Abstract
This study investigates the molecular geochemistry of the Boxing Sag, a low-maturity lacustrine system in the Dongying Depression, using integrated Rock–Eval pyrolysis and gas chromatography–mass spectrometry (GC–MS) analyses of source rocks, shale oils, and conventional oils. The upper Es4 Member of the Shahejie Formation is characterized by moderate organic richness, Type II kerogen, and oil-window maturity (R o ∼ 0.65–1.05%), supporting active hydrocarbon generation with limited expulsion. Although shale oils and conventional oils share a common lacustrine source, they exhibit fundamentally different compositional behaviors. Shale oils display relatively uniform molecular compositions and systematic depth-dependent maturity trends, reflecting in situ generation and short-distance micromigration within nanopore networks. In contrast, conventional oils show pronounced compositional variability and no correlation with depth, indicating multistage charging, long-distance migration, and mixing of hydrocarbons with different maturity histories. Apparent biomarker variations, such as increases in G/C30H and Ol/C30H ratios, are primarily driven by selective depletion of C30 hopane rather than changes in depositional conditions. These results suggest that shale oil and conventional oil in the Boxing Sag represent two end-member expressions of a single lacustrine petroleum system governed by varying degrees of retention, redistribution, and expulsion. The resulting retention–migration continuum links shale oil retention, redistribution, expulsion, and conventional oil accumulation within a unified lacustrine petroleum system and provides a conceptual framework for interpreting coupled unconventional–conventional hydrocarbon systems.


1. Introduction
The rapid expansion of shale oil development has fundamentally reshaped petroleum geology by demonstrating that organic-rich shales can function simultaneously as source, reservoir, and seal. − Major North American shale plays such as the Bakken, Eagle Ford, and Permian Basin established a development model dominated by highly mature marine systems characterized by extensive hydrocarbon generation, retention, and production directly from source rocks. − However, these conceptual models are primarily based on marine shale systems and cannot be directly applied to lacustrine basins, where depositional environments, organic matter input, lithofacies heterogeneity, and thermal evolution differ substantially. −
Lacustrine shale systems in eastern China, particularly within the Bohai Bay Basin, are typically characterized by organic-rich mudstones dominated by Type I–II kerogen derived mainly from algal and bacterial organic matter with variable terrestrial inputs. − These source rocks were commonly deposited under stratified reducing to anoxic lacustrine conditions favorable for organic matter preservation and hydrocarbon generation. , Unlike many North American marine systems, most Chinese lacustrine shale systems are currently within low- to moderate-maturity stages (R o ∼ 0.6–1.0%), where hydrocarbon generation, retention, migration, and expulsion may occur simultaneously. Consequently, retained shale oil, redistributed hydrocarbons, and conventionally trapped oils commonly coexist within the same petroleum system. − Recent studies increasingly suggest that lacustrine shale oil systems should be regarded as dynamic accumulation systems involving coupled retention and migration processes rather than isolated self-sourced reservoirs. ,
A key unresolved issue in lacustrine shale systems concerns the relationship between retained shale oil and migrated conventional oil. Previous studies demonstrated that hydrocarbons generated within shale systems may undergo selective retention, intraformational redistribution, and limited short-distance migration controlled by lithofacies heterogeneity, pore structure, adsorption capacity, and pressure gradients. , In this study, “micromigration” refers to nanoscale hydrocarbon redistribution within organic matter pores and mineral-associated pore networks inside the source rock, whereas “short-distance migration” refers to limited migration from source intervals into adjacent reservoirs or nearby traps within the same petroleum system. In contrast, “expulsion” refers to the effective release of hydrocarbons from source rocks into discrete carrier systems or conventional reservoirs. Clarifying these concepts is important because many lacustrine shale systems preserve transitional accumulation states between retained and migrated hydrocarbons rather than completely separated conventional accumulations.
Hydrocarbon migration and retention in shale systems are fundamentally controlled by nanoscale pore structures and molecular interactions. Organic-rich shales contain abundant nanopores within organic matter and clay-rich matrices, where hydrocarbon mobility is strongly influenced by molecular size exclusion and polarity-driven adsorption. , Larger and more polar compounds, such as steranes and hopanes, are preferentially retained within shale matrices, whereas smaller and less polar hydrocarbons are more easily mobilized. Experimental and geological studies further demonstrate that retained oils and expelled oils may exhibit substantial differences in biomarker composition due to migration-related fractionation and selective adsorption processes. Similarly, variations in petroleum fractions and residual oil content can significantly influence hydrocarbon mobility and shale oil enrichment within saline-lacustrine systems.
Recent advances in lacustrine shale oil research have highlighted the importance of integrating hydrocarbon retention, migration, and accumulation processes into integrated accumulation models. , Biomarkers such as diahopanes, diasteranes, steranes, and hopanes not only record the depositional environment and organic matter input but also respond sensitively to hydrocarbon generation conditions, migration pathways, and shale oil enrichment processes. Increasing evidence indicates that molecular differences between shale oils and conventional oils may not necessarily reflect distinct source origins but instead represent varying degrees of retention, adsorption, and migration fractionation within a single source system. However, the extent to which migration-related fractionation modifies molecular compositions during the transition from retained shale oil to migrated conventional oil remains poorly constrained in lacustrine basins.
The Boxing Sag within the Dongying Depression provides an ideal natural laboratory to investigate these issues because both shale oil and conventional oil are primarily derived from the lacustrine Shahejie Formation (Es3–Es4) within a unified petroleum system. Previous studies demonstrated that shale oils and conventional oils share broadly similar biomarker assemblages indicative of common source affinities. , However, significant differences exist in bulk composition and molecular distributions between the two oil types. Shale oils are commonly enriched in lighter hydrocarbons and depleted in high-molecular-weight biomarkers, whereas conventional oils exhibit broader molecular distributions. These compositional differences suggest that migration-related fractionation and selective retention exert major controls on hydrocarbon accumulation and redistribution within the Boxing Sag petroleum system.
Accordingly, this study integrates Rock–Eval pyrolysis and GC–MS analyses of source rocks, shale oils, and conventional oils from the Boxing Sag to investigate the relationships among hydrocarbon generation, retention, migration, and molecular fractionation within a lacustrine shale oil system. The objectives are to (1) characterize the molecular compositions of source rocks and associated hydrocarbons; (2) evaluate oil–source relationships between shale oils and conventional oils; and (3) identify the molecular effects of migration-related fractionation and selective retention. By linking molecular compositions with lithofacies heterogeneity, pore-related retention behavior, and thermal maturity, this study aims to clarify the evolutionary relationship between retained shale oil and migrated conventional oil and to provide a more robust framework for oil-source correlation and shale oil evaluation in lacustrine basins.
2. Geological Background and Methods
2.1. Geological Setting of the Boxing Sag, Dongying Depression
The Dongying Depression is a Cenozoic continental rift basin developed on the Paleozoic basement of the North China Plate and is one of the most prolific hydrocarbon provinces in eastern China. , It exhibits a fault-controlled lacustrine basin architecture characterized by asymmetric half-graben geometry formed during Paleogene extension and subsequently modified by Neogene thermal subsidence. The depression is subdivided into several secondary structural units, including the Boxing, Lijin, Niuzhuang, and Minfeng sags, separated by uplifted structural highs such as the Qingcheng, Binxian, Chenjiazhuang, and Guangrao rises (Figure a). These structural elements, together with regionally developed normal faults, define the extensional framework and strongly influence sedimentary distribution and hydrocarbon accumulation. Within this setting, the Boxing Sag is located in the southwestern part of the depression along the downthrown side of the Gaoqing–Pingnan Fault, forming a major depocenter and a key shale oil exploration target. ,
1.

Geological setting and stratigraphic framework of the boxing sag, dongying depression. (a) Regional structural map showing the distribution of major sags, uplifts, faults, and well locations; (b) structural contour map of the C5 horizon showing fault architecture and horizontal well deployment; (c) stratigraphic column showing lithology, lake-level changes, and tectonic evolution, with the Es3–Es4 members identified as the principal source rock intervals.
The Boxing Sag developed as a structurally controlled half-graben system dominated by syndepositional normal faults trending NE–SW and NW–SE (Figure b). These faults controlled basin subsidence, accommodation space, and sediment dispersal, forming a typical “fault–slope” depositional architecture with a steep fault-controlled margin and a gentle opposing slope. Internally, the sag is highly compartmentalized, with dense faulting, small fault block spacing, and variable formation dips. Structural contours of key intervals (approximately −3000 to −3600 m) reflect strong segmentation and complex geometry, which exert fundamental control on pressure distribution, fracture development, and hydrocarbon migration pathways.
This structural complexity strongly influences the shale oil enrichment and producibility. The highly segmented fault-block system creates heterogeneous pressure regimes and compartmentalized reservoirs while also providing pathways for vertical fluid migration. Faults and associated fracture systems act both as conduits and barriers, depending on their sealing capacity and connectivity, thereby controlling hydrocarbon accumulation patterns and reservoir performance.
Stratigraphically, the Boxing Sag contains a thick Cenozoic succession in which the Paleogene Shahejie (Es) Formation constitutes the principal hydrocarbon-bearing interval (Figure c). Among its subdivisions, the Es3 and Es4 members are the primary targets for shale oil exploration. These units were deposited during synrift stages characterized by rapid subsidence and deep lacustrine environments, which provided favorable conditions for organic matter accumulation and preservation.
The Es4 member, particularly the upper submember (Es4 u), developed in a semiclosed to closed saline lacustrine system with high evaporation rates, restricted circulation, and persistent water-column stratification. It is dominated by laminated calcareous shales, dolomitic mudstones, and marls, commonly associated with evaporites such as gypsum and salt. , These depositional conditions promoted bottom water anoxia and organic matter preservation, while carbonate-rich laminae enhanced rock brittleness and fracture development, making this interval favorable for shale oil accumulation.
By comparison, the Es3 member reflects a more open lacustrine system influenced by increased clastic input under delta-lacustrine conditions. It consists of dark mudstones, calcareous shales, and interbedded siltstones, resulting in greater lithological heterogeneity. Organic matter in the Es3–Es4 intervals generally exhibits moderate to high organic richness, with total organic carbon (TOC) values commonly ranging from 1% to 5%. Kerogen is predominantly Type I–II, indicating strong oil-generating potential, and thermal maturity (R o ∼ 0.5–1.0%) corresponds to early to peak oil-window conditions favorable for liquid hydrocarbon generation.
From a petroleum system perspective, the hydrocarbon accumulation in the Boxing Sag is dominated by a self-sourced lacustrine shale system characterized by strong hydrocarbon retention and limited short-distance migration. Elevated S1 values and an oil saturation index (OSI) indicate substantial hydrocarbon retention within source rock intervals. Lithofacies heterogeneity exerts important controls on storage capacity and fluid mobility: carbonate-rich laminated shales generally exhibit higher brittleness and enhanced fracture development, whereas clay-rich facies display stronger adsorption capacity but reduced mobility. , Hydrocarbon redistribution is mainly controlled by faults, microfractures, and lithofacies contrasts. , Current development strategies, including horizontal well deployment from centralized platforms (Figure b), reflect the strong structural and lithological controls on shale oil enrichment within the Boxing Sag.
2.2. Samples and Analytical Methods
2.2.1. Samples
Table summarizes the conventional oils, shale oils, and source rock extracts analyzed in this study from the Shahejie Formation (Es3–Es4 interval) in the Boxing Sag. Here, Es3 1 and Es4 u denote the lower part of the third member and the upper part of the fourth member of the Shahejie Formation, respectively. Here, Es3 1 and Es4 u denote the lower part of the third member and the upper part of the fourth member of the Shahejie Formation, respectively. The conventional oil samples (FSX101, F42, FX184, G946, and G87) are mainly derived from the Es3 1–Es4u interval and cover a depth range of approximately 2969.9 to 3685.3 m true vertical depth (TVD). These samples represent relatively discrete reservoir intervals with production zones spanning ∼2958–3818 m. Conversely, shale oil samples (FY101, FYP1, FY2HF, F191HF, and FY3HF) are exclusively sourced from the upper Es4 Member (Es4 u) and exhibit broader production intervals (3471–5730 m), reflecting horizontal well development within low-permeability source rocks. The shale oil wells are generally distributed at intermediate to deeper depths (TVD ∼ 3327–3918.5 m), bridging the depth range between conventional oils and the deepest source rock samples.
1. Sample Information Showing Stratigraphic Units, Sample Types, Depth Intervals, and TVD.
| well | age | type | interval (m) | TVD (m) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| FSX101 | Es3l–Es4u | conv. Oil | 2958–3018.5 | 2969.89 |
| F42 | Es3l–Es4u | conv. Oil | 3102.5–3394.5 | 3248.5 |
| FX184 | Es3l–Es4u | conv. Oil | 3388–3730 | 3538 |
| G946 | Es4u | conv. Oil | 3418.9–3792 | 3605.45 |
| G87 | Es3l–Es4u | conv. Oil | 3552–3818.5 | 3685.25 |
| FY101 | Es4u | shale oil | 3471.3–4658.0 | 3327 |
| FYP1 | Es4u | shale oil | 3595.0–5305.0 | 3385 |
| FY2HF | Es4u | shale oil | 3649.2–5681.5 | 3519 |
| F191HF | Es4u | shale oil | 3672.0–3840.0 | 3537 |
| FY3HF | Es4u | shale oil | 4124.0–5730.0 | 3918.5 |
| GX86 | Es4u | source rock | 3669 | |
| GX86 | Es4u | source rock | 3774 | |
| GX86 | Es4u | source rock | 3849.4 | |
| GX86 | Es4u | source rock | 3904 | |
| GX86 | Es4u | source rock | 3990.5 | |
| GX86 | Es4u | source rock | 3998.8 | |
| FY3HF | Es4u | source rock | 3807.6 |
The source rock data set is dominated by a vertical profile from Well GX86, with six samples spanning 3669 to 3998.8 m TVD, supplemented by one sample from FY3HF at 3807.6 m. All source rock samples are from the Es4 u interval, ensuring stratigraphic consistency with the shale oil system. This continuous depth coverage provides a robust framework for evaluating maturity evolution, hydrocarbon generation, and molecular variation with depth. Together, the integrated data setlinking conventional oil, shale oil, and in situ source rock extractsenables systematic comparison of geochemical characteristics across different hydrocarbon phases and facilitates evaluation of hydrocarbon generation, retention, and migration processes within the Boxing Sag petroleum system.
2.2.2. Rock–Eval Analysis
Rock–Eval pyrolysis and TOC analysis were conducted using a VINCI Rock–Eval 6 pyrolyzer coupled with an infrared (IR) detection system to evaluate organic matter abundance, type, and thermal maturity. In this procedure, finely crushed rock samples are first heated to 300 °C under an inert nitrogen atmosphere to volatilize free and adsorbed hydrocarbons (S1), after which the temperature is increased to 650 °C at a rate of 25 °C/min to thermally crack kerogen and release additional hydrocarbons (S2). During this stage, CO2 generated from oxygen-bearing functional groups (S3) was continuously monitored by the IR detector. A subsequent oxidation phase reaching ∼850 °C in an oxygen-rich environment quantified the remaining carbon as CO and CO2 (S4CO and S4CO2). TOC is calculated by integrating carbon released during both pyrolysis and oxidation, together with hydrocarbons measured in S1 and S2. Derived geochemical parameters, including Hydrogen Index (HI), Oxygen Index, and T max (temperature at maximum S2 yield), provide constraints on kerogen type and thermal maturity.
2.2.3. Gas Chromatography–Mass Spectrometry Analyses
Approximately 60 g of powdered rock sample was subjected to Soxhlet extraction using 300 mL of dichloromethane for 72 h to efficiently recover extractable organic matter. Total extracts and crude oils were redissolved in petroleum ether, and asphaltenes were removed through precipitation by adding excess solvent. The remaining maltene fraction was then fractionated using silica gel/alumina column chromatography. Sequential elution was performed to separate saturated (aliphatic) hydrocarbons using petroleum ether and aromatic hydrocarbons using a dichloromethane–petroleum ether mixture (2:1, v/v).
Gas chromatography–mass spectrometry (GC–MS) analyses of both saturated and aromatic fractions were conducted using Agilent 7890/5975i and 7890B/5977 GC–MS systems. Each system was equipped with an HP-5 MS fused silica capillary column (30 m × 0.25 mm internal diameter, 0.25 μm film thickness). For saturated hydrocarbons, the oven temperature program started at 40 °C (held for 5 min), followed by a ramp to 325 °C at 4 °C/min, with a final hold of 15 min to ensure complete elution of high-molecular-weight compounds. For aromatic hydrocarbons, the temperature program was adjusted to begin at 60 °C, increase to 150 °C at 8 °C/min, and then ramp to 320 °C at 4 °C/min, to optimize separation of aromatic compounds.
Quantitative analysis was achieved by using internal standard calibration. Deuterated n-alkane (D50-C24) and d4-cholestane were added to the saturated hydrocarbon fraction, while d10-phenanthrene was used as an internal standard for the aromatic fraction. Mass spectrometric detection was performed in electron ionization mode at 70 eV, using both full-scan acquisition for compound identification and selective ion monitoring for biomarker analysis. Helium was used as the carrier gas under the constant flow conditions. Compound concentrations were calculated from peak area integration relative to internal standards without applying individual response factor corrections, allowing consistent semiquantitative comparison among samples.
3. Results
3.1. Source Rock Quality and Hydrocarbon Generation Potential
The Rock–Eval pyrolysis data set provides the geochemical framework for evaluating source rock quality, hydrocarbon generation potential, and hydrocarbon retention in the Boxing Sag. The analyzed samples from wells GX86 and FY3HF, spanning a depth interval of approximately 3669 to 3998.8 m, collectively indicate a moderately rich lacustrine petroleum system characterized by oil-prone kerogen within the oil window (Table ).
2. Rock–Eval Pyrolysis Parameters of Source Rock Samples from the Boxing Sag.
| well | depth (m) | S1 mg/g rock | S2 mg/g rock | S3 mg/g rock | TOC wt % | T max°C | R eq % | HI mg/g TOC | OSI mg/g TOC |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GX86 | 3669 | 0.67 | 3.92 | 0.06 | 1.32 | 445 | 0.85 | 297 | 51 |
| GX86 | 3774.5 | 0.64 | 4.06 | 0.08 | 1.52 | 449 | 0.92 | 268 | 42 |
| GX86 | 3849.4 | 2.07 | 5.38 | 0.09 | 1.74 | 445 | 0.85 | 310 | 119 |
| GX86 | 3904 | 1.76 | 5.27 | 0.06 | 1.89 | 449 | 0.92 | 279 | 93 |
| GX86 | 3990.5 | 1.73 | 1.53 | 0.05 | 0.87 | 448 | 0.90 | 177 | 200 |
| GX86 | 3998.8 | 0.62 | 2.46 | 0.09 | 1.27 | 456 | 1.05 | 193 | 49 |
| FY3HF | 3807.6 | 1.04 | 2.45 | 0.08 | 1.24 | 449 | 0.92 | 198 | 84 |
Equivalent R o calculated using R eq = 0.018 × T max −7.16 (Jarvie et al.).
TOC values reported in Table range from 0.87 to 1.89 wt %, indicating fair to good organic matter abundance. Although these values are somewhat lower than the basin-scale averages for the Es3–Es4 intervals, , they remain sufficient to sustain effective hydrocarbon generation, particularly when coupled with favorable kerogen type. The vertical distribution of TOC is heterogeneous, with relatively enriched intervals occurring between approximately 3849 and 3904 m, where TOC values reach ∼1.7–1.9 wt %. This likely reflects localized variations in depositional productivity and preservation conditions.
The hydrocarbon generation potential, reflected by S2 values in Table (1.53–5.38 mg/g rock), indicates moderate generative capacity. The most favorable intervals occur between ∼3770 and 3900 m, where S2 values exceed 4 mg/g rock, reaching maxima of 5.38 mg/g at 3849.4 and 5.27 mg/g at 3904 m. These intervals correspond to higher HI values of 268–310 mg/g TOC, confirming the dominance of oil-prone Type II kerogen. Conversely, deeper samples (>3990 m) show reduced HI values (∼177 mg/g TOC), indicating progressive kerogen transformation and reduced remaining generative potential.
Thermal maturity parameters summarized in Table provide additional constraints on the evolution of the system. T max values range from 445 to 456 °C, corresponding to equivalent vitrinite reflectance (R eq) values of approximately 0.85–1.05%, as calculated using the empirical relationship of Jarvie et al. These values indicate that the source rocks are within the oil window to early peak oil generation stage. This maturity range overlaps with the principal productive interval of the Boxing Sag and is consistent with effective oil generation from Type I–II kerogen at relatively low maturity.
The variability in the free hydrocarbon content and retention behavior is also evident in Table . S1 values range from 0.62 to 2.07 mg/g of rock, while the OSI varies between 42 and 200 mg/g of TOC. The sample at 3849.4 m shows particularly high S1 (2.07 mg/g) and OSI (119 mg/g of TOC), indicating localized enrichment of retained hydrocarbons and limited expulsion efficiency. This supports a strong hydrocarbon retention within the lacustrine shale system.
3.2. Molecular Characteristics of Source Rock Extracts and Oils
The total ion chromatograms (TICs) of the saturated and aromatic hydrocarbon fractions for source rock extracts, shale oils, and conventional oils are presented in Figure . The saturated hydrocarbon chromatograms (Figure left) are uniformly dominated by a homologous series of n-alkanes, with carbon numbers ranging from n-C10 to n-C35 +, displaying a unimodal to slightly skewed distribution. The overall similarity in chromatographic distributions indicate a common source affinity and broadly comparable maturity levels. The lack of strong odd–even predominance and the smooth n-alkane profiles further support a mature to moderately mature system, with limited compositional differences among hydrocarbon phases.
2.

TICs of saturated (left) and aromatic (right) hydrocarbon fractions for source rock extracts, shale oils, and conventional oils. Numbers in the saturated fraction denote carbon numbers of n-alkanes (n-C10 to n-C35 +). Key compounds include n-alkanes (n-Cn), isoprenoids (Pr: pristane; Ph: phytane), alkylnaphthalenes (N, MN, C2–C4N), and alkylphenanthrenes (P, MP, C2–C3P).
Despite this overall similarity, subtle yet consistent differences are evident in the relative abundance of isoprenoids and branched alkanes. Source rock extracts are relatively enriched in isoprenoids (e.g., pristane and phytane) and branched/cyclic alkanes compared to shale oils and conventional oils. Unlike shale oils, migrated hydrocarbonsparticularly conventional oilsshow a slight enrichment in n-alkanes relative to these more complex compounds. This pattern reflects migration-related molecular fractionation in which n-alkanes are preferentially mobilized, whereas isoprenoids and branched compounds are relatively retained within the source rock matrix. Such behavior is consistent with differences in the molecular structure, polarity, and adsorption affinity in fine-grained sedimentary systems.
By comparison, the TICs of the aromatic hydrocarbon fractions (Figure , right) exhibit more complex and variable distributions. These chromatograms are dominated by alkylnaphthalene and alkylphenanthrene series, with multiple isomers contributing to each cluster of peaks. Clear distinctions among source rock extracts, shale oils, and conventional oils are evident in both peak intensities and distribution patterns. Variations in aromatic compound distributions likely reflect differences in the thermal maturity and migration-related fractionation.
More importantly, the isomer distributions within individual aromatic compound families vary markedly among samples. Ratios of methylnaphthalene and dimethylnaphthalene isomers as well as methylphenanthrene isomers show systematic differences, underscoring their sensitivity to maturity and fractionation processes. Shale oils generally display more uniform aromatic compositions with depth, consistent with equilibration with adjacent source rocks and the dominance of in situ generation coupled with short-range migration. By contrast, conventional oils exhibit greater compositional heterogeneity, suggesting the mixing of hydrocarbons derived from multiple sources or generated at different maturity stages. These results reveal that aromatic hydrocarbons are particularly sensitive to maturity evolution and migration-related fractionation.
Biomarkers of source rock extracts and oils provide key insights into hydrocarbon generation processes and the effects of thermal maturity and migration. Figure illustrates the m/z 191 and m/z 217 mass chromatograms of source rock extracts, representing terpane and sterane distributions, respectively. The m/z 191 chromatograms (Figure left) show depth-related but nonmonotonic variations in terpane composition. The shallowest sample (3669 m) is dominated by pentacyclic terpanes, particularly C30 hopane, indicating moderate maturity. With increasing depth to 3774 m, tricyclic terpanes and rearranged hopanes (Ts, C29Ts, C30D) become more pronounced, reflecting enhanced thermal stress and catalytic rearrangement. At 3849 m, Ts becomes dominant, indicating enhanced thermal rearrangement. At greater depths (3904–3990.5 m), tricyclic terpanes increase significantly, although the deepest GX86 sample shows a reversal toward hopane dominance, suggesting additional organofacies controls. By comparison, sterane distributions (Figure right) remain relatively stable, indicating that steranes primarily reflect original organic matter input rather than maturity.
3.

Depth-decoupled variations in terpane (m/z 191) and sterane (m/z 217) distributions in source rock extracts, illustrating the combined influence of thermal maturity and organofacies on biomarker assemblages. Abbreviations: TT, tricyclic terpane; TeT, tetracyclic terpane; Ts, 18α(H)-22,29,30-trisnorneohopane; Tm, 17α(H)-22,29,30-trisnorhopane; C29Ts, 18α(H)-30-norneohopane; C30D, C30-diahopane (15α-methyl-17α(H)-27-norhopane); Ol, oleanane; G, gammacerane; P, pregnane; St, steranes.
Figure presents biomarker distributions of conventional oils and highlights strong compositional variability independent of depth. The m/z 191 chromatograms (Figure , left) show irregular fluctuations in tricyclic terpanes and rearranged hopanes, with some samples exhibiting high-maturity signatures (e.g., enrichment in rearranged hopanes) and others retaining lower-maturity characteristics. The absence of systematic depth trends indicates mixing of hydrocarbons generated at different maturity stages. The m/z 217 sterane distributions (Figure , right) remain relatively consistent, reinforcing that steranes are less sensitive to migration and mixing processes. The decoupling between terpane variability and sterane stability supports multistage hydrocarbon charging.
4.

Depth-decoupled variations in terpane (m/z 191) and sterane (m/z 217) distributions of conventional oils, highlighting pronounced compositional heterogeneity and the lack of a systematic depth-dependent trend; compound abbreviations are as defined in Figure .
Shale oils display comparatively uniform molecular characteristics, as shown in Figure . The m/z 191 chromatograms (Figure left) consistently show C30 hopane dominance, indicating a common lacustrine source. Variations in tricyclic terpanes and rearranged hopanes are relatively minor and do not exhibit strong depth dependence. The sterane distributions (Figure right) are highly consistent, with stable C27–C29 proportions, indicating uniform source input and depositional conditions. Relative to source rock extracts, shale oils exhibit reduced compositional variability, reflecting partial homogenization during short-distance migration. This suggests that shale oils largely preserve the primary geochemical signature of their source rocks while undergoing limited redistribution.
5.

Representative m/z 191 (terpane) and m/z 217 (sterane) mass chromatograms of shale oil samples, illustrating relatively uniform molecular compositions and limited compositional variation with depth. Compound abbreviations are as defined in Figure .
3.3. Depositional Environment and Molecular Fractionation
The depositional environment and organic matter input of the Boxing Sag system can be evaluated using biomarker ratios and molecular cross-plots. Figure shows the Pr/n-C17 versus Ph/n-C18 cross-plot, which provides insights into redox conditions, organic matter type, and maturity. All samples cluster within a narrow range (∼0.15–0.6 for both ratios), indicating limited variability in depositional conditions. Most samples fall within the Type II to mixed Type II/III fields, suggesting a dominantly lacustrine algal source with minor terrestrial input. Source rock extracts in Figure tend to show slightly higher ratios, reflecting less mature compositions, whereas oils plot at lower values due to preferential depletion of n-alkanes during maturation. The tight clustering indicates that thermal maturity exerts the dominant control, whereas depositional conditions remained relatively stable.
6.

Cross-plot of Pr/n-C17 versus Ph/n-C18 ratios showing organic matter type, redox conditions, and maturity evolution for source rocks and oils in the Boxing Sag (Interpretation based on Peters et al.).
Figure combines biomarker ratios and concentration data to assess molecular fractionation during hydrocarbon generation and migration. The Pr/Ph ratio remains tightly constrained (0.54–0.92) without a depth-dependent trend, indicating persistently reducing depositional conditions. Conversely, G/C30H and Ol/C30H ratios increase systematically with depth, particularly in shale oils and GX86 source rock extracts, where the highest values occur near ∼3900 m. Conventional oils, however, show relatively low and stable ratios throughout. The parallel behavior of these ratios suggests a common controlling process unrelated to major changes in depositional environment or organic matter input.
7.

Depth-dependent variations of biomarker ratios and C30 hopane concentration illustrating preferential depletion of C30 hopane relative to gammacerane and oleanane with increasing depth.
Absolute concentration profiles clarify the controlling mechanism: C30 hopane decreases progressively with depth, particularly in shale oils and GX86 extracts, whereas gammacerane and oleanane do not exhibit corresponding enrichment. This inverse relationship indicates that the increases in the G/C30H and Ol/C30H ratios are driven by preferential depletion of C30 hopane rather than enhanced input of other biomarkers. This behavior is consistent with selective molecular fractionation during hydrocarbon generation and migration with preferential depletion of C30 hopane relative to gammacerane and oleanane. The data remain consistent with predominantly algal organic matter input under conditions lacking strong water column stratification. These results highlight the limitation of using biomarker ratios alone to infer the depositional environment in mature systems where differential preservation may overprint primary signals.
3.4. Thermal Maturity Evolution and Integrated Petroleum System Interpretation
Thermal maturity parameters derived from biomarkers and aromatic compounds provide a comprehensive framework for understanding hydrocarbon evolution in the Boxing Sag. Figure presents biomarker maturity ratios, including T s/(T s + T m), C29Ts/(C29Ts + C29H), C30D/(C30D + C30H), and DiaSt/St (diasteranes/regular steranes). Conventional oils in Figure exhibit strong scatter and no correlation with depth, indicating mixing of hydrocarbons with different maturities. Three oils (FSX101, F42, and G946) consistently show lower maturity signatures, whereas two oils (FX184 and G87) display a moderately higher maturity across multiple parameters. This heterogeneity and lack of depth dependence support multiple charging events and the vertical mixing of hydrocarbons with different maturities. In contrast, shale oils show a much more coherent and systematic relationship with the depth. The four shallower shale oil samples (<3600 m) exhibit intermediate maturity values, positioned between the low- and high-maturity groups of conventional oils. Notably, the deepest shale oil sample from FY3HF displays the highest maturity among all analyzed oils, consistent with all maturity parameters. The progressive increase with depth indicates that shale oils largely preserve local maturity trends, despite limited redistribution through micromigration.
8.

Depth-dependent variations of biomarker maturity parameters (T s/(T s + T m), C29Ts/(C29 T s + C29H), C30D/(C30D + C30H), and DiaSt/St) showing contrasting maturity trends between conventional oils, shale oils, and source rock extracts, and evidence for multiple charging events and differential molecular fractionation.
Source rock extracts show more complex behavior. Although their maturity generally increases with depth, the correlation is weaker and more irregular compared to shale oils. This poor depth correlation is partly attributed to variations in organofacies, which influence biomarker distributions independently of maturity. Additionally, selective depletion of regular hopanesparticularly in deeper intervalsalters the relative abundance of isomerization-sensitive compounds, thereby distorting traditional maturity parameters. Consequently, biomarker ratios in source rock extracts reflect both thermal maturity and migration-related compositional fractionation.
Figure presents depth-dependent variations in four alkylnaphthalene maturity parameters, including MNR, DNR, TMNr, and TeMNr, for shale oils, source rock extracts, and conventional oils from the Boxing Sag. Overall, shale oils exhibit coherent maturity trends across all parameters (Figure a–d), with values progressively increasing from the shallower intervals (∼3300–3500 m) to the deepest sample near ∼3900 m. MNR values increase from ∼1.3–1.4 to ∼2.3, DNR values rise from ∼9–11 to ∼18–20, and both TMNr and TeMNr increase from ∼0.7 to ∼1.0 and ∼0.95, respectively. These systematic variations indicate progressive in situ thermal maturation and relatively limited migration-related overprinting in the shale oil system.
9.

Depth-dependent variation of alkylnaphthalene-derived maturity parameters (MNR, DNR, TMNr, and TeMNr) in conventional oils, shale oils, and source rock extracts, highlighting contrasting maturity evolution patterns and charge heterogeneity in the Boxing Sag.
In comparison, GX86 source rock extracts display similar but weaker maturity trends, generally characterized by lower parameter values and greater variability, particularly below ∼3800 m (Figure a–d). MNR values remain mainly within ∼0.8–1.2, whereas DNR values cluster around ∼5–8 but become increasingly scattered at greater depths. TMNr and TeMNr exhibit moderate increases with depth but remain less systematic than those observed in shale oils. This increased variability likely reflects the combined influence of organofacies heterogeneity, selective molecular depletion, and compositional fractionation during hydrocarbon generation and expulsion. The pronounced dispersion of DNR values at higher maturity further suggests reduced parameter reliability under advanced thermal evolution conditions, likely related to changes in aromatic isomerization equilibria.
Conventional oils differ markedly from shale oils and source rock extracts by exhibiting scattered maturity values across all alkylnaphthalene parameters without coherent depth relationships (Figure a–d). MNR values fluctuate mainly between ∼1.0 and ∼1.7, DNR values between ∼6 and ∼12, and both TMNr and TeMNr display broad dispersion independent of burial depth. The absence of consistent maturity gradients indicates that conventional oils record more complex charge histories involving hydrocarbons generated at different maturity stages and introduced through multiple migration and charging events. Collectively, the alkylnaphthalene maturity parameters distinguish the relatively coherent thermal evolution preserved in shale oils from the heterogeneous charging history reflected in conventional oils.
Figure presents aromatic maturity parameters derived from methylphenanthrene and methyldibenzothiophene isomers, including MPI1, Rc, MPI3, and MDR, and shows evolution patterns broadly comparable to those observed for alkylnaphthalene parameters. Shale oils display systematic maturity increases across all parameters with increasing depth (Figure a–d). MPI1 values increase from ∼0.5–0.7 at ∼3300–3400 m to ∼1.0 near ∼3900 m, corresponding to calculated R c (calculated as R c = MPI1 × 0.6 + 0.4, Radke et al values increasing from ∼0.7% to ∼1.0%. MPI3 values similarly rise from ∼0.7 to ∼1.4, whereas MDR values increase substantially from ∼6 to ∼30 with depth. These coherent maturity trends indicate progressive thermal evolution within the shale oil system and suggest that shale oils largely preserve local in situ maturity signals.
10.

Depth profiles of aromatic maturity parameters for conventional oils, shale oils, and source rock extracts (GX86, FY3HF): (a) MPI1, (b) Rc, (c) MPI3, and (d) MDR, illustrating contrasting maturity evolution patterns between shale oils, conventional oils, and source rock extracts in the Boxing Sag.
Source rock extracts again show intermediate behavior characterized by weaker maturity trends and increased variability relative to shale oils (Figure a–d). Most GX86 extracts display relatively constrained MPI1 and R c values (∼0.5–0.8 and ∼0.7–0.8%, respectively), although deeper samples reach significantly higher values. MPI3 values remain mainly within ∼0.7–0.9 but increase markedly in the deepest sample, whereas MDR values fluctuate strongly, reaching a maximum near ∼3900 m before declining in the deepest interval. Compared with shale oils, the weaker and less systematic maturity relationships in source rock extracts likely reflect the combined effects of organofacies heterogeneity, molecular depletion, and migration-related fractionation during hydrocarbon generation and expulsion.
Conventional oils exhibit broad scatter across all aromatic maturity parameters without systematic depth dependence (Figure a–d). MPI1 and R c values remain relatively low and dispersed, MPI3 values fluctuate within a narrow but inconsistent range, and MDR values vary widely between ∼3 and ∼11. This heterogeneity suggests that conventional oils represent mixtures of hydrocarbons generated at different maturity stages and emplaced through multiple charging events. Overall, the aromatic maturity parameters consistently demonstrate that shale oils preserve relatively coherent thermal maturity evolution, whereas conventional oils record more complex migration and charge histories, with source rock extracts occupying an intermediate position influenced by both maturity evolution and molecular fractionation processes.
4. Discussion
4.1. Retention-Dominated Low-Maturity Lacustrine Shale Oil System
Hydrocarbon generation in the Boxing Sag demonstrates that effective shale oil accumulation can occur at relatively low thermal maturity (R o ∼0.65–1.0%). However, this characteristic should not be interpreted as uniquely lacustrine because organic matter composition varies substantially among both lacustrine and marine petroleum systems. In particular, sulfur-rich Type II-S kerogen, commonly developed in anoxic marine environments, can also initiate hydrocarbon generation at relatively low maturity. Therefore, the relatively early hydrocarbon generation observed in the Boxing Sag is more appropriately attributed to hydrogen-rich Type I–II lacustrine kerogen rather than to a strict lacustrine–marine distinction. ,
Rock–Eval results indicate moderate organic richness (TOC = 0.87–1.89 wt %) and HI values of 177–310 mg HC/g TOC, suggesting sufficient generative potential despite lower TOC than some marine shale systems. The interval between ∼3770 and 3900 m exhibits the strongest coupling between TOC, S2, HI, and maturity, indicating the most effective hydrocarbon generation window. T max values of 445–456 °C and equivalent maturity values of R o ∼ 0.85–1.05% confirm that most samples are within the oil window, while relatively high S1 values indicate substantial in situ hydrocarbon retention even at modest maturity levels.
Unlike classical expulsion-dominated petroleum systems, hydrocarbons in the Boxing Sag remain largely confined within the source rock matrix, forming a predominantly self-sourced shale-oil system dominated by retention and limited redistribution. OSI values generally range from 50 to 200 mg HC/g TOC, although their significance varies among lithofacies. Carbonate-rich laminated shales may achieve effective hydrocarbon mobility at moderate OSI values, whereas clay-rich intervals commonly require higher saturation thresholds because of stronger adsorption and poorer pore connectivity. Consequently, OSI alone cannot reliably predict producibility and must be evaluated together with mineralogical and petrophysical characteristics.
The relatively narrow range of Pr/Ph and related depositional proxies indicates generally stable depositional conditions and similar organic matter input throughout the studied interval. Aromatic maturity parameters such as MPI1, TMNr, and MDR broadly support a low- to moderate-maturity interpretation, although these parameters should be applied cautiously at relatively low maturity because they may also be affected by source facies, mineral catalysis, biodegradation, and early expulsion processes prior to thermal equilibrium. In this study, aromatic maturity indices are therefore used as supplementary indicators together with Rock–Eval and biomarker evidence rather than as independent maturity constraints.
Overall, the Boxing Sag represents a retention-dominated lacustrine shale oil system characterized by early hydrocarbon generation, limited expulsion, and a strong adsorption-related retention. These characteristics provide the geochemical basis for understanding the subsequent redistribution and migration processes within the basin.
4.2. Micromigration and Retention-Controlled Shale Oil Evolution
Shale oil evolution in the Boxing Sag is dominated by in situ generation, limited redistribution, and strong retention, resulting in a petroleum system primarily controlled by micromigration within nanopore networks. In this study, “micromigration” refers to hydrocarbon movement over microscopic to intraformational scales within adjacent pores, organic matter networks, and microfractures, whereas “short-distance migration” describes limited migration between closely associated lithofacies or thin interbeds. Conversely, “expulsion” refers to effective hydrocarbon discharge from source rocks into structurally or stratigraphically distinct carrier systems.
Unlike conventional petroleum systems dominated by long-distance transport, hydrocarbon movement in shale reservoirs is strongly constrained by nanopore confinement, capillary forces, and adsorption effects. , Biomarker evidence indicates that source rock extracts preserve systematic maturity-related variations, particularly within terpane distributions, whereas shale oils exhibit relatively homogeneous compositions characterized by consistent C30-hopane dominance and limited variability in terpane assemblages. This homogenization most likely reflects localized redistribution of hydrocarbons generated over a narrow maturity interval rather than the mixing of unrelated oil charges.
The principal mechanism controlling this behavior is localized micromigration under strong retention conditions. During hydrocarbon generation, newly generated fluids redistribute over short distances through nanopores and microfractures within the same source interval. , This process promotes limited mixing among hydrocarbons generated at slightly different maturities, thereby reducing local compositional variability while still preserving coherent maturity trends with depth (Figures –). Consequently, shale oils exhibit relatively systematic maturity gradients compared with the scattered patterns observed in conventional oils.
Sterane distributions remain comparatively stable between source rocks and shale oils, indicating the preservation of original organic matter input and limited large-scale fractionation. However, several biomarker parameters require a cautious interpretation. Variations in G/C30H and Ol/C30H ratios may partly reflect decreasing relative abundances of C30 hopane caused not only by migration-related fractionation but also by clay mineral catalysis and lithofacies-dependent effects. Therefore, these parameters are interpreted here together with maturity indicators, lithological characteristics, and broader biomarker trends rather than as independent migration proxies.
At the pore scale, molecular retention is strongly influenced by nanopore structure and mineral composition. Experimental and molecular simulation studies have demonstrated that nanopore confinement selectively restricts the mobility of larger and structurally complex molecules, whereas adsorption onto clay minerals preferentially retains polar and heteroatomic compounds. These coupled confinement–adsorption processes contribute to molecular fractionation during redistribution and may partly explain the simplified and relatively homogeneous compositions observed in retained shale oils.
The boxing sag therefore illustrates that shale oil systems may evolve through progressive redistribution within retention-dominated nanopore networks prior to large-scale expulsion. As the thermal maturity and pore connectivity increase, these systems may gradually transition toward more migration-dominated behavior.
4.3. Migration-Dominated Conventional Oil System
Conventional oils in the Boxing Sag represent the migration-dominated end member of the petroleum system characterized by long-distance transport, multistage charging, and compositional mixing. In contrast to shale oils, conventional oils display substantial variability in biomarker and aromatic maturity parameters, indicating more complex migration and accumulation histories.
Ratios such as T s/(T s + T m), C29Ts/(C29Ts + C29H), and C30D/(C30D + C30H) exhibit broad distributions, suggesting contributions from hydrocarbons generated at different maturity stages. Aromatic maturity parameters show similarly scattered patterns, , consistent with episodic hydrocarbon charging and mixing rather than simple in situ accumulation.
This variability is most reasonably explained by multistage migration and reservoir charging. Earlier generated oils were likely emplaced into reservoirs and subsequently mixed with later, more mature hydrocarbon inputs. Structural connectivity played a key role in facilitating this process. Fault systems provide effective vertical and lateral migration pathways linking deeper source intervals with shallower reservoirs. Reservoirs with stronger structural connectivity generally exhibit greater compositional heterogeneity, whereas relatively isolated reservoirs preserve more localized geochemical signatures.
Migration-related fractionation further modified the oil compositions during transport. Processes including phase separation, adsorption, and molecular size discrimination selectively altered hydrocarbon distributions along migration pathways. , Larger and less mobile molecules may have been preferentially retained during migration, whereas lighter compounds were transported more efficiently.
Sterane distributions remain relatively stable among conventional oils, supporting a broadly similar source origin. In contrast, terpane assemblages show substantially greater variability, reflecting the combined influence of maturity differences, migration fractionation, and oil mixing. This decoupling between relatively stable source-related parameters and more variable migration–sensitive parameters provides strong evidence of migration-dominated accumulation processes.
Overall, the conventional oil reservoirs in the Boxing Sag record a more open petroleum system characterized by effective expulsion, fault-controlled transport, and multistage hydrocarbon charging, contrasting sharply with the strongly retained shale oil system.
4.4. Retention–Migration Continuum in a Coupled Lacustrine Petroleum System
The integrated geochemical data set indicates that shale oil and conventional oil in the Boxing Sag are genetically linked within a single lacustrine petroleum system but represent different degrees of hydrocarbon retention, redistribution, and migration rather than completely independent systems. Figure conceptually summarizes this retention–migration continuum and illustrates the progressive transition from retention-dominated shale oil accumulations to migration-dominated conventional reservoirs. The principal contribution of this study is therefore not the proposal of a universally applicable petroleum system model, but rather the demonstrationusing integrated biomarker, Rock–Eval, and compositional evidencethat shale oil and conventional oil within the Boxing Sag can be linked through a retention–migration continuum operating within a single lacustrine source system. The results further show that measurable molecular differences between retained and migrated oils may develop even where source input remains relatively uniform.
11.

Conceptual schematic of the retention–migration continuum in lacustrine petroleum systems, illustrating the transition from retention-dominated shale oil accumulations to migration-dominated conventional oil reservoirs. Increasing thermal maturity, pore connectivity, and migration efficiency progressively shift the system from nanopore-hosted, strongly retained hydrocarbons with limited micromigration to fault-connected reservoirs characterized by long-distance migration, hydrocarbon mixing, and migration-related fractionation. Corresponding geochemical signatures evolve from uniform biomarker distributions and coherent maturity gradients to compositional heterogeneity and weak depth dependence.
At one end of the continuum, the shale oil system is characterized by in situ generation, strong adsorption, nanopore confinement, and limited micromigration. Hydrocarbons remain largely trapped within low-permeability lithofacies, producing relatively uniform oil compositions and coherent maturity trends that maintain strong source–oil affinity. Unlike shale oils, the conventional oil system represents a migration-dominated end member in which hydrocarbons were more effectively expelled and transported through fault-connected pathways, resulting in multistage charging, compositional mixing, and greater geochemical heterogeneity.
Between these two end-members exists a spectrum of intermediate states controlled by changing thermal maturity, pore connectivity, retention strength, and structural migration efficiency. As thermal maturity increases, progressive development of organic pores and improved pore connectivity enhance hydrocarbon mobility, promoting a transition from localized redistribution to more effective expulsion and migration (Figure ). Structural connectivity further regulates whether hydrocarbons remain retained within source intervals or migrate to structurally connected reservoirs.
Biomarker relationships provide additional support for this coupled retention–migration framework. Source-related parameters, including Pr/n-C17 and Ph/n-C18, remain relatively consistent throughout the interval, indicating broadly similar depositional conditions and organic matter input. In contrast, variations in G/C30H and Ol/C30H ratios likely reflect the combined influence of migration-related fractionation, selective retention, clay mineral interactions, and adsorption effects rather than simple source heterogeneity alone. Because these variations coincide with relatively stable source-related signatures, the observed molecular differences are more reasonably interpreted as postgenerative redistribution effects associated with varying migration efficiencies.
These observations may provide a useful reference for other lacustrine basins in which shale oil and conventional oil coexist within closely associated source-reservoir systems, particularly where fault-controlled migration and retention-related fractionation occur simultaneously. However, the relative importance of adsorption, retention, expulsion, and structural migration processes will vary substantially among basins depending on kerogen type, mineral composition, thermal maturity, burial history, and tectonic evolution. Consequently, the proposed retention–migration continuum should be regarded primarily as a conceptual framework for interpreting coupled lacustrine petroleum systems rather than as a universally transferable predictive model.
From an exploration perspective, Figure highlights that unconventional and conventional resources may coexist within the same lacustrine basin and may be controlled by different combinations of retention efficiency, pore connectivity, and structural migration pathways. Integrating molecular geochemistry with lithofacies and structural analysis is therefore important for evaluating the transition between retained and migrated hydrocarbon systems.
In summary, the Boxing Sag represents a coupled lacustrine petroleum system in which shale oil and conventional oil are linked through varying degrees of retention, redistribution, expulsion, and migration. Figure provides a simplified conceptual model illustrating how these processes collectively control hydrocarbon composition, migration behavior, and accumulation styles within mixed unconventional–conventional lacustrine systems.
5. Conclusions
The Boxing Sag represents a low-maturity lacustrine petroleum system characterized by Type I–II kerogen and oil-window conditions (R o ∼ 0.65–1.0%). Rock–Eval parameters, including elevated S1 and OSI, indicate efficient hydrocarbon generation coupled with substantial in situ retention. This reflects a system in which expulsion is limited and hydrocarbons largely accumulate within the source rock matrix.
Shale oils display consistent molecular compositions and clear maturity-dependent trends. These features indicate dominant in situ generation with only limited redistribution through micromigration within nanopore networks. As a result, shale oils largely preserve the primary geochemical signature of their source rocks while exhibiting a predictable vertical maturity evolution.
Conventional oils, in contrast, exhibit pronounced compositional variability and lack systematic depth-related trends. This behavior reflects multistage hydrocarbon charging, long-distance migration, and mixing of fluids generated at different maturities. Despite this variability, biomarker assemblages confirm that conventional oils are genetically linked to the same lacustrine source rock.
Together, shale oil and conventional oil in the Boxing Sag represent two end-member expressions of a coupled lacustrine petroleum system governed by varying degrees of retention, redistribution, migration, and expulsion. Their differences arise primarily from secondary processes such as migration, fractionation, and mixing rather than source heterogeneity. This retention–migration continuum provides a useful conceptual framework for integrating geochemical and reservoir analyses to better constrain hydrocarbon evolution and optimize exploration strategies in lacustrine basins.
Acknowledgments
This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant No. 42302161 and 42473034), Oil & Gas Major Project (2025ZD1400803), and Scientific Research Project of Sinopec Shengli Oilfield Branch Company (YKQ2502). We also extend our heartfelt appreciation to Steve Larter from the University of Calgary and two anonymous reviewers for their constructive comments, which significantly enhanced the quality of this manuscript.
The authors declare no competing financial interest.
References
- Passey, Q. R. ; Bohacs, K. M. ; Esch, W. L. ; Klimentidis, R. ; Sinha, S. . From oil-prone source rock to gas-producing shale reservoir geologic and petrophysical characterization of unconventional shale-gas reservoirs. SPE; 2010, SPE-131350. [Google Scholar]
- Jarvie, D. M. Shale resource systems for oil and gas: Part 2 Shale-oil resource systems. In Shale Reservoirs Giant Resources for the 21st Century; AAPG Memoir, 2012; Vol. 97, pp 89–119. [Google Scholar]
- Hackley P. C., Zhang T., Jubb A. M., Valentine B. J., Dulong F. T., Hatcherian J. J.. Organic petrography of Leonardian (Wolfcamp A) mudrocks and carbonates, Midland Basin, Texas. The fate of oil-prone sedimentary organic matter in the oil window. Mar. Pet. Geol. 2020;112:104086. doi: 10.1016/j.marpetgeo.2019.104086. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Gaswirth S. B., Marra K. R.. Assessment of undiscovered oil resources in the Bakken and Three Forks formations, Williston Basin Province, Montana, North Dakota, and South Dakota, 2013. AAPG Bull. 2015;99:639–660. doi: 10.1306/08131414051. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Grubert E.. The Eagle Ford and Bakken shale regions of the United States: A comparative case study. Extr. Ind. Soc. 2018;5:570–580. doi: 10.1016/j.exis.2018.09.011. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Jarvie, D. M. Big three tight oil plays, USA: Bakken, Eagle Ford, and Wolf Camp. In 2019 AAPG International Conference and Exhibition; Buenos Aires, 2019; pp 1–40. [Google Scholar]
- Wang M., Guo Z., Jiao C., Lu S., Li J., Xue H.. et al. Exploration progress and geochemical features of lacustrine shale oils in China. J. Pet. Sci. Eng. 2019;178:975–986. doi: 10.1016/j.petrol.2019.04.029. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Jin Z., Zhu R., Shen Y.. Several issues worthy of attention in current lacustrine shale oil exploration and development. Pet. Explor. Dev. 2021;48:1471–1484. doi: 10.1016/s1876-3804(21)60303-8. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Huang H., di Primio R., Pedersen J. H., Silva R., Algeer R., Ma J.. et al. On the determination of oil charge history and the practical application of molecular maturity markers. Mar. Pet. Geol. 2022;139:105586. doi: 10.1016/j.marpetgeo.2022.105586. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Deng Y., Chen S., Pu X., Yan J.. Characteristics and controlling factors of shale oil reservoir spaces in the Bohai Bay Basin. Acta Geol. Sin. 2020;94:253–268. doi: 10.1111/1755-6724.14286. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Hu T., Pang X., Jiang F., Wang Q., Liu X., Wang Z.. et al. Movable oil content evaluation of lacustrine organic-rich shales: Methods and a novel quantitative evaluation model. Earth-Sci. Rev. 2021;214:103545. doi: 10.1016/j.earscirev.2021.103545. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Feng Y., Yang Z., Jiang W., Zhang H., Zhang T., Liu C., Li P., Zhu J., Wang X.. The influence of mudstone lithofacies sedimentation on the development of shale oil “sweet-spot intervals” within large down-warped lacustrine basins in China. Mar. Pet. Geol. 2024;169:107063. doi: 10.1016/j.marpetgeo.2024.107063. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Liang C., Cao Y., Jiang Z., Wu J., Guoqi S., Wang Y.. Shale oil potential of lacustrine black shale in the Eocene Dongying depression: Implications for geochemistry and reservoir characteristics. AAPG Bull. 2017;101:1835–1858. doi: 10.1306/01251715249. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Liu H., Li J., Liu P., Wang X., Wang Y., Qiu Y.. et al. Enrichment conditions and strategic exploration direction of Paleogene shale oil in Jiyang Depression. Acta Pet. Sin. 2022;43:1717–1729. [Google Scholar]
- Zou C., Yang Z., Cui J., Zhu R., Hou L., Tao S.. et al. Formation mechanism, geological characteristics and development strategy of nonmarine shale oil in China. Pet. Explor. Dev. 2013;40:15–27. doi: 10.1016/S1876-3804(13)60002-6. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Shi J., Jin Z., Liu Q., Zhang T., Fan T., Gao Z.. Laminar characteristics of lacustrine organic-rich shales and their significance for shale reservoir formation: A case study of the Paleogene shales in the Dongying Sag, Bohai Bay Basin, China. Asian J. Earth Sci. 2022;223:104976. doi: 10.1016/j.jseaes.2021.104976. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Guo X., Wang E., Ma X., Li M., Qian M., Cao T.. et al. Lacustrine shale oil systems in China: Advances in characterization methods and resource accumulation models. Earth-Sci. Rev. 2025;270:105256. doi: 10.1016/j.earscirev.2025.105256. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Wang E., Li M., Ma X., Qian M., Cao T., Li Z., Jin Z.. Inter-strata oil migration and its implications of hydrocarbon accumulation in the lacustrine shale system of the Lucaogou Formation, Jimusaer Sag, Junggar Basin. Mar. Pet. Geol. 2025;181:107533. doi: 10.1016/j.marpetgeo.2025.107533. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Guo Q., Yao Y., Hou L., Tang S., Pan S., Yang F.. Oil migration, retention, and differential accumulation in “sandwiched” lacustrine shale oil systems from the Chang 7 member of the Upper Triassic Yanchang Formation, Ordos Basin, China. Int. J. Coal Geol. 2022;261:104077. doi: 10.1016/j.coal.2022.104077. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Han Y., Horsfield B., LaReau H., Mahlstedt N.. Intraformational migration of petroleum: Insights into the development of sweet spot in the Cretaceous Niobrara shale-oil system, Denver Basin. Mar. Pet. Geol. 2019;107:301–309. doi: 10.1016/j.marpetgeo.2019.05.026. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Loucks R. G., Reed R. M., Ruppel S. C., Jarvie D. M.. Morphology, genesis, and distribution of nanometer-scale pores in siliceous mudstones of the Mississippian Barnett Shale. J. Sediment. Res. 2009;79:848–861. doi: 10.2110/jsr.2009.092. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Zhang H., Huang H., Li Z., Liu M.. Oil physical status in lacustrine shale reservoirs–A case study on Eocene Shahejie Formation shales, Dongying Depression, East China. Fuel. 2019;257:116027. doi: 10.1016/j.fuel.2019.116027. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Leythaeuser D., Mackenzie A., Schaefer R. G., Bjorøy M.. A novel approach for recognition and quantification of hydrocarbon migration effects in shale-sandstone sequences. AAPG Bull. 1984;68:196–219. doi: 10.1306/AD4609FE-16F7-11D7-8645000102C1865D. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Guo R., Zhang J., Tang X., Jiang Z., Zhang B.. Comparison of biomarkers in retained oil and expelled oil of lacustrine marlstone determined by hydrous pyrolysis: Application to hydrocarbon migration determination in the tight oil reservoir. Geol. J. 2022;57:1552–1571. doi: 10.1002/gj.4355. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Zhu C., Jiang F., Zhang P., Zhao Z., Chen X., Wu Y.. et al. Effect of petroleum chemical fraction and residual oil content in saline lacustrine organic-rich shale: A case study from the Paleogene Dongpu Depression of North China. Pet. Sci. 2023;20:649–669. doi: 10.1016/j.petsci.2022.09.013. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Wang E., Feng Y., Guo T., Li M.. Oil content and resource quality evaluation methods for lacustrine shale: A review and a novel three-dimensional quality evaluation model. Earth-Sci. Rev. 2022;232:104134. doi: 10.1016/j.earscirev.2022.104134. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Wang E., Li M., Ma X., Qian M., Cao T., Li Z.. et al. Diahopane and diasterane as the proxies for paleoenvironment, hydrocarbon generation condition, and shale oil accumulation. Chem. Geol. 2024;670:122447. doi: 10.1016/j.chemgeo.2024.122447. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Wang Y., Hou Y., Yang J.. Microscopic mechanisms of intrasource micro-migration and enrichment of lacustrine shale oil: A case study of Chang73 submember of Triassic Yanchang Formation, Ordos Basin, NW China. Pet. Explor. Dev. 2025;52:1247–1261. doi: 10.1016/S1876-3804(25)60639-2. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Li, G. ; Cao, X. ; Lv, Q. ; Lv, J. ; Cheng, Z. . Analysis of key factors controlling initial production capacity in shale oil horizontal wells: A case study of the Boxing Depression in the Shengli region. In Proceedings of the International Field Exploration and Development Conference 2024; Springer, 2024; pp 1377–1393. [Google Scholar]
- Wang Y., Liu L., Meng J., Jiang Z., Gao Y., Liu S.. Oil-source correlation study of the Paleogene red beds in the Boxing sag of the Dongying depression, eastern China. Rev. Mex. Cienc. Geol. 2012;29:725–734. [Google Scholar]
- Chen J., Guo X., Han Y., He S., Wang Y., Wang X.. et al. Combination of basin modelling and carbazoles to investigate secondary oil migration pathways in the Dongying depression of the Bohai Bay Basin, China. Mar. Pet. Geol. 2021;131:105163. doi: 10.1016/j.marpetgeo.2021.105163. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Liu H., Bao Y., Li M., Li Z., Wu L., Zhu R.. et al. Geochemical parameters for evaluating shale oil enrichment and mobility: A case study of shales in the Bakken Formation, Williston Basin and the Shahejie Formation, Jiyang Depression. Oil Gas Geol. 2024;45:622–636. [Google Scholar]
- Chen S., Liu X., Cui Y., Zhao X., Zhang J.. Palaeogene structural evolution of Dongying Depression, Bohai Bay Basin, NE China. Int. Geol. Rev. 2017;59:259–273. doi: 10.1080/00206814.2016.1223559. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Huang H., Zhang H., Li Z., Liu M.. Thermal maturation regime revisited in the Dongying Depression, Bohai Bay Basin, east China. Geofluids. 2021;2021:1–17. doi: 10.1155/2021/6020850. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Tian R., Xian B., Liu J., Wu Q., Rahman N. U., Chen P., Li Q., Wang Z., Chen S., Yu J.. et al. Variability of sequence architecture in a rift margin controlled by tectonic activity: The Eocene Dongying Depression, Bohai Bay Basin, China. Basin Res. 2024;36:e12876. doi: 10.1111/bre.12876. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Han D., Li Z., Li S., Xu C., Long L.. Geochemical characteristics of Paleogene mudstones in the Boxing Sag north of the west Shandong Rise and their tectonic implications. Chin. J. Geol. 2007;42:678–689. [Google Scholar]
- Yang Y.. Shale oil development techniques and application based on ternary-element storage and flow concept in Jiyang Depression, Bohai Bay Basin, East China. Pet. Explor. Dev. 2024;51:380–393. doi: 10.1016/S1876-3804(24)60030-3. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Fang Z., Zhang L., Ma C.. Development and controlling factors of shale lithofacies cycles in a continental rift basin: A case study of Es4u in the Boxing Subsag. Front. Earth Sci. 2023;11:1136012. doi: 10.3389/feart.2023.1136012. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Feng Y., Li S., Lu Y.. Sequence stratigraphy and architectural variability in late Eocene lacustrine strata of the Dongying Depression, Bohai Bay Basin, eastern China. Sediment. Geol. 2013;295:1–26. doi: 10.1016/j.sedgeo.2013.07.004. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Liu H., Zhang S., Wang X., Zhang P., Li J., Wang Y.. et al. Types and characteristics of shale lithofacies combinations in continental faulted basins: A case study from upper sub-member of Es4 in Dongying Sag, Jiyang Depression. Earth Sci. 2023;48:30–48. [Google Scholar]
- Wang X., Liu H., Zhang P., Li J., Li Z.. et al. Fluid inclusions and petroleum geological significance in the upper fourth member of Shahejie Formation, Boxing subsag. Nat. Gas Geosci. 2026;37:518–527. [Google Scholar]
- Zhang L., Liu Q., Zhu R., Li Z., Lu X.. Source rocks in Mesozoic–Cenozoic continental rift basins, east China: A case from Dongying depression, Bohai Bay Basin. Org. Geochem. 2009;40:229–242. doi: 10.1016/j.orggeochem.2008.10.013. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Yang Y., Khan D., Qiu L., Du Y., Jiang L., Li W.. et al. Microscopic reservoir characteristics of the lacustrine calcareous shale: An example from the Es4s shale of the paleogene Shahejie formation in Boxing Sag, Dongying Depression. ACS Omega. 2022;7:36748–36761. doi: 10.1021/acsomega.2c05055. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Wang X., Liu H., Zhang S., Li Z., Du Z., Li P.. Micro-migration characteristics of shale oil in Boxing Sag. Geol. Rev. 2023;69:270–272. [Google Scholar]
- Zhang S., Liu H., Liu Y., Wang Y., Wang M., Bao Y.. et al. Main controls and geological sweet spot types in Paleogene shale oil rich areas of the Jiyang Depression, Bohai Bay basin, China. Mar. Pet. Geol. 2020;111:576–587. doi: 10.1016/j.marpetgeo.2019.08.054. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Jarvie D. M., Hill R. J., Ruble T. E., Pollastro R. M.. Unconventional shale-gas systems: The Mississippian Barnett Shale of north-central Texas as one model for thermogenic shale-gas assessment. AAPG Bull. 2007;91:475–499. doi: 10.1306/12190606068. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Peters K. E., Fraser T. H., Amris W., Rustanto B., Hermanto E.. Geochemistry of crude oils from eastern Indonesia. AAPG Bull. 1999;83:1927–1942. doi: 10.1306/E4FD4643-1732-11D7-8645000102C1865D. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Didyk B. M., Simoneit B. R. T., Brassell S. T., Eglinton G.. Organic geochemical indicators of palaeoenvironmental conditions of sedimentation. Nature. 1978;272:216–222. doi: 10.1038/272216a0. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Radke M., Welte D. H., Willsch H.. Geochemical study on a well in the Western Canada Basin: relation of the aromatic distribution pattern to maturity of organic matter. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta. 1982;46:1–10. doi: 10.1016/0016-7037(82)90285-X. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Pepper A. S., Corvi P. J.. Simple kinetic models of petroleum formation. Part I: oil and gas generation from kerogen. Mar. Pet. Geol. 1995;12:291–319. doi: 10.1016/0264-8172(95)98381-E. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Huang H., Zhang H., Ma Y.. Staged-cumulative charging and differential accumulation of continental shale oil: A case study of Permian Lucaogou Formation shale oil in Junggar Basin, NW China. Pet. Explor. Dev. 2026;53:96–109. doi: 10.1016/S1876-3804(26)60677-5. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Moldowan J. M., Sundararaman P., Schoell M.. Sensitivity of biomarker properties to depositional environment and/or source input in the Lower Toarcian of SW-Germany. Org. Geochem. 1986;10:915–926. doi: 10.1016/S0146-6380(86)80029-8. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Gou Q., Xu S., Hao F., Shu Z., He S., Wu Z.. Differences in the nanopore structure of organic-rich shales with distinct sedimentary environments and mineral compositions. Energy Fuels. 2021;35:16562–16577. doi: 10.1021/acs.energyfuels.1c02555. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Radke M., Welte D. H., Willsch H.. Maturity parameters based on aromatic hydrocarbons: Influence of the organic matter type. Org. Geochem. 1986;10:51–63. doi: 10.1016/0146-6380(86)90008-2. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- van Aarssen B. G. K., Bastow T. P., Alexander R., Kagi R. I.. Distributions of methylated naphthalenes in crude oils: indicators of maturity, biodegradation and mixing. Org. Geochem. 1999;30:1213–1227. doi: 10.1016/S0146-6380(99)00097-2. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Lampe C., Song G., Cong L., Mu X.. Fault control on hydrocarbon migration and accumulation in the Tertiary Dongying depression, Bohai Basin, China. AAPG Bull. 2012;96:983–1000. doi: 10.1306/11031109023. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Larter S. R., Aplin A. C.. Reservoir geochemistry: Methods and applications. Geol. Soc. London Spec. Publ. 1995;86:5–32. doi: 10.1144/GSL.SP.1995.086.01.02. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- Jia G., Gao Y., Song J.. Study on “source-facies-potential” coupling relationship during oil and gas accumulation in Paleogene red beds, Boxing Subsag: a case study of the section Jin26-Binxie703. Pet. Geol. Recovery Eff. 2015;22:1–9. [Google Scholar]
- Zhang H., Huang H., Li Z., Liu M.. Comparative study between sequential solvent-extraction and multiple isothermal stages pyrolysis: A case study on Eocene Shahejie Formation shales, Dongying Depression, East China. Fuel. 2020;263:116591. doi: 10.1016/j.fuel.2019.116591. [DOI] [Google Scholar]
