In the late 1970s, emergency departments of urban hospitals were staffed by physicians without formal training in emergency medicine, which was not recognized as a distinct, specific discipline. Comprehensive emergency care was rare. Most university emergency departments did not provide round-the-clock coverage by an attending physician, and during the night shift unsupervised junior residents made all decisions related to patient care. Undergraduate education in emergency medicine did not exist, and a 1-year rotating internship was often sufficient in many jurisdictions to obtain a licence for general practice and to practise emergency medicine.
In June 1980, the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada (RCPSC) recognized emergency medicine as a free-standing specialty requiring 4 years of residency training. (This was subsequently extended to 5 years.) Concurrently, the College of Family Physicians of Canada (CFPC) identified the need to upgrade emergency medicine education for family physicians (FPs) and created the administrative framework for a 1-year training program. As a result, emergency care in Canada today is provided by a heterogeneous group of clinicians. In urban centres, emergency departments are staffed by specialists who hold fellowships from the RCPSC (FRCPCs), FPs with certificates of special competence in emergency medicine from the CFPC (CCFP-EMs) and progressively fewer FPs and clinicians with a general licence.1 The situation is different in smaller regional and rural hospitals, where the latter 2 groups provide virtually all emergency care. This diversity of emergency care providers reflects the varied educational, economic and geographic realities of our vast country, and it is further complicated by an overall shortage of Canadian emergency physicians.2,3,4
Moorehead and colleagues5 have calculated that, in the United States, physicians certified or trained in emergency medicine fill 58% of full-time-equivalent positions in acute care hospitals, and FPs and internists account for most of the rest. Adapting their formula to a Canadian setting, we can calculate that physicians certified in emergency medicine in this country fill about 45% of full-time-equivalent positions and that FPs fill the rest. In the United States, 124 emergency medicine training programs produce 1136 graduates each year.6 In Canada, at present, there are 27 training programs: 11 for FRCPCs and 16 for CCFP-EMs, with 20 and 70 postgraduate entry positions, respectively.7,8 Even with 2 educational tracks, the proportion of residency positions that are in emergency medicine is 21% lower in Canada than in the United States.
In Canadian urban and regional settings, career emergency physicians are coming increasingly from these 2 educational tracks and provide comprehensive, round-the-clock patient care. This workforce comprises a large cohort of full- or half-time clinicians and a smaller group of physicians in academic tracks. However, the 2 educational tracks are distinctly different. The objective of the FRCPC program is to provide residents with in-depth knowledge of emergency medicine and to prepare them for academic careers involving teaching, research and administration. The mandatory curriculum includes a year of basic clinical training, a number of months in adult and pediatric emergency departments, and a broad base of training in surgical and medical specialties, critical care and anesthesia. Training in pre-hospital care, administration and epidemiology is common, and 1 year is devoted to subspecialization, research or medical education. In fact, many residency programs exceed the minimum requirements for emergency department training.
The CCFP-EM track aims to “provide family physicians with … enhanced skills in emergency medicine” and to prepare future CCFP-EM educators and administrators.9 The certification year is intense, with time divided evenly among adult and pediatric emergency medicine and related subspecialties. Time constraints preclude virtually all elective work. Since it would be impossible to provide residents with the in-depth and comprehensive knowledge required for an academic career during this year, the primary objective is clinical competence.
Graduates of these 2 educational streams work mainly in urban areas. FRCPCs typically practise at university centres or in other settings that can support a number of full-time emergency physicians. Because of marketplace demands, many graduating CCFP-EMs also end up practising full-time emergency medicine in urban centres.1 For FRCPCs and a number of CCFP-EMs, this is in keeping with their respective college-given mandate. As trainees continue to graduate, we may expect that urban patients will receive increasingly consistent and high-quality emergency care. As the quality of emergency care increases in our cities, it is important to pay particular attention to the challenge of providing emergency care in other settings.
To address this, over the last 10 years, the CFPC has implemented changes to the training of residents in the core family medicine programs and has made emergency medicine training mandatory. Currently, the challenge for those who provide education in acute care to rural FPs is to provide an adequate base of knowledge and skills for independent function. Training of family medicine residents needs to maximize educational opportunities in all settings by offering rotations in urban and regional emergency departments and in rural locations. New educational resources in emergency medicine for FP trainees should help this process, but more exposure under the supervision of qualified and experienced urban, regional or rural mentors is still needed.10
Future urban emergency practice should become the domain of physicians certified in this speciality, whether FRCPCs or CCFP-EMs. Emergency departments in larger centres are the entry points for patients who present with increasingly more acute or complex medical, psychological or social problems. It is appropriate that practitioners with the most intensive training should carry out patient care, clinical teaching and research in those settings. FRCPCs will be able to draw upon their preparation for academic work and didactic teaching and by virtue of their training in family medicine, CCCFP-EMs will be able to apply their humanistic skills to patient care and clinical teaching.11 FPs will continue to be responsible for providing much of the emergency care in our rural settings. Although training in emergency skills for FPs is, overall, too short, we may expect that the further development of educational resources for emergency medicine in core family medicine programs will enhance the quality of emergency care in nonurban settings.
β See related article page 1548
Footnotes
Competing interests: None declared.
Correspondence to: Dr. Ivan P. Steiner, Studies in Medical Organizations, Department of Family Medicine and Division of Emergency Medicine, University of Alberta, CSC Rm. 565, 10240 Kingsway Ave., CSC Rm. 565, Edmonton AB T5H 3V9; fax 780 477-4916; ivan.steiner@ualberta.ca
References
- 1.Chan BTB. Do family physicians with emergency medicine certification actually practise family medicine? CMAJ 2002;167(8):869-70. [PMC free article] [PubMed]
- 2.Lloyd S, Streiner D, Shannon S. Burnout, depression, life and job satisfaction among Canadian emergency physicians. J Emerg Med 1994;12(4):559-65. [DOI] [PubMed]
- 3.Beveridge R, Lloyd S. Manpower survey (III): emergency physician supply and demand. CAEP Communiqué 1996;Fall:7-9.
- 4.Steiner IP, Yoon PW, Goldsand G, Rowe BH. Resource contribution by Canadianfaculties of medicine to the discipline of emergency medicine. Can J Emerg Med 2001;3(1):13-8. [DOI] [PubMed]
- 5.Moorehead JC, Gallery ME, Hirshkorn C, Barnaby DP, Barsan WG, Conrad LC, et al. A study of the workforce in emergency medicine: 1999. Ann Emerg Med 2002;40(1):3-15. [DOI] [PubMed]
- 6.Hoffman GL, Bock BF, Gallagher EJ, Korte RC, Radke Mw, Reinhart MA. American Baord of Emergency Medicine task force on residency training information. Ann of Emerg Med 2002 ;39 (5): 510-27. [DOI] [PubMed]
- 7.Steiner IP, Yoon PW, Holroyd BR. Manpower crisis in emergency medicine: Can residency programs make an impact? Can J Emerg Med 2000;2(2):103-5. [DOI] [PubMed]
- 8.Association of Canadian Medical Colleges. Canadian Post-MD Education Registry (CAPER). National summary 2001-2002 post-MD trainees. Ottawa: The Association; 2002. Available: www.caper.ca/Pages/DTablesCY-NationalSummary.html (accessed 2003 Mar 25).
- 9.College of Family Physicians of Canada. Standards for Accreditation of Residency Training Programs. Toronto: The College; 2003. Available: www.cfpc.ca/education/education.asp (accessed 2003 May 15).
- 10.Steiner IP, Patton MA, editors. Educational reference manual. Core emergency medicine training in family medicine residency programs. Ottawa: Canadian Association of Emergency Physicians; 2002. Available: www.caep.ca/006.residents/006-docs/objectives.CoreFamilyMed-ResidencyPrograms.pdf (accessed 2003 Mar 25).
- 11.Steiner IP, Yoon PW, Kelly KD, Diner BM, Donoff MG, Mackey DS, et al. Resident evaluation of clinical teachers based on teachers' certification. Acad Emerg Med. In press. [DOI] [PubMed]