly important in understanding consumer choices (Giacalone et al., 2022). The inclusion of IBU aims to ensure that the products are highly appropriate for the intended consumption context, whereas the assessment of product‐elicited emotions addresses the irrational and impulsive nature of consumers’ food choices. These measures provide valuable insights beyond liking data and can help explain why liking alone may not always predict a food product's success in the marketplace (Dalenberg et al., 2014; Giacalone et al., 2022). Understanding whether plant‐based meat alternatives fit within similar situational appropriateness and elicit comparable emotions to their animal‐based counterparts could be of great interest to practitioners (Elzerman et al., 2021).

2. MATERIALS AND METHODS

2.1. The recruitment process

The sensory experiment was conducted at the Cornell Sensory Evaluation Center located in Ithaca, New York (USA). The participants consisted of an untrained panel of consumers who met the study criteria to participate, that was, aged over 18 years, with no food allergies/intolerances (wheat/gluten, tree nuts, soy, and coconut), responsible for their households’ purchases, and had purchased burgers at least once over the past 6 months prior to the study. The study obtained permission from the Cornell University Institutional Review Board (Protocol ID 1908009006).

Data were collected using computers equipped with the RedJade® Sensory Software Suite (RedJade Sensory Solutions LLC) and the Qualtrics® platform. The final sample considered for the analysis was 177 participants, with 87 participants in the blind group and 90 in the informed group (Table S1 for full demographics).

2.2. Study design

Upon arriving at the session, participants were asked to read and sign the consent form and received $5 as a participation incentive. They were randomly assigned to either the blind or informed treatment group (between‐subject design). In both treatments, respondents were asked to taste four burgers: one 100% beef, one blended meat–vegetable, and two plant‐based meat alternatives. Participants in the blind condition had no information about the products; however, in the informed condition, the monitor screen showed consumers the key composition characteristics of each burger before proceeding to tasting and evaluating the products. For the beef burger, a “made using 100% ground beef” text was displayed, whereas, for the blended one, it was indicated that the product was “made with 70% beef and 30% mushrooms.” Instead, for the two plant‐based burgers, participants were informed about the type of proteins used: one was described as a burger “made using pea proteins” and the other as “made using animal‐like proteins” (this last burger contains the protein heme from soy, which is thought to impart a distinctive meat‐like flavor), following the approach used in the study by Van Loo et al. (2020). Moreover, to prevent the potential influence of commercial brand names on consumer choices (Van Loo et al., 2020), the brand names were withheld from the participants.

2.3. Product preparation

The four types of burgers were purchased from different locations and stored under frozen conditions (−18 ± 2°C) to ensure consistent sensory quality during the experiment.

All burger samples were prepared on the day of testing in a professional kitchen located adjacent to the sensory room. Products were cooked according to the instructions provided on the package, that is, cooked in a frying pan. The burgers were cooked, cut into portions, and kept warm in slow cookers. Each sample consisted of half a burger patty, which was sufficient for two to three bites, and was presented on a white plate labeled with a three‐digit code number.

Each test was conducted in individual sensory booths at room temperature, illuminated with white light, and equipped with adequate ventilation, temperature regulation, and sound protection. To prevent order effects, the samples were presented in a monadic sequence following a balanced complete block design, employing Williams’ (1949) Latin Square design. Filtered still water and unsalted crackers were available to participants to cleanse their palates before tasting each sample.

2.4. Evaluation procedure

In both conditions, participants were asked to taste the four patties monadically and respond to several sections of questions, including (1) overall liking and liking of specific sensory modalities, (2) the evaluation of sensory terms, (3) the emotional profile, and (4) the IBU for each product.

In the first set of questions, respondents were asked to rate each burger using a fully labeled nine‐point hedonic scale (“Dislike extremely,” “Dislike very much,” “Dislike moderately,” “Dislike slightly,” “Neither like nor dislike,” “Like slightly,” “Like moderately,” “Like very much,” “Like extremely”) for overall liking, appearance, odor, texture, and flavor (Peryam & Pilgrim, 1957). The second set of questions consisted of RATA questions. Based on previous sensory studies on meat (Grasso et al., 2017, 2019; Neville et al., 2017; Schouteten et al., 2016), 26 sensory attributes grouped into 4 sensory modalities were selected, i.e., appearance, odor, texture, and flavor (Table S2). Each participant was presented with a list of these terms and asked to rate the intensity of the attributes they considered appropriate for describing each burger. The intensity of each selected appropriate sensory attribute was rated using a three‐point structured scale (1 = “low,” 2 = “medium,” and 3 = “high”). Participants were instructed to leave the scale blank if a term was not applicable (Vidal et al., 2018).

After evaluating the sensory characteristics of each burger, participants were asked to assess the associated emotional profile and usage context using a check‐all‐that‐apply (CATA) technique. They were initially asked, “How does it make you feel? Please select all that apply,” followed by a list of 11 statements (e.g., It makes me feel full of energy and reinvigorated) associated with different emotions. The statements were selected and/or adapted from studies that evaluated consumers’ perceptions of food, particularly meat (Olsen et al., 2014; Schouteten et al., 2015, 2016). Sentences were used instead of adjectives and nouns to provide a clearer idea of the indicated emotional state (Spinelli et al., 2014).

In the last section, participants were asked to specify the most appropriate usage context(s) for the tasted burger by answering the question, “Which of the following usage context(s) do you think this burger would be appropriate for? Please check all that apply.” A list of relevant usage contexts (totaling 13) was chosen based on existing classifications of situational variables affecting food choice and acceptance, including location (e.g., at home and at a fine‐dining restaurant), occasions (e.g., “For any occasion”), social surroundings (e.g., “To eat with friends and family”), physiological processes (e.g., “When I am really hungry”), and mental processes (e.g., “When I want to be healthy”). The statements were selected and/or adapted from studies that assessed consumers’ perceptions of food (Giacalone et al., 2015; Giacalone & Jaeger, 2016). The presentation order of both the emotion profiles and usage context was balanced across subjects in both experiments. The list of statements provided during the experiments is available in Tables S3 and S4.

2.5. Data analysis

To analyze the liking‐related questions (overall liking, appearance, odor, texture, and flavor), an analysis of variance (ANOVA) and pairwise comparisons were conducted across the blind and informed conditions. For the RATA questions, two methods can be used to analyze data from RATA scales: (i) frequency of selection or (ii) weighted frequency of selection (RATA scoring) (Ares & Bruzzone et al., 2014). Using the second method, the RATA attributes were weighted on a four‐point scale, taking the intensity scores into account (i.e., “not applicable” = 0, “low intensity” = 1, “medium intensity” = 2, and “high intensity” = 3) (Vidal et al., 2018). The data were treated as parametric and analyzed using ANOVA and t‐tests (Meyners et al., 2016).

Then, a correspondence analysis (CA) was also performed on the frequency table of the RATA sensory attributes in both blind and informed conditions (Ares et al., 2010). The results of this analysis are reported in Figure S1a,b. The RV coefficient was used to assess the similarity between the sample configurations in the first two dimensions (Ares & Bruzzone et al., 2014).

We then combined the RATA‐as‐CATA data (term frequency) with the nine‐point hedonic scores for each sample (Ares, Dauber et al., 2014) to conduct a penalty‐lift analysis. Through this analysis, the difference in average overall liking was calculated between observations where a specific attribute was selected and observations where the same term was not used (Grasso et al., 2019; Meyners & Castura, 2014).

Emotional conceptualizations and the IBU responses were analyzed using standard methods for CATA questions (Meyners et al., 2013). We employed Fisher's exact test to compare the frequency of selection for each emotion and IBU. Within each treatment (blind and informed), Cochran's Q tests (with Sheskin as the post hoc test) were conducted to determine whether there were differences in the emotions and IBU associated with the four burgers (Jaeger et al., 2019). The use of CA, that is, the visualization of the contingency table, allowed the projection of the data into orthogonal dimensions. CA was performed on the frequency tables of emotional conceptualizations and IBU for both conditions (blind and informed) with the assessment of the similarity between the sample configurations of the emotional conceptualizations/IBU in the first two dimensions of the CA using the RV coefficient (Robert & Escoufier, 1976). A penalty‐lift analysis of the product‐elicited emotions for the four burgers was also conducted within the two conditions (blind and informed).

The analysis was performed using XLSTAT (version 2020.4.1 build 1032, Addinsoft) and IBM SPSS Statistics® (Version 28.0, IBM Corp.), which was also employed to create the CA figures. The statistical tests were performed at a significance level of p < 0.05, and Bonferroni corrections were applied for the post hoc tests.

3. RESULTS

3.1. Sensory liking

Table 1 reports the mean ratings for overall liking, appearance, odor, flavor, and texture of the four patties within each treatment measured on a nine‐point scale ranging from 1 corresponding to dislike extremely to 9 corresponding to like extremely. The scores varied between 4.70 (the texture of the pea protein burger) and 6.84 (the appearance of the animal‐like protein burger).

TABLE 1.

The sensory scores (mean and standard deviations) of the four patties in the blind and informed conditions.

Overall liking Appearance Odor Flavor Texture
Product Blind Info Blind Info Blind Info Blind Info Blind Info
Ground beef 5.55 y ,a (1.70) 6.40 x ,a (1.77) 4.90 y ,b (1.73) 5.61 x ,b (2.00) 5.77 y ,a (1.51) 6.57 x ,a (1.47) 5.89 y ,a (1.77) 6.68 x ,a (1.64) 5.02 x ,b (2.01) 5.60 x ,b (1.96)
Blended 5.39 y ,a (2.06) 6.31 x ,a (1.87) 5.33 x ,b (1.83) 5.48 x ,b (1.91) 5.26 y ,a (1.58) 5.77 x ,b (1.53) 5.36 y ,a (2.12) 6.22 x ,a (1.86) 5.52 y ,b (2.12) 6.33 x ,a (1.76)
Pea protein 5.23 x, a (2.09) 5.09 x ,b (2.28) 5.13 x ,b (1.95) 5.40 x ,b (2.01) 5.22 x ,a (1.85) 5.32 x ,b (1.93) 5.47 x ,a (2.04) 5.31 x ,b (2.31) 5.06 x ,b (2.15) 4.70 x ,c (2.24)
Animal‐like protein 6.01 y ,a (2.04) 6.77 x ,a (1.57) 6.78 x ,a (1.48) 6.84 x ,a (1.48) 5.72 x ,a (1.75) 5.89 x ,b (1.80) 6.01 y ,a (2.01) 6.66 x ,a (1.76) 6.43 x ,a (1.61) 6.74 x ,a (1.32)
a–c

Products with different lowercase letter codes, within the same column, indicate significant differences among the four samples within the same condition (p < 0.05 considering Bonferroni's correction).

x,y

Products with different letter codes, within the same row, are significantly different for overall liking, appearance, odor, flavor, and texture between the two conditions (blind/informed) (p < 0.05).

In the blind condition, there were no significant differences observed in overall liking across the four burgers. On the other hand, in the informed condition, the ANOVA revealed that there was a statistically significant difference in the overall liking among products (F(3356) = 13.384, p < 0.001). Post hoc comparisons using the Bonferroni test indicated that the mean overall liking score for the pea product was significantly lower than the 100% beef burger (p < 0.001, 95% C.I. = [−2.06, −0.56]), the blended (p < 0.001, 95% C.I. = [−1.97, −0.47]), and the animal‐like protein burger (p < 0.001, 95% C.I. = [−2.43, −0.93]). Notably, the effect size of the overall liking between the animal‐like protein and pea protein burgers was medium in the blind condition (d = 0.38) but became much larger in the informed condition (d = 0.86). Comparing the effect sizes of the overall liking scores between the blind and informed conditions for each burger, a similar medium effect for the beef (d = 0.49), blended (d = 0.47), and animal‐like protein (d = 0.41) burgers was observed. However, no effect of information (d = 0.06) was found for the pea protein burger, with mean values remaining the same across conditions.

Moving on to the sensory modalities, the animal‐like protein burger received significantly higher liking scores compared to the other burgers in terms of appearance, both in the blind (6.78) and informed (6.84) treatments, which indicates moderate liking. The beef, pea protein, and blended burgers had average liking scores of around 5, which suggests that participants neither liked nor disliked the appearance of these burgers. The 100% beef burger obtained the lowest liking score in the blind group for appearance, whereas the score significantly increased in the informed condition (t (175) = −2.53, p = 0.012). The effect size between the liking scores of the animal‐like protein burger and the beef burger for appearance in the blind condition was the largest (d = 1.17) compared to the other products.

In the blind condition, no significant differences for the liking of the odor were found among the four products. On the other hand, in the informed condition, there were significant differences among burgers (F(3356) = 8.306, p < 0.001), with the mean liking score of the odor for the beef product being significantly higher than the blended (p = 0.010, 95% C.I. = [0.13, 1.47]), the animal‐like protein (p = 0.046, 95% C.I. = [0.01, 1.35]), and the pea protein (p < 0.001, 95% C.I. = [0.57, 1.91]). Regarding flavor liking, no significant differences were observed across the four burgers in the blind condition. In the informed group, significant differences were detected (F(3356) = 10.076, p < 0.001), with the mean score for the pea product being significantly lower than beef (p < 0.001, 95% C.I. = [−2.12, −0.61]), the blended (p = 0.009, 95% C.I. = [−1.67, −0.16]), and the animal‐like protein burger (p < 0.001, 95% C.I. = [−2.10, −0.59]). Comparing the liking for the odors and flavor scores for the 100% beef and pea protein burgers, a larger effect size in the informed (d = 0.73 for odor; d = 0.68 for flavor) compared to the blind (d = 0.33 for odor; d = 0.22 for flavor) condition was observed. The results for texture revealed that in the blind condition, there was a statistically significant difference among products (F(3344) = 9.226, p < 0.001). Post hoc comparisons indicated that the animal‐like protein sample received a significantly higher liking score for texture than the beef (p < 0.001, 95% C.I. = [0.60, 2.21]), the blended (p = 0.018, 95% C.I. = [0.10, 1.71]), and the pea protein burger (p < 0.001, 95% C.I. = [0.56, 2.17]). Similarly, a statistically significant difference among products was detected also in the informed condition (F(3, 356) = 21.213, p < 0.001); post hoc comparisons indicated that the pea protein sample received a significantly lower liking score for texture than beef (p = 0.007, 95% C.I. = [−1.63, −0.17]), the blended (p < 0.001, 95% C.I. = [−2.36, −0.90]), and the animal‐like protein burger (p < 0.001, 95% C.I. = [−2.78, −1.31]), with the largest effect size (d = 1.11) observed between the animal‐like protein and the pea protein burger.

In the informed condition, the overall liking score of males was significantly higher than that of the female group for the animal‐like protein burger (t(88) = 2.025, p = 0.046) and pea protein (t(88) = 2.119, p = 0.037). However, no significant differences were found between the beef and the blended product. Thus, the effect of providing information on overall liking differed between gender. For the female group, between the blind and the informed condition, there was no significant differences in the overall liking of the animal‐like protein burger, whereas, in the male group, there was a significant increase (t(56) = −2.715, p = 0.009) in liking when the information was disclosed. Thus, the male gender was more influenced by the treatment information (animal‐like protein) than the female group.

Altogether, these findings suggest that product information influences the product liking scores to some extent, except for the pea protein burger.

3.2. Sensory profiling

3.2.1. Rating score

The ANOVA analysis revealed that the RATA method was able to capture significant differences among the four samples for all the sensory attributes except for “salty” and “greasy” (Table 2). In terms of appearance, the animal‐like burger received the highest score for “brown (inside)” in both the blind (2.03) and informed group (2.21) and “characteristic of meat” (2.16 and 2.21). The pea protein burger was perceived as having the most processed appearance (2.10 and 1.93) and obtained the lowest scores for “characteristic of meat” (1.02 and 1.32) in both conditions.

TABLE 2.

The 26 rate‐all‐that‐apply (RATA) scores (mean and standard deviations) for the 4 patties in the blind and informed conditions.

Ground beef Blended Pea protein Animal‐like protein
Attributes Blind Info Blind Info Blind Info Blind Info
Appearance
Brown color (inside) 1.21c, x (0.97) 1.38c, x (1.02) 1.61b, x (0.89) 1.79b, x (0.91) 1.17c, x (1.01) 0.98d, x (0.70) 2.03a, x (0.89) 2.21a, x (0.77)
Moist appearance 0.66b, y (0.75) 0.90c, x (0.69) 1.25a, x (0.92) 1.16bc, x (0.96) 1.26a, x (0.98) 1.54a, x (0.97) 1.53a, x (1.01) 1.69a, x (0.96)
Processed appearance 1.55b, x (1.03) 1.47b, x (1.11) 1.43b, x (1.06) 1.71ab, x (1.02) 2.10a, x (0.86) 1.93a, x (1.01) 1.45b, x (1.02) 1.50b, x (1.00)
Uniform color (outside) 1.46b, x (1.08) 1.62b, x (0.98) 1.63ab, x (0.97) 1.62b, x (1.00) 1.44b, x (1.17) 1.53b, x (0.98) 1.92a, x (0.95) 2.09a, x (0.93)
Characteristic of meat 1.67b, y (1.03) 2.18ab, x (0.96) 1.76ab, x (1.05) 1.88b, x (0.88) 1.02c, y (0.98) 1.32c, x (0.96) 2.16a, x (0.90) 2.21ab, x (0.92)
Odor
Meat‐like 1.64a, y (1.07) 2.33a, x (0.79) 1.23ab, x (0.94) 1.47b, x (0.91) 0.95b, x (0.99) 0.93c, x (0.95) 1.13b, x (1.13) 1.34b, x (0.96)
Unusual 0.55b, x (0.83) 0.44c, x (0.69) 0.92ab, x (1.00) 0.90b, x (0.95) 1.11a, x (1.06) 1.32a, x (0.96) 0.97a, x (1.04) 1.02ab, x (1.02)
Legume‐like 0.29b, x (0.61) 0.24b, x (0.48) 0.52ab, x (0.73) 0.46b, x (0.75) 0.76a, y (0.94) 1.13a, x (1.07) 0.67a, x (0.90) 0.54b, x (0.80)
Wheat‐cereal like 0.23b, x (0.50) 0.23b, x (0.47) 0.31ab, x (0.58) 0.30b, x (0.61) 0.56a, x (0.80) 0.57a, x (0.78) 0.44ab, x (0.74) 0.38ab, x (0.61)
Flavor
Flavorful 1.29b, y (0.86) 1.63ab, x (0.98) 1.13b, y (0.97) 1.86ab, x (0.94) 1.47ab, x (1.04) 1.54a, x (1.11) 1.71a, x (1.08) 2.00b, x (1.07)
Tastes like meat 2.09a, y (1.05) 2.47a, x (0.82) 1.38b, y (1.08) 1.79b, x (0.91) 0.99b, x (1.02) 0.94c, x (0.90) 1.15b,x (0.95) 1.43b, x (1.05)
Sweet 0.26b, x (0.53) 0.38b, x (0.66) 0.39ab, y (0.67) 0.64ab, x (0.85) 0.57a, x (0.80) 0.62ab, x (0.76) 0.51ab, x (0.78) 0.72a, x (0.90)
Saltyns 1.16 y (0.94) 1.46 x (0.96) 1.16 x (0.97) 1.26 x (0.84) 1.18 x (0.92) 1.27 x (1.07) 1.33 x (0.95) 1.53 x (1.00)
Smoky/Grill 0.89b, y (0.98) 1.36a, x (0.97) 0.69b, x (0.80) 0.90b, x (0.85) 1.32a, x (1.09) 1.32a, x (0.98) 0.98ab, x (1.06) 1.18ab, x (.94)
Off‐flavor 0.18b, x (0.58) 0.14c, x (0.41) 0.57a, x (1.06) 0.67ab, x (1.09) 0.68a, x (0.99) 0.99b, x (1.19) 0.55a, x (0.96) 0.53a, x (0.85)
Wheat–cereal‐like 0.21b, x (0.55) 0.17c, x (0.46) 0.33ab, x (0.71) 0.27bc, x (0.67) 0.57a, x (0.88) 0.58a, x (0.86) 0.37ab, x (0.73) 0.44ab, x (0.67)
Legume‐like 0.18c, x (0.47) 0.16c, x (0.39) 0.47bc, x (0.79) 0.44bc, x (0.81) 0.92a, x (1.02) 1.09a, x (1.09) 0.82ab, x (1.02) 0.66b, x (0.88)
Unusual flavor 0.32b, x (0.75) 0.18c, x (0.44) 0.99a, y (1.17) 0.67b, x (0.97) 1.02a, x (1.03) 1.16a, x (1.12) 0.76a, x (1.03) 0.76b, x (0.98)
Texture
Characteristic of beef 1.66a, y (1.03) 2.26a, x (0.94) 1.57a, x (1.08) 1.73b, x (0.92) 0.99b, x (0.99) 0.83c, x (0.84) 1.39ab, y (1.05) 1.78b, x (1.01)
Juicy 0.63c, y (0.82) 0.97c, x (0.93) 1.77a, x (1.05) 1.76a, x (1.13) 1.10b, x (0.98) 1.30bc, x (0.95) 1.38ab, y (1.08) 1.72a, x (1.03)
Fibrous 1.14ab, x (1.08) 0.86b, x (1.03) 0.86ab, x (1.00) 0.74b, x (0.98) 1.20b, x (1.15) 1.33a, x (1.06) 0.76a, x (0.95) 0.99ab, x (1.05)
Granular 0.55b, x (0.89) 0.50b, x (0.89) 0.41b, x (0.71) 0.40b, x (0.70) 1.26a, x (1.20) 1.00a, x (1.15) 0.67b, x (0.94) 0.56b, x (0.82)
Soft 0.37c, x (0.67) 0.42c, x (0.67) 1.53a, x (1.18) 1.34b, x (1.14) 0.83b, x (0.95) 0.94a, x (1.03) 0.89b, x (1.03) 1.03ab, x (1.04)
Greasyns 0.70 x (0.86) 0.92 x (0.97) 0.90 x (1.08) 1.02 x (1.03) 0.87 x (0.91) 0.91 x (0.92) 1.05 x (0.95) 1.00 x (0.98)
Easy to cut/Falls apart 0.54c, x (0.82) 0.62c, x (0.88) 1.67a, x (1.06) 1.67a, x (1.03) 1.25ab, x (1.05) 1.19b, x (1.07) 1.15b, x (0.97) 1.40ab, x (1.13)
Difficult to cut/Dense 1.31c, x (1.22) 1.23a, x (1.15) 0.31a, x (0.67) 0.32c, x (0.63) 0.77b, x (1.00) 0.74b, x (0.95) 0.39a, x (0.69) 0.33c, x (0.56)
a–d

Different lowercase letters indicate significant differences (p < 0.05 considering Bonferroni's correction) among samples within the same condition (across rows).

x,y

Different lowercase letters indicate significant differences (p < 0.05) between the two conditions blind‐informed within the same product sample.

Regarding odor, the 100% beef burger had the highest score for “meat like” in both blind (1.64) and informed (2.33) conditions, whereas the pea protein burger had the highest intensity for “legume‐like” in both conditions (0.76 and 1.13). For the latter burger, providing information about the type of protein (pea) significantly increased the perception of smelling legumes (t (174) = −2.46, p = 0.015).

For flavor, the animal‐like protein burger received the highest score for being “flavorful” in both conditions. The term “tastes like meat” was perceived with high intensity for the 100% beef burger (2.09 and 2.47), followed by the blended burger (1.38 and 1.79) and the animal‐like burger (1.15 and 1.43). Interestingly, the term “smoky‐grill” was highest for the pea protein sample in the blind condition (1.32); however, in the informed group, the beef burger scored the highest (1.36), perhaps due to the common perception that this product should have a grilled flavor. The pea protein burger also received the highest scores in both conditions for “wheat–cereal‐like” (0.57 and 0.58) and “legume‐like” flavors (0.92 and 1.09).

In terms of the texture attributes, the 100% beef burger received the highest scores for “characteristic of beef” in both blind (1.66) and informed groups (2.28), followed by the animal‐like protein sample (1.39 and 1.78). The blended burger was perceived as the most “juicy” (1.77 and 1.76), the “softest” (1.53 and 1.34), and the most “easy to cut” (1.67 and 1.67). These results may be attributed to the presence of mushrooms, which contribute to these sensory properties. On the contrary, the pea protein sample scored highest in “fibrous” (1.20 and 1.33) and “granular” (1.26 and 1.00).

The RATA results demonstrate how providing information about the type of burger influenced the perceived intensity of the attributes associated with meat (i.e., “characteristic of meat” for the appearance, “meat‐like” for the odor, “characteristic of beef” for the texture). It leads to increased intensities for the 100% beef burger, whereas there was little impact on the perceived intensities of these attributes for the other burgers.

3.2.2. Penalty‐lift analysis of the sensory attributes

The results of the penalty‐lift analysis are presented in the bar charts (Figure 1a,b) and illustrate the key sensory attributes that have an impact on the overall liking, in order from the most positive (top) to the most negative (bottom) drivers (Meyners, 2016). The penalty‐lift analysis for the sensory attributes was conducted for each sample in both the blind and informed conditions to investigate whether the provided information had an impact on the drivers of liking or disliking (Grasso et al., 2022, 2017). Due to the large number of attributes, only the most important drivers, which best differentiate among samples, are included in the figures. These findings can be used to prioritize attribute importance as the overall liking can be influenced by the presence of a positive attribute (i.e., the selected term) or the absence of a negative attribute (Meyners & Castura, 2014).

FIGURE 1.

(a) Visualization of the results from the penalty‐lift analysis of the sensory attributes in the blind condition; (b) visualization of the results from the penalty‐lift analysis of the sensory attributes in the informed condition.

graphic file with name JFDS-89-2974-g001.jpg

graphic file with name JFDS-89-2974-g004.jpg

In the blind condition, the presence of being “flavorful,” “tastes like meat,” and “salty” was found to be the most common contributors to increase consumer acceptability for all samples. Interestingly, between the two plant‐based burgers, only the animal‐like protein burger was associated with attributes such as “characteristics of beef (texture)” and “meat odor,” which impacted the liking. As expected, the main driver for liking the blended burger was its “juiciness,” which can be attributed to the inclusion of mushrooms as an ingredient. In the informed condition, it was noteworthy to observe that the 100% beef burger was recognized as having a negative meat taste, likely due to overall burger quality and cooking parameters. On the other hand, the main drivers of liking of the two plant‐based burgers were related to meat attributes such as “characteristics of beef (texture),” “meat odor,” and “smoky/grill.” Conversely, the common drivers of dislike in both blind and informed conditions were the “off‐flavor” and “unusual flavor.” For the two plant‐based burgers, “unusual odor” was also a strong driver for dislike.

3.3. Emotional profiling

Table 3 presents the frequencies of the emotional conceptualizations for the four burgers in both the blind and informed conditions. Overall, participants indicated that approximately 29.8% of the emotional conceptualizations were applicable during the blind condition, whereas 39.1% were applicable during the informed condition. It is important to note that although high frequencies were observed for emotions such as “satisfied”, relatively high frequencies were also found for more negative emotional conceptualizations such as “disgust” and “disappointed”. These results might be caused by different consumer segments as products which are liked by certain consumers should evoke more positive emotions while other consumers might report negative emotions due to dislike (Dalenberg et al., 2014).

TABLE 3.

Usage frequencies (percentage of participants) of emotional conceptualizations for the four burgers under blind (n = 87) and informed conditions (n = 90).

Blind Informed
Ground beef Blended Pea protein Animal‐like protein Ground beef Blended Pea protein Animal‐like protein
It makes me feel full of energy and reinvigorated 18.4 16.1 24.1 24.1 46.7a 40ab 32.2b 44.4ab
It makes me feel worried 14.9 20.7 17.2 14.9 22.2 22.2 20 21.1
It satisfies me 50.6 49.4 44.8 55.2 68.9a 68.9a 47.8b 67.8a
It gratifies me, rewards me 21.8 20.7 20.7 26.4 40.0 46.7 32.2 43.3
I associate it with happy memories of my childhood 20.7 18.4 16.1 20.7 52.2a 30b 18.9b 23.3b
It pleasantly surprises me 33.3ab 28.7b 43.7ab 48.3a 21.1b 56.7a 48.9a 64.4a
It makes me curious 28.7b 33.3b 57.5a 54.0a 18.9c 45.6b 54.4ab 63.3a
It makes me feel indifferent 36.8 32.2 27.6 23.0 35.6 34.4 36.7 30
It makes me feel disgusted 27.6 29.9 33.3 23.0 31.1ab 31.1ab 43.3a 24.4b
It disappoints me 36.8 48.3 50.6 37.9 53.3ab 40b 63.3a 36.7b
It makes me feel guilty 18.4 17.2 13.8 12.6 40.0a 21.1b 17.8b 21.1b
abc

Different superscripts indicate significant differences in the usage frequencies for the burgers within a condition (blind/informed).

No significant impact of the information was observed on the emotional conceptualizations, as the pairwise comparison for each emotion and each burger was not significantly different (p > 0.05). However, when comparing within conditions (blind or informed), differences in the applicability of the emotions emerged among the four product samples. For instance, the animal‐like burger evoked more emotions related to surprise compared to the blended and pea protein burger. Notably, a greater number of participants in the informed condition indicated that the burger made with 100% ground beef evoked happy memories from childhood compared to the other three burgers. In contrast, no significant difference was found between the four burgers regarding the evocation of happy childhood memories among participants in the blind condition. In general, providing information resulted in more significant differences in the emotional conceptualizations of the four burgers (seven differences observed in the informed condition compared to two differences in the blind condition).

Figure 2 illustrates the results of the CA of the emotion conceptualizations. The figure shows where the four products and the 11 product‐elicited emotion terms are located on the map, both in the blind (Figure 2a) and informed conditions (Figure 2b). The percentage of data variance explained by the first and second dimensions of the CA was higher than 95% for both blind and informed treatments, with a strong first dimension (69.9% and 73.0%) and a weak (less important) second dimension (24.7% and 24.7%), respectively. RV coefficient was 0.610 and was nonsignificant (p = 0.542), suggesting that information had an impact on the sample configurations.

FIGURE 2.

FIGURE 2

Correspondence analysis (CA) plots showing the first two dimensions of the CA models based upon the emotional conceptualization data of the four burgers within (a) the blind condition and (b) the informed condition.

Figure 3 shows the penalty‐lift analysis of the emotional profiles and illustrates which emotions have the most positive (top) and most negative (bottom) impact on the overall liking. In the blind condition (Figure 3a), the main drivers for liking were similar across the four burgers with “satisfied,” “surprised,” and “gratified/rewarded” as the top three emotional conceptualizations. In the informed condition (Figure 3b), it is interesting to note that the emotional conceptualization of “happy memories of childhood” is the second driver of liking for the beef burger. It is also worth noting that for the plant‐based animal‐like burger, the term “full of energy/reinvigorated” was among the top three drivers of liking. As expected, the most common contributors to decreasing the consumer liking for all samples, in both blind and informed conditions, were being “worried”, “disgusted” and “disappointed”.

FIGURE 3.

FIGURE 3

(a) Visualization of the results from the penalty‐lift analysis of the emotions in the blind condition; (b) visualization of the results from the penalty‐lift analysis of the emotions in the informed condition.

3.4. Item‐by‐use

Table 4 shows the frequencies of situational appropriateness for the four burgers under blind and informed conditions. Significant differences were observed for the IBU within each condition; however, when comparing the perceived appropriateness of the burgers between the two conditions, no significant difference was observed. In the blind condition, the animal‐like burger was considered more appropriate for consumption “When I am at home” compared to the ground beef burger. Conversely, the ground beef burger was seen as more appropriate in a fast‐food chain. Both the pea protein burger and the animal‐like protein burger were perceived as more suitable options for those wanting to eat healthy, compared to the ground beef burger.

TABLE 4.

Frequencies (percentage of participants) of situational appropriateness for the four burgers under the blind (n = 87) and informed conditions (n = 90).

Blind Informed
Ground beef Blended Pea protein Animal‐like protein Ground beef Blended Pea protein Animal‐like protein
“When I want to indulge myself” 12.6 9.2 17.2 14.9 41.1a 23.3b 6.7c 26.7ab
“When I am in a barbeque with friends” 44.8 35.6 28.7 35.6 75.6a 46.7b 27.8c 42.2bc
“When I am at a fine‐dining restaurant” 0 2.3 2.3 3.4 11.1 15.6 8.9 14.4
“When I am at home” 24.1b 28.7ab 31ab 42.5a 61.1a 47.8ab 35.6b 57.8a
“For any occasion” 13.8 14.9 14.9 25.3 52.2a 42.2a 20.0b 37.8a
“When I am in a fast‐food chain” 44.8a 35.6a 16.1b 34.5a 71.1a 28.9b 21.1b 23.3b
“To eat with friends and family” 25.3 25.3 29.9 37.9 57.8a 42.2ab 32.2b 47.8ab
“As a burger for women” 3.4 8 6.9 6.9 11.1 7.8 8.9 12.2
“As a burger for men” 5.7 3.4 4.6 8 21.1a 5.6b 4.4b 12.2ab
“When I want to be healthy” 10.3b 23ab 33.3a 27.6a 3.3b 55.6a 46.7a 54.4a
“When I am really hungry” 40.2 40.2 41.4 42.5 70.0a 40.0bc 26.7c 53.3ab
“When I want to be environmentally sustainable” 11.5c 21.8bc 37.9a 29.9ab 1.1c 40.0b 58.7ab 60a
“For something a bit more sophisticated” 0.0b 2.3ab 5.7ab 8a 5.6b 21.1a 8.9ab 16.7ab
abc

Different superscripts indicate significant differences in the frequencies of appropriateness for the burgers within a condition (blind/informed).

For the participants who received information, the ground beef burger was perceived as more appropriate for indulgence, barbecuing with friends, and consuming in a fast‐food chain compared to the other burgers. Gender stereotypes also played a role, with the ground beef burger seen as more suitable for men compared to the blended and pea protein burgers. Although the ground beef burger was associated with a higher number of participants considering it appropriate when they are very hungry, it was also considered more suitable for healthy eating or environmental sustainability compared to other burgers (such as the animal‐like burger) by a significantly lower number of individuals. The blended and animal‐like burgers were seen as appropriate alternatives to the ground beef burger on certain occasions, such as when eating at home or with friends and family.

Figure 4 illustrates the CA of the IBU and shows where the 4 burgers and the 13 item‐by‐use situational appropriateness are located on the map, both in the blind condition (Figure 4a) and with the information disclosure (Figure 4b). The percentage of data variance explained by the first and second dimensions of the CA was higher than 90% for both blind and informed treatments, with a strong first dimension (80.9% and 89.6%) and a weak (less important) second dimension (12.5% and 7.5%, respectively). Although the RV coefficient was relatively high with a value of 0.877, the p‐value was 0.083, indicating that the sample configurations in the CA were less similar.

FIGURE 4.

FIGURE 4

Correspondence analysis (CA) plots showing the first two dimensions of the CA models based upon the item‐by‐use (IBU) data for the four burgers within (a) the blind treatment and (b) the informed treatment.

4. DISCUSSION

This research contributes to the growing body of literature on consumer acceptance of meat alternatives by examining whether and how providing information influences the sensory characteristics, the emotional profile, and the situational appropriateness of plant‐based and hybrid burgers.

Our results indicate that the animal‐like protein burger was appreciated in both conditions; specifically, when the information was disclosed, the liking scores significantly increased for the overall liking and flavor attributes. Participants in the information group particularly appreciated the meat resemblance and identified attributes such as “beef‐like texture” and “meat‐like odor” as important drivers of their liking. Moreover, consumers could also detect the typical flavor characteristic of beef. This finding can be attributed to the specific ingredient formulation of this product, particularly, the presence of soy hemoglobin, which emulates meat properties even after the patty is cooked. This suggests that making minor adjustments to key ingredients in modern meat analogs can enhance the acceptance of specific plant‐based alternatives. As previously suggested by Cordelle et al. (2022), the acceptability of plant‐based protein products could be enhanced by incorporating ingredients that try to mimic meat flavor to improve the flavor.

In addition to the flavor, the color also plays a vital role in shaping consumer perception of taste and overall product acceptance (He et al., 2020). The “bloody” color (“characteristic of meat”) that was reported for the plant‐based animal‐like protein burger represented a high‐quality sensory attribute. As a result, a positive perception of the product's appearance before consumption could contribute to the establishment of positive expectations that could be subsequently met during the tasting experience. These findings suggest that the hemoglobin protein, used as a colorant and flavoring agent, effectively mimics the sensory attributes commonly associated with traditional meat.

The pea protein burger was associated with more negative terms, such as “unusual flavor”, “off‐flavor”, “processed appearance” and “granular” texture, in both blind and informed conditions. These findings are consistent with previous studies by Grasso et al. (2022), Fiorentini et al. (2020), and Boukid et al. (2021), which indicated that undesirable taste and unappetizing appearance can occur when using some plant ingredients in meat analogs. Moreover, Smetana et al. (2021) found that a pea‐based burger was less associated with sensory attributes like “flavor” and “meat taste” compared to its beef counterpart. The lack of positive sensory evaluation, even with information disclosure, could be attributed to the low familiarity of consumers with pea protein as a plant‐based ingredient, as suggested by Caparros Megido et al. (2016) and Lemken et al. (2019). For a clearer interpretation of these results, we can also look at the differences in the mean scores (effect size) for the four burgers. In particular, in the informed condition, larger effects in overall liking, appearance, and texture were found between the animal‐like protein burger and the pea protein burger, compared to the blind condition. Thus, when the nature of the product is disclosed, these sensory modalities can better discriminate between these two products.

From the hedonic liking results, consumers appreciated the blended burger slightly less than the 100% beef and animal‐like protein burgers. However, the blended patty still received a generally positive appreciation (scores around 6), which confirms that mushrooms can be used as a substitute for meat without a significant reduction in overall liking (Guinard et al., 2016). In particular, in the informed group, the patty received a slightly higher hedonic score than in the blind group, which emphasizes the role of knowing the nature of the product (i.e., made with 70% beef and 30% mushrooms). Furthermore, to promote the consumption of hybrid meat products, previous authors (Asioli et al., 2023; Banovic & Barone, 2021) have underlined the need to better understand the role of providing information, for instance by stressing the sensory or health benefits of the vegetable ingredients used.

Results suggested that the information strengthened the sensory perception of meat‐like attributes for the 100% beef burger, particularly the odor and texture. This could be explained by the sensory expectations that are created when participants receive information on the type of product, and these expectations were confirmed during the tasting (Piqueras‐Fiszman & Spence, 2015; Santagiuliana et al., 2019).

The discussion on what information to provide on the label of plant‐based meat alternatives is of great interest to practitioners, as it can have significant effects on consumers’ choices. A recent study by Demartini et al. (2022) demonstrated that a vegan label negatively impacted consumers’ perception of the tastiness and healthiness of plant‐based meat alternatives, whereas using a meat‐sounding label had no impact.

Several studies have examined the situational appropriateness and food choice (e.g., Giacalone & Jaeger, 2019; Giacalone et al., 2015; Jaeger et al., 2019); however, limited research has focused on emotions and situational uses of plant‐based meat alternatives (Elzerman et al., 2021; Schouteten et al., 2016). Consistently with previous studies, our findings reveal that emotional associations were very similar between blind and informed conditions for each burger, which highlights the sensory‐driven nature of food product emotions (Schouteten et al., 2016; Spinelli et al., 2015). In particular, satisfaction was the emotional conceptualization that mostly increased the liking for all types of burgers, including plant‐based burgers. Previous research (Gutjar, Dalenberg et al., 2015; Gutjar, de Graaf et al., 2015) demonstrated that positive emotions, such as happiness and satisfaction, are good predictors of product choice. In our study, in the informed condition, where participants were aware of the product description, the ground beef burger was associated with more positive emotions than the others. Specifically, “Happy memories of childhood” was the second driver of liking for the beef burger. This suggests that knowing that the product is familiar (e.g., beef burger) strongly contributes to increasing the liking as it is associated with previous experience. On the other hand, still in the informed condition, the two plant‐based meat alternatives evoked emotions of curiosity and surprise, although the animal‐like burger scored higher in satisfaction and lower in disappointment compared to the pea protein burger. Moreover, the informed condition resulted in more significant differences between the samples, aligning with prior research (Schouteten et al., 2016; Spinelli et al., 2015).

Our work, by incorporating the actual taste experience, extends the findings of a study by Elzerman et al. (2021), which assessed the situational appropriateness of meat and meat substitutes among Dutch consumers through a survey. Our results found that the ground beef burger was perceived as more appropriate for various daily life situations (e.g., “barbecues with friends” and “fast‐food chains”) compared to the plant‐based alternatives. Moreover, in the informed condition, the beef burger was frequently associated with “being really hungry”, whereas the blended burger was linked to something “sophisticated”.

On the other hand, the mental process of appropriateness (e.g., “seeking healthiness” and “environmental sustainability”) was more frequently associated with the two plant‐based burgers compared to the beef and hybrid burgers. This suggests that consumers with a specific attitude toward health and sustainability are more likely to embrace veggie burgers. Integrating this information with sensory attributes can provide a better understanding of consumers’ expectations, product experience and product performance in the market. For practitioners, our results imply the need for tailored communication strategies across different alternative protein products.

Although our study provides insights regarding the consumer perception of different meat alternatives, some limitations should be acknowledged, which both restrict the generalization of the results and open avenues for future research. First, although the participants’ backgrounds encompassed diverse sociodemographic characteristics, the selected population sample cannot be considered representative of the general US population. As a matter of fact, our research was conducted at a tasting location on a college campus, resulting in a sample that skewed towards younger highly‐educated individuals and females compared to the general public. Future studies should include a more balanced sample in terms of sociodemographic and eating habits variables, as our sample included omnivores/flexitarians and high‐frequency meat consumers. Future sensory studies could also consider comparisons between plant‐based burgers only with the aim to include vegetarian and vegan consumers and to deeply investigate the role of diets toward plant‐based meat alternatives. In addition, although four commercially available burgers were included to represent market availability, the variation in ingredient compositions necessitates attention when making relative comparisons among them. Our focus was primarily on the impact of product information disclosure of sensory, emotional, and appropriateness drivers on liking for each product. The study used information provision (e.g., “animal‐like protein burger”) as a way to mimic a potential message on the product packaging; however, it was beyond the aim of this study to investigate consumers’ knowledge and interpretation of these messages and to test other wording for plant‐based meat alternatives. Therefore, further studies could explore the best communication strategies to provide claims on packaging that could support consumers understand the main characteristics of plant‐based alternative products. In addition, it would be worth investigating to what extent the provision of different types of information (e.g., the impact these products have on health and/or sustainability) could influence the drivers of liking.

5. CONCLUSIONS

The success of meat alternatives, such as plant‐based and blended burgers, among meat consumers depends on how consumers evaluate their sensory profile, emotional profile, and situational appropriateness, as well as the information provided.

Although this study provides only a snapshot of some main ingredients used in modern meat analogs, our results demonstrate that product descriptions have an impact on consumer acceptance. Considering the distinct meat‐like attributes found in some plant‐based meat alternatives currently available on the market, which provide a sense of eating real meat, it is reasonable to assume that individuals following a vegetarian or vegan diet may not fully experience this sensation. Consequently, product marketing communication strategies should consider what information to report in terms of sensory and ingredient characteristics by defining the extent to which their alternatives resemble regular meat products.

In addition to sensory evaluations, it is crucial to consider other meaningful measures, such as emotions and appropriateness, to gain a comprehensive understanding of how plant‐based and hybrid meat alternatives are perceived compared to their animal‐based counterparts. By going beyond simple measures of liking, our research provides novel insights into consumer behavior prediction and marketing strategies for plant‐based meat alternatives.

AUTHOR CONTRIBUTIONS

Giovanni Sogari: Conceptualization; writing—original draft; methodology; formal analysis; supervision; investigation; project administration; writing—review and editing. Simona Grasso: Writing—original draft; methodology; formal analysis; data curation; writing—review and editing; visualization. Vincenzina Caputo: Conceptualization; investigation; writing—original draft; writing—review and editing. Miguel I. Gómez: Conceptualization; funding acquisition; investigation; supervision; writing—review and editing. Cristina Mora: Writing—review and editing; conceptualization; funding acquisition; supervision. Joachim J. Schouteten: Writing—review and editing; formal analysis; data curation; visualization.

CONFLICT OF INTEREST STATEMENT

The authors declare that they have no known financial conflicts of interest or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.

Supporting information

Table S1 Sample demographics (%).

Table S2 Terms used in the RATA questions divided into four categories.

Table S3 Emotion sentences.

Table S4 Usage contexts.

Figure S1 CA plots showing the first two dimensions of the CA models based upon the sensory term data for the four burgers of (a) the blind treatment and (b) the informed treatment.

JFDS-89-2974-s001.docx (96.4KB, docx)

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

We sincerely appreciate the research assistants of the Cornell Campus who contributed to the data collection.

REFERENCES

  1. Andreani, G. , Sogari, G. , Marti, A. , Froldi, F. , Dagevos, H. , & Martini, D. (2023). Plant‐based meat alternatives: Technological, nutritional, environmental, market, and social challenges and opportunities. Nutrients, 15(2), 452. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  2. Ares, G. , Bruzzone, F. , Vidal, L. , Cadena, R. S. , Giménez, A. , Pineau, B. , Hunter, D. C. , Paisley, A. G. , & Jaeger, S. R. (2014). Evaluation of a rating‐based variant of check‐all‐that‐apply questions: Rate‐all‐that‐apply (RATA). Food Quality and Preference, 36, 87–95. http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0950329314000536 [Google Scholar]
  3. Ares, G. , Dauber, C. , Fernández, E. , Giménez, A. , & Varela, P. (2014). Penalty analysis based on CATA questions to identify drivers of liking and directions for product reformulation. Food Quality and Preference, 32, 65–76. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0950329313000955 [Google Scholar]
  4. Ares, G. , Giménez, A. , Barreiro, C. , & Gámbaro, A. (2010). Use of an open‐ended question to identify drivers of liking of milk desserts. Comparison with preference mapping techniques. Food Quality and Preference, 21(3), 286–294. http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S095032930900069X [Google Scholar]
  5. Asioli, D. , Banovic, M. , Barone, A. M. , Grasso, S. , & Nayga, R. M. (2023). European consumers’ valuation for hybrid meat: Does information matter? Applied Economic Perspectives and Policy, 45(1), 44–62. 10.1002/aepp.13283 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
  6. Banovic, M. , & Barone, A. M. (2021). The hybrid enigma: The importance of self‐construal for the effectiveness of communication messages promoting sustainable behaviour. Food Quality and Preference, 94, 104334. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0950329321002172 [Google Scholar]
  7. Boukid, F. (2021). Plant‐based meat analogues: From niche to mainstream. European Food Research and Technology, 247(2), 297–308. 10.1007/s00217-020-03630-9 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
  8. Boukid, F. , Rosell, C. M. , & Castellari, M. (2021). Pea protein ingredients: A mainstream ingredient to (Re)formulate innovative foods and beverages. Trends in Food Science & Technology, 110, 729–742. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0924224421001473 [Google Scholar]
  9. Caparros Megido, R. , Gierts, C. , Blecker, C. , Brostaux, Y. , Haubruge, É. , Alabi, T. , & Francis, F. (2016). Consumer acceptance of insect‐based alternative meat products in western countries. Food Quality and Preference, 52, 237–243. [Google Scholar]
  10. Cordelle, S. , Redl, A. , & Schlich, P. (2022). Sensory acceptability of new plant protein meat substitutes. Food Quality and Preference, 98, 104508. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0950329321003906 [Google Scholar]
  11. Cutroneo, S. , Angelino, D. , Tedeschi, T. , Pellegrini, N. , & Martini, D. (2022). Nutritional quality of meat analogues: Results from the food labelling of Italian products (FLIP) project. Frontiers in Nutrition, 9, 852831. https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fnut.2022.852831 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  12. Dalenberg, J. R. , Gutjar, S. , Ter Horst, G. J. , de Graaf, K. , Renken, R. J. , & Jager, G. (2014). Evoked emotions predict food choice. PLoS ONE, 9(12), e115388. 10.1371/journal.pone.0115388 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  13. Demartini, E. , Vecchiato, D. , Finos, L. , Mattavelli, S. , & Gaviglio, A. (2022). Would you buy vegan meatballs? The policy issues around vegan and meat‐sounding labelling of plant‐based meat alternatives. Food Policy, 111, 102310. [Google Scholar]
  14. Elzerman, J. E. , Keulemans, L. , Sap, R. , & Luning, P. A. (2021). Situational appropriateness of meat products, meat substitutes and meat alternatives as perceived by Dutch consumers. Food Quality and Preference, 88, 104108. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0950329320303773 [Google Scholar]
  15. Fiorentini, M. , Kinchla, A. J. , & Nolden, A. A. (2020). Role of Sensory Evaluation in Consumer Acceptance of Plant‐Based Meat Analogs and Meat Extenders: A Scoping Review. Foods, 9(9), 1334. 10.3390/foods9091334 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  16. Giacalone, D. , Clausen, M. P. , & Jaeger, S. R. (2022). Understanding barriers to consumption of plant‐based foods and beverages: Insights from sensory and consumer science. Current Opinion in Food Science, 48, 100919. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2214799322001217 [Google Scholar]
  17. Giacalone, D. , Frøst, M. B. , Bredie, W. L. P. , Pineau, B. , Hunter, D. C. , Paisley, A. G. , Beresford, M. K. , & Jaeger, S. R. (2015). Situational appropriateness of beer is influenced by product familiarity. Food Quality and Preference, 39, 16–27. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0950329314001311 [Google Scholar]
  18. Giacalone, D. , & Jaeger, S. R. (2016). Better the devil you know? How product familiarity affects usage versatility of foods and beverages. Journal of Economic Psychology, 55, 120–138. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0167487016000180 [Google Scholar]
  19. Giacalone, D. , & Jaeger, S. R. (2019). Consumer ratings of situational (‘Item‐by‐Use’) appropriateness predict food choice responses obtained in central location tests. Food Quality and Preference, 78, 103745. [Google Scholar]
  20. Giacalone, D. , Llobell, F. , & Jaeger, S. R. (2022). ‘Beyond Liking’ measures in food‐related consumer research supplement hedonic responses and improve ability to predict consumption. Food Quality and Preference, 97, 104459. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0950329321003414 [Google Scholar]
  21. Grasso, S. , & Jaworska, S. (2020). Part meat and part plant: Are hybrid meat products fad or future? Foods, 9(12), 1888. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  22. Grasso, S. , Monahan, F. J. , Hutchings, S. C. , & Brunton, N. P. (2017). The effect of health claim information disclosure on the sensory characteristics of plant sterol‐enriched turkey as assessed using the check‐all‐that‐apply (CATA) methodology. Food Quality and Preference, 57, 69–78. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0950329316302580 [Google Scholar]
  23. Grasso, S. , Rondoni, A. , Bari, R. , Smith, R. , & Mansilla, N. (2022). Effect of information on consumers’ sensory evaluation of beef, plant‐based and hybrid beef burgers. Food Quality and Preference, 96, 104417. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0950329321002998 [Google Scholar]
  24. Grasso, S. , Smith, G. , Bowers, S. , Ajayi, O. M. , & Swainson, M. (2019). Effect of texturised soy protein and yeast on the instrumental and sensory quality of hybrid beef meatballs. Journal of Food Science and Technology, 56(6), 3126–3135. 10.1007/s13197-018-3552-9 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  25. Guinard, J. X. , Myrdal Miller, A. , Mills, K. , Wong, T. , Lee, S. M. , Sirimuangmoon, C. , Schaefer, S. E. , & Drescher, G. (2016). Consumer acceptance of dishes in which beef has been partially substituted with mushrooms and sodium has been reduced. Appetite, 105, 449–459. 10.1016/j.appet.2016.06.018 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  26. Gutjar, S. , Dalenberg, J. R. , De Graaf, C. , De Wijk, R. A. , Palascha, A. , Renken, R. J. , & Jager, G. (2015). What reported food‐evoked emotions may add: A model to predict consumer food choice. Food Quality and Preference, 45, 140–148. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0950329315001378 [Google Scholar]
  27. Gutjar, S. , de Graaf, C. , Kooijman, V. , De Wijk, R. A. , Nys, A. , Ter Horst, G. J. , & Jager, G. (2015). The role of emotions in food choice and liking. Food Research International, 76, 216–223. [Google Scholar]
  28. He, J. , Evans, N. M. , Liu, H. , & Shao, S. (2020). A review of research on plant‐based meat alternatives: Driving forces, history, manufacturing, and consumer attitudes. Comprehensive Reviews in Food Science and Food Safety, 19(5), 2639–2656. 10.1111/1541-4337.12610 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  29. Jaeger, S. R. , Lee, P.‐Y. , Jin, D. , Chheang, S. L. , Rojas‐Rivas, E. , & Ares, G. (2019). The item‐by‐use (IBU) method for measuring perceived situational appropriateness: A methodological characterisation using CATA questions. Food Quality and Preference, 78, 103724. [Google Scholar]
  30. Lemken, D. , Spiller, A. , & Schulze‐Ehlers, B. (2019). More room for legume—Consumer acceptance of meat substitution with classic, processed and meat‐resembling legume products. Appetite, 143, 104412. http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0195666318314181 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  31. Markets and Markets . (2020). Plant‐based meat market size, share & growth trends | industry statistics and forecasts | marketsandmarkets . (October 2, 2021). https://www.marketsandmarkets.com/Market‐Reports/plant‐based‐meat‐market‐44922705.html
  32. Martin, C. , Lange, C. , & Marette, S. (2021). Importance of additional information, as a complement to information coming from packaging, to promote meat substitutes: A case study on a sausage based on vegetable proteins. Food Quality and Preference, 87, 104058. http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S095032932030327X [Google Scholar]
  33. Meyners, M. (2016). Testing for differences between impact of attributes in penalty‐lift analysis. Food Quality and Preference, 47, 29–33. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0950329314002109 [Google Scholar]
  34. Meyners, M. , & Castura, J. (2014). Check‐all‐that‐apply questions. In Varela P. & Ares G. (Eds.), Novel techniques in sensory characterization and consumer profiling (pp. 271–306). CRC Press. [Google Scholar]
  35. Meyners, M. , Castura, J. C. , & Carr, B. T. (2013). Existing and new approaches for the analysis of CATA data. Food Quality and Preference, 30(2), 309–319. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0950329313001079 [Google Scholar]
  36. Meyners, M. , Jaeger, S. R. , & Ares, G. (2016). On the analysis of rate‐all‐that‐apply (RATA) data. Food Quality and Preference, 49, 1–10. http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0950329315300045 [Google Scholar]
  37. Neville, M. , Tarrega, A. , Hewson, L. , & Foster, T. (2017). Consumer‐orientated development of hybrid beef burger and sausage analogues. Food Science & Nutrition, 5(4), 852–864. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1002/fsn3.466 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  38. Ng, M. , Chaya, C. , & Hort, J. (2013). The influence of sensory and packaging cues on both liking and emotional, abstract and functional conceptualisations. Food Quality and Preference, 29(2), 146–156. [Google Scholar]
  39. OECD and FAO . (2020). OECD‐FAO agricultural outlook 2020–2029. OECD. https://www.oecd‐ilibrary.org/agriculture‐and‐food/oecd‐fao‐agricultural‐outlook‐2020‐2029_1112c23b‐en [Google Scholar]
  40. Olsen, N. V. , Røssvoll, E. , Langsrud, S. , & Scholderer, J. (2014). Hamburger hazards and emotions. Appetite, 78, 95–101. http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0195666314001226 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  41. Peryam, D. R. , & Pilgrim, F. J. (1957). Hedonic scale method of measuring food preferences. Food Technology, 11, (Suppl), 9–14. [Google Scholar]
  42. Piqueras‐Fiszman, B. , & Spence, C. (2015). Sensory expectations based on product‐extrinsic food cues: An interdisciplinary review of the empirical evidence and theoretical accounts. Food Quality and Preference, 40, 165–179. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0950329314001980 [Google Scholar]
  43. Robert, P. , & Escoufier, Y. (1976). A unifying tool for linear multivariate statistical methods: The RV‐ coefficient. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society. Series C (Applied Statistics), 25(3), 257–265. http://www.jstor.org/stable/2347233 [Google Scholar]
  44. Santagiuliana, M. , Bhaskaran, V. , Scholten, E. , Piqueras‐Fiszman, B. , & Stieger, M. (2019). Don't judge new foods by their appearance! How visual and oral sensory cues affect sensory perception and liking of novel, heterogeneous foods. Food Quality and Preference, 77, 64–77. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0950329319301284 [Google Scholar]
  45. Schouteten, J. J. , De Steur, H. , De Pelsmaeker, S. , Lagast, S. , de Bourdeaudhuij, I. , & Gellynck, X. (2015). An integrated method for the emotional conceptualization and sensory characterization of food products: The EmoSensory® wheel. Food Research International, 78, 96–107. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0963996915302404 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  46. Schouteten, J. J. , De Steur, H. , De Pelsmaeker, S. , Lagast, S. , Juvinal, J. G. , de Bourdeaudhuij, I. , Verbeke, W. , & Gellynck, X. (2016). Emotional and sensory profiling of insect‐, plant‐ and meat‐based burgers under blind, expected and informed conditions. Food Quality and Preference, 52, 27–31. [Google Scholar]
  47. Smetana, S. , Profeta, A. , Voigt, R. , Kircher, C. , & Heinz, V. (2021). Meat substitution in burgers: Nutritional scoring, sensorial testing, and life cycle assessment. Future Foods, 4, 100042. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2666833521000320 [Google Scholar]
  48. Sogari, G. , Caputo, V. , Joshua Petterson, A. , Mora, C. , & Boukid, F. (2023). A sensory study on consumer valuation for plant‐based meat alternatives: What is liked and disliked the most? Food Research International, 169, 112813. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0963996923003587 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  49. Spinelli, S. , Masi, C. , Dinnella, C. , Zoboli, G. P. , & Monteleone, E. (2014). How does it make you feel? A new approach to measuring emotions in food product experience. Food Quality and Preference, 37, 109–122. http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0950329313002267 [Google Scholar]
  50. Spinelli, S. , Masi, C. , Zoboli, G. P. , Prescott, J. , & Monteleone, E. (2015). Emotional responses to branded and unbranded foods. Food Quality and Preference, 42, 1–11. [Google Scholar]
  51. Williams, E. J. (1949). Experimental designs balanced for the estimation of residual effects of treatments. Australian Journal of Chemistry, 2(2), 149–168. 10.1071/CH9490149 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
  52. van Loo, E. J. , Caputo, V. , & Lusk, J. L. (2020). Consumer preferences for farm‐raised meat, lab‐grown meat, and plant‐based meat alternatives: Does information or brand matter? Food Policy, 95, 101931. http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0306919220301354 [Google Scholar]
  53. Vidal, L. , Ares, G. , Hedderley, D. I. , Meyners, M. , & Jaeger, S. R. (2018). Comparison of rate‐all‐that‐apply (RATA) and check‐all‐that‐apply (CATA) questions across seven consumer studies. Food Quality and Preference, 67, 49–58. http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0950329316302695 [Google Scholar]

Associated Data

This section collects any data citations, data availability statements, or supplementary materials included in this article.

Supplementary Materials

Table S1 Sample demographics (%).

Table S2 Terms used in the RATA questions divided into four categories.

Table S3 Emotion sentences.

Table S4 Usage contexts.

Figure S1 CA plots showing the first two dimensions of the CA models based upon the sensory term data for the four burgers of (a) the blind treatment and (b) the informed treatment.

JFDS-89-2974-s001.docx (96.4KB, docx)

Articles from Journal of Food Science are provided here courtesy of Wiley

RESOURCES