Abstract
In accordance with Article 6 of Regulation (EC) No 396/2005, the applicant Corteva submitted a request to the competent national authority in Sweden to modify the existing maximum residue levels (MRLs) for the active substance propyzamide in oilseed rape, mustard seeds, gold of pleasure seeds, linseeds, sesame seeds, hemp seeds, borage seeds and honey. The data submitted in support of the request were found to be sufficient to derive MRL proposals for all the crops under assessment. Adequate analytical methods for enforcement are available to control the residues of propyzamide in plant matrices and honey at the validated limit of quantification (LOQ) of 0.01 and 0.05 mg/kg, respectively. Based on the risk assessment results, EFSA concluded that the short‐term and long‐term intake of residues resulting from the use of propyzamide according to the reported agricultural practices is unlikely to present a risk to consumer health.
Keywords: consumer risk assessment, honey, MRL, oilseeds, pesticide, propyzamide
SUMMARY
In accordance with Article 6 of Regulation (EC) No 396/2005, Corteva submitted an application to the competent national authority in Sweden (Evaluating Member State, EMS) to set new maximum residue levels (MRLs) for the active substance propyzamide in oilseed rape, mustard seeds, gold of pleasure seeds, linseeds, sesame seeds, hemp seeds, borage seeds and honey. The EMS drafted an evaluation report in accordance with Article 8 of Regulation (EC) No 396/2005, which was submitted to the European Commission and forwarded to the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) on 3 April 2018. To accommodate for the intended uses of propyzamide, the EMS proposed to raise the existing MRLs in rapeseeds/canola seeds, mustard seeds, gold of pleasure seeds, linseeds, sesame seeds, hemp seeds and borage seeds from the limit of quantification (LOQ) of 0.01 to 0.2 mg/kg and to raise the existing MRLs in honey from the LOQ of 0.05 to 0.06 mg/kg.
On 26 April 2018, the European Commission sent a mandate to EFSA to assess the application and the evaluation report (ER) as required by Article 10 of the MRL regulation.
In 2018, EFSA identified data gaps which needed further clarifications and requested them to the EMS. In 2024, the EMS SE submitted the requested information in a first revised evaluation report. Subsequently, EFSA discussed the toxicological assessment provided in the updated ER and specifically asked for advice to the cross‐cutting (cc) working group (WG) on genotoxicity to conclude on the genotoxic potential of relevant metabolites. The WG identified some outstanding points prior to conclude on the genotoxic potential of propyzamide metabolite RH‐26702 and the clock‐stop was maintained by EFSA, requesting the applicant to provide further information. A second updated ER was submitted to EFSA in July 2025. The revised assessment was discussed again with the ccWG on genotoxicity in September 2025, and in the expert meeting on Mammalian Toxicology, on 25–28 November 2025 (Pesticides peer review meeting 190).
The peer review experts' discussion on mammalian toxicology identified the need for final clarifications, which were subsequently provided to EFSA in an updated ER. EFSA then conducted a written procedure with the Member States (MSs) peer review experts from peer review meeting 190 (April 2026) to review the updated information received. This led to a final peer review experts' discussion, held on 22–25 June 2026 (Pesticides peer review meeting TC 213). On 3 July 2026, the EMS submitted a final revised evaluation report, replacing all previously submitted evaluation reports, which enabled EFSA to officially resume its assessment.
Based on the conclusions derived by EFSA in the framework of Regulation (EC) No 1107/2009, the data evaluated under a previous MRL assessment and the additional data provided by the EMS in the framework of this application, the following conclusions are derived.
As regards mammalian toxicity, based on the available data, the assessed metabolites RH‐24848, RH‐25891, RH‐26521, RH‐26059, RH‐25337, RH‐26702 and RH‐24644 were considered unlikely to be genotoxic and there is no evidence that any of them are more toxic than the parent compound. The health‐based guidance values (HBGVs) of propyzamide are applied.
The metabolism of propyzamide following foliar application was investigated in primary crops belonging to the groups of root crops, leafy crops and pulses/oilseeds. At harvest, propyzamide was the main residue in lettuce and alfalfa. The parent compound was not detected in rapeseeds and in sugar beet leaves and root where a major part of the radioactive residues was characterised as polar compounds that accounted for 37% total radioactive residue (TRR) in rapeseeds and up to 71% TRR in sugar beet root and leaves. Although recovered at low proportions (< 10% TRR) in lettuce only, the glucoside conjugated metabolites, the malonyl glucoside conjugated metabolites and metabolite RH‐24644 were identified at high absolute concentrations. Residues of glucoside and malonyl glucoside conjugated forms of RH‐26521 also occurred in alfalfa in significant proportions. The new study on oilseed rape submitted with the present MRL application and performed at a lower application rate than the metabolism study submitted for the EU peer review indicated no other metabolic products of propyzamide, which was the only component identified in the forage. In seeds and trash, extractable residues were too low to be characterised.
Nature of residues in rotational crops has also been investigated under the EU pesticides peer review in lettuce, carrot and wheat after the soil application of propyzamide. Parent propyzamide was identified in significant proportions in lettuce and in carrot tops. Mannoside conjugate of RH‐25337 and glucoside of RH‐26702 recovered predominantly in lettuce, carrot top and wheat forage and straw.
Overall, the EU pesticides peer review concluded that the metabolism of propyzamide in primary and in rotational crops is comparable.
Studies investigating the effect of processing on the nature of propyzamide (hydrolysis studies) demonstrated that the active substance is stable.
Based on the metabolic pattern identified in metabolism studies, hydrolysis studies and the toxicological relevance of metabolites, the residue definitions for plant products were proposed in the framework of EU pesticides peer review as propyzamide for enforcement and provisionally as ‘sum of propyzamide and all metabolites (and their conjugates) bearing the 3,5‐dichlorobenzioc acid (DCBA) moiety, expressed as propyzamide’ for risk assessment. The data submitted in this MRL application were considered sufficient to confirm these residue definitions. These residue definitions are applicable to primary crops, rotational crops and processed products.
EFSA concluded that, for the crops assessed in this application, metabolism of propyzamide in primary and in rotational crops, and the possible degradation in processed products has been sufficiently addressed and that the previously derived residue definitions are applicable.
In the absence of specific metabolism studies on honey, the studies investigating the nature of residues in primary and rotational crops and studies investigating the degradation of the active substance during pasteurisation are considered to derive the residue definitions for honey; the same residue definitions as mentioned for plant commodities are therefore proposed for honey.
Sufficiently validated analytical methods based on LC‐MS/MS are available to quantify residues in the crops assessed in this application according to the enforcement residue definition. The methods enable quantification of residues at or above 0.01 mg/kg in oilseed crops and 0.05 mg/kg in honey (LOQs).
The available residue trials on oilseed rape are sufficient to derive an MRL proposal of 0.2 mg/kg for oilseed rape – which could be extrapolated to mustard seeds, gold of pleasure seeds, linseeds, sesame seeds, hemp seeds and borage seeds. In the oilseed residue trials, the flowers were also analysed to estimate the magnitude of propyzamide residues in honey. The data were considered sufficient to derive an MRL proposal of 0.06 mg/kg for honey.
Specific studies investigating the magnitude of propyzamide residues in processed commodities are not required, as the total theoretical maximum daily intake (TMDI) is below the trigger value of 10% of the ADI.
The possible transfer of propyzamide residues to crops grown in rotation has been assessed in the EU MRL review and the pesticides peer review on the basis of confined rotational crop study. According to this study, in succeeding crops planted in soil treated at 4.48 kg a.s./ha, significant residue levels of parent propyzamide and conjugates of RH‐25337 and RH‐26702 are expected for short‐cycle crops planted 30 days after treatment (DAT). Even though the intended application rate of propyzamide on oilseed rape (750 g/ha) is significantly lower than the application rate used in the rotational crop metabolism study (4.48 kg/ha), without rotational crop field trials the actual magnitude of residues in rotational crops cannot be estimated. Therefore, before granting an authorisation for the use of propyzamide, and to avoid propyzamide residues in rotational crops in case of crop failure, it is recommended that the Member States consider the need for establishing the plant back intervals for rotational crops that have a short vegetation period.
As the crops under assessment and their by‐products are used as feed items, the potential carry‐over into food of animal origin was assessed. The calculated livestock dietary burden exceeded the trigger value of 0.004 mg/kg bw per day for ruminants. However, the updated dietary burden calculations performed in the context of this MRL application indicate that residues in the feed crops under consideration from the new intended uses do not have a significant impact on the levels previously calculated during the MRL review. Therefore, an update of the MRLs for commodities of animal origin is not required within the framework of the present application.
The toxicological profile of propyzamide was assessed in the framework of the EU pesticides peer review under Regulation (EC) No 1107/2009, and the data were sufficient to derive an acceptable daily intake (ADI) of 0.05 mg/kg bw per day and an acute reference dose (ARfD) of 0.13 mg/kg bw. The metabolites included in the residue definition for risk assessment are of similar or lower toxicity than the parent active substance.
The consumer risk assessment was performed with revision 3.1 of the EFSA Pesticide Residues Intake Model (PRIMo). The short‐term exposure did not exceed the ARfD for any of the crops assessed in this application. The estimated long‐term dietary intake accounted for a maximum of 3% of the ADI (NL toddler diet). EFSA notes that the consumers' risk assessment might be underestimated due to the risk assessment input values corresponding to the existing EU MRLs being based solely on measured propyzamide residues, since metabolites bearing the 3,5‐DCBA moiety were not previously included in the risk assessment residue definition. However, considering that these metabolites have a similar or lower toxicity than the parent compound and that chronic exposure is very low, it is not expected that their contribution would alter the overall outcome of the risk assessment.
EFSA concluded that the proposed use of propyzamide on oilseed crops under consideration and residues in honey from propyzamide uses on melliferous crops will not result in a consumer exposure exceeding the toxicological reference values and therefore is unlikely to pose a risk to consumers' health.
EFSA proposes to amend the existing MRLs as reported in the summary table below.
Full details of all end points and the consumer risk assessment can be found in Appendices B, C, D.
| Code a | Commodity | Existing EU MRL (mg/kg) | Proposed EU MRL (mg/kg) | Comment/justification |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Enforcement residue definition: propyzamide F | ||||
| 0401010 | Linseeds | 0.01* | 0.2 | The submitted residue trials on rapeseeds are sufficient to derive an MRL proposal and support the residue data extrapolation to mustard seeds, gold of pleasure seeds, linseeds, sesame seeds, hemp seeds and borage seeds. The MRL proposal reflects the more critical residue situation of the SEU use. Risk for consumers unlikely. |
| 0401040 | Sesame seeds | 0.01* | 0.2 | |
| 0401060 | Rapeseeds/canola seeds | 0.01* | 0.2 | |
| 0401080 | Mustard seeds | 0.01* | 0.2 | |
| 0401120 | Borage seeds | 0.01* | 0.2 | |
| 0401130 | Gold of pleasure seeds | 0.01* | 0.2 | |
| 0401140 | Hemp seeds | 0.01* | 0.2 | |
| 1040000 | Honey and other apiculture products b | 0.05* | 0.06 | The MRL proposal is based on residues in aerial parts (flowers) analysed in rapeseeds residue studies. Risk for consumers unlikely. |
Abbreviations: MRL, maximum residue level; SEU, southern Europe.
Indicates that the MRL is set at the limit of analytical quantification (LOQ).
Commodity code number according to Annex I of Regulation (EC) No 396/2005.
According to Regulation (EC) No 396/2005, MRLs are not applicable to other apiculture products until individual products have been identified and listed within this group.
Fat soluble.
ASSESSMENT
The European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) received an application to modify the existing maximum residue level (MRL) for propyzamide in oilseeds and honey. The detailed description of the intended uses of propyzamide, which are the basis for the current MRL application, is reported in Appendix A.
Propyzamide is the ISO common name for 3,5‐dichloro‐N‐(1,1‐dimethylprop‐2‐ynyl)benzamide (IUPAC name). The chemical structures of the active substance and its main metabolites are reported in Appendix E.
Propyzamide was evaluated in the framework of Regulation (EC) No 1107/2009 1 for renewal of approval with Sweden designated as Rapporteur Member State (RMS). The representative uses evaluated were post‐emergence spray applications in winter oilseed rape and lettuce, to control grasses and some broad‐leafed weeds. The draft assessment report (DAR) prepared by the RMS has been peer reviewed by EFSA (EFSA, 2016). Propyzamide was approved for renewal 2 in 2018.
Upon renewal, the European Commission identified the need for submission of confirmatory data, including the completion of assessment of toxicological profile of metabolites identified in significant concentration in primary and rotational crops. The EFSA peer review of the risk assessment for the active substance propyzamide in light of confirmatory data submitted in the area of mammalian toxicology and residues was finalised in 2022 (EFSA, 2020, 2022). However, in the framework of this assessment, the toxicological profile of metabolites RH‐24644 and RH‐26702 (identified as lead compounds from a grouping and read‐across approach) was not fully characterised, and their genotoxic potential could not be ruled out. Thus, reference values set for propyzamide could not be applied to these metabolites, and consequently, in the area of residues, the plant residue definition for risk assessment could not be finalised and a robust consumer dietary intake calculation could not be conducted.
The EU MRLs for propyzamide are established in Annex II of Regulation (EC) No 396/2005. 3 The review of existing MRLs according to Article 12 of Regulation (EC) No 396/2005 (MRL review) has been performed (EFSA, 2012) and the proposed modifications have been implemented in the MRL legislation. After completion of the MRL review, EFSA has issued one reasoned opinion on the modification of MRLs for propyzamide in herbal infusions (EFSA, 2013). The proposals from this reasoned opinion have been considered in recent MRL regulation. 4
In accordance with Article 6 of Regulation (EC) No 396/2005, the applicant Corteva submitted an application to the competent national authority in Sweden (evaluating Member State, EMS) to set new maximum residue levels (MRLs) for the active substance propyzamide in oilseed rape, mustard seeds, gold of pleasure seeds, linseeds, sesame seeds, hemp seeds, borage seeds and honey. The EMS drafted an evaluation report in accordance with Article 8 of Regulation (EC) No 396/2005, which was submitted to the European Commission and forwarded to the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) on 3 April 2018. To accommodate for the intended uses of propyzamide, the EMS proposed to raise the existing MRLs in rapeseeds/canola seeds, mustard seeds, gold of pleasure seeds, linseeds, sesame seeds, hemp seeds and borage seeds from the limit of quantification (LOQ) of 0.01 to 0.2 mg/kg and to raise the existing MRLs in honey from the LOQ of 0.05 to 0.06 mg/kg.
On 26 April 2018, the European Commission sent a mandate to EFSA to assess the application and the evaluation report as required by Article 10 of the MRL regulation.
EFSA assessed the application and identified data gaps which were requested to the EMS. The updated information was received in 2024 and followed by extensive discussions, first with the experts from the cross‐cutting (cc) Working Group (WG) on genotoxicity (EFSA, 2024, 2025a) and then with the MSs peer review experts (EFSA, 2025b, 2026). As a result, the EMS submitted a final updated evaluation report (ER) to EFSA in July 2026, which replaced the previously submitted one.
EFSA based its assessment on the evaluation report submitted by the EMS (Sweden, 2018; as revised in 2026), the draft assessment report (DAR) and its addenda (Sweden, 2015, 2016) prepared under Regulation (EC) 1107/2009, the Commission review report on propyzamide (European Commission, 2018a, 2022), the conclusion on the peer review of the pesticide risk assessment of the active substance propyzamide (EFSA, 2016) and its confirmatory data (EFSA, 2020, 2022), as well as the conclusions from previous EFSA opinions on propyzamide, including the reasoned opinion on the MRL review according to Article 12 of Regulation No 396/2005 (EFSA, 2012, 2013).
For this application, the data requirements established in Regulation (EU) No 283/2013 5 and the guidance documents applicable at the date of submission of the application to the EMS are applicable (European Commission, 2010, 2017, 2018b, 2023a, 2023b; OECD, 2013). The assessment is performed in accordance with the legal provisions of the Uniform Principles for the Evaluation and the Authorisation of Plant Protection Products adopted by Commission Regulation (EU) No 546/2011. 6
A selected list of end points of the studies assessed by EFSA in the framework of this MRL application including the end points of relevant studies assessed previously is presented in Appendix B.
The evaluation report submitted by the EMS (Sweden, 2018) and the exposure calculations using the EFSA Pesticide Residues Intake Model (PRIMo) are considered as supporting documents to this reasoned opinion and, thus, are made publicly available as background documents to this reasoned opinion. 7
1. MAMMALIAN TOXICOLOGY
The toxicological profile of propyzamide was assessed in the framework of the EU pesticides peer review in 2016 (EFSA, 2016). A data gap was set to address the toxicity of the metabolites RH‐24848, RH‐25891, RH‐26521, RH‐26059, RH‐25337, RH‐26702 and RH‐24644 in primary and in rotational crops and the health‐based guidance values (HBGVs) of the parent compound could not be applied as their genotoxic potential could not be ruled out. Moreover, none of the metabolites were identified as major rat metabolites. In the framework of the present MRL application, additional information has been submitted. The new data regarding the metabolites was discussed during Peer Review Meeting TC 190 (November, 2025), i.e. for the metabolites RH‐24848, RH‐25891, RH‐26521, RH‐26059, RH‐25337, RH‐26702 and RH‐24644. Metabolites RH‐24644 and RH‐25891 were further discussed during Peer Review Meeting TC 213 (June, 2026).
The assessments of both genotoxicity and general toxicity were done using grouping and read‐across approaches considering two different groups. Group 1 consisted of RH‐24848, RH‐25337 (lead compound), RH‐26059, RH‐26521 and RH‐26702 (lead compound). Group 2 consisted of RH‐24644 (lead compound) and RH‐25891. Based on the lack of sufficient similarity, including the presence of an alkyne moiety, propyzamide was not grouped with any of the metabolites.
Regarding metabolite RH‐24644, it was concluded unlikely to be genotoxic based on a weight of evidence approach including a positive bacterial reverse mutation test (in the presence of metabolic activation), a negative in vitro mammalian cell micronucleus assay, an inconclusive Pig‐A assay and a negative transgenic rodent assay in liver and bone marrow. Metabolite RH‐25891 was concluded unlikely to be genotoxic based on QSAR analysis and read‐across from metabolite RH‐24644.
Similarly, metabolite RH‐26702 was concluded unlikely to be genotoxic based on a weight of evidence approach including a positive bacterial reverse mutation test (in the absence of metabolic activation), a negative in vitro mammalian cell micronucleus assay, an inconclusive Pig‐A assay and a negative transgenic rodent assay in liver, bone marrow and duodenum. As for metabolite RH‐25337, based on a negative bacterial reverse mutation test and a negative in vitro mammalian cell micronucleus assay, it was concluded unlikely to be genotoxic. Thus, the other metabolites of group 1, i.e. RH‐24848, RH‐26521, RH‐26059, were considered as unlikely to be genotoxic based on QSAR analysis and read‐across from metabolites RH‐26702 and RH‐25337.
In short‐term toxicity studies with propyzamide, no observed adverse effect level (NOAEL) was identified and lowest observed adverse effect levels (LOAELs) of 37 mg/kg bw per day and 40.5 mg/kg bw per day were determined (EFSA, 2016). In available repeated‐dose toxicity studies, NOAELs of 71 and 68 mg/kg bw per day were identified for metabolites RH‐24644 and RH‐26702, respectively. Based on the comparison of NOAELs and commonalities of effects (hepatotoxicity) in these studies, metabolite RH‐24644 was considered of similar, or lower, toxicity compared to the active substance. Based on grouping and read‐across, the same conclusion was reached for metabolite RH‐25891. For metabolites included in group 1, the HBGVs of parent were used as worst‐case scenario considering that there is no indication of higher toxicity compared to the parent based on the available experimental data on RH‐26702.
Considering the available information, all assessed metabolites were considered unlikely to be genotoxic and there is no evidence that any of the metabolites are more toxic than the parent compound. Thus, the HBGVs of the parent compound can be applied, i.e. an ADI of 0.05 mg/kg bw per day (based on the results of short‐term and long‐term studies (liver, kidney effects) and an uncertainty factor (UF) of 100 and an ARfD of 0.13 mg/kg bw (based on an acute neurotoxicity study and UF of 300 for the use of a LOAEL) (EFSA, 2016).
2. RESIDUES IN PLANTS
2.1. Nature of residues and methods of analysis in plants
2.1.1. Nature of residues in primary crops
The metabolism of propyzamide in primary crops belonging to the group of leafy crops (lettuce), pulses/oilseeds (alfalfa, oilseed rape) and root crops (sugar beets) has been investigated in the framework of the MRL review and EU pesticides peer review (EFSA, 2012, 2016). Metabolism studies were conducted using 14C‐propyzamide labelled on the phenyl ring. The active substance was applied both pre‐ and post‐emergence on lettuce and post‐emergence on alfalfa, rapeseed and sugar beet at early growth stages (GSs) BBCH 13–19.
At harvest in mature plants, propyzamide was present in significant proportions in lettuce and in alfalfa (42.5% and 58% TRR, respectively). In rapeseed forage and root, it accounted for up to 15.5% TRR and the compound RH‐24644 was identified predominantly in the roots (45% TRR). The parent compound was not detected in rapeseeds and in sugar beet leaves and root where a major part of the radioactive residues was characterised as polar compounds that accounted for 37% TRR in rapeseeds and up to 71% TRR in sugar beet root and leaves. Although recovered at low proportions (< 10% TRR) in lettuce only, the glucoside conjugated metabolites (aglycons RH‐24848, RH‐25891, RH‐26521, RH‐26059) (0.045–0.07 mg eq/kg), the malonyl glucoside conjugated metabolites (aglycons RH‐24848, RH‐25891, RH‐26521) (0.082–0.29 mg eq/kg) and metabolite RH‐24644 (0.11 mg eq/kg) were identified at high absolute concentrations. Residues of glucoside and malonyl glucoside conjugated forms of RH‐26521 also occurred in alfalfa in significant proportions (14% TRR). It is noted that the available metabolism data did not enable the identification of a predominant compound in the bulk of the conjugated metabolites as the relative proportion of each individual compound/aglycon was not determined in this study (EFSA, 2016).
An additional metabolism study on oilseed rape was submitted in support of the current MRL application (Sweden, 2018). This study investigated the metabolism of propyzamide in oilseed rape treated by a foliar application with 14C‐phenyl‐propyzamide at BBCH 18‐19 with an application rate of 840 g a.s./ha, which was lower than the application rate investigated in oilseed rape metabolism study submitted for the EU pesticides peer review (1.6 kg/ha). Foliage samples were collected 0 and 30 days after application. Mature oilseed rape seeds and trash were collected 150 days after application. Total radioactive residues (TRR) in oilseed rape foliage decreased from 63.55 to 9.83 mg eq/kg between application (0 DAT) and 30 days after treatment. At maturity, 150 days after treatment, the TRR was 0.010 in seeds and 0.027 mg eq/kg in trash.
No metabolic products of propyzamide were observed in this study on oilseed rape. Propyzamide was the only component identified in the forage (102.5% TRR and 89.2% TRR at application and 30 days after treatment, respectively). Due to the low levels of unidentified minor components in the forage, individually not accounting for more than 1.0% TRR, no additional identification efforts were made. While in seeds and trash, extractable residues were too low to be characterised. These results were qualitatively similar to the findings of the previous metabolism study on oilseed rape assessed in the EU pesticides peer review where propyzamide was the only residue in forage declining rapidly from the application to 31 days after treatment and at maturity TRR in seeds and trash were significantly lower than in forage (EFSA, 2016).
For the intended use, the metabolic behaviour in primary crops is sufficiently addressed.
2.1.2. Nature of residues in rotational crops
Propyzamide is authorised or is proposed to be used on several crops that can be grown in rotation with other crops. According to the soil degradation studies evaluated in the framework of the EU peer review, the DT90 value of propyzamide, metabolites RH‐24644 and RH‐24580 exceed the trigger value of 100 days requiring further studies investigating the nature and magnitude of residues in rotational crops (EFSA, 2016).
A confined rotational crop metabolism study evaluated under the EU pesticides peer review (EFSA, 2016) was conducted with bare soil application of propyzamide labelled on the phenyl ring at a dose rate of 4.48 kg a.s./ha (5.3 N rate of the intended GAP for this application). Lettuce, carrot and wheat were planted at different plant back intervals (PBIs) (30, 180 and 365 days). Parent propyzamide was identified in significant proportions in lettuce (15%–42% TRR) and in carrot top (17% TRR). Mannoside conjugate of RH‐25337 and glucoside of RH‐26702 were recovered predominantly in lettuce, carrot top and wheat forage and straw. Metabolites' identification was not carried out in carrot root and wheat grain.
The peer review concluded that significant residue levels of parent propyzamide and conjugates of RH‐25337 and RH‐26702 are expected for short‐cycle crops as lettuce planted 30 days after treatment (DAT) and a data gap was set to conduct rotational crops field trials on leafy crops, root crops and small grain crops for the determination of propyzamide, mannoside conjugate of RH‐25337 and glucoside conjugate of RH‐26702 residues at 30 days PBI (EFSA, 2016).
Overall, the EU peer review concluded that the metabolic pattern in primary and rotational crops proceeds in a similar pathway.
For the proposed use assessed in this application, no further information is required.
2.1.3. Nature of residues in processed commodities
The effect of processing on the nature of propyzamide was investigated in the framework of the EU pesticides peer review (EFSA, 2016). These studies showed that propyzamide is hydrolytically stable under standard processing conditions representative of pasteurisation, baking/brewing/boiling and sterilisation.
2.1.4. Analytical methods for enforcement purposes in plant commodities
Analytical methods for the determination of propyzamide residues (enforcement residue definition) were assessed during the MRL review and EU pesticides peer review (EFSA, 2012, 2016). These methods are sufficiently validated and allow quantifying residues of parent propyzamide in food and feed of plant origin by liquid chromatography with tandem mass spectrometry (LC‐MS/MS) at or above the LOQ of 0.01 mg/kg in high water, high oil, dry and acidic commodities.
Additionally, even if not needed for enforcement purposes, a new analytical method suitable for the quantitative determination of residues of propyzamide and all metabolites containing the 3,5‐dichlorobenzoic acid moiety (3,5‐DCBA) (proposed risk assessment residue definition) in high water, high oil, dry and acidic commodities was submitted with the present application (Sweden, 2018). In this method, residues of propyzamide and metabolites containing the 3,5‐DCBA moiety were extracted from the sample matrices with acetonitrile/water 80:20 and then hydrolysed to 3,5‐DCBA with 9N sulfuric acid at 100°C for 12 h. Following the hydrolysis, the samples were purified and then derivatised with N‐methyl‐N‐(tert‐butyldimethylsilyl)‐trifluoroacetamide (MTBSTFA) for 60 min at 60°C. The obtained derivatised samples were then analysed by gas chromatography with negative‐ion chemical ionisation mass spectrometry (GC/NCI‐MS).
This method was validated in all these crop matrices at an LOQ of 0.01 mg/kg according to the Guidance SANTE/2020/12830 Rev.2.
2.1.5. Storage stability of residues in plants
The storage stability of parent propyzamide in plants stored under frozen conditions was investigated in the framework of the EU pesticides peer review (EFSA, 2016). It was demonstrated that parent propyzamide was stable in high oil content commodities for at least 18 months in whole plant material and 24 months in seeds when stored at −20°C. Additionally, storage stability was also demonstrated for parent propyzamide in high water, dry and acidic commodities for 13–36 months when stored between −18°C and −20°C.
EFSA noted that storage stability had been demonstrated only for the parent compound, propyzamide, and that no information was available on the stability of the metabolites (and their conjugates) bearing the 3,5‐dichlorobenzoic acid (3,5‐DCBA) moiety that are included in the residue definition for risk assessment. The applicant was therefore requested to investigate the storage stability of the metabolites included in the risk assessment residue definition.
In response, the applicant submitted a position paper to justify the storage stability of these metabolites. In this paper, the applicant pointed out that the residue definition for risk assessment comprises propyzamide and its metabolites containing the 3,5‐DCBA moiety, without specifying individual metabolites. Accordingly, the analytical method used for risk assessment determines the total amount of the 3,5‐DCBA moiety rather than individual metabolites. The method relies on acid hydrolysis, which cleaves the alkyl side chain of propyzamide and its metabolites and quantifies the total concentration of the 3,5‐DCBA moiety as a surrogate for the sum of propyzamide and its metabolites. Therefore, any transformation of the alkyl side chain occurring during frozen storage would not affect the quantification of the combined residues of propyzamide and its metabolites containing the 3,5‐DCBA moiety.
The EMS and EFSA agreed with this justification and therefore considered that storage stability data for each individual metabolite bearing the 3,5‐DCBA moiety were not required. The available storage stability data for propyzamide, together with the analytical method based on the common 3,5‐DCBA moiety, were considered sufficient to support the storage stability of the residue definition for risk assessment, comprising propyzamide and all metabolites containing the 3,5‐DCBA moiety.
2.1.6. Proposed residue definitions
Based on the metabolic pattern identified in metabolism studies, the results of hydrolysis studies, the toxicological significance of metabolites and the capabilities of analytical methods, the following residue definitions were proposed by the EU peer review of the pesticide risk assessment of the active substance propyzamide in light of the confirmatory data submitted (EFSA, 2020, 2022):
residue definition for risk assessment (provisional): sum of propyzamide and all metabolites (and their conjugates) bearing the 3,5‐dichlorobenzioc acid (DCBA) moiety, expressed as propyzamide.
residue definition for enforcement: propyzamide.
The same residue definitions are applicable to rotational crops and processed products.
The residue definition for enforcement set in Regulation (EC) No 396/2005 for plant commodities is identical with the above‐mentioned residue definition.
Considering the additional information provided with this application, particularly the toxicological characterisation of all metabolites containing the 3,5‐DCBA moiety, EFSA concluded that these residue definitions are appropriate and that the provisional residue definition for risk assessment can be confirmed as ‘sum of propyzamide and all metabolites (and their conjugates) bearing the 3,5‐dichlorobenzoic acid (DCBA) moiety, expressed as propyzamide’. This conclusion is supported by the fact that all these metabolites are covered by the toxicological profile of propyzamide (see Section 1) and that a common moiety analytical method suitable for the quantitative determination of residues of propyzamide and all metabolites containing the 3,5‐DCBA moiety is available (see Section 2.1.4).
2.2. Magnitude of residues in plants
2.2.1. Magnitude of residues in primary crops
In support of the MRL application, the applicant submitted residue trials performed in oilseed rape. The samples were analysed for the parent compound and the metabolites included in the residue definition for risk assessment. According to the assessment of the EMS, the methods used were sufficiently validated and fit for purpose (Sweden, 2018). The samples of these residue trials were stored under conditions for which the integrity of the samples has been demonstrated.
As oilseed rape is a major crop in both NEU and SEU, eight trials in each zone should be submitted. EFSA noted that a GAP‐compliant and sufficient number of residue trials performed in oilseed rape was previously submitted and assessed under the EU peer review (EFSA, 2016). However, these residue trials were analysed for the parent propyzamide only. Therefore, EFSA requested the applicant to provide residue trials on oilseed rape compliant with the GAP and analysing for residues of metabolites included in the residue definition for risk assessment.
The applicant provided with the current application a new set of residue trials on oilseed rape conducted in NEU and SEU during the period 2019–2021 (Sweden, 2026). These studies contained 20 trials consisting of 10 NEU and 10 SEU trials. Out of these, 10 trials (5 NEU and 5 SEU) were harvest studies and 10 trials (5 NEU and 5 SEU) were decline studies. These new trials were designed to evaluate simultaneously residues of propyzamide only and propyzamide and all metabolites (and their conjugates) containing the 3,5‐DCBA moiety, expressed as propyzamide. As the MRL is based on the residue definition for enforcement, set as propyzamide only, the applicant combined the residue trials previously submitted and assessed under the EU peer review with the newly submitted trials. Moreover, the applicant also merged the NEU and SEU trials to derive an MRL of 0.2 mg/kg for oilseed rape which is proposed to be extrapolated also to mustard seeds, gold of pleasure seeds, linseeds, sesame seeds, hemp seeds and borage seeds as the same GAP is proposed for these crops.
EFSA noted that, according to the EU Technical Guidelines on data requirements for setting maximum residue levels, comparability of residue trials and extrapolation on residue data on products from plant and animal origin (SANTE/2019/12752, European Commission, 2023b), it is appropriate to combine NEU and SEU residue trials for one crop/commodity when the trials are representative of the same GAP, the data sets belong to the same statistical population and the MRL proposals derived from the individual data sets fall within the same or a neighbouring class. EFSA further noted that, while the NEU and SEU trials are representative of the same GAP, the two data sets (NEU and SEU) belong to different statistical populations and the MRL proposals derived from the individual data sets do not fall within the same or a neighbouring class (NEU MRL = 0.10 mg/kg and SEU MRL = 0.20 mg/kg). Therefore, EFSA considered it more appropriate to use the more critical data set (SEU) to set an MRL and to derive the input values (STMR and HR) for the dietary consumers risk assessment. In fact, this has no impact on the proposed MRL (0.2 mg/kg). Finally, EFSA agreed with the proposed extrapolation to the whole oilseeds group (0401020) based on the same GAP which is in line with the recommended extrapolations of the EU Technical Guidelines SANTE/2019/12752 (European Commission, 2023b).
2.2.2. Magnitude of residues in rotational crops
The possible transfer of propyzamide residues to crops grown in rotation has been assessed in the EU MRL review and the pesticides peer review on the basis of confined rotational crop study, see Section 2.1.2 (EFSA, 2012, 2016).
According to this study, in succeeding crops planted in soil treated at 4.48 kg a.s./ha, significant residue levels of parent propyzamide and conjugates of RH‐25337 and RH‐26702 are expected for short‐cycle crops as lettuce planted 30 days after treatment (DAT). The EU pesticides peer review set a data gap to conduct rotational crops field trials on leafy crops, root crops and small grain crops for the determination of propyzamide, mannoside conjugate of RH‐25337 and glucoside conjugate of RH‐26702 residues at 30 days PBI (EFSA, 2016). This data gap was not addressed with the peer review confirmatory data or with the present assessment.
Even though the intended application rate of propyzamide on oilseed rape (750 g/ha) is significantly lower than the application rate used in the rotational crop metabolism study (4.48 kg/ha – 5.3 N rate of the intended GAP for the present assessment), without rotational crop field trials the actual magnitude of residues in rotational crops cannot be estimated. Therefore, before granting an authorisation for the use of propyzamide, and in order to avoid residues in rotational crops in the event of crop failure, it is recommended that Member States consider the need to establish plant back intervals for rotational crops with a short vegetation period.
2.2.3. Magnitude of residues in processed commodities
Specific processing studies for the crops under assessment are not available and are not required as they are not expected to affect the outcome of the risk assessment considering the extremely low individual contribution to the ADI of the crops under assessment (see Appendix B.5).
2.2.4. Proposed MRLs
The available data are considered sufficient to derive MRL proposals as well as risk assessment values for the commodities under evaluation (see Appendix B.2.2). In Section 5, EFSA assessed whether residues on these crops resulting from the intended uses are likely to pose a consumer health risk.
3. RESIDUES IN LIVESTOCK AND FISH
By‐products of rapeseeds and linseeds may be used for feed purposes. Hence, it was necessary to update the previous dietary burden calculation for livestock (EFSA, 2012), including rapeseed and linseed by‐products, to estimate whether the intended uses of propyzamide would have an impact on the residues expected in food of animal origin and would trigger a modification of these MRLs.
In the framework of the MRL review for propyzamide, the dietary burden for livestock was calculated for the authorised uses of propyzamide on feed crops, exceeding the trigger value of 0.1 mg/kg DM for dairy ruminants, meat ruminants and pigs. Further investigation of residues was therefore required in these groups of livestock (EFSA, 2012). The EU pesticides peer review also calculated the livestock dietary burdens for the representative use on oilseed rape and concluded that the trigger value of 0.004 mg/kg bw day is reached only for lamb and that residues above 0.01 mg/kg are not expected in animal matrices and MRLs for livestock matrices are not required (EFSA, 2016). However, this calculation did not take into consideration authorised uses reported for the MRL review.
Therefore, EFSA updated the dietary burden calculations performed under the MRL review according to the OECD guidelines (OECD, 2013) with the new risk assessment values derived from the intended uses of propyzamide in oilseed rape and linseed submitted under the present application (see Section D.1 for detailed input values). The results of the dietary burden update (see Section B.3) indicate that the residues in feed crops under consideration from the new intended uses do not have an impact on the dietary burden levels calculated previously by the MRL review. Thus, an update of the MRLs for commodities of animal origin is not needed in the framework of the present application and the conclusions derived in the MRL review that significant residues in animal matrices of ruminants and pigs and milk are not expected and that MRLs for these commodities can be established at the LOQ remain applicable.
Oilseed crops in scope of this application and their by‐products could be used as fish feed items and propyzamide is a lipophilic compound (log Pow = 3.27), thus has the potential to accumulate in fish tissue. Therefore, EFSA calculated the dietary burden for fish using the Fraunhofer fish dietary burden calculator. 8 The input values used in the calculation are summarised in Appendix D.2. The maximum dietary burden estimated was 0.046 mg/kg for common carp, 0.037 mg/kg for rainbow trout and 0.023 mg/kg for Atlantic salmon. The threshold value of 0.1 mg/kg DM (European Commission, 2023) was not exceeded for any of the three fish categories, and therefore, significant residues in fish tissues are not expected and additional investigations on the nature and magnitude of propyzamide residues in fish are not required.
3.1. Nature of residues and methods of analysis in livestock
Metabolism studies in livestock (laying hens and lactating goats) have been assessed previously in the framework of the EU MRL review and the EU pesticides peer review (EFSA, 2012, 2016). The following residue definitions were derived: ‘propyzamide’ for enforcement purposes and ‘sum of propyzamide and all metabolites (and their conjugates) bearing the 3,5‐dichlorobenzoic acid (DCBA) moiety, expressed as propyzamide’ for risk assessment.
It is noted that the enforcement residue definition currently in place in Regulation (EC) No 396/2005 is still set as ‘Sum of propyzamide and all metabolites containing the 3,5‐dichlorobenzoic acid moiety, expressed as propyzamide’.
An analytical method is available for the enforcement of residues in meat, fat, liver and kidney, with an LOQ of 0.01 mg/kg for meat and fat and 0.1 mg/kg for liver and kidney. The method converts all metabolites containing the 3,5‐dichlorobenzoic acid (DCBA) moiety into 3,5‐dichlorobenzoic acid and is therefore suitable for enforcing the residue definition currently laid down in Regulation (EC) No 396/2005. EFSA notes that, during the MRL review, a data gap was identified regarding the availability of an independent laboratory validation (ILV) for this method, and confirmatory data were therefore requested (EFSA, 2012).
The storage stability of parent propyzamide in animal products was evaluated during the EU peer review (Sweden, 1998, 2003). Storage stability of propyzamide was demonstrated in milk, eggs and animal tissues for up to 3 months when stored deep frozen.
3.2. Magnitude of residues in livestock
Livestock feeding studies were provided and assessed in the framework of the EU peer review and MRL review (EFSA, 2012; Sweden, 1998) confirming that no changes to the EU MRLs on animal products set at the LOQ were needed. Results of the dietary burden update indicate that the residues in feed crops under consideration from the new intended uses do not have an impact on the dietary burden levels calculated previously; therefore, no changes for the MRLs for commodities of animal origin are needed in the framework of the present application. The MRLs in animal matrices are currently set on a tentative basis, pending submission of further data (ILV and a confirmatory method) for validation of the analytical method for enforcement.
4. RESIDUES IN HONEY
4.1. Nature of residues in honey
Honey is produced by bees from sugary secretions of plants (floral nectar mainly) through regurgitation, enzymatic conversion and water evaporation and followed by storage in the bee hives for a certain time period.
In the absence of specific metabolism studies with honey bees, studies investigating the nature of residues in primary crops and rotational crops and studies investigating the degradation during pasteurisation should be considered to determine the nature of residues in honey (European Commission, 2018b). It is likely that the nature of residues in pollen and nectar collected from primary and rotational crops, as well as in honey (resulting from the residues in floral nectar), is the same as in primary and rotational crops.
Considering that sufficient data investigating the metabolic profile in primary and rotational crops and the degradation of the active substance under standard hydrolysis conditions are available, no further information is required for the current application according to the guidelines. However, it would be desirable to further investigate whether enzymatic processes involved in the production of honey occurring in the bee gut or during storage in the beehive have an impact on the nature of residues in honey.
4.1.1. Analytical methods in honey
In the framework of the present assessment, the applicant submitted new analytical methods for the quantitative determination in honey of residues of parent propyzamide only as well as residues of propyzamide and all metabolites containing the 3,5‐DCBA moiety (Sweden, 2018).
In the multiresidue method for the quantitative determination of parent propyzamide only, after extraction from the honey sample, the final samples were analysed for parent propyzamide by liquid chromatography with tandem mass spectrometry (LC‐MS/MS). While in the common moiety method for the quantitative determination in honey of residues of propyzamide and all metabolites containing the 3,5‐DCBA moiety, residues were extracted from honey with acetonitrile/water 80:20 and then hydrolysed to 3,5‐DCBA with 9N sulfuric acid at 100°C for 12 h. Following the hydrolysis, the samples were purified and then derivatised with N‐methyl‐N‐(tert‐butyldimethylsilyl)‐trifluoroacetamide (MTBSTFA) for 60 min at 60°C. The obtained derivatised samples were then analysed by gas chromatography with negative‐ion chemical ionisation mass spectrometry (GC/NCI‐MS).
Both methods were validated for the analysis of parent propyzamide only at an LOQ of 0.05 mg/kg and for the analysis of propyzamide and all metabolites containing the 3,5‐DCBA moiety at an LOQ of 0.05 mg/kg to the Guidance SANTE/2020/12830 Rev.2 (European Commission, 2023a).
4.1.2. Storage stability of residues in honey
The storage stability of residues of propyzamide in oilseed rape was investigated in the framework of the EU pesticides peer review (EFSA, 2016). It was demonstrated that parent propyzamide was stable in oily crops such as oilseed rape for at least 24 months (720 days) in whole plant (forage) material and 18 months (540 days) in seed/grain when stored at approximately −20°C. No new storage stability study in honey is provided. However, this study is not necessary as the proposed MRL for honey is based on the residue levels detected in flowers of oilseed rape, for which storage stability is considered demonstrated for both parent propyzamide as well as all metabolites (and their conjugates) bearing the 3,5‐DCBA moiety as reported in Section 2.1.5.
4.1.3. Proposed residue definitions
In the absence of specific metabolism studies on honey, the studies investigating the nature of residues in primary and rotational crops and studies investigating the degradation of the active substance during pasteurisation are considered to derive the residue definitions for honey; the same residue definitions as mentioned for plant commodities are therefore proposed.
4.2. Magnitude of residues in honey
In several of the oil seed rape residue trials described in Section 2.2.1 above, flowers of oilseed rape were analysed for both parent propyzamide only and propyzamide and all metabolites (and their conjugates) bearing the 3,5‐DCBA moiety.
According to the Technical Guidelines for determining the magnitude of pesticide residues in honey and setting MRLs in honey (SANTE/11956/2016 rev.9), ‘if the highest residue level in aerial parts of plants is equal to or above the threshold value of 0.05 mg/kg but below 0.5 mg/kg, an MRL proposal can be made based on the HR and on the hypothesis of a transfer factor of 1 from aerial parts to honey depending on the outcome of the risk assessment and if the MRL is safe for consumers’ (European Commission, 2018b).
In the residue trials of oilseed rape detecting the residue level in aerial crop parts (flowers), the highest residue values in flowers were detected at 0.055 mg/kg as parent propyzamide only and at 0.059 mg/kg as propyzamide and all metabolites (and their conjugates) bearing the 3,5‐DCBA moiety. Since these values are above the threshold value of 0.05 mg/kg but below 0.5 mg/kg, the applicant is proposing to derive an MRL for honey at 0.06 mg/kg (after OECD rounding) according to the residue definition for enforcement as propyzamide only.
According to the assessment of the EMS, the methods used are sufficiently validated for the quantification of residues of both parent propyzamide only and propyzamide and all metabolites (and their conjugates) bearing the 3,5‐DCBA moiety and are fit for purpose (Sweden, 2026). Moreover, the samples of residue trials detecting the residue level in aerial crop parts (flowers) were stored under conditions for which the integrity of the samples has been demonstrated.
The available residue trials are sufficient to derive an MRL proposal of 0.06 mg/kg for honey. It should be noted that, currently, MRLs set for honey are not applicable to other apicultural products following Commission Regulation (EU) 2018/62. 9
Magnitude of residues from EU national monitoring programme
Within the framework of Article 32 of Regulation (EC) No 396/2005 (official national control programmes), monitoring data were submitted to EFSA. Honey samples collected between 2018 and 2024 in several countries were analysed. All the honey samples analysed (4377) showed propyzamide residue levels below the LOQ of 0.01 mg/kg (analytical method LOQ for monitoring purposes).
Overall, the monitoring data demonstrate that the proposed MRL for honey, derived from residue levels in aerial crop parts (flowers) as presented in this application, is higher than the residue levels observed in honey samples available on the market.
4.2.1. Proposed MRLs
The available data are considered sufficient to derive an MRL proposal of 0.06 mg/kg as well as risk assessment values for honey (see Appendix B.4.2.1). In Section 5, EFSA assessed whether residues on these crops resulting from the intended uses are likely to pose a consumer health risk.
It should be noted that, currently, MRLs set for honey are not applicable to other apicultural products following Commission Regulation (EU) 2018/62. 10
5. CONSUMER RISK ASSESSMENT
EFSA performed a dietary risk assessment using revision 3.1 of the EFSA PRIMo (EFSA, 2018, 2019). This exposure assessment model contains food consumption data for different subgroups of the EU population and allows the acute and chronic exposure assessment to be performed in accordance with the internationally agreed methodology for pesticide residues (FAO, 2016).
The health‐based guidance values for propyzamide used in the risk assessment (i.e. ADI and ARfD values) were derived in the framework of the EU pesticides peer review (European Commission, 2018a). The metabolites included in the risk assessment residue definition were considered to be of similar or lower toxicity than the parent compound (see Section 1).
Short‐term (acute) dietary risk assessment
The short‐term exposure assessment was performed in accordance with the internationally agreed methodology and focused on the commodities assessed in this application. The calculations were based on the STMR derived from supervised field trials and the complete list of input values can be found in Appendix D.3.
The short‐term exposure did not exceed the ARfD for honey and any of the crops assessed in this application.
Long‐term (chronic) dietary risk assessment
In the framework of the MRL review, a comprehensive long‐term exposure assessment was performed, taking into account the existing uses at EU level (EFSA, 2012). EFSA updated the calculation with the relevant STMR values derived from the residue trials submitted in support of this MRL application and the STMRs derived in another EFSA opinion published after the MRL review (EFSA, 2013). The input values used in the exposure calculations are summarised in Appendix D.3.
The estimated long‐term dietary intake accounted for a maximum of 3% of the ADI (NL toddler diet). The contribution of residues expected in the commodities assessed in this application to the overall long‐term exposure is very low and is presented in more detail in Appendix B.5.
EFSA notes that the consumer risk assessment is affected by non‐standard uncertainties, as the risk assessment input values for the existing uses are based solely on measured propyzamide residues, since metabolites bearing the 3,5‐DCBA moiety were not previously analysed. However, considering the large margin of safety and that these metabolites have an equal or lower toxicity than the parent compound, it is not expected that their contribution would alter the overall outcome of the risk assessment.
Furthermore, for some of the existing EU MRLs, the Article 12 confirmatory data gaps have not been addressed, and therefore, the consumer exposure is considered tentative.
EFSA concluded that the short‐term and long‐term intake of residues of propyzamide resulting from the existing and the intended uses is unlikely to present a risk to consumer health.
For further details on the exposure calculations, a screenshot of the Report sheet of the PRIMo is presented in Appendix C.
6. CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS
The data submitted in support of this MRL application were found to be sufficient to derive an MRL proposal for oilseed rape, mustard seeds, gold of pleasure seeds, linseeds, sesame seeds, hemp seeds, borage seeds and honey. The intended use of propyzamide on crops that could be used as feed items did not trigger the modification of the existing MRLs in commodities of animal origin.
In order to avoid propyzamide residue uptake in rotational crops, it is recommended that Member States when granting authorisation of propyzamide consider the need to establish plant back intervals for rotational crops with a short vegetation period.
EFSA concluded that the proposed use of propyzamide on oilseed rape, mustard seeds, gold of pleasure seeds, linseeds, sesame seeds, hemp seeds, borage seeds and honey will not result in a consumer exposure exceeding the health‐based guidance values and therefore is unlikely to pose a risk to consumers' health.
The MRL recommendations are summarised in Appendix B.6.
ABBREVIATIONS
- ADI
acceptable daily intake
- AR
applied radioactivity
- ARfD
acute reference dose
- a.s.
active substance
- BBCH
growth stages of mono‐ and dicotyledonous plants
- bw
body weight
- CAC
Codex Alimentarius Commission
- CAS
Chemical Abstract Service
- CCPR
Codex Committee on Pesticide Residues
- CEN
European Committee for Standardisation (Comité Européen de Normalisation)
- CF
conversion factor for enforcement to risk assessment residue definition
- cGAP
critical GAP
- CIPAC
Collaborative International Pesticide Analytical Council
- CIRCA
(EU) Communication & Information Resource Centre Administrator
- CIRCABC
Communication and Information Resource Centre for Administrations, Businesses and Citizens
- CS
capsule suspension
- CV
coefficient of variation (relative standard deviation)
- CXL
Codex maximum residue limit
- DALA
days after last application
- DAR
draft assessment report
- DAT
days after treatment
- DM
dry matter
- DP
dustable powder
- DS
powder for dry seed treatment
- DT90
period required for 90% dissipation (define method of estimation)
- dw
dry weight
- EC
emulsifiable concentrate
- ECD
electron capture detector
- EDI
estimated daily intake
- EMS
evaluating Member State
- eq
residue expressed as a.s. equivalent
- ESI
electrospray ionisation
- EURL
EU Reference Laboratory (former Community Reference Laboratory (CRL))
- FAO
Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations
- FID
flame ionisation detector
- FLD
fluorescence detector
- FPD
flame photometric detector
- GAP
Good Agricultural Practice
- GC
gas chromatography
- GC‐MS
gas chromatography with mass spectrometry
- GCPF
Global Crop Protection Federation (formerly International Group of National Associations of Manufacturers of Agrochemical Products (GIFAP))
- GLP
Good Laboratory Practice
- GR
granule
- GS
growth stage
- HPLC
high‐performance liquid chromatography
- HPLC‐MS
high‐performance liquid chromatography with mass spectrometry
- HPLC‐MS/MS
high‐performance liquid chromatography with tandem mass spectrometry
- HR
highest residue
- IEDI
international estimated daily intake
- IESTI
international estimated short‐term intake
- ILV
independent laboratory validation
- IPCS
International Programme of Chemical Safety
- ISO
International Organisation for Standardisation
- IUPAC
International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry
- JMPR
Joint FAO/WHO Meeting on Pesticide Residues
- Koc
organic carbon adsorption coefficient
- LC
liquid chromatography
- LOAEL
lowest observed adverse effect level
- LOD
limit of detection
- LOQ
limit of quantification
- MRL
maximum residue level
- MS
mass spectrometry detector
- MS
Member States
- MS/MS
tandem mass spectrometry detector
- MW
molecular weight
- NEU
northern Europe
- NOAEL
no observed adverse effect level
- NPD
nitrogen/phosphorous detector
- OECD
Organisation for Economic Co‐operation and Development
- PAFF
Standing Committee on Plants, Animals, Food and Feed
- PBI
plant back interval
- PF
processing factor
- PHI
preharvest interval
- Pow
partition coefficient between n‐octanol and water
- PRIMo
(EFSA) Pesticide Residues Intake Model
- PROFile
(EFSA) Pesticide Residues Overview File
- QSAR
Quantitative Structure‐Activity Relationship
- QuEChERS
Quick, Easy, Cheap, Effective, Rugged, and Safe (analytical method)
- RA
risk assessment
- RAC
raw agricultural commodity
- Rber
statistical calculation of the MRL by using a non‐parametric method
- RD
residue definition
- Rmax
statistical calculation of the MRL by using a parametric method
- RMS
rapporteur Member State
- RPF
relative potency factor
- SANCO
Directorate‐General for Health and Consumers
- SC
suspension concentrate
- SCPAFF
Standing Committee on Plants, Animals, Food and Feed (formerly: Standing Committee on the Food Chain and Animal Health; SCFCAH)
- SEU
southern Europe
- SG
water‐soluble granule
- SL
soluble concentrate
- SP
water‐soluble powder
- STMR
supervised trials median residue
- TAR
total applied radioactivity
- TMDI
theoretical maximum daily intake
- TRR
total radioactive residue
- UV
ultraviolet (detector)
- WG
water‐dispersible granule
- WHO
World Health Organization
- WP
wettable powder
REQUESTOR
European Commission
QUESTION NUMBER
EFSA‐Q‐2018‐00328
COPYRIGHT FOR NON‐EFSA CONTENT
EFSA may include images or other content for which it does not hold copyright. In such cases, EFSA indicates the copyright holder and users should seek permission to reproduce the content from the original source.
APPENDIX A. Summary of intended GAP triggering the amendment of existing EU MRLs
| Crop and/or situation | NEU, SEU, MS or country | F, G or I a | Pests or group of pests controlled | Preparation | Application | Application rate per treatment | PHI (days) d | Remarks | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Type b | Conc. a.s. (g/kg or g/L) | Method kind | Range of growth stages & season c | Number min–max | Interval between application (days) min–max | g a.s./hL min–max | Water (L/ha) min–max | Rate max | Unit | ||||||
| Oilseed Rape | NEU/SEU | F | Grasses and broad‐leaved weed species | SC | 2.1 | Broadcast Tractor mounted boom sprayer | 19 | 1 | n/a | 210 | 80–400 | 840 | g a.s./ha | ≥ 120 | |
|
Mustard seeds Gold of Pleasure seeds Linseeds Sesame seeds Hemp seeds Borage seeds |
NEU/SEU | F | Grasses and broad‐leaved weed species | SC | 1.875 | Broadcast Tractor mounted boom sprayer | 12–19 | 1 | n/a | 187.5 | 80–400 | 750 | g a.s./ha | ≥ 120 | |
Abbreviations: a.s., active substance; GAP, Good Agricultural Practice; MRL, maximum residue level; MS, Member State; NEU, northern European Union; SC, soluble concentrate; SEU, southern European Union.
Outdoor or field use (F), greenhouse application (G) or indoor application (I).
CropLife International Technical Monograph no 2, 7th Edition. Revised March 2017. Catalogue of pesticide formulation types and international coding system.
Growth stage range from first to last treatment (BBCH Monograph, Growth Stages of Plants, 1997, Blackwell, ISBN 3‐8263‐3152‐4), including, where relevant, information on season at time of application.
PHI – minimum preharvest interval.
APPENDIX B. List of endpoints
B.1. MAMMALIAN TOXICOLOGY

Summary (Regulation (EU) No 1107/2009, Annex II, point 3.1 and 3.6)

B.2. RESIDUES IN PLANTS
B.2.1. Nature of residues and analytical methods for enforcement purposes in plant commodities
B.2.1.1. Metabolism studies, analytical methods and residue definitions in plants
| Primary crops (available studies) | Crop groups | Crop(s) | Application(s) | Sampling (DAT) | Comment/source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Root crops | Sugar beet | Foliar, 1 × 1.5 kg/ha BBCH 16 | 20, 148 | [Ph‐13C]‐Propyzamide (EFSA, 2016) | |
| Leafy crops | Lettuce | Pre/Post emergence, (1 × 2.24 kg/ha/1 × 2.24 kg/ha) | 0, 15, 30, 55 | [Ph‐13C]‐Propyzamide (EFSA, 2016) | |
| Pulses/oilseeds | Rapeseeds | Foliar, 1 × 1.6 kg/ha, 3 to 4 leaf stage | 0, 31, 104, 188 | [Ph‐13C]‐Propyzamide (EFSA, 2016) | |
| Rapeseeds | Foliar, 1 × 0.84 kg/ha, BBCH 18‐19 | 0, 30, 150 | [Ph‐13C]‐Propyzamide (Sweden, 2018) | ||
| Alfalfa | Foliar, 1 × 4.48 kg/ha | 0, 25, 45, 120 | [Ph‐13C]‐Propyzamide (EFSA, 2016) |
| Rotational crops (available studies) | Crop groups | Crop(s) | Application(s) | PBI (DAT) | Comment/Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Root/tuber crops | Carrot | Bare soil application | 180, 365 | [Ph‐13C]‐Propyzamide bare soil, 4.48 kg a.s/ha, ploughing at 10 cm depth (EFSA, 2016) | |
| Leafy crops | Lettuce | Bare soil application | 30, 180, 365 | ||
| Cereal (small grain) | Wheat | Bare soil application | 365 |

B.2.1.2. Stability of residues in plants
| Plant products (available studies) | Category | Commodity | T (°C) | Stability period | Compounds covered 11 | Comment/source | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Value | Unit | ||||||
| High water content |
Apple Lettuce Peaches |
−20 | 36 | Months | Parent | EFSA (2016) | |
| High oil content |
Rapeseed Soya bean seed |
−20 |
18 24 |
Months | Parent | EFSA (2016) | |
| High protein content | Dry bean seed | −18 | 13 | Months | Parent | EFSA (2016) | |
| High acid content | Grapes | −20 | 36 | Months | Parent | EFSA (2016) | |
B.2.2. Magnitude of residues in plants
B.2.2.1. Summary of residues data from the supervised residue trials
| Commodity | Region a | Residue levels observed in the supervised residue trials (mg/kg) | Comments/source | Calculated MRL (mg/kg) | HR b (mg/kg) | STMR c (mg/kg) | CF d |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oilseed Rape | NEU |
Mo: < 0.01 (×12), 0.024, 0.027, 0.034, 0.039, 0.042, 0.09 RA: < 0.01 (×3), 0.012, 0.015, 0.017, 0.022, 0.024, 0.025, 0.054 |
Residue trials on oilseed rape compliant with GAP. Extrapolation to mustard seeds, gold of pleasure seeds, linseeds, sesame seeds, hemp seeds and borage seeds possible. | 0.10 |
Mo: 0.090 RA: 0.054 |
Mo: 0.010 RA: 0.016 |
1.7 |
| Oilseed Rape | SEU |
Mo: < 0.01 (×2), 0.01, 0.011, 0.012, 0.015, 0.017, 0.027, 0.039, 0.043, 0.044, 0.051, 0.053, 0.053, 0.054, 0.067, 0.1, 0.169 RA: 0.02, 0.02, 0.026, 0.04, 0.069, 0.071, 0.088, 0.092, 0.093, 0.15 |
Residue trials on oilseed rape compliant with GAP. Extrapolation to mustard seeds, gold of pleasure seeds, linseeds, sesame seeds, hemp seeds and borage seeds possible. | 0.20 |
Mo: 0.169 RA: 0.150 |
Mo: 0.041 RA: 0.070 |
1.7 |
Abbreviations: GAP, Good Agricultural Practice; Mo, monitoring; MRL, maximum residue level; RA, risk assessment.
NEU: Outdoor trials conducted in northern Europe, SEU: Outdoor trials conducted in southern Europe.
Highest residue. The highest residue for risk assessment refers to the whole commodity and not to the edible portion.
Supervised trials median residue. The median residue for risk assessment refers to the whole commodity and not to the edible portion.
Conversion factor to recalculate residues according to the residue definition for monitoring to the residue definition for risk assessment.
B.2.2.2. Residues in rotational crops

B.2.2.3. Processing factors
No processing studies were submitted in the framework of the present MRL application.
B.3. RESIDUES IN LIVESTOCK
Dietary burden calculation according to OECD (2013).
| Relevant groups (subgroups) | Dietary burden expressed in | Most critical subgroup a | Most critical commodity b | Trigger exceeded (Y/N) | Previous assessment (EFSA, 2012) | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| mg/kg bw per day | mg/kg DM | mg/kg DM | ||||||
| Median | Maximum | Median | Maximum | Maximum | ||||
| Cattle (all) | 0.007 | 0.007 | 0.17 | 0.17 | Dairy cattle | Beet, sugar | Y | 0.007 |
| Cattle (dairy only) | 0.007 | 0.007 | 0.17 | 0.17 | Dairy cattle | Beet, sugar | Y | 0.007 |
| Sheep (all) | 0.008 | 0.008 | 0.18 | 0.18 | Lamb | Beet, sugar | Y | 0.008 |
| Sheep (ewe only) | 0.001 | 0.006 | 0.03 | 0.18 | Ram/Ewe | Beet, sugar | Y | 0.006 |
| Swine (all) | 0.003 | 0.003 | 0.09 | 0.09 | Swine (finishing) | Beet, sugar | N | 0.003 |
| Poultry (all) | 0.001 | 0.001 | 0.02 | 0.02 | Turkey | Rapeseed meal | N | 0.001 |
| Poultry (layer only) | 0.001 | 0.001 | 0.01 | 0.01 | Poultry layer | Rapeseed meal | N | 0.001 |
| Fish (common carp) | – | – | – | 0.046 | Oilseeds and oilfruits | Vegetable Oil | N | – |
| Fish (rainbow trout) | – | – | – | 0.037 | Oilseeds and oilfruits | Vegetable Oil | N | – |
| Fish (Atlantic salmon) | – | – | – | 0.023 | Oilseeds and oilfruits | Vegetable Oil | N | – |
Abbreviations: bw, body weight; DM, dry matter; n.a., not applicable.
When one group of livestock includes several subgroups (e.g. poultry ‘all’ including broiler, layer and turkey), the result of the most critical subgroup is identified from the maximum dietary burdens expressed as ‘mg/kg bw per day’.
The most critical commodity is the major contributor identified from the maximum dietary burden expressed as ‘mg/kg bw per day’.
B.3.1. Metabolism studies, methods of analysis and residue definitions in livestock

B.3.2. Stability of residues in livestock
| Animal products (available studies) | Animal | Commodity | T (°C) | Stability period | Compounds covered | Comment/source | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Value | Unit | ||||||
| Ruminant | Muscle | −18 | 6 | Months | Propyzamide | EFSA (2016) | |
| Liver | −18 | 6 | Months | ||||
| Kidney | −18 | 6 | Months | ||||
| Fat | −18 | 6 | Months | ||||
| Milk | −20 | 36 | Months | ||||
| Eggs | −18 | 6 | Months | ||||
| Poultry | Eggs | −18 | 6 | Months | Propyzamide | EFSA (2016) | |
B.3.3. Magnitude of residues in livestock
Not needed. The calculated dietary burden did not change significantly compared to the assessment of the MRL review. Consequently, a modification of the existing MRLs in products of animal origin (all set at the LOQ) is not necessary and the conclusion of the MRL review remains valid (EFSA, 2012).
B.4. RESIDUES IN HONEY
B.4.1. Nature of residues and analytical methods for enforcement purposes in honey
B.4.1.1. Metabolism studies, analytical methods and residue definitions in honey

B.4.1.2. Storage stability of residues in honey
Not provided as the proposed MRL for honey is based on the residue levels detected in flowers of oilseed rape, for which storage stability is considered demonstrated for both parent propyzamide as well as all metabolites (and their conjugates) bearing the 3,5‐DCBA moiety (see Section 2.1.5).
B.4.2. Magnitude of residues in honey
B.4.2.1. Summary of residues data from the supervised residue trials
| Commodity | Region a | Residue levels observed in the supervised residue trials (mg/kg) | Comments/source | Calculated MRL (mg/kg) | HR b (mg/kg) | STMR c (mg/kg) | CF d |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oilseed Rape – aerial part (flowers) | NEU |
Mo: < 0.01 (×6), 0.035, 0.038 RA: < 0.01 (×3), 0.015, 0.056, 0.059 |
Residue trials on oilseed rape compliant with GAP and analysed for aerial part (flowers). | 0.04 (based on HR RD‐Mo) |
Mo: 0.038 RA: 0.059 |
Mo: 0.01 RA: 0.012 |
1.6 |
| Oilseed Rape – aerial part (flowers) | SEU |
Mo: < 0.01, 0.021, 0.025, 0.026, 0.031, 0.055 RA: 0.038, 0.041, 0.054, 0.058 |
Residue trials on oilseed rape compliant with GAP and analysed for aerial part (flowers). | 0.06 (based on HR RD‐Mo) |
Mo: 0.055 RA: 0.058 |
Mo: 0.026 RA: 0.048 |
1.7 |
| Oilseed Rape – aerial part (flowers) | Combined NEU and SEU |
Mo: < 0.01 (×7); 0.021; 0.025; 0.026; 0.031; 0.035; 0.038; 0.055 RA: < 0.01 (3×); 0.015; 0.038; 0.041; 0.054; 0.056; 0.058; 0.059 |
Residue trials on oilseed rape compliant with GAP and analysed for aerial part (flowers). |
0.06 (based on HR RD‐Mo) |
Mo: 0.055 RA: 0.059 |
Mo: 0.015 RA: 0.040 |
1.6 |
Abbreviations: GAP, Good Agricultural Practice; Mo, monitoring; MRL, maximum residue level; n.r., not relevant; RA, risk assessment.
Indicates that the MRL is proposed at the limit of quantification.
NEU: Outdoor trials conducted in northern Europe, SEU: Outdoor trials conducted in southern Europe.
Highest residue. The highest residue for risk assessment refers to the whole commodity and not to the edible portion.
Supervised trials median residue. The median residue for risk assessment refers to the whole commodity and not to the edible portion.
Conversion factor to recalculate residues according to the residue definition for monitoring to the residue definition for risk assessment.
B.5. CONSUMER RISK ASSESSMENT

B.6. RECOMMENDED MRLS
| Code a | Commodity | Existing EU MRL (mg/kg) | Proposed EU MRL (mg/kg) | Comment/justification |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Enforcement residue definition: propyzamide F | ||||
| 0401010 | Linseeds | 0.01* | 0.2 | The submitted residue trials on rapeseeds are sufficient to derive an MRL proposal and support the residue data extrapolation to mustard seeds, gold of pleasure seeds, linseeds, sesame seeds, hemp seeds and borage seeds. The MRL proposal reflects the more critical residue situation of the SEU use. Risk for consumers unlikely. |
| 0401040 | Sesame seeds | 0.01* | 0.2 | |
| 0401060 | Rapeseeds/canola seeds | 0.01* | 0.2 | |
| 0401080 | Mustard seeds | 0.01* | 0.2 | |
| 0401120 | Borage seeds | 0.01* | 0.2 | |
| 0401130 | Gold of pleasure seeds | 0.01* | 0.2 | |
| 0401140 | Hemp seeds | 0.01* | 0.2 | |
| 1040000 | Honey and other apiculture products b | 0.05* | 0.06 | The MRL proposal is based on residues in aerial parts (flowers) analysed in rapeseeds residue studies. Risk for consumers unlikely. |
Abbreviations: MRL, maximum residue level; SEU, southern Europe.
Indicates that the MRL is set at the limit of analytical quantification (LOQ).
Commodity code number according to Annex I of Regulation (EC) No 396/2005.
According to Regulation (EC) No 396/2005, MRLs are not applicable to other apiculture products until individual products have been identified and listed within this group.
Fat soluble.
APPENDIX C. Pesticide Residue Intake Model (PRIMo)


APPENDIX D. Input values for the exposure calculations
D.1. LIVESTOCK DIETARY BURDEN CALCULATIONS
| Feed commodity | Median dietary burden | Maximum dietary burden | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Input value a (mg/kg) | Comment | Input value a (mg/kg) | Comment | |
| Risk assessment residue definition: Sum of propyzamide and all metabolites (and their conjugates) bearing the 3,5‐dichlorobenzioc acid (DCBA) moiety, expressed as propyzamide | ||||
| Apple pomace | 0.05 | STMR × default PF (5) (EFSA, 2012) b | 0.05 | STMR × default PF (5) (EFSA, 2012) b |
| Peas (dry) | 0.01 | STMR (EFSA, 2012) | 0.01 | STMR (EFSA, 2012) |
| Beans(dry) | 0.01 | STMR (EFSA, 2012) | 0.01 | STMR (EFSA, 2012) |
| Sugar beet, dried pulp | 0.36 | STMR × default PF (EFSA, 2012) b | 0.36 | STMR × default PF (EFSA, 2012) b |
| Sugar beet, ensiled pulp | 0.06 | STMR × default PF (EFSA, 2012) b | 0.06 | STMR × default PF (EFSA, 2012) b |
| Sugar beet, molasses | 0.56 | STMR × default PF (EFSA, 2012) b | 0.56 | STMR × default PF (EFSA, 2012) b |
| Rape seed | 0.07 | STMR × PF (1) (proposed) c | 0.07 | STMR × PF (1) (proposed) c |
| Rape seed meal | 0.07 | STMR × PF (1) (proposed) c | 0.07 | STMR × PF (1) (proposed) c |
| Flaxseed/Linseed | 0.07 | STMR × PF (1) (proposed) c | 0.07 | STMR × PF (1) (proposed) c |
| Sunflower seed meal | 0.01 | STMR (EFSA, 2012) | 0.01 | STMR (EFSA, 2012) |
| Soya bean seed | 0.01 | STMR (EFSA, 2012) | 0.01 | STMR (EFSA, 2012) |
| Soya bean meal | 0.01 | STMR × PF (1) (EFSA, 2012) c | 0.01 | STMR × PF (1) (EFSA, 2012) c |
| Soya bean hulls | 0.01 | STMR × PF (1) (EFSA, 2012) c | 0.01 | STMR × PF (1) (EFSA, 2012) c |
| Alfalfa | 0.01 | STMR (EFSA, 2012) | 0.01 | HR (EFSA, 2012) |
| Alfalfa hay | 0.03 | STMR × default PF (2.5) (EFSA, 2012) b | 0.03 | HR × default PF (2.5) (EFSA, 2012) b |
| Alfalfa meal | 0.03 | STMR × default PF (2.5) (EFSA, 2012) b | 0.03 | HR × default PF (2.5) (EFSA, 2012) b |
| Alfalfa silage | 0.01 | STMR × default PF (1.1) (EFSA, 2012) b | 0.01 | STMR × default PF (1.1) (EFSA, 2012) b |
Abbreviations: HR, highest residue; PF, processing factor; STMR, supervised trials median residue.
Figures in the table are rounded to two digits, but the calculations are normally performed with the actually calculated values (which may contain more digits). To reproduce dietary burden calculations, the unrounded values need to be used.
In the absence of processing factors supported by data, default processing factors (in bracket) were, respectively, included in the calculation to consider the potential concentration of residues in these commodities.
Concentration of residues in these commodities is not expected considering that propyzamide is fat‐soluble and therefore expected to migrate to the oil fraction. Default processing factors have therefore not been included in the calculation in line with proposals of the MRL review.
D.2. DIETARY BURDEN CALCULATION FOR FISH
| Feed commodity | Dietary burden | |
|---|---|---|
| Input value (mg/kg) | Comment | |
| Risk assessment residue definition: Sum of propyzamide and all metabolites (and their conjugates) bearing the 3,5‐dichlorobenzioc acid (DCBA) moiety, expressed as propyzamide (EFSA, 2016) | ||
| Canola/rapeseed, meal, pre‐press solvent extracted | 0.07 | STMR (proposed) × PF (1) a |
| Linseed, meal, mechanically or solvent extracted | 0.07 | STMR (proposed) × PF (1) a |
| Mustard seed, meal, solvent extracted | 0.07 | STMR (proposed) × PF (1) a |
| Sesame seed, meal | 0.07 | STMR (proposed) × PF (1) a |
| Soya bean, seed, heat processed | 0.01 | STMR (EFSA, 2012) × PF (1) a |
| Soya bean, meal, mechanically or solvent extracted | 0.01 | STMR (EFSA, 2012) × PF (1) a |
| Soya bean, without hulls, meal, solvent extracted | 0.01 | STMR (EFSA, 2012) × PF (1) a |
| Soya bean, protein concentrate | 0.01 | STMR (EFSA, 2012) × PF (1) a |
| Sunflower seed, without hulls, meal, mechanically or solvent extracted | 0.01 | STMR (EFSA, 2012) × PF (1) a |
| Sunflower seed, meal, mechanically or solvent extracted | 0.01 | STMR (EFSA, 2012) × PF (1) a |
| Oilseeds and oil fruits (vegetable oil) | 0.07 | STMR (proposed) × PF (1) a |
Abbreviations: PF, processing factor; STMR, supervised trials median residue.
Concentration of residues in these commodities is not expected considering that propyzamide is fat soluble and therefore expected to migrate to the oil fraction. Default processing factors have therefore not been included in the calculation.
D.3. CONSUMER RISK ASSESSMENT
| Commodity | Existing/proposed MRL (mg/kg) | Source | Chronic risk assessment | Acute risk assessment | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Input value a (mg/kg) | Comment | Input value a (mg/kg) | Comment b | |||
| Risk assessment residue definition: sum of propyzamide and all metabolites (and their conjugates) bearing the 3,5‐dichlorobenzioc acid (DCBA) moiety, expressed as propyzamide | ||||||
| Almonds | 0.02 | EFSA (2012) | 0.01 | STMR‐RAC | 0.015 | HR‐RAC |
| Chestnuts | 0.02 | EFSA (2012) | 0.01 | STMR‐RAC | 0.015 | HR‐RAC |
| Hazelnuts/cobnuts | 0.02 | EFSA (2012) | 0.01 | STMR‐RAC | 0.015 | HR‐RAC |
| Walnuts | 0.02 | EFSA (2012) | 0.01 | STMR‐RAC | 0.015 | HR‐RAC |
| Apples | 0.02 | EFSA (2012) | 0.01 | STMR‐RAC | 0.015 | HR‐RAC |
| Pears | 0.02 | EFSA (2012) | 0.01 | STMR‐RAC | 0.015 | HR‐RAC |
| Quinces | 0.02 | EFSA (2012) | 0.01 | STMR‐RAC | 0.015 | HR‐RAC |
| Medlar | 0.02 | EFSA (2012) | 0.01 | STMR‐RAC | 0.015 | HR‐RAC |
| Loquats/Japanese medlars | 0.02 | EFSA (2012) | 0.01 | STMR‐RAC | 0.015 | HR‐RAC |
| Other pome fruit | 0.02 | EFSA (2012) | 0.01 | STMR‐RAC | ||
| Apricots | 0.02 | EFSA (2012) | 0.01 | STMR‐RAC | 0.015 | HR‐RAC |
| Cherries (sweet) | 0.02 | EFSA (2012) | 0.01 | STMR‐RAC | 0.015 | HR‐RAC |
| Peaches | 0.02 | EFSA (2012) | 0.01 | STMR‐RAC | 0.015 | HR‐RAC |
| Plums | 0.02 | EFSA (2012) | 0.01 | STMR‐RAC | 0.015 | HR‐RAC |
| Other stone fruit | 0.02 | EFSA (2012) | 0.01 | STMR‐RAC | ||
| Courgettes | 0.02 | EFSA (2012) | 0.02 | STMR‐RAC | 0.02 | HR‐RAC |
| Pumpkins | 0.02 | EFSA (2012) | 0.02 | STMR‐RAC | 0.02 | HR‐RAC |
| Broccoli | 0.02 | EFSA (2012) | 0.01 | STMR‐RAC | 0.02 | HR‐RAC |
| Cauliflowers | 0.02 | EFSA (2012) | 0.01 | STMR‐RAC | 0.02 | HR‐RAC |
| Other flowering brassica | 0.02 | EFSA (2012) | 0.01 | STMR‐RAC | ||
| Lamb's lettuce/corn salads | 0.6 | EFSA (2012) | 0.112 | STMR‐RAC | 0.42 | HR‐RAC |
| Lettuces | 0.6 | EFSA (2012) | 0.112 | STMR‐RAC | 0.42 | HR‐RAC |
| Escaroles/broad‐leaved endives | 0.6 | EFSA (2012) | 0.112 | STMR‐RAC | 0.42 | HR‐RAC |
| Cress and other sprouts and shoots | 0.2 | EFSA (2012) | 0.01 | STMR‐RAC | 0.15 | HR‐RAC |
| Roman rocket/rucola | 0.2 | EFSA (2012) | 0.01 | STMR‐RAC | 0.15 | HR‐RAC |
| Baby leaf crops (including brassica species) | 0.2 | EFSA (2012) | 0.01 | STMR‐RAC | 0.15 | HR‐RAC |
| Chervil | 0.2 | EFSA (2012) | 0.01 | STMR‐RAC | 0.15 | HR‐RAC |
| Chives | 0.2 | EFSA (2012) | 0.01 | STMR‐RAC | 0.15 | HR‐RAC |
| Celery leaves | 0.2 | EFSA (2012) | 0.01 | STMR‐RAC | 0.15 | HR‐RAC |
| Parsley | 0.2 | EFSA (2012) | 0.01 | STMR‐RAC | 0.15 | HR‐RAC |
| Sage | 0.2 | EFSA (2012) | 0.01 | STMR‐RAC | 0.15 | HR‐RAC |
| Rosemary | 0.2 | EFSA (2012) | 0.01 | STMR‐RAC | 0.15 | HR‐RAC |
| Thyme | 0.2 | EFSA (2012) | 0.01 | STMR‐RAC | 0.15 | HR‐RAC |
| Basil and edible flowers | 0.2 | EFSA (2012) | 0.01 | STMR‐RAC | 0.15 | HR‐RAC |
| Laurel/bay leaves | 0.2 | EFSA (2012) | 0.01 | STMR‐RAC | 0.15 | HR‐RAC |
| Tarragon | 0.2 | EFSA (2012) | 0.01 | STMR‐RAC | 0.15 | HR‐RAC |
| Other herbs | 0.2 | EFSA (2012) | 0.01 | STMR‐RAC | ||
| Cardoons | 0.02 | EFSA (2012) | 0.02 | STMR‐RAC | 0.02 | HR‐RAC |
| Globe artichokes | 0.02 | EFSA (2012) | 0.02 | STMR‐RAC |
0.02 |
HR‐RAC |
| Linseeds | 0.2 | Proposed MRL | 0.07 | STMR‐RAC | 0.07 | STMR‐RAC |
| Sesame seeds | 0.2 | Proposed MRL | 0.07 | STMR‐RAC | 0.07 | STMR‐RAC |
| Rapeseeds/canola seeds | 0.2 | Proposed MRL | 0.07 | STMR‐RAC | 0.07 | STMR‐RAC |
| Mustard seeds | 0.2 | Proposed MRL | 0.07 | STMR‐RAC | 0.07 | STMR‐RAC |
| Borage seeds | 0.2 | Proposed MRL | 0.07 | STMR‐RAC | 0.07 | STMR‐RAC |
| Gold of pleasure seeds | 0.2 | Proposed MRL | 0.07 | STMR‐RAC | 0.07 | STMR‐RAC |
| Hemp seeds | 0.2 | Proposed MRL | 0.07 | STMR‐RAC | 0.07 | STMR‐RAC |
| Chamomille | 0.4 | EFSA (2013) | 0.066 | STMR‐RAC | 0.22 | HR‐RAC |
| Hibiscus/roselle | 0.4 | EFSA (2013) | 0.066 | STMR‐RAC | 0.22 | HR‐RAC |
| Rose | 0.4 | EFSA (2013) | 0.066 | STMR‐RAC | 0.22 | HR‐RAC |
| Jasmine | 0.4 | EFSA (2013) | 0.066 | STMR‐RAC | 0.22 | HR‐RAC |
| Lime/linden | 0.4 | EFSA (2013) | 0.066 | STMR‐RAC | 0.22 | HR‐RAC |
| Other herbal infusions (dried flowers) | 0.4 | EFSA (2013) | 0.066 | STMR‐RAC | ||
| Strawberry leaves | 0.4 | EFSA (2013) | 0.066 | STMR‐RAC | 0.22 | HR‐RAC |
| Rooibos | 0.4 | EFSA (2013) | 0.066 | STMR‐RAC | 0.22 | HR‐RAC |
| Mate/maté | 0.4 | EFSA (2013) | 0.066 | STMR‐RAC | 0.22 | HR‐RAC |
| Other herbal infusions (dried leaves) | 0.4 | EFSA (2013) | 0.066 | STMR‐RAC | ||
| Horseradish, root spices | 0.07 | 0.02 | STMR‐RAC | 0.05 | HR‐RAC | |
| Sugar beet roots | 0.08 | EFSA (2012) | 0.02 | STMR‐RAC | 0.05 | HR‐RAC |
| Honey and other apiculture products | 0.06 | Proposed MRL | 0.04 | STMR‐RAC | 0.06 | HR‐RAC |
Abbreviations: HR‐RAC, highest residue in raw agricultural commodity; PeF, Peeling factor; STMR‐RAC, supervised trials median residue in raw agricultural commodity.
Figures in the table are rounded to two digits, but the calculations are normally performed with the actually calculated values (which may contain more digits). To reproduce dietary burden calculations, the unrounded values need to be used.
Input values for the commodities which are not under consideration for the acute risk assessment are reported in grey.
Consumption figures in the EFSA PRIMo are expressed as meat. Since the a.s. is a fat‐soluble pesticides, STMR and HR residue values were calculated considering a 80%/90% muscle and 20%/10% fat content for mammal/poultry meat, respectively (FAO, 2016).
APPENDIX E. Used compound codes
| Code/trivial name a | IUPAC name/SMILES notation/InChiKey b | Structural formula c |
|---|---|---|
| Propyzamide |
3,5‐dichloro‐N‐(1,1‐dimethylprop‐2‐yn‐1‐yl)benzamide CC(C)(C#C)NC(=O)c1cc(Cl)cc(Cl)c1 PHNUZKMIPFFYSO‐UHFFFAOYSA‐N |
|
| RH‐24644 |
2‐(3,5‐dichlorophenyl)‐4,4‐dimethyl‐5‐methylidene‐4,5‐dihydro‐1,3‐oxazole CC1(C)N=C(OC1=C)c1cc(Cl)cc(Cl)c1 NUHZEWAYELBUEX‐UHFFFAOYSA‐N |
|
| RH‐24580 |
3,5‐dichloro‐N‐(2‐methyl‐3‐oxobutan‐2‐yl)benzamide CC(C)(NC(=O)c1cc(Cl)cc(Cl)c1)C(=O)C IOSJQUCGMMIFFY‐UHFFFAOYSA‐N |
|
| RH‐24848 |
3,5‐dichloro‐N‐(1‐hydroxy‐2‐methylpropan‐2‐yl)benzamide CC(C)(CO)NC(=O)c1cc(Cl)cc(Cl)c1 BFLGNYKVVYMFPC‐UHFFFAOYSA‐N |
|
| RH‐26521 |
3,5‐dichloro‐N‐[(3RS)‐3,4‐dihydroxy‐2‐methylbutan‐2‐yl]benzamide CC(C)(NC(=O)c1cc(Cl)cc(Cl)c1)C(O)CO OISMUZCBMAAETM‐UHFFFAOYSA‐N |
|
| RH‐26059 |
3‐(3,5‐dichlorobenzamido)‐3‐methylbutanoic acid CC(C)(CC(=O)O)NC(=O)c1cc(Cl)cc(Cl)c1 FFQDAJZDTYHVLR‐UHFFFAOYSA‐N |
|
| RH‐25337 |
3,5‐dichloro‐N‐[(3RS)‐3‐hydroxy‐2‐methylbutan‐2‐yl]benzamide CC(C)(NC(=O)c1cc(Cl)cc(Cl)c1)C(O)C JTUJLOMJJBGYLL‐UHFFFAOYSA‐N |
|
| RH‐26702 |
3,5‐dichloro‐N‐(4‐hydroxy‐2‐methyl‐3‐oxobutan‐2‐yl)benzamide CC(C)(NC(=O)c1cc(Cl)cc(Cl)c1)C(=O)CO UEYPXEPKBVGNOH‐UHFFFAOYSA‐N |
|
Abbreviations: InChiKey, International Chemical Identifier Key; IUPAC, International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry; SMILES, simplified molecular‐input line‐entry system.
The metabolite name in bold is the name used in the conclusion.
ACD/Name 2025.2.5 ACD/Labs 2025.2.5 (File Version N25E41, Build 147950, 3 February 2026).
ACD/ChemSketch 2025.2.5 ACD/Labs 2025.2.5 (File Version C65H41, Build 147869, 26 January 2026).
EFSA (European Food Safety Authority) , Leite, S. B. , Bellisai, G. , Bernasconi, G. , Binaglia, M. , Castellan, I. , Castoldi, A. F. , Chiusolo, A. , Colas, M. , Crivellente, F. , Del Aguila, M. , Ferreira, L. , Istace, F. , Lanzoni, A. , Leuschner, R. , Louisse, J. , Mangas, I. , Mazzega, S. , Mioč, A. , Panzarea, M. , … Verani, A. (2026). Modification of the existing maximum residue levels for propyzamide in oilseeds and honey. EFSA Journal, 24(10), e10324. 10.2903/j.efsa.2026.10324
Approved: 3 September 2026
Correspondence: Ask a Question
The declarations of interest of all scientific experts active in EFSA's work are available at https://open.efsa.europa.eu/experts.
Notes
Regulation (EC) No 1107/2009 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 21 October 2009 concerning the placing of plant protection products on the market and repealing Council Directives 79/117/EEC and 91/414/EEC. OJ L 309, 24.11.2009, p. 1–50.
Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2018/755 of 23 May 2018 renewing the approval of the active substance propyzamide, as a candidate for substitution, in accordance with Regulation (EC) No 1107/2009 of the European Parliament and of the Council concerning the placing of plant protection products on the market, and amending the Annex to Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) No 540/2011.C/2018/2636. OJ L 128, 24.5.2018, pp. 4–8.
Regulation (EC) No 396/2005 of the Parliament and of the Council of 23 February 2005 on maximum residue levels of pesticides in or on food and feed of plant and animal origin and amending Council Directive 91/414/EEC. OJ L 70, 16.03.2005, p. 1–16.
For an overview of all MRL Regulations on this active substance, please consult: https://ec.europa.eu/food/plant/pesticides/eu‐pesticides‐database/start/screen/mrls.
Commission Regulation (EU) No 283/2013 of 1 March 2013 setting out the data requirements for active substances, in accordance with Regulation (EC) No 1107/2009 of the European Parliament and of the Council concerning the placing of plant protection products on the market. OJ L 93, 3.4.2013, p. 1–84.
Commission Regulation (EU) No 546/2011 of 10 June 2011 implementing Regulation (EC) No 1107/2009 of the European Parliament and of the Council as regards uniform principles for evaluation and authorisation of plant protection products. OJ L 155, 11.6.2011, p. 127–175.
Background documents to this reasoned opinion are published on OpenEFSA portal and are available at the following link: https://open.efsa.europa.eu/study‐inventory/EFSA‐Q‐2023‐00328.
Available here: https://www.ime.fraunhofer.de/en/Research_Divisions/Division_AE/Software_E/DBC.html.
Commission Regulation (EU) 2018/62 of 17 January 2018 replacing Annex I to Regulation (EC) No 396/2005 of the European Parliament and of the Council. C/2018/0138. OJ L 18, 23.1.2018, p. 1–73.
Commission Regulation (EU) 2018/62 of 17 January 2018 replacing Annex I to Regulation (EC) No 396/2005 of the European Parliament and of the Council. C/2018/0138. OJ L 18, 23.1.2018, p. 1–73.
Storage stability studies were provided only for the parent compound propyzamide. Specific studies on the storage stability of the metabolites (and their conjugates) bearing the 3,5‐DCBA moiety are not considered necessary since the residue definition for risk assessment includes propyzamide and its metabolites containing the 3,5‐DCBA moiety, with individual metabolites not being specified, and the analytical method for risk assessment analyses for the sum of the 3,5‐dichlorobenzoic acid moiety, not individual metabolites (see Section 2.1.5, Sweden, 2018).
REFERENCES
- EFSA (European Food Safety Authority) . (2012). Reasoned opinion on the review of the existing maximum residue levels (MRLs) for propyzamide according to article 12 of regulation (EC) No 396/2005 prepared by EFSA pesticide risk assessment peer review (PRAPeR) unit. EFSA Journal, 10(4), 2690. 10.2903/j.efsa.2012.2690 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- EFSA (European Food Safety Authority) . (2013). Reasoned opinion on the modification of the existing MRLs for propyzamide in leaves, flowers and roots of herbal infusions. EFSA Journal, 11(9), 3378. 10.2903/j.efsa.2013.3378 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- EFSA (European Food Safety Authority) . (2016). Conclusion on the peer review of the pesticide risk assessment of the active substance propyzamide. EFSA Journal, 14(8), 4554. 10.2903/j.efsa.2016.4554 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- EFSA (European Food Safety Authority) , Brancato, A. , Brocca, D. , Ferreira, L. , Greco, L. , Jarrah, S. , Leuschner, R. , Medina, P. , Miron, I. , Nougadere, A. , Pedersen, R. , Reich, H. , Santos, M. , Stanek, A. , Tarazona, J. , Theobald, A. , & Villamar‐Bouza, L. (2018). Guidance on use of EFSA pesticide residue intake model (EFSA PRIMo revision 3). EFSA Journal, 16(1), 5147. 10.2903/j.efsa.2018.5147 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- EFSA (European Food Safety Authority) , Anastassiadou, M. , Brancato, A. , Carrasco Cabrera, L. , Ferreira, L. , Greco, L. , Jarrah, S. , Kazocina, A. , Leuschner, R. , Magrans, J. O. , Miron, I. , Pedersen, R. , Raczyk, M. , Reich, H. , Ruocco, S. , Sacchi, A. , Santos, M. , Stanek, A. , Tarazona, J. , … Verani, A. (2019). Pesticide residue intake model‐ EFSA PRIMo revision 3.1 (update of EFSA PRIMo revision 3). EFSA Supporting Publications, EN‐1605. 10.2903/sp.efsa.2019.EN-1605 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- EFSA (European Food Safety Authority) , Borroto, J. , Castoldi, A. F. , Chiusolo, A. , Colagiorgi, A. , Colas, M. , Crivellente, F. , De Lentdecker, C. , Istace, F. , Jarrah, S. , Kardassi, D. , Magrans, O. , Mangas, I. , Miron, I. , Molnar, T. , Parra Morte, J. M. , Terron, A. , Tiramani, M. , & Vagenende, B. (2022). Conclusion on the peer review of the pesticide risk assessment for the active substance propyzamide in light of confirmatory data submitted. EFSA Journal, 20(2), 7034. 10.2903/j.efsa.2022.7034 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- EFSA (European Food Safety Authority) . (2020). Outcome of the consultation with member states, the applicant and EFSA on the pesticide risk assessment for propyzamide in light of confirmatory data. EFSA Supporting Publications, 17(10), EN‐1935. 10.2903/sp.efsa.2020.EN-1935 [DOI] [Google Scholar]
- EFSA (European Food Safety Authority) . (2024). Advice of the cross‐cutting working group Genotoxicity on the genotoxicity assessment of propyzamide metabolites. June 2024. Available online: www.efsa.europa.eu
- EFSA (European Food Safety Authority) . (2025a). Advice of the cross‐cutting working group Genotoxicity on the genotoxicity assessment of propyzamide metabolites held on 06 October 2025. Available online: www.efsa.europa.eu
- EFSA (European Food Safety Authority) . (2025b). Pesticides peer review meeting report on the active substance propyzamide held on 25‐28 November 2025. Peer Review Meeting on Mammalian Toxicology TC, 190, 15. Available online: www.efsa.europa.eu [Google Scholar]
- EFSA (European Food Safety Authority) . (2026). Pesticides peer review meeting report on the active substance propyzamide held on 22–25 June 2026. Peer Review Meeting on Mammalian Toxicology TC, 213, 9. Available online: www.efsa.europa.eu [Google Scholar]
- European Commission . (2010). Classes to be used for the setting of EU pesticide Maximum Residue Levels (MRLs). SANCO 10634/2010‐rev. 0, Finalised in the Standing Committee on the Food Chain and Animal Health at its meeting of 23–24 March 2010.
- European Commission . (2017). Appendix D. Guidelines on comparability, extrapolation, group tolerances and data requirements for setting MRLs. 7525/VI/95‐rev. 10.3, 13 June 2017.
- European Commission . (2018a). Final Renewal report for the active substance PROPYZAMIDE finalised in the Standing Committee on Plants, Animals, Food and Feed at its meeting on 22 March 2018 in view of the renewal of the approval of PROPYZAMIDE as active substance in accordance with Regulation (EC) No 1107/2009. SANTE/11797/2016 rev.4 .12 February 2018.
- European Commission . (2018b). Technical guidelines for determining the magnitude of pesticide residues in honey and setting Maximum Residue Levels in honey. SANTE/2016/11956, Rev. 9, 14 September 2018.
- European Commission . (2022). Final Renewal report for the active substance PROPYZAMIDE finalised in the Standing Committee on Plants, Animals, Food and Feed at its meeting on 22 March 2018 in view of the renewal of the approval of PROPYZAMIDE as active substance in accordance with Regulation (EC) No 1107/2009 and updated by the Standing Committee on Plants, Animals, Food and Feed on 14 October 2022. SANTE/11797/2016 rev.5. 12 February 2018. 14 October 2022.
- European Commission . (2023a). Guidance Document on Pesticide Analytical Methods for Risk Assessment and Post‐approval Control and Monitoring Purposes. SANTE/2020/12830, Rev. 2, 14 February 2023.
- European Commission . (2023b). Technical guidelines on data requirements for setting maximum residue levels, comparability of residue trials and extrapolation on residue data on products from plant and animal origin. SANTE/2019/12752, 10 May 2023.
- FAO (Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations) . (2016). Submission and evaluation of pesticide residues data for the estimation of maximum residue levels in food and feed. Pesticide residues. 3rd Edition. FAO Plant Production and Protection Paper 225, 298 pp.
- OECD (Organisation for Economic Co‐operation and Development) . (2013). Guidance document on residues in livestock. In: Series on Pesticides No 73. ENV/JM/MONO(2013)8, 04 September 2013.
- Sweden . (1998). Draft assessment report on the active substance propyzamide prepared by the rapporteur Member State Sweden in the framework of Council Directive 91/414/EEC, May 1998.
- Sweden . (2003). Addendum to the draft assessment report on the active substance propyzamide prepared by the rapporteur Member State Sweden in the framework of Council Directive91/414/EEC, February 2003.
- Sweden . (2015). Renewal assessment report (RAR) on the active substance propyzamide prepared by the rapporteur Member State Sweden in the framework of Regulation (EC) No 844/2012, July 2015. Available online: www.efsa.europa.eu
- Sweden . (2016). Revised renewal assessment report (RAR) on propyzamide prepared by the rapporteur Member State Sweden in the framework of Regulation (EC) No 844/2012, April 2016. Available online: www.efsa.europa
- Sweden . (2018). Evaluation report on the modification of MRLs for propyzamide in oilseeds and honey. January 2018, revised in March 2026, 203 pp. Available online: www.efsa.europa.eu
