Skip to main content
. 2026 Sep 25. Online ahead of print. doi: 10.1039/d6ra07080a

Table 2. Comparative technical and cleaner-production assessment of dyeing and process-intensification strategies.

Strategy Representative operating conditions Main mechanism Technical outcome Water or energy benefit New burden or limitation Scale-up status Ref.
Conventional exhaust dyeing Commonly pH 3–6, 80–100 °C, 45–60 min and LR 1 : 20–1 : 50; selected systems at 1 : 10 Protonation, adsorption and internal diffusion Broad applicability; K/S usually increases with acidity and temperature until equilibrium or degradation Established equipment and process control High water, heating, rinsing and soaping demand Industrially established 20, 40, 59, 76, 77, 96, 115 and 132
Mordant-free dyeing Usually pH 3–5 and 70–100 °C; alkaline for indigo and cationic dyes Ionic attraction, hydrogen bonding, hydrophobic association or in situ pigment formation K/S = 18.60 for olive leaf and 21.94 for T. catappa; wet fastness up to 4–5, but poor light fastness in some systems Avoids metal salts and metal-bearing effluent May require strong pH control, reduction, heat and repeated washing Laboratory to pilot 40, 72, 80, 96, 122, 132 and 140
Metallic mordanting Commonly 0.2–10% owf or g L−1; pre-, simultaneous/meta- or post-mordanting Dye–metal–fiber coordination and metal–tannin complexation FeSO4 increased K/S from 10.6 to 15.8 and light fastness from 4 to 7; alum, tin and zinc effects were dye-dependent Can improve fixation and reduce unfixed dye Toxicity, residual-metal release, sludge and shade alteration Technically mature but increasingly restricted 22, 74, 78, 79, 102, 115, 120, 131, 133, 135, 137, 139, 145 and 150
Biomordanting Approximately 1–50% owf; pre-, simultaneous or post-application Additional phenolic, cationic, proteinaceous or film-forming sites Walnut husk and pinecone gave K/S = 18.77 and 18.62 with washing fastness = 5 and light fastness = 8 Renewable or waste-derived alternatives to metals High dosage, extraction, variability, COD, curing and washing Mainly laboratory or pilot 22, 33, 42, 57, 70, 88, 90, 102, 117, 118, 120, 130, 137, 140, 143, 158 and 170
Microwave-assisted dyeing Generally 1–10 min irradiation; optima frequently 4–6 min Volumetric heating and accelerated diffusion Exhaustion increased from 63% to 93%; K/S was approximately 8.4 after 4 min in one system Major reduction in treatment time Non-uniform heating and insufficient specific-energy reporting Laboratory 13, 67, 83, 84, 92, 127 and 170
Ultrasound-assisted dyeing Approximately 30–100 °C, 30–120 min and 100–500 W Cavitation and boundary-layer disruption K/S increased to approximately 6.35–7.21; selected fastness grades improved by about 0.5 grade Potential reduction in temperature or duration Scale-dependent acoustic distribution and pigment degradation Bench or laboratory 37, 43, 82, 92 and 123
Plasma activation Air plasma, DBD or corona; seconds to 15 min Surface oxidation, roughening and increased wettability Rice-straw K/S increased from 6.6 to 10.7; washing fastness increased from 4 to 5 in a separate study Dry and rapid surface activation Surface ageing, high voltage and possible over-etching Laboratory to semi-industrial 20, 41, 65 and 93
Laser activation Approximately 4–20 W with controlled scanning Local thermal or photochemical morphology modification K/S increased from 9.7 to 15.1 at 12 W but declined at higher powers Dry, localized and patternable Fiber melting, adhesion and limited penetration Laboratory or pilot patterning 45
Electron-beam activation Up to approximately 300 kGy Radical generation and surface functionalization Maximum K/S = 18.1 with an 8% breaking-force loss Rapid treatment without wet initiators Shielding, capital cost and strength loss Laboratory 105
Enzymatic coloration HRP/H2O2 at approximately 55 °C for up to 3 h Oxidative polymerization of phenolic precursors K/S up to 4.5 with ex situ chitosan Mild temperature and no metallic mordant Enzyme cost, oxidant use and long reaction time Proof-of-concept 32, 33 and 144
Microbial in situ coloration Approximately 30 °C for up to 24 h Biosynthesis and simultaneous pigment formation or fixation Avoids separate pigment synthesis or reduction in selected systems Lower processing temperature and fewer isolated stages Long reaction, sterility and biological control Proof-of-concept 34, 157 and 160
Nanoformulation Aqueous nano-dispersions or biosynthesized nanoparticles Improved dispersion, surface area and entrapment AgNP-assisted K/S = 3.36, light fastness = 5 and 100% antibacterial reduction Can combine coloration and functional finishing Nanoparticle release and toxicological uncertainty Laboratory 163, 172 and 174
Deep eutectic solvent ChCl/LA 1 : 2, 60 °C and 60 min Nonaqueous pigment solubilization and transport K/S = 3.33, but washing ΔE = 10.77 Eliminates the aqueous dye bath High viscosity, solvent recovery and after washing Early laboratory 158
Supercritical CO2 Approximately 110–120 °C and 3500–5000 psi CO2 plasticization and nonaqueous diffusion Water- and mordant-free PA66 coloration No conventional dye-bath wastewater High pressure, capital cost and restricted natural-dye solubility Laboratory or pilot 68 and 165
Low-liquor or solvent-assisted dyeing LR down to 1 : 10–1 : 20; D5 or oil-based carriers Increased bath concentration or phase transfer LR 20 : 1 gave 72.14% berberine exhaustion; D5 gave K/S = 2.64 Reduced water and heated-liquor volume Solvent recovery, toxicity and washing requirements Laboratory to technically scalable 66, 76, 164 and 166
Digital inkjet printing Approximately 80 pL droplets and 300 dpi in the reported system Localized drop-on-demand deposition High-resolution curcumin coloration and functionalization Low application liquor and suitability for short runs Ink stability, nozzle performance, pretreatment and after washing Industrial platform; natural-dye inks mainly laboratory-scale 42