The Effects of Hypercapnia on Cerebral Autoregulation in Ventilated Very Low Birth Weight Infants

Abstract

Permissive hypercapnia, a strategy allowing high Paco₂, is widely used by neonatologists to minimize lung damage in ventilated very low birth weight (VLBW) infants. While hypercapnia increases cerebral blood flow (CBF), its effects on cerebral autoregulation of VLBW infants are unknown. Monitoring of mean CBF velocity (mCBFv), Paco₂, and mean arterial blood pressure (MABP) from 43 ventilated VLBW infants during the first week of life was performed during and after 117 tracheal suctioning procedures. Autoregulation status was determined during tracheal suctioning because it perturbs cerebral and systemic hemodynamics. The slope of the relationship between mCBFv and MABP was estimated when Paco₂ was fixed at 30, 35, 40, 45, 50, 55, and 60 mm Hg. A slope near or equal to 0 suggests intact autoregulation, i.e. CBF is not influenced by MABP. Increasing values >0 indicate progressively impaired autoregulation. Infants weighed 905 ± 259 g and were 26.9 ± 2.3 wk gestation. The autoregulatory slope increased as Paco₂ increased from 30 to 60 mm Hg. While the slopes for Paco₂ values of 30 to 40 mm Hg were not statistically different from 0, slopes for Paco₂ ≥45 mm Hg indicated a progressive loss of cerebral autoregulation. The autoregulatory slope increases with increasing Paco₂, suggesting the cerebral circulation becomes progressively pressure passive with hypercapnia. These data raise concerns regarding the use of permissive hypercapnia in ventilated VLBW infants during the first week of life, as impaired autoregulation during this period may be associated with increased vulnerability to brain injury.

Neonatologists frequently use permissive hypercapnia, a strategy that allows high Paco₂ (45–55 mm Hg), to avoid ventilator-induced lung injury during mechanical ventilation of premature infants (1). The theoretical benefit of permissive hypercapnia is that lower tidal volumes and mean airway pressures may prevent alveolar overdistension and lung injury (1). Randomized controlled trials of permissive hypercapnia, however, failed to demonstrate significant improvements in survival without chronic lung disease over routine ventilation strategies (1,2). Despite its widespread use, the effects of permissive hypercapnia on cerebral autoregulation of premature infants are not known.

Cerebral autoregulation is an essential physiologic mechanism that maintains constant blood flow to the brain despite variations in cerebral perfusion pressure (3). The BP range over which CBF remains constant is known as the autoregulatory plateau. In this portion of the curve, CBF is independent of BP and the slope is 0. Below the autoregulatory plateau, CBF declines; above it, CBF rises in a pressure-passive manner (Fig. 1 A) (4,5). In contrast, in impaired autoregulation, CBF linearly follows changes in BP (over all BPs), where the slope is significantly >0 (Fig. 1B) (6). Despite the widespread belief that cerebral autoregulation is impaired in sick, ventilated premature infants (6), recent evidence using continuous monitoring systems suggests that many premature infants do have intact autoregulation (7,8).

Figure 1.

(A) Example of intact cerebral autoregulation. Adapted from van de Bor and Walther (4) and Papile et al. (5). (B) Example of impaired cerebral autoregulation. Adapted from Lou et al. (6).

Hypercapnia causes cerebral vasodilation, increases CBF in premature infants, and may contribute to the development of IVH (9–12). Although the etiology of neonatal brain injury is multifactorial, disturbances of CBF and cerebral autoregulation play an important role (7,13,14). Hypercapnia in animals has been associated with impaired cerebral autoregulation (3,15). Conversely, impaired autoregulation associated with a variety of pathologic conditions in animals and adults can be restored by hyperventilation (Paco₂ 25–30 mm Hg) (16). Although the ideal Paco₂ range for premature infants is not known, we hypothesized that cerebral autoregulation would become progressively impaired with increasing Paco₂. Therefore, the objective of this study was to examine the effects of increasing Paco₂ on the cerebral autoregulatory capacity of ventilated premature infants during the first week of life.

METHODS

Study sample

VLBW (birth weight, 501–1500 g) infants born at the University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences between July 2002 and February 2004 were eligible for this observational study if they required mechanical ventilation for respiratory distress syndrome, had a 3.7 Fr umbilical arterial catheter placed during newborn stabilization, and had normal cranial ultrasound findings before the study. Infants with major congenital anomalies were excluded. Routine intensive care procedures were left to the discretion of the attending neonatologist.

Monitoring equipment

Continuous BP monitoring was performed with an umbilical arterial catheter (Diametrics Medical Ltd., St. Paul, MN; Argyle/Tyco Healthcare/Kendall, Mansfield, MA) attached to a BP transducer (Transpac IV, Abbott Critical Care Systems, North Chicago, IL). The transducer was connected to a cardiorespiratory monitor (Spacelabs, Redmond, WA) and calibrated.

Continuous blood gas monitoring was performed with a Neotrend-L (Diametrics Medical Ltd.) fiber optic sensor that was placed in the umbilical arterial catheter. The sensor was connected to a satellite Trendcare monitor (Diametrics Medical Ltd.) that continuously displayed pH, Paco₂, Pao₂, temperature, bicarbonate, base excess, and oxygen saturations in real-time.

Continuous measurements of right middle cerebral artery CBF velocity were made using a transcranial Doppler ultrasound system (Nicolet Biomedical Pioneer, Madison, WI). A lightweight 2-MHz pulsed-wave button transducer was placed transtemporally anterior to the external ear and above the zygomatic arch and held in place by an appropriately sized crocheted hat (courtesy of the Arkansas Extension Homemakers Council). A depth of 16–22 mm was used to study the M1 portion of the middle cerebral artery. A 100-Hz low-pass filter was used to dampen “noise” from the vessel wall. Reliable CBF velocity measurements were obtained when the highest intensity acoustic signal was perceived and the highest intensity Doppler spectra visualized. The ultrasound intensity (5–21 mW/cm²) was well below the recommendations for continuous monitoring (17). CBF velocity tracings were consistent >1 h with minimal or no drift in the signal intensity. The investigator or research assistant was present at the bedside during all monitoring periods.

Analog signals from the BP monitor (112 samples/s, 10 mV/1 mm Hg), blood gas monitor (1 sample/s; Paco₂: 25 mV/1 mm Hg; Pao₂: 4 mV/1 mm Hg), and transcranial Doppler (100 samples/s, 10 mV/1 cm/s) were collected simultaneously with a data acquisition system (PowerLab 8 channel, ADInstruments, Mountain View, CA). Cyclic wave form analysis was performed on the BP data to calculate the MABP (the average amplitude of the BP wave form over one cycle) and systolic and diastolic BP (maximum and minimum values of the BP cycle, respectively). Digital output from the blood gas monitor was converted to an analog signal by a digital-to-analog converter. Fast Fourier analysis was performed on the CBF velocity signal to determine the systolic, diastolic, and mCBFv.

Autoregulation testing using tracheal suctioning

Adult autoregulation testing procedures, such as altering BP pharmacologically or by rapid removal of a thigh cuff and assessing changes in CBF, are too invasive and may actually induce brain injury in premature infants. Therefore, we tested cerebral autoregulatory capacity by comparing simultaneous changes in CBF velocity with changes in MABP, during tracheal suctioning procedures. Tracheal suctioning was used as a provocative autoregulatory test since it is known to substantially affect BP, gas exchange, and cerebral hemodynamics in ventilated VLBW infants (18,19).

Experimental protocol

Informed consent was obtained from a parent before study participation. Blood pressure, Paco₂, Pao₂, and CBF velocity were continuously monitored from each VLBW infant before, during, and after clinically indicated tracheal suctioning procedures during the first week of life. Infants were monitored up to twice daily during the first 3 d and once daily during the next 4 d. Monitoring began approximately 15 min before tracheal suctioning, when infants were quiet and not undergoing any other procedures, and continued for 45 min postprocedure. The University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences Institutional Review Board approved the study protocol.

Suctioning of ventilated VLBW infants through the endotracheal tube was performed to clear tracheobronchial airways of secretions and to maintain artificial airway patency. This procedure is standardized, was performed only when clinically indicated, and was never routinely scheduled. The endotracheal tube was disconnected from the ventilator and an appropriate sized suction catheter was sterilely inserted to no more than ½ cm below the tip of the endotracheal tube. Wall suction (80–100 cm H₂O) was applied to the catheter, which was withdrawn with one consistent movement. This procedure took 15–20 s. The endotracheal tube was then reconnected to the ventilator with presuction settings and the infant was allowed to recover before the next suction pass. The process was repeated once or twice more until the airway was clear. Saline was rarely used with tracheal suctioning during the first week of life.

Statistical analysis

For the analysis, continuous measurements of MABP (in the presumed autoregulatory plateau range of 30–40 mm Hg inclusive) (4), Paco₂, and mCBFv during and after suctioning procedures during the first postnatal week were used. The objective was to estimate the autoregulatory plateau slope for each infant suctioning session at seven Paco₂ levels (30, 35, 40, 45, 50, 55, and 60 mm Hg), chosen to cover the range of mildly hypocapnic and permissively hypercapnic values. Those estimates were then used to test whether the mean autoregulatory plateau slopes at the seven chosen Paco₂ levels were statistically different.

The methodology was as follows:

1. A robust technique (least median of squares) was used to remove data artifacts from each suctioning session (20). The average percentage of movement artifacts was approximately 8%.

2. The following multiple linear regression model was implemented for each suctioning session allowing one to “plug in” different values of Paco₂ (Paco₂ = 30, 35, 40, 45, 50, 55, and 60 mm Hg) and obtain autoregulatory plateau slope estimates at each of those levels of Paco₂:

$$mCBFv={\beta }_0+{\beta }_{1}MABP+{\beta }_{2}PaC{O}_2+{\beta }_{3}MAPB*PaC{O}_2+∊$$

For example, when Paco₂ = 45 mm Hg, the autoregulatory plateau slope estimate can be shown to be ${\widehat{\beta }}_1+45{\widehat{\beta }}_3$. For statistical modeling validation purposes, the PRESS statistic was compared with the error sum of squares for each model via a percentage change calculation. [Briefly, if the PRESS statistic is close to the error sum of squares, then the fitted model passes validation criteria (21)]. The average percentage change of the PRESS statistic from the error sum of squares was approximately 1.1%.

1. A regression diagnostic, called a leverage (“hat”) value, was calculated for each slope estimate from each infant suctioning session. When a leverage value was high, thereby identifying an observation that was the result of extreme extrapolation and therefore statistically unreliable, the corresponding autoregulatory plateau slope estimate was omitted from the analysis.

2. A repeated measures ANOVA was performed on the autoregulatory plateau slope estimates that remained after step 3 (corresponding to acceptable leverage values), to test whether the mean autoregulatory plateau slopes at the seven Paco₂ levels were statistically different. Also, a 95% confidence interval was constructed for the mean autoregulatory plateau slopes at each of the seven Paco₂ levels. Slopes not statistically different from 0 were considered to represent intact autoregulation, whereas slopes >0 represented impaired autoregulation.

RESULTS

Infant characteristics (n = 43) are shown in Table 1. Mean airway pressure was 7.2 ± 1.5 cm H₂O and Fio₂ was 26.8 ± 8.1%. Baseline arterial blood gases were: 1) pH: 7.30 ± 0.08; 2) Paco₂: 46.2 ± 7.3 mm Hg; and 3) Pao₂: 65.6 ± 18.5 mm Hg. MABP was 37.1 ± 5.2 mm Hg and heart rate was 142.5 ± 13.5 beats/min. Mean CBF velocity was 17.6 ± 5.1 cm/s. There were 2.7 ± 1.5 suctioning sessions per subject. There were 11 suctioning sessions on DOL #1, 42 on DOL #2, 28 on DOL #3, 13 on DOL #4, 13 on DOL #5, 7 on DOL #6, and 3 suctioning sessions on DOL #7.

Table 1.

Characteristics of 43 neonates

Characteristic	Value
Birth weight (g)	905 ± 259*
Gestational age (wk)	26.9 ± 2.3*
Race
White	28 (65)
Black	11(26)
Hispanic	4 (9)
Gender
Female	24(56)
male	19(44)
Survival	41(95)
Multifetal pregnancies	15(35)
Preterm delivery
Preterm labor	13(30)
Pregnancy-induced hypertension	10(23)
Premature rupture of the membranes	8(19)
Chorioamnionitis	6(14)
Placental abruption or previa	3 (7)
Prolapsed cord	2 (5)
Intrauterine death of twin	1 (2)
Antenatal steroids	40(93)
Cesarean section	34(79)
Apgar scores
1 Min	4 (1–8)†
5 Min	7 (1–9)†
Worst cranial ultrasound
Grade 1 IVH	1 (2)
Grade 2 IVH	1 (2)
Grade 3 IVH	1 (2)
Grade 4 IVH	0 (0)
Periventricular leukomalacia	1 (2)

Values are no. (%).

^*Plus-minus values are means ± SD.

^†Apgar scores: median (range).

Analysis

The effect of increasing Paco₂ on the estimated slopes of the autoregulatory plateau for the study sample is shown in Figure 2 (also see Fig. 1, A and B). Estimated mean slopes and 95% confidence intervals for Paco₂ values 30, 35, 40, 45, 50, 55, and 60 mm Hg are illustrated in Figure 3. The estimated means of the slope of the autoregulatory plateau (cm/s * mm Hg⁻¹) increased as Paco₂ increased (p = 0.004), and were not affected by day of life (p = 0.994). The estimated mean slopes for Paco₂ values of 30, 35, and 40 mm Hg represented intact autoregulation as confidence intervals included 0. In contrast, estimated mean slopes for Paco₂ values ≥45 mm Hg indicated a progressive loss of cerebral autoregulation.

Figure 2.

The influence of increasing Paco₂ values on the estimated slope of the autoregulatory plateau in 43 ventilated VLBW infants. The autoregulatory plateau (the relationship between mCBFv and MABP at 30–40 mm Hg) is demonstrated for seven Paco₂* values. A slope near or equal to 0 suggests intact cerebral autoregulation whereas increasing values >0 indicate progressively impaired autoregulation.

Figure 3.

Estimated mean slopes and 95% confidence intervals of the autoregulatory plateau for Paco₂ values 30, 35, 40, 45, 50, 55, and 60 mm Hg for 43 VLBW infants. Bars indicate 95% confidence intervals for the mean slopes of the autoregulatory plateaus for Paco₂ 30 (n = 82), 35 (n = 94), 40 (n = 100), 45 (n = 103), 50 (n = 100), 55 (n = 90), and 60 mm Hg (n = 83). The horizontal line at slope 0 indicates intact autoregulation. The estimated means of the slope of the autoregulatory plateau (cm/s * mm Hg⁻¹) increased as Paco₂ increased (p = 0.004).

DISCUSSION

This observational study provides the first data in human VLBW infants during the first week of life suggesting that increasing Paco₂ is associated with progressive impairment of cerebral autoregulation. Detection of autoregulatory capacity during this vulnerable period of life is important because premature infants who lack autoregulation and have perturbations of BP leading to CBF fluctuations are more likely to develop brain injury compared with those with intact CBF regulation (7,13,14). Our observations may be extremely important given the widespread use of permissive hypercapnia in the management of ventilated premature infants throughout the world. However, since we did not examine the relationship between Paco₂ and cerebral autoregulation on neurodevelopmental outcome, we cannot recommend avoidance of permissive hypercapnia at this time.

Intact brain function results from well-regulated CBF mechanisms that are coupled to cerebral metabolic needs and respond appropriately to alterations in BP and chemical regulators, such as carbon dioxide, one of the most potent mediators of cerebral vascular tone. Hypercapnia may lead to impaired autoregulation by increasing vasodilation of the cerebral resistance arterioles. Should BP increase concomitantly with hypercapnia, autoregulatory mechanisms may be overcome causing CBF to increase in a pressure passive manner due to ineffective vasoconstriction. During hypotension, additional vasodilation may not be possible resulting in pressure passive decreases in CBF. Thus, the ability to autoregulate CBF with changes in BP is significantly dependent on Paco₂ (16).

Our observations in VLBW infants are consistent with classic studies in adults and animals demonstrating that hypercapnia (>55 mm Hg) is associated with impaired cerebral autoregulation while moderate hypocapnia and normocapnia is associated with intact autoregulation (3,15,16,22). Lou et al. (23) were the first to suggest that cerebral autoregulation was also similarly affected by Paco₂ levels in ventilated premature infants, and that hypocapnia may prevent IVH by reestablishing intact cerebral autoregulation. They examined the relationship between Paco₂ in the first hour of life and subsequent brain injury in VLBW infants and found that those with the highest Paco₂ had the highest incidence of IVH. Thus, prevention of brain injury by restoration of autoregulation by limiting hypercapnia may be more appropriate for managing neonatal respiratory diseases than permissive hypercapnia from a CNS perspective.

There is extensive, albeit retrospective, evidence that hypocapnia in premature infants is associated with poor neurode-velopmental outcome, including periventricular leukomalacia (PVL), IVH, and cerebral palsy (24–26), possibly due to cerebral vasoconstriction, decreased CBF, and decreased cerebral oxygen delivery. Therefore, prevention of hypocapnia must also be a primary objective in the management of these infants. By targeting mild to moderate hypercapnia during ventilation of premature infants, it has been suggested that permissive hypercapnia may be neuroprotective by avoidance of accidental hypocapnia (27). On the other hand, inadvertent hypercapnia may result from this method, and hypercapnia has been associated with IVH (9,10,12). In fact, in the initial pilot trial of permissive hypercapnia in premature infants, many infants in the hypercapnic group had maximum Paco₂ >55 mm Hg, perhaps out of the traditional “safe” range of hypercapnia (1,28).

Most of the studies examining the role of cerebral autoregulation in the pathogenesis of neonatal brain injury found that absent autoregulation was associated with IVH whereas intact autoregulation was protective (7,14,29). In a recent study, near-infrared spectroscopy was used to establish the status of autoregulation in ventilated premature infants (7). Eight of 17 infants with impaired autoregulation had severe IVH or PVL. In contrast, only 2 of 15 infants with intact autoregulation suffered severe brain lesions.

Others have attempted to determine the status of cerebral autoregulation in premature infants by examining the slope (percentage change in CBF/1 mm Hg change in MABP) of the relationship between measurements of CBF and MABP (14,30,31). In addition to arbitrarily defining a critical value between 0.5 and 1.5% change in mCBFv/1 mm Hg change in MABP as intact autoregulation (30–32), they did not take into account simultaneous changes in Paco₂ that clearly cause changes in CBF and MABP in the same direction, which may be interpreted as impaired autoregulation. Although these critical values are somewhat arbitrary, values as high as 2.7–4% were present in infants with severe IVH, and presumably represented impaired autoregulation (14,32). We do not report a critical value inasmuch as we do not have enough study infants with severe brain injury to define a specific value. We have, however, shown that increasing slopes are associated with impaired autoregulation and speculate that premature infants with increased slopes are at increased risk for brain injury.

There were four limitations of this study. Even though we used Doppler ultrasound to measure mCBFv instead of direct measures of CBF, neonatal (33) studies found good correlation between relative changes in both measurements. The Doppler method has the advantages of being noninvasive, easily performed at the bedside, and providing real-time information. Further, it does not require radioactive materials, patient manipulations, or alterations of Fio₂. The second limitation is that we used statistical modeling to determine the effects of Paco₂ on cerebral autoregulation instead of prospectively assigning infants to certain Paco₂ ranges and comparing their capacity for autoregulation. Thus, we are cautious in making sweeping recommendations regarding the continued use of permissive hypercapnia in ventilated premature infants from our observational trial. Thirdly, while we observed that increasing Paco₂ was associated with impaired autoregulation, we did not directly demonstrate that impaired autoregulation was associated with brain injury. This was not possible given the lack of brain injury in our cohort of infants, although there is sufficient previous evidence in the neonatal literature demonstrating that impaired autoregulation is associated with brain injury. Lastly, we did not examine the effects of other variables such as gestational age, postnatal age, mode of ventilation, ductal shunting, requirement for vasopressor support, and interactions between the variables, on the capacity for autoregulation. Our goal in this manuscript, however, was to examine the effects of hypercapnia on the capacity for autoregulation. Additional research and study subjects are required to assess other factors that may be associated with autoregulatory capacity in VLBW infants.

In conclusion, the slope of the autoregulatory plateau increases with increasing Paco₂, suggesting the cerebral circulation becomes more pressure passive with increasing hypercapnia. These novel data on the effects of elevated Paco₂ on the capacity for cerebral autoregulation raise concerns regarding the widespread use of permissive hypercapnia in VLBW infants. Careful control of Paco₂ during the first week of life, by preventing hypercapnia as well as hypocapnia, may be identified as a potential clinical goal (by using a continuous arterial blood gas system) to restore intact cerebral autoregulation, prevent the initiation or extension of IVH, and prevent the development of PVL in ventilated VLBW infants.