ABSTRACT
Nursing values include commitment to care for all and facilitation of healthy environments. The actualisation of these values, however, is often constrained by healthcare systems when overly influenced by neoliberal priorities for revenue generation. Assuming this context, the dynamics of two ontological nursing motives, loving service (agape) and creative agency (eros), are considered as they relate to nursing axiology, lived experience, and practice. Transversal analysis is engaged to further explore the implications that posthumanist philosophy may have for the relationship of eros–agape dynamics. Consequences for nursing practice and qualitative experience are considered. The analysis concludes in three propositions. The first, that in realigning loving service (agape) aspects of nursing with the nurse person's development of creativity and agency (eros), the nurse‐person may be more satisfied in ego reward, and the actualisation of nursing values that hold commitment to all persons, facilitation of healthy environments, and actions of human caring, could be better supported. The second, that posthumanism, particularly the aspects of intersubjectivity and co‐being, may transform the possibilities of eros and agape ontological motives in nursing to support greater emergence of connected multidirectional caring; so that the nurse‐person is less alienated in providing care and, instead, is an active member of caring ecologies. The third, that in realigning loving service (agape) aspects of nursing with the nurse person's development of creativity and agency (eros), the nurse‐person may be more satisfied in ego reward, and the actualisation of nursing values that hold commitment to all persons, facilitation of healthy environments, and actions of human caring, could be better supported.
Keywords: agape, eros, nursing, ontological, posthumanism
The work of nursing is often determined, not only by nursing values and professional autonomy, but also by institutional directives that prioritise revenue‐generation. Even for mission‐driven healthcare institutions, the context of neoliberal economic systems often serves as a limit to the full extension of care. Neoliberal motivational structures may limit time available for human interactions of care, limit allocation of resources to address upstream health determinants, and discourage change to circumstances which create unhealthy environments when such change may threaten financial interests of powerful actors. This arrangement restrains a nursing ethos that centres caring for all and promotion of salutary environments, thus frustrating the actualisation of nursing role, limiting the contributions of nursing, and diminishing the satisfaction of nurse persons. The profession of nursing has, arguably, developed increased agency within institutions and has set to actualise commitments to social justice and environmental health. However, limitations persist.
In this paper, I develop ontologically rooted propositions to support the emergence of nursing towards greater capacity in care, greater professional well‐being, and contribution to planetary well‐being. This work develops ideas on particular ontological motives in nursing, specifically eros and agape, and explores relevant implications held in posthuman philosophy.
1. Assumptions
The analysis moves forward holding several assumptions. One of these is the understanding that nursing values include human caring, care for all, and support of healthy environments. It is also understood that nursing axiology, including professional values, is both important and contested. Furthermore, this analysis is built on the assumption that the experience of the nurse‐person is meaningful and worthy of nurturance.
2. Philosophical Approach
The logic of this work begins with consideration of the alignment of the ontological forces of agape and eros, and implications for nursing experience and practice. Next, the philosophical approach of transversal analysis is engaged to explore the ways in which posthuman perspectives relate to the nursing eros–agape dynamic. The analysis is transversal in that it will take up the ways that posthumanism may both relate, support, put pressure against and, subsequently, open cracks within the humanist framing that allow for alternative ontological relationships and approaches to practice to emerge in nursing. Transversal analysis here is also sensitive to the presence of transversal dynamics within the subject of analysis.
Use of the transversal has been advanced by Deleuze and Guattari (1987), Rosi Braidotti (2013) and Bayo Akómoláfé (2019). Deleuze and Guattari engaged the concept as an alternative to the psychological notion of transference—so that a transversal relationship (between therapist and patient) was no longer the subordinate therapeutic relationship but was connected, bidirectional, and changeable. In a discussion of Guattari's ideas, Laberge (2024) explained, “Transversality is therefore a mode of association which is neither vertical nor horizontal, but which moves unexpectedly from one register to another.” (p. 102).
The notion of transversal has been extended to many fields, including political economy and I use it here, as Akómoláfé (2019) and Braidotti (2013), as a way of opening understandings, of looking for the cracks in established ways, of letting in light, and opening new possibilities.
3. Analysis
Prior work (Valentine‐Maher 2008) has offered conceptualisations of the ontological forces of agape and eros and proposed that the dynamic of these forces is important for the development of nursing role. This new work continues the analysis and extends to consider the implications of humanist and posthumanist perspectives.
3.1. Agape and Eros in Nursing
Agape is understood as a love without self‐interest—a giving love often seen as spiritual in nature. Although the term is incorporated in some religious contexts, it is not necessarily associated with religion. Agape is a love for the world and those in it. Ernest Becker (1973, 151–152) has discussed agape as an ontological motive. Agape motive is present in nursing's situatedness in beyond‐self connection and caring—expressed both directly to persons and in concern for the environment which affects health.
Eros, a different ontological motive, is a force of self‐development, creativity, and agency. As discussed by Becker (1973, 153), it is individuation and the power of self‐expansion. In nursing the eros motive is actualised, in part, in professional autonomy.
However, the full development of eros via professional autonomy, or other creative self‐expansion, is nursing may be blocked or diverted when the nurse's intention in eros‐driven work is to address care, or environment, in ways that challenge primacy of economic profit.
The barrier may be understood as what is described as the “depth dimension” by Marcuse (1979). The depth dimension is the imperative reproduction of dominant societal values, in this case, the reproduction of neoliberalist approaches in nursing practice environments. Neoliberalism is understood as a social, political and economic arrangement in which the structures of a liberal humanistic society are more highly tuned to the processes of capital accumulation (as an occupant of individual rights status) than to concerns of the common good. In effect, eros and agape integration in nursing has been disrupted by the depth dimension of neoliberalism in health care systems. This disruption involves stunting of core claimed values of nursing to the detriment of both nursing care and nursing lived experience.
I suggest a move towards a reflective and purposeful ontological empowerment in which, challenging the hold of the depth‐dimension of neoliberalism, there is a claim on the rightness of both eros and agape alignment with nursing values, and the expression of these values in practice. Creative power and ego satisfaction could merge with service and loving attendance—transforming the eros/agape dynamic to a satisfying, beneficent, and generative dynamic. Such an ontological change would involve the growth of critical consciousness and the development of strategies and pathways to create opportunity for values‐actualised nursing practice.
The first proposition of this paper is as follows: In realigning loving service (agape) aspects of nursing with the nurse person's development of creativity and agency (eros), the nurse‐person may be more satisfied in ego reward, and the actualisation of nursing values that hold commitment to all persons, facilitation of healthy environments, and actions of human caring, could be better supported.
3.2. Humanist to Posthumanist Implications
3.2.1. The Context of Humanism
Professional nursing has primarily operated within the constructs of liberal humanism, the philosophical structure guiding liberal democracies. The traditions of humanism are traced to Cicero (1st century BCE), who drew from the Paideia of the ancient Greeks—a pattern of thought and infrastructure to support the development of full beautiful selves (men) to serve the state as good citizens. Humanism holds primarily the development of individual self which then proceeds to contribute to the social good (good citizenship). Within the framework of liberal humanism are many of the tools with which human dignity and protection are sought, notably the concept of universal human rights. However, critical consideration of liberal humanism reveals that the primacy of the individual fails to adequately attend to material conditions which affect groups or classes of people. This allows far reaching systems of economic exploitation to exist with responses to this exploitation focused more on individual opportunity than broad population impact. The neoliberal turn of liberal humanism supports capital accumulation as a primary self/individual interest even over the interest of populations.
Posthuman philosopher Francesca Ferrando (2021) acknowledges “The philanthropic tendency of the ideal humanism, which means loving and supporting each other, as humans, is indeed precious” but notes the “damaging myths of human and anthropocentric superiority” (p. 222). The emphasis on self in humanism serves to make the individual distinct both from other persons and from nature—providing conditions for potential alienation in lived experience and for the ease of exploitation of nature.
In relation to the humanistic centrality of the human self as distinct from the ‘all’ of the natural world, posthuman philosopher and public intellectual Báyò Akómoláfé illustrates the ontological implications of “desacralizing the world” (2020), noting,
This anthropocentricity has material consequences. In seeing ourselves as independent, essential, whole, removed, distant, complete, sovereign and in control, we neglect the world that grants us our bodies. We fail to decorate the porosity and ongoing transcorporeality (a term by philosopher, Stacy Alaimo) that means we actually live through manifold bodies. We shut off the ecological intelligences and senses that might reframe our problems in surprising new ways. (2020)
Although claiming universality of humanity and concern for human welfare, humanism has not been successful in preventing the de‐humanisation of some for the purposes of control, extraction, and/or exploitation. In an important distinction, scholar Zakiyyah Iman Jackson writes that the de‐humanisation observed to accompany humanism is “more accurately interpreted as the violence of humanization or the burden of inclusion into a racially hierarchised universal humanity.” (2021, 18).
3.2.2. The Potential in Posthumanism
The emergence of critical post‐humanism is a response to the deeply rooted shortcomings of humanism for ‘well beings’ (human and all). Posthumanism holds a complexity of threads of thought and meaning. I do not, in this analysis, take up each of these threads. For example, I do not directly take up the focus on technological and human relationships, which is also a part of some posthuman thought. Rather, this analysis engages the critical and ecological elements of posthumanism.
4. Implications for Ontological/Phenomenological Experience of Eros and Agape Motives
At the core of posthumanism is human connection and relationality with “the all” of the human and natural world, co‐being, and intersubjectivity. The ecological connections in posthumanism have immediate ontological implications and so translate to human practices in communities. Along a transversal—this ontological attitude communicates with humanist notions of self, other, and care for humanity to expand the lived experience from being of self to include being of with, Ferrando's “We, Are” (2021, 224). Posthumanism comes to this insight in relation to humanism, but this is not a new insight. Similar perspectives and robust ecologically connected ontologies exist, particularly in communities and groups not primarily claiming liberal humanistic traditions, and in groups and schools of thought with critical traditions.
In direct relationship to nursing, Smith et al. (2024) write in a posthuman critique of the culture and politics of the unidirectional approach to nursing care, “narrow expectations of care are reinforced by problematic imaginings of what it means to be a nurse, alienating nurses as people from the humans and more‐than‐humans in their care.” (p. 4). The question here of what it means to be a nurse relates to the posthuman suggestion of what it might mean to be part of the beyond human (both human and connected with the all). Posthumanism is itself in a transversal attitude—not with a complete rejection of humanism but with a shift. The transversal connection of posthuman ideas offers the possibility for an integration of multi‐way relationship and intersubjectivity in the agape‐eros dynamic in nursing, from caring for to caring with.
A vision for relational and sustaining care has been brought forward by the Care Collective (2020). The group writes of the idea of “universal care” as both hands‐on direct care and care as “social capacity and activity involving the nurturing of all that is necessary for the welfare and flourishing of life” (p. 5). They explain that “All forms of care between all categories of human and non‐human should be valued, recognised and resourced equally, according to their needs or ongoing sustainability” (p. 40), and “…that all our lives are improved when we care and are cared for, and when we care together” (p. 44). This is a vision far beyond the particularities of nursing—and the implications for nursing are important—showing us an image of what relational, situationally responsive care could be. In this vision, there is both an alternative to many of the current realities of nursing practice, as well as echoes of the values of presence and of concern for the environment held in nursing. In addition to encouraging a societal shift, the vision seems to be a lesson for a vision of liberated nursing.
A posthuman expansion in eros and agape motive to a more connected and relational ontology relieves alienation and pressure of the paradoxical pairing of individualism and sacrifice in nursing care and brings, for nurse‐persons, greater ease and pleasure, in holding concern and taking actions for healthier beings and communities.
The second proposition of this paper is as follows: Posthumanism, particularly the aspects of intersubjectivity and co‐being, may transform the possibilities of eros and agape ontological motives in nursing to support greater emergence of connected multidirectional caring, so that the nurse‐person is less alienated in providing care and, instead, is an active member of caring ecologies.
4.1. Implications for Praxis of Eros and Agape Motives
An important additional core element of posthumanism is the sensibility of the externalisation and exploitation of persons and of other nature—exploitation within, and by, societies grounded in humanism. Although not the only critical response to these failings in liberal humanism, posthumanism draws up an alternative of situated realities and relational subjectivity that humanism has failed to embrace—what the subaltern may carry forward. This is an emancipatory orientation, as feminist and posthumanist philosopher Braidotti describes,
…an enlarged sense of inter‐connection between self and others, including the nonhuman or ‘earth’ others. This practice of relating to others requires and is enhanced by the rejection of self‐centred individualism. It produces a new way of combining self‐interests with the well‐being of an enlarged community, based on environmental inter‐connections. (2013, 48)
If eros and agape motives in nursing are more relational with the world (human and nature), there is less internal resistance and more sustenance within nursing sensibilities for the work of care for persons and all. The ego reward is being with and together—being for “the all” of each other. This relationality then builds to just responses with others. Braidotti writes,
…the critical posthuman subject within an eco‐philosophy of multiple belongings, as a relational subject constituted in and by multiplicity, that is to say a subject that works across differences and is also internally differentiated, but still grounded and accountable. Posthuman subjectivity expresses an embodied and embedded and hence partial form of accountability, based on a strong sense of collectivity, relationality and hence community building. (2013, 49)
The posthuman attitude brings affirmative commitments towards emancipatory practices; the type of practices which address important determinants of health such as alienation, environmental degradation, racism, sexism, bigotry, extractive economies, and poverty. This position holds implications for facing the depth‐dimension of neoliberalism in health care, implications that incorporate both the individually felt ontological experience as well as the possibilities for emancipatory nursing practices more aligned with nursing values.
As Hodge and Olson (2024) suggest, posthumanism as a lens may help to facilitate greater understanding of possibilities for nursing emancipatory actions. In an exploration of critical posthumanism in relationship to nursing ways of knowing, Hodge and Olson (2024) propose an exercise that would engage a posthuman perspective—a conceptual mapping exercise beginning with a particular patient case and tracing the tentacular relationships with the world (what we know as social and physical determinants of health, but moving the focus of concern beyond the endpoint person). In this type of expansion of thinking and sensibility, I suggest, for example, one might consider that an exacerbation of COPD due to wildfire smoke exposure is related to the over‐burning of forest, and entangled with the plants, animals, air, other humans, and nurse‐person who are also touched by these circumstances., “We, Are” touched by these circumstances.
This way of conceptualising is not completely unknown in nursing—to understand the importance of environment to health, even to consider the earth as a patient. However, what a posthuman perspective brings is a greater sense of unity within circumstances, and an attitude of affirmatively addressing these circumstances
Such emancipatory action might look like organised nursing advocacy for environmental protection, or against oppression of communities, or for institutional policies that support greater community engagement in hospital practices, or institutional practices that support deeper caring practice (e.g., nursing presence) in direct care. I propose that a greater agape and eros merger facilitated by posthumanism adds fortitude and spirit to those inclined towards such action. This brings both vision and strength to overcome depth‐dimension barriers to greater realisation of nursing values.
The third proposition of this paper is as follows: The emancipatory attitude of posthumanism (with an interest in non‐dominated, intersubjective, interconnected subjects) brings both a critical lens of understanding and ontological vitality to eros and agape merger—thus supporting nurses to more fully act on caring, emancipatory, and environmental values.
5. Conclusion
This enquiry has discussed eros–agape ontological dynamics in nursing, then engaged transversal analysis in exploration of the relevant implications of posthumanist philosophy. For each of these elements of enquiry, the relationship of ontological considerations to nursing axiology, lived experience, and practice was considered. Having engaged in the spirit of wondering, the analysis arrives at three propositions. The propositions are restated here.
-
1.
In realigning loving service (agape) aspects of nursing with the nurse person's development of creativity and agency (eros), the nurse‐person may be more satisfied in ego reward, and the actualisation of nursing values that hold commitment to all persons, facilitation of healthy environments, and actions of human caring, could be better supported.
-
2.
Posthumanism, particularly the aspects of intersubjectivity and co‐being, may transform the possibilities of eros and agape ontological motives in nursing to support greater emergence of connected multidirectional caring, so that the nurse‐person is less alienated in providing care and, instead, is an active member of caring ecologies.
-
3.
The emancipatory attitude of posthumanism (with an interest in non‐dominated, intersubjective, interconnected subjects) brings both a critical lens of understanding and ontological vitality to eros and agape merger—thus supporting nurses to more fully act on caring, emancipatory, and environmental values.
Conflicts of Interest
The author declares no conflicts of interest.
Acknowledgements
The author thanks Dr. Alan Mandell for critical feedback on the draft paper. The analysis presented here is entirely the authors. There was no use of generative AI in the analysis or writing of this work. Funding for conference attendance for the initial presentation of ideas, that were later developed further in this paper, was provided by the SUNY Empire Foundation as part of the Arthur Imperatore Community Forum Fellowship.
Data Availability Statement
Data sharing not applicable to this article as no datasets were generated or analysed during the current study.
References
- Akómoláfé, B. (Speaker). 2019. “The Insurgency of the Invisible [Audio podcast].” Emerge podcast With Daniel Thorson, July 8. https://creators.spotify.com/pod/profile/emerge/episodes/Bayo-Akomolafe---The-Insurgency-of-the-Invisible-e4i097. [Google Scholar]
- Akómoláfé, B. 2020. “Coming Down to Earth.” Articles, March 11. https://www.bayoakomolafe.net/post/coming-down-to-earth. [Google Scholar]
- Becker, E. 1973. The Denial of Death. The Free Press. [Google Scholar]
- Braidotti, R. 2013. The Posthuman. Polity Press. [Google Scholar]
- Deleuze, G. , and Guattari F.. 1987. A Thousand Plateaus. University of Minnesota Press. [Google Scholar]
- Ferrando, F. 2021. “Beyond Posthuman Theory: Tackling Realities of Everyday Life.” Journal of Posthumanism 1, no. 2: 219–224. 10.33182/jp.v1i2.1840. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Hodge, L. A. , and Olson J. K.. 2024. “Critical Posthumanism: A Double‐Edged Sword for Advancing Nursing Knowledge in Planetary Health.” Nursing Inquiry 31, no. 4: e12677. 10.1111/nin.12677. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Jackson, Z. I. 2021. Becoming Human: Matter and Meaning in an Antiblack World. New York University Press. 10.18574/9781479834556. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Laberge, J.‐S. 2024. “Transversality, or How Not to Reproduce the Organisations You Fight.” Deleuze and Guattari Studies 18, no. 1: 98–119. 10.3366/dlgs.2024.0544. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Marcuse, H. 1979. “Ecology and the Critique of Modern Society.” Capitalism Nature Socialism 3, no. 3: 29–38. Talk given to students in 1979; Published in 1992. [Google Scholar]
- Smith, J. , Willis E., Hopkins‐Walsh J., Dillard‐Wright J., and Brown B.. 2024. “The Vitruvian Nurse and Burnout: New Materialist Approaches to Impossible Ideals.” Nursing Inquiry 31, no. 1: e12538. 10.1111/nin.12538. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- The Care Collective . 2020. The Care Manifesto: The Politics of Interdependence. Edited by Chatzidakis A., Hakim A. J., Litter J., Rootenber C. and Sega L.. Verso. [Google Scholar]
- Valentine‐Maher, S. 2008. “The Transformative Potential of Realigning Agape and Eros in the Continued Development of Nursing's Role.” Research and Theory for Nursing Practice 22, no. 3: 171–181. [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
Associated Data
This section collects any data citations, data availability statements, or supplementary materials included in this article.
Data Availability Statement
Data sharing not applicable to this article as no datasets were generated or analysed during the current study.
