Skip to main content
Arthroscopy Techniques logoLink to Arthroscopy Techniques
. 2026 Aug 4;15(8):e70200. doi: 10.1002/atn2.70200

Combined Anterior Cruciate Ligament Tensioned Remnant Suspension Repair and Autograft Reconstruction for Sherman I‐II Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injuries

Zirong Huang 1, Wenhan Yang 1, Wenzhe Feng 1, Yankan Ou 1, Weimin Zhu 1,✉
PMCID: PMC13435299  PMID: 42553685

Abstract

Arthroscopic anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with tensioned remnant preservation is a simple, reproducible strategy designed to enhance graft biology and stability in appropriately selected patients while maintaining anatomic tunnel accuracy. Prioritized for acute cases with functional remnants (Sherman I‐II), the approach leverages the remnant's “biologic scaffold” and “fluid‐seal” effects to promote graft synovialization, revascularization, and reinnervation, reduce synovial fluid washout into the tunnels, and potentially improve rotational control. When applied under strict indications, this remnant‐preserving, tensioning strategy can achieve functional outcomes comparable to standard anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction while providing additional benefits for graft integration and joint stability.


graphic file with name ATN2-15-e70200-g002.webp

Anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injury is among the most common traumas in sports medicine, and ACL reconstruction (ACLR) is widely recognized as the standard surgical approach to restore knee stability and function. 1 Nevertheless, postoperative residual instability and graft rerupture remain prevalent, prompting ongoing efforts to optimize surgical techniques. 2 In recent years, ACLR with preservation of the tibial remnant has attracted increasing attention due to its potential “biological sleeve” effect: histological evidence indicates that the ACL remnant retains synovial blood supply, fibroblasts, and mechanoreceptors, which may facilitate graft synovialization, revascularization, and reinnervation, while the “seal effect” may reduce joint fluid ingress into the bone tunnels, thereby potentially improving graft integration and joint stability. 3 , 4 , 5

Despite these theoretical advantages, clinical outcomes of remnant‐preserving ACLR remain heterogeneous. Some studies suggest enhanced postoperative stability, lower graft failure rates, and accelerated functional recovery, whereas others report no significant differences compared with conventional techniques. Additionally, concerns have been raised regarding limited visualization, challenges in accurate tunnel placement, and an increased risk of cyclops lesions associated with remnant preservation.

It is critical to note that the benefits of remnant preservation depend on the “quality‐load” status of the remnant. Mechanoreceptors are primarily located in the subsynovial layer around the tibial footprint, and their number declines with increasing time from injury; moreover, functionally loaded, longer remnants exhibit greater reinnervation potential. Therefore, tensioned remnant preservation in patients with a shorter interval from injury and a higher proportion of functional remnant may maximize both biological and stability‐related benefits. 5 Building upon this evidence and recent advances, we propose—under strict indications and targeting acute injuries with Sherman type I‐II remnants—an arthroscopic technique that is simple and efficient while achieving both “complete preservation and tensioning.” This approach aims to maximize preservation of peripheral synovial‐vascular‐neural structures without compromising anatomic tunnel placement, to mitigate the risks of cyclops lesions and tunnel malposition, and to achieve overall functional outcomes comparable to standard ACLR with superior rotational stability. 2 , 6

SURGICAL TECHNIQUE

Step 1: Positioning and Anesthesia

Under combined spinal‐epidural anesthesia, the patient is placed supine. The operative limb is positioned to meet 2 intraoperative requirements: (1) effortless placement into the hyperflexion position for femoral tunnel preparation and (2) the ability for the knee to hang freely off the table edge to facilitate tendon harvest and handling. Confirm stability and reproducibility of positioning before incision and ensure seamless intraoperative transitions between positions (Video 1).

VIDEO 1.

Download video file (80.1MB, mp4)

This video shows arthroscopic remnant‐tensioning suspension fixation combined with anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction for Sherman I‐II anterior cruciate ligament injury (right knee): After anesthesia, the patient was placed supine and standard arthroscopic portals were established. Femoral‐side torn fibers were debrided with a shaver, the femoral tunnel aperture was positioned at the native anatomic footprint and reamed to match the graft diameter, and a shuttle loop was passed from the femoral tunnel aperture and retrieved to the lateral skin for later use. The tibial aimer tip was positioned slightly posterior to the center of the anterior cruciate ligament tibial remnant, and the tibial tunnel was created with controlled drilling to preserve the tibial remnant. Using a suture hook with high‐strength sutures, 2 continuous bites were placed across the remnant for secure traction; the traction loop and sutures were retrieved through the same working portal, tied to the traction loop, and pulled out through the tibial tunnel. The adjustable loop traction suture was then passed into the shuttle loop, and the 2 strands securing the remnant were each threaded through the 2 openings of the adjustable loop; all sutures were seated within the shuttle loop. By pulling the lateral femoral shuttle, the graft was advanced through the tibial tunnel into the joint and seated within the femoral tunnel, with a probe gently mobilizing the remnant to facilitate smooth graft entry and accurate positioning. After graft seating, the high‐strength sutures were tensioned to drape the remnant over the graft and maintain appropriate tension, and knots were tied with a knot pusher onto the surface of the adjustable loop to complete fixation. Video content can be viewed at https://doi.org/10.1002/atn2.70200.

Step 2: Graft Harvest and Preparation

With the knee flexed approximately 90°, a 2 cm oblique incision (45°) is made about 2 cm medial to the apex of the tibial tubercle. Layered dissection is performed to harvest the gracilis and semitendinosus tendons. After complete removal of adherent muscle fibers, the tendons are doubled to form a 4‐strand construct according to available length. The graft diameter (preferably ≥8 mm) and effective length (preferably ≥7 cm) are measured. A No. 1 absorbable Vicryl suture is used to whipstitch the free ends, and the graft is loaded onto an adjustable‐loop cortical suspension device for later passage.

Step 3: Portal Establishment and Remnant Assessment

Standard anterolateral and anteromedial portals are established. A thorough arthroscopic assessment of the ACL remnant is performed, documenting length and tear pattern. The accessory medial portal is created between the medial femoral condyle and the medial tibial plateau. Under anterolateral visualization, a guide pin is used to simulate the trajectory for the femoral tunnel to avoid iatrogenic chondral injury from instrument impingement on the medial femoral condyle and to secure adequate working space and visualization for precise tunnel placement.

Step 4: Femoral Tunnel Preparation

Loose remnant fibers are selectively debrided to expose the femoral footprint; radiofrequency may be used to mark the planned tunnel entry if needed. The knee is flexed to approximately 120° and placed in hyperflexion position. With the scope in the central (intercondylar) portal and instruments through the medial portal, a 4 mm guide pin is advanced from the center of the femoral remnant footprint to establish the femoral tunnel. After drilling, a depth gauge is used to measure tunnel length. Based on the graft diameter, an appropriately sized reamer is used to create a 2 cm femoral socket (Figure 1A). A femoral passing suture is then shuttled from the intra‐articular tunnel aperture to the skin, ensuring a straight, untwisted path (Figure 1B).

FIGURE 1.

FIGURE 1

Arthroscope inserted through the central portal. Arthroscopic view (A) showing the established femoral tunnel in the patient's right knee. A traction suture loop exits the femoral tunnel to the lateral skin surface for later use. The blue line indicates the intra‐articular traction suture loop (B).

Step 5: Tibial Tunnel Preparation

With the knee flexed to 90°, a 60° tibial guide is positioned, placing its intra‐articular tip at the posterior‐central region of the ACL tibial remnant footprint. A 2.0 mm guide pin is advanced, followed by sequential reaming to match the graft diameter. As the reamer approaches breakthrough at the tibial tunnel aperture, forward pressure is reduced and drilling is slowed to avoid remnant injury, thereby preserving continuity for subsequent remnant coverage and tensioning.

Step 6: Remnant Suturing and Creation of Traction Pathway

Through the central portal, a suture passer introduces high‐strength suture (Figure 2). Two continuous bites are placed across the superior portion of the ACL remnant to achieve robust tissue purchase (Figure 3). Using a suture retriever, both limbs of the high‐strength suture along with the previously placed shuttle suture are retrieved through the central portal, and the high‐strength suture is tied to the shuttle (Figure 4A). Through the tibial tunnel, both the shuttle and the 2 high‐strength suture limbs are pulled out to the tibial side, completing the traction pathway (Figure 4B).

FIGURE 2.

FIGURE 2

The patient is in the supine position, with the right knee hanging vertically at the edge of the operating table. Using the tip of a suture hook, a high‐strength suture is passed, and through a medial portal, 2 loops are used to wrap the mid‐upper portion of the anterior cruciate ligament remnant.

FIGURE 3.

FIGURE 3

The patient is in the supine position, with the right knee hanging vertically at the edge of the operating table. With an assistant stabilizing the tail of the suture hook, a straight clamp is introduced through the anteromedial portal to grasp and retrieve the high‐strength suture from the tip of the suture hook, thereby forming a loop around the remnant.

FIGURE 4.

FIGURE 4

The patient is in the supine position, with the right knee hanging at the edge of the operating table. After the high‐strength suture used to bundle the remnant is passed through the traction suture loop, it is tied (A). A grasper is then used to retrieve the traction loop through the tibial tunnel (B).

Step 7: Graft Passage and Remnant Coverage

The adjustable‐loop (ETButton Adjustable Loop Titanium Plate, Rejoin Mastin Medical Devices) traction suture is passed into the shuttle loop. The 2 high‐strength remnant sutures—designated to wrap and tension the remnant over the graft—are each passed through different openings of the adjustable loop and then loaded into the shuttle (Figure 5A‐C). The shuttle is pulled steadily from the femoral side to draw the graft sequentially through the tibial tunnel, across the joint, and into the femoral tunnel. A probe is used to gently mobilize the remnant to ensure graft visualization and smooth seating into the femoral socket. The cortical button is flipped on the lateral femoral cortex, and the adjustable loop is tightened to seat the graft securely within the socket. The 2 high‐strength remnant sutures are then tensioned to achieve complete remnant coverage of the graft with appropriate tension. A knot pusher is used to secure the remnant sutures deep to the adjustable loop, finalizing an integrated construct of “remnant tensioning with full graft coverage.” (Figure 5D).

FIGURE 5.

FIGURE 5

The patient is in the supine position, with the right knee hanging at the edge of the operating table. The traction suture of the adjustable titanium loop is passed through the traction suture loop (A). Then, the 2 high‐strength sutures used to bundle the remnant are each threaded into the openings at both ends of the titanium loop (B) and placed into the traction suture loop for later retrieval (C), ultimately forming the suspensory fixation shown in (D).

Step 8: Tibial‐Side Fixation

With longitudinal graft tension maintained, a 1.5 mm guidewire is placed at the tibial aperture. The knee is positioned at approximately 20° of flexion, and an interference screw (ReliaFix PEEK Interference Screw, Rejoin Mastin Medical Devices) is inserted to secure the distal graft. Graft tension, range of motion, and remnant coverage are reassessed arthroscopically to confirm the absence of impingement or mechanical catching, completing the intra‐articular portion of the procedure. Surgical pearls and pitfalls of the procedure are described in Table 1. Advantages and disadvantages are presented in Table 2.

TABLE 1.

Pearls and Pitfalls of Key Surgical Steps

Pearls Use a dual‐portal approach for femoral tunnel placement: place the arthroscope through the central (intercondylar) portal and introduce drilling instruments via the medial portal to improve hand‐eye coordination and placement accuracy
Reference the center of the remnant footprint for the femoral tunnel aperture to ensure anatomic positioning
For remnant wrapping, use high‐strength sutures with entry points placed in the superior‐central portion of the remnant; avoid full‐thickness, transremnant stitches to preserve vascularity
Position the tibial tunnel at the posterior‐central region of the remnant footprint to facilitate complete remnant coverage of the reconstructed graft
Pass the high‐strength remnant sutures through the adjustable loop in advance and secure them after final tensioning to achieve an integrated construct of remnant tensioning, coverage, and fixation
Pitfalls With the knee in extreme flexion, the preserved remnant may obscure visualization, compromising anatomic femoral tunnel placement and causing malposition
During tibial tunnel creation, inadequate control of force as the reamer approaches cortical breakthrough at the intra‐articular aperture can macerate the tibial remnant and disrupt its continuity
Aggressive handling with a suture passer can fray or further tear the superior remnant fibers, reducing the purchase and effectiveness of high‐strength suture wrapping
As the graft passes into the tunnels, remnant obstruction may hinder confirmation of cortical button flipping and graft seating timing, increasing the risk of fixation errors

TABLE 2.

Advantages and Disadvantages

Advantages Preservation of proprioceptors, potentially enhancing sensorimotor feedback and proprioceptive recovery
Protection of the graft and reduction of the synovial fluid “washing effect” into the bone tunnels, facilitating tendon‐bone healing
Improved knee stability with the potential for superior functional outcomes
Disadvantages Improper technique may still result in cyclops lesion formation, causing loss of knee extension
Remnant preservation increases procedural complexity, including anatomic tunnel placement and graft passage/seating
An overly anterior tibial tunnel position can lead to graft impingement in the intercondylar notch, increasing wear and risk of failure

Postoperative Rehabilitation

Postoperative rehabilitation begins with protected partial weight‐bearing on postoperative day 1. From weeks 0 to 2, prioritize achieving full knee extension while gradually increasing flexion to 90°. Between weeks 2 and 4, progress flexion to approximately 120° and emphasize quadriceps isometric contractions and straight‐leg raises. From weeks 6 to 12, advance to closed‐chain functional exercises and proprioceptive training to improve gait and stair negotiation. At approximately 3 months, initiate low‐impact activities such as jogging, swimming, and cycling while avoiding cutting, sudden stops, and jumping. Approximately 1 year postoperatively, consider return to sport when knee stability is restored, isokinetic strength symmetry and functional testing meet criteria, and no significant quadriceps atrophy is present.

DISCUSSION

Preservation of the ACL remnant confers clear biologic and biomechanical advantages. First, the remnant serves as a natural scaffold that promotes graft integration with surrounding tissues and reduces micromotion of the graft during knee flexion‐extension. Second, the residual tissue can share load, thereby decreasing graft stress and, over the long term, enhancing the mechanical stability of the reconstruction. 7 However, although some prior techniques advocated remnant preservation, they did not achieve sufficient remnant coverage over the graft or maintain effective remnant tension, and thus failed to fully realize the advantages of promoting graft synovialization. 8

From a surgical standpoint, more complete remnant preservation combined with tensioning enables improved coverage of the femoral and tibial tunnels by the remnant, mitigating the synovial fluid “washing” effect, which can otherwise lead to tunnel enlargement and adversely affect synovialization. 9 Based on this, precise selection of surgical indications is critical: we recommend prioritizing patients in the acute phase of injury with arthroscopic classification of the remnant as Sherman type I‐II.

Regarding concerns about tunnel placement, current evidence suggests that remnant preservation does not compromise accuracy. Kosy et al. reported that maintaining the remnant does not affect the precision of tibial tunnel placement. 10 By contrast, femoral tunnel placement is more challenging due to remnant masking; nevertheless, a three‐dimensional computed tomography‐based study confirmed that even with a substantial remnant, anatomic tunnel positioning can still be achieved when employing remnant‐preserving techniques. 11

Another common concern is the development of cyclops lesions. Bierke et al. study indicated that, in remnant‐preserving reconstructions, these lesions are often caused by torn bundles of the tendon graft. 6 In our experience, cyclops lesions more frequently occur in Sherman type III‐IV cases, in which the remnant is too short to be suspended under tension. Over time, the remnant may kink and contract anterior to the knee, predisposing to lesion formation. These observations further clarify our indications: prioritize Sherman type I‐II cases; perform judicious debridement or radiofrequency shrinkage for excessively lax torn bundles; and exercise caution in patients with a narrow intercondylar notch, as remnant preservation may increase the risk of graft impingement.

In summary, patient selection and remnant management directly influence outcomes. We recommend selecting acute phase patients with Sherman type I‐II remnants for remnant‐preserving reconstruction and tensioning the remnant arthroscopically so that it fully covers the graft without overtensioning, thereby optimizing the balance between promoting synovialization and ensuring mechanical stability.

DISCLOSURES

The authors (Z.H., W.Y., W.F., Y.O., W.Z.) declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

This study was supported by Shenzhen Medical Research Fund (C2501008), Shenzhen Second People's Hospital Clinical Research Fund of Shenzhen High‐level Hospital Construction Project (2023yjlcyj030), Shenzhen Second People's Hospital Clinical Research Fund of Shenzhen High‐level Hospital Construction Project (20243357002), Shenzhen University Medical‐Educational Collaborative High‐Quality Innovation and Development Project (YJXT20250103), Shenzhen High‐level Hospital Construction Fund (2025WQJJ03) and, 2020 Shenzhen University Graduate Education Reform Project (SZUGS2020JG09).

REFERENCES

  • 1. Murray MM. Optimizing outcomes of ACL surgery‐is autograft reconstruction the only reasonable option? J Orthop Res. 2021;39:1843‐1850. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 2. Allende F, Allahabadi S, Sachdev D, et al. Comparing clinical outcomes and knee stability in remnant‐preserving ACL reconstruction versus standard ACL reconstruction: A systematic review and meta‐analysis. Am J Sports Med. 2024;52:3651‐3661. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 3. Musahl V, Engler ID, Nazzal EM, et al. Current trends in the anterior cruciate ligament part II: Evaluation, surgical technique, prevention, and rehabilitation. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc. 2022;30:34‐51. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 4. Sato D, Inoue M, Kasahara Y, et al. Effects of preserving anatomically positioned and adequate remnant ACL tissue in double‐bundle ACL reconstruction. Orthop J Sports Med. 2023;11:23259671231162389. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 5. Kosy JD, Mandalia VI. Anterior cruciate ligament mechanoreceptors and their potential importance in remnant‐preserving reconstruction: A review of basic science and clinical findings. J Knee Surg. 2018;31:736‐746. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 6. Bierke S, Häner M, Karpinski K, Hees T, Petersen W. No increased rate of cyclops lesions and extension deficits after remnant‐preserving ACL reconstruction using the sparing technique. J Orthop Surg Res. 2022;17:463. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 7. Chen C, Zhang J, Bei C, Xin L. Remnant‐preserving techniques in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: A systematic review and meta‐analysis. BMC Surg. 2025;25:304. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 8. Hong L, Li X, Zhang H, et al. Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with remnant preservation: A prospective, randomized controlled study. Am J Sports Med. 2012;40:2747‐2755. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 9. Zhang Q, Zhang S, Cao X, Liu L, Liu Y, Li R. The effect of remnant preservation on tibial tunnel enlargement in ACL reconstruction with hamstring autograft: A prospective randomized controlled trial. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc. 2014;22:166‐173. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 10. Kosy JD, Walmsley K, Gordon EA, et al. Remnant preservation does not affect accuracy of tibial tunnel positioning in single‐bundle ACL reconstruction. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc. 2021;29:1157‐1163. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 11. Buscayret F, Temponi EF, Saithna A, Thaunat M, Sonnery‐Cottet B. Three‐dimensional CT evaluation of tunnel positioning in ACL reconstruction using the single anteromedial bundle biological augmentation (SAMBBA) technique. Orthop J Sports Med. 2017;5:2325967117706511. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]

Articles from Arthroscopy Techniques are provided here courtesy of John Wiley & Sons on behalf of the Arthroscopy Association of North America

RESOURCES