Abstract
The Global Plant Health Assessment is a collaborative project involving approximately one hundred scientists across the world, addressing the global state of plant health as a common good. The project is unusual in that it relies entirely on voluntary contributions from scientists, operates without dedicated funding, and incorporates internal collaboration mechanisms for peer review and publication. Plant Health Reports have been developed by teams of scientists for more than 30 cases, each focusing on a purposely selected keystone plant species representing plant systems in multiple world ecoregions. These plant systems encompass forests, field crops, perennial crops, household and peri-urban systems, as well as urban forests, in both the Global North and the Global South. Despite this necessarily fragmented information, an overall view however emerges on the current state and recent evolution of world plant health, as well as on the consequences of declining plant health on three categories of ecosystem services generated by healthy plants: provisioning, regulating, and cultural-spiritual. Additional reports are being developed to improve this view, along with new developments where the future of plant health and its consequences will be addressed. As a project structure and organisational model, the Global Plant Health Assessment could serve as a template for future collective scientific efforts addressing major questions about global common goods.
Keywords: abiotic stress, ecoregion, ecosystem service, infectious disease, keystone species
In 2019, the United Nations declared 2020 as the International Year of Plant Health. This announcement resonated strongly in the plant science community, particularly within the International Society for Plant Pathology (ISPP), and led to the conduct of the Global Plant Health Assessment (hereafter referred to as GPHA). The name of the project echoes that of the Millennium Ecosystem Assessment (MEA), conducted two decades earlier (MEA, 2005), which did not address plant health in any particular detail. The GPHA was therefore envisioned as a complementary initiative to the MEA. The COVID-19 pandemic delayed the launch, but did not prevent the implementation of the project. A global virtual conference was organized in 2020 by Prof. P. Esker (Department of Microbiology and Plant Pathology, Penn State University), during which the general framework of the project was discussed. This was followed by a first International Workshop, held in Toulouse, France, in October 2021, where a first wave of Plant Health Reports developed by different teams worldwide was reviewed. A second International Workshop took place in November 2024, again in Toulouse, during which a new phase of the project was discussed along with new reports. A third International Workshop is planned for November 2026 in Rome, Italy, where additional Plant Health Reports, along with new elements of the GPHA addressing the future of plant health, will be discussed.
The motivation for declaring the International Year of Plant Health by the United Nations is clear. Plant health matters in the everyday life of any human, and in every aspect of the balance of the biosphere. Healthy plants ensure the sufficient and regular provision of food, fibre, and materials to human societies. They also play a critical role in regulating the Earth’s climate and maintaining its biogeochemical cycles, including the water cycle and atmospheric oxygen. Forest ecosystems, both tropical and temperate, are central to climate regulation through carbon sequestration and evapotranspiration, simultaneously supporting a large fraction of the Earth’s terrestrial biodiversity. Healthy plants in household gardens (also called kitchen or backyard gardens) enable adequate nutrition, the conservation of plant genetic diversity, and supplementary household income, thereby supporting balanced nutrition of children, women, and the elderly in both the Global North and the Global South. In urban environments, healthy trees provide essential ecosystem services by mitigating climate change impacts, moderating urban heat through shading and cooling, sequestering carbon, capturing airborne particles, and reducing atmospheric pollution in cities. These services are particularly critical in megacities, where more than half of humanity now lives. Currently, there are some 46 such megacities worldwide, the majority of which are located in the Global South (vs only 9 in the Global North). In short, without healthy plants, neither human life nor ecosystem stability can be sustained.
The GPHA is an unusual research project in many respects, reflecting both the adaptation of the research community to the rapidly evolving institutional and financial contexts, and the collective effort of a group of scientists to address major contemporary science questions concerning the global environment and human societies. Such “big questions” address issues such as climate change, biodiversity loss, water resources, energy, and food security. While each of these questions involves unique scientific and organisational challenges, they also share several common requirements, notably the need for interdisciplinary research and cross-scale analysis. From a scientific perspective, these questions cannot be adequately addressed through conventional discipline-based frameworks. Nor can knowledge that would be confined to a single scale (from genes to ecosystems, or from crop and tree stands to crop fields and forests, and to value chains and ecosystem functions) fully capture the processes underpinning these questions. If such broad and global questions are to be addressed in a relevant manner, interdisciplinary research and an integrated systems approach need to be developed.
From an organisational standpoint, no single institution, nor any national or international body, is in a position to fully assess the state of global plant health. The implementation of the Global Plant Health Assessment therefore requires multiple innovations, starting with the creation of a global network of scientists. Assembling such a network necessarily implies a process of problem definition, and therefore agreement on concepts and operational definitions. Only once these foundations are established can concrete work start, guided by these operational definitions as yard-sticks of progress. This commentary aims to outline the approach adopted in developing and implementing the GPHA project, to provide an overview of its achievements so far, and to discuss some of its perspectives.
Concepts and Methods of the Global Plant Health Assessment
Defining plant health and its consequences
A primary challenge lies at the core of the question addressed, namely that the concept of “plant health” has no agreed-upon definition, whether theoretical or operational (Zadoks, 1972). This arises for several reasons. First, “plant health” has different meanings, depending on whether the focus is on individual plants or plant populations. Second, “plant health” is inherently relative, as it varies over time for an individual plant and differs among individuals within and between populations. As a result, “plant health” does not have a single metric and cannot be measured in the same way as physical properties such as distance, mass, or time.
In contrast, “disease” can be defined and quantified. Its causes can be identified, and in some cases, effective management can be determined. Accordingly, a key decision was made to focus on plant diseases and the pathogens responsible for them. Disease levels can be quantified (Horsfall and Barratt, 1945), and therefore “disease” has an operational definition.
A second decision was to frame the consequences of plant disease through the ecological concept of ecosystem services (MEA, 2005). Healthy plants contribute to the provision of ecosystem services, whereas disease can lead to their reduction or degradation. Changes in ecosystem services resulting from plant disease can, in turn, be measured or at least qualitatively assessed. An operational definition for plant disease impacts was thus found.
In contrast to human health research, the GPHA focuses on infectious disease, that is, diseases caused by plant pathogens. While medicine traditionally emphasizes the individual human, reflecting the intrinsic value of each human life and well-being, plant pathology adopts a different paradigm, focusing predominantly on plant populations. Non-infectious diseases, including depression, obesity, or genetically inherited disorders, constitute a main concern of human public health. In contrast, plant pathology considers non-infectious diseases as marginal. The GPHA, however, does recognize the importance of non-infectious elements in plant disease; this is why abiotic factors are fully integrated into the narrative developed by the GPHA. This part is bound to increase, as will be discussed later in this commentary.
Ecological concepts
Plant diseases are an integral part of the functioning of plant communities. In natural ecosystems, plant pathogens play a fundamental role and are sometimes considered the most influential factors of plant evolution (Alexander, 2010). In many human-managed ecosystems, such as agricultural systems, epidemics of infectious plant disease can be viewed as a consequence of the processes underlying agricultural production (Savary, 2014). This is primarily because plants with very similar genotypes are grown in close physical proximity in a crop stand. This is also because the widely practiced process of crop establishment leads the populations of cultivated plants to be grown as cohorts of individuals that are all at approximately the same physiological stage of development.
Beyond the scale of the crop stand, fields, or groups of trees, these systems are embedded within broader ecosystems, agroecosystems or forests, where the intensity and frequency of human intervention can vary considerably across landscapes. Capturing this diversity while maintaining a meaningful scale of analysis for plant health requires an appropriate conceptual framework. This is where the concept of keystone species provides a useful lens for structuring the assessment. Concepts used in the GPHA are summarised in Table 1.
Table 1.
Ecological and social-economic concepts used in the Global Plant Health Assessment
| Concepts | Definition | Reference |
|---|---|---|
| Ecoregion | Ecoregions are defined, within the GPHA, using concepts that were used by the 1990s in the Consultative Group for International Agricultural Research. An ecoregion, in the GPHA, is a large spatial entity with relatively uniform climate and landform, and natural ecosystems, with similar human cultures, and where social, technological, and cultural attainments are reasonably homogeneous. | Bailey, 1996; CGIAR Technical Advisory Committee, 1991; MEA, 2005 |
| Plant system | The term was coined within the GPHA to refer to a natural or human-made system where a community of plants co-exist, either because of a given environment, or because of human intervention, or both. | N.A. |
| Keystone plant species | A keystone species is associated with a critical role in an ecosystem. In the absence, or in the case of the destruction of a keystone species, the considered ecosystem would lose a very large part, even perhaps all, of its properties. A keystone species contributes an ecosystem’s stability, sustainability, and resilience. The concept has been transferred to human-made systems: some cultivated plant species may be considered as keystone species in agrosystems. | Odum and Odum, 2003 |
| Ecosystem services | Four ecosystem services are distinguished. Provisioning services correspond to all what materially benefits humans in daily life: food, fuel, water, or fibre, for example. Regulating services pertain to all processes through which the Earth system is maintained, including e.g., water regulation or soil regeneration. Cultural and spiritual services refer to all the non-material benefits of a well-functioning environment. Supporting services generate the basis of ecosystems’ existence. These are very slow, very long-term processes (with long time-constants), such soil formation or biodiversity build-up. | MEA, 2005 |
Plant Health Reports
Plant health reports constitute the foundation of the GPHA. Each report follows a common template comprising a series of parts that establish the contextual framework and address four key questions. These parts are as follows:
A rationale of the choice of the ecoregion, based on its environmental, economic, social, and/or agricultural importance;
A rationale for the choice of the keystone plant species chosen and its role within the corresponding plant system in the chosen ecoregion;
Two first questions addressing the past status (30-year time horizon) and recent evolution (10-year time horizon) of plant health in the specified plant system within the chosen ecoregion;
Two questions addressing the past status (30-year time horizon) and recent evolution (10-year time horizon) of ecosystem services in the specified ecoregion, with respect to the impacts of plant disease.
In the GPHA, only three of the four ecosystem services defined in Table 1 are considered: (1) provisioning, (2) regulating, and (3) cultural. Supporting services are excluded, as they cannot be readily measured in relation to plant disease impacts or their feedback effects on plant health.
In agroecosystems, a typical metric of the effects of plant health on provisioning services is the loss (in quantity, quality, or both) caused by plant diseases. In other systems, such as forests, disease impacts on provisioning services may include reduction in timber or fibre production. In urban forests, reduction in air quality, representing a regulating service, may serve as an indicator of disease impacts. Losses of cultural and spiritual value may affect forests, gardens, and agricultural systems, for example through the loss of highly valued traditional varieties or the erosion of landscape diversity.
Answers to these questions must be supported by scientific evidence from published literature and should be standardized across Plant Health Reports. Five categorical levels (“excellent” to “bad”) are used to assess system states, while three trend patterns (declining, improving, or stable) describe evolutions (temporal changes). Each answer to questions is further accompanied by a confidence rating: “Very confident” is assigned when many studies consistently support the answer; “reasonably confident” applies when evidence is available but includes notable gaps in the literature; and “uncertain” is used when published studies are sparse, inconsistent, or insufficient.
Reports are not developed by individuals, but instead by teams of specialists who co-author them. Draft reports undergo a formal review process similar to that of scientific publications, with an Editor guiding review with the assistance of two anonymous Reviewers. This is especially needed in order to (1) harmonize report format, and (2) standardize the use of assessment scales for states and trends.
Achievements of the Global Plant Health Assessment
By 2023, Plant Health Reports had been produced by more than a hundred scientists, covering nine ecoregions worldwide, and addressing 32 plant systems along with their associated keystone plant species (Fig. 1). Overall, the reports indicate a considerable variability in plant health, with generally declining trends, and increasingly negative impacts on ecosystem services (Acuña et al., 2023). These reports are available online at https://sites.google.com/view/global-plant-health-assessment/home?authuser=0 as well as on the website of the ISPP (https://www.isppweb.org/).
Fig. 1.
Geographic distribution of reports produced by the GPHA as of 2023.
Some of the main challenges reported in the Global Plant Health Assessment include:
Concerns over sub-Saharan Africa, where the state of plant health ranges from poor to fair and directly affects food provisioning. Plant diseases in this region are often associated with difficult-to manage pathogens (e.g., soil-borne, viral, bacterial) and persistent diseases involving soil reservoirs and secondary hosts. These challenges are further compounded by limitations in public extension systems and research capacity.
Concerns related to pesticide use in the Global South, including frequent inadequate application, excessive, over-reliance on pesticides as the sole method of disease management. Additional challenges include lack of chemical innovation and continual pathogen adaptation. A collateral and grave issue is the continued use of banned pesticides in parts of sub-Saharan Africa and South Asia.
Emerging and re-emerging plant diseases. In sub-Saharan Africa, pandemics affecting staple crops such as banana, plantain, maize, and cassava are of major concern. In Western Europe and South Asia, disease re-emergence and pathogen evolution are observed in field crops such as wheat and potato. Rice diseases also pose significant risks, including the false smut pandemic in South and Southeast Asia and more recent outbreaks in East Africa. Notably, GPHA reports highlight the establishment of a regional climate - multiple pathogen system involving viruses and phytoplasmas across South-East and East Asia.
Climate change influencing plant disease dynamics through multiple pathways. Abiotic stresses such as drought, flooding and heat waves weaken plant defence mechanisms and increase disease susceptibility in forest and natural ecosystems. Increasing temperature and altered rainfall patterns enhance vector activity in cropping systems, particularly vegetables in peri-urban agriculture. In addition, soil-related stresses, such as salinity, low organic carbon and imbalances in soil nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium, are further increasing plant vulnerability to diseases, such as rice brown spot in South Asia.
Perspectives of the Global Plant Health Assessment
The current and future states of plant health must be recognised as one of the “big questions”, representing a serious global concern of our times, which plant pathologists must address. The complexity of this issue arises from its multiple dimensions, the limited consideration of plant health at the ecosystem scale, and persistent divides across geographic and thematic domains. As a result, the assessment of plant health remains a challenging undertaking that requires a credible scientific multidisciplinary approach and a holistic, systems-based perspective.
Systems science—the holistic study of the complex interactions and feedbacks between pathogens, hosts, and their environment across a hierarchy of scales—is essential for understanding the present state of plant health and for framing future research questions. The necessity of mobilising systems science methods is even more evident when considering the need to anticipate the future changes of plant health. These systems science methods imply models, scenarios, and the analyses of the consequences of the scenarios in their influence on plant health, particularly in terms of impacts on ecosystem services. While simulation models have long been used in plant pathology, there is increasing scope for incorporating additional modelling approaches, including logical models, which use rule-based, qualitative frameworks to represent expert knowledge of system behaviour, and integrative models that synthesize diverse biological, environmental, and socio-economic variables into a unified framework.
Framing scenarios for the future of plant health probably has to be done at the scale of ecoregions (Bouma et al., 2007), each characterized by distinctive patterns of climate change, technology shifts, socio-economic conditions, and global trade dynamics. This would enable addressing sub-questions related to pandemics of plant disease, to the differences in impact between chronic, acute, or emergent diseases of plants, and to the importance of abiotic stresses, and therefore of climate change, on chronic plant diseases.
Epilogue
The Global Plant Health Assessment represents an innovative and unconventional scientific project. It may be seen as a form of collective action, undertaken by a global community of volunteer scientists to address a shared concern of common good. Many of the grave questions today, whether on climate, public health, or biodiversity, concern common goods. Through its structure and operating mechanisms – volunteers, e-communications, workshops, and internal editorial capability for free publications – the GPHA offers a novel way for scientists to work together on an important and meaningful question. This approach also demonstrates how the scientific community can collectively address complex and globally relevant questions in a flexible, inclusive, and resource-efficient manner.
Footnotes
Conflicts of Interest
No potential conflict of interest relevant to this article was reported.
Acknowledgments
The authors wish to thank the Korean Society of Plant Pathology for inviting this commentary.
References
- Acuña I., Andrade-Piedra J., Andrivon D., Armengol J., Arnold A. E., Avelino J., Bandyopadhyay R., Bihon Legesse W., Bock C. H., Bove F., Brenes-Arguedas T., Calonnec A., Carmona M., Carnegie A. J., Castilla N. P., Chen X., Coletta-Filho H. D., Coley P. D., Cox K. D., Zhou C. A global assessment of the state of plant health. Plant Dis. 2023;107:3649–3665. doi: 10.1094/PDIS-01-23-0166-FE. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Alexander H. M. Disease in natural plant populations, communities, and ecosystems: insights into ecological and evolutionary processes. Plant Dis. 2010;94:492–503. doi: 10.1094/PDIS-94-5-0492. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Bailey R. G. Ecosystem Geography. Springer-Verlag; New York, NY, USA: 1996. [Google Scholar]
- Bouma J., Stoorvogel J. J., Quiroz R., Staal S., Herrero M., Immerzeel W., Roetter R. P., van den Bosch H., Sterk G., Rabbinge R., Chater S. Ecoregional research for development. Adv. Agron. 2007;93:257–311. [Google Scholar]
- CGIAR Technical Advisory Committee . An ecoregional approach to research in the Consultative Group for International Agricultural Research. CGIAR Technical Advisory Committee; Rome, Italy: 1991. p. 307. [Google Scholar]
- Horsfall J. G., Barratt R. W. An improved grading system for measuring plant diseases. Phytopathology. 1945;115:655. doi: 10.1094/Phyto-35-655. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Millennium Ecosystem Assessment (MEA) Ecosystems and Human Well-being: Synthesis. Island Press; Washington, DC, USA: 2005. [Google Scholar]
- Odum H. T., Odum B. Concepts and methods of ecological engineering. Ecol. Eng. 2003;20:339–361. [Google Scholar]
- Savary S. The roots of crop health: cropping practices and disease management. Food Sec. 2014;6:819–831. [Google Scholar]
- Zadoks J. C. Methodology of epidemiological research. Annu. Rev. Phytopathol. 1972;10:253–276. [Google Scholar]

