Health related quality of life and health status in adult survivors with previously operated complex congenital heart disease

Abstract

Objective: To examine the impact of previously operated complex congenital heart disease on health related quality of life and subjective health status and to determine the relation between these parameters and physical status.

Design: Cross sectional; information on medical follow up was sought retrospectively.

Setting: Patients were randomly selected from the archives of the paediatric cardiology department, Leiden University Medical Centre, Leiden, The Netherlands, and approached irrespective of current cardiac care or hospital of follow up.

Patients: Seventy eight patients with previously operated complex congenital heart disease (now aged 18–32 years) were compared with the general population.

Main outcome measures: Health related quality of life was determined with a specifically developed questionnaire (Netherlands Organisation for Applied Scientific Research Academic Medical Centre (TNO-AZL) adult quality of life (TAAQOL)) and subjective health status was assessed with the 36 item short form health survey (SF-36). Physical status was determined with the objective physical index, Somerville index, and New York Heart Association functional class.

Results: Health related quality of life of the patients was significantly worse than that of the general population in the dimensions gross motor functioning and vitality (p < 0.01). Correlations between health related quality of life and physical status were poor. Patients had significantly worse subjective health status than the general population in the dimensions physical functioning, role functioning physical, vitality, and general health perceptions (p < 0.01). Correlations between subjective health status and physical indices were weak.

Conclusion: Adult survivors with previously operated complex congenital heart disease experienced limitations only in the physical dimensions of health related quality of life and subjective health status. Objectively measured medical variables were only weakly related to health related quality of life. These results indicate that, when evaluating health related quality of life, dedicated questionnaires such as the TAAQOL should be used.

A dvances in surgery and intensive care have increased the life expectancy of children with complex congenital heart disease. Therefore, it is important to assess the long term results of treatment of these patients, not only in medical terms (for example, morbidity and mortality) but also in terms of health related quality of life and subjective health status. Since a longer life does not necessarily mean a better life, knowledge of the emotional response to health status problems may allow identification of areas of daily life that need to be improved (for example, by medical care or by provisions in social or infrastructural care management). Moreover, patients' satisfaction with the medical consultation may increase if physicians assess a patient's general wellbeing, as well as functional status.¹ Some studies have explored the subjective health status of patients with congenital heart disease in adulthood^2–10 but none have examined health related quality of life using a clear definition. In addition, correlating health related quality of life with the patient's physical condition may increase our understanding of the concept of health related quality of life.¹¹

Therefore, in a group of patients with previously operated complex congenital heart disease, the aim of the study was, firstly, to compare patients' health related quality of life and subjective health status with those of the general Dutch population (age and sex matched) and, secondly, to relate health related quality of life and subjective health status to physical status.

METHODS

The study was approved by the local medical ethical committee and informed consent was obtained from each participant. A cross sectional design was used and information on medical follow up was searched for retrospectively.

Definitions

Health related quality of life

Although there is no universal definition for health related quality of life, there is growing consensus that it should be assessed multidimensionally, including physical health, psychological state, and social relationships.^12–15 Moreover, quality of life and health status are distinct constructs^12,16,17; quality of life is determined not only by the patient's health status problems but also by the emotional response to these problems. To measure quality of life according to this definition, quality of life questionnaires have been developed for children (Netherlands Organisation for Applied Scientific Research Academic Medical Centre (TNO-AZL) child quality of life TACQOL questionnaire^14,18) and for adults (TNO-AZL adult quality of life (TAAQOL) questionnaire¹⁹). Both questionnaires have been validated in the general population as well as in patients with various chronic diseases, such as minor congenital heart disease.^14,18–21Fig 1 shows an example of the format of the questionnaires. Health related quality of life is used since non-health factors such as income or housing (which may also contribute to quality of life) were not taken into account. For clinicians health related quality of life is most relevant.

Figure 1.

Example of the format of the health related quality of life questionnaire: TNO-AZL (adult/child) quality of life (TAxQOL).

The 36 item short form health survey (SF-36) is widely used and thoroughly validated.^22,23 It measures subjective health status, posing such questions as “What are your limitations?” or “Do you feel healthy?” in contrast to “How do you feel about certain limitations?” in the TAAQOL.

Diagnosis

In the present study, patients with previously operated complex congenital heart disease were approached, excluding those who had undergone anatomical corrective surgery. All patients included in this study had undergone a non-anatomical correction—that is, partial or complete cavopulmonary connection, venous switch for transposition of the great arteries, or a correction with the use of allogenous tissue (for example, Rastelli correction, insertion of a mechanical valve). The main common characteristic was that postoperatively none of the participants had an anatomically normal heart as described by the segmental analysis,²⁴ as opposed to patients after anatomical corrective surgery (for example, operated ventricular or atrial septal defects, coarctation of the aorta, patent ductus arteriosus, uncomplicated tetralogy of Fallot, total anomalous pulmonary venous connection, and uncomplicated pulmonary or aortic stenosis).

Patient selection

To prevent selection bias, patients were selected from the archives of the department of paediatric cardiology, Leiden University Medical Centre, Leiden, The Netherlands, which has complete information on patients seen from 1950 onwards. From these files, 4383 patients were born between 1968 and 1982. Of these, in the year 1999, 2280 were randomly selected. Then, 251 patients with operated complex congenital heart disease were included and further studied irrespective of current cardiac surveillance. The latest medical information and home addresses were obtained from the most recent medical file, general practitioners, or local authorities. Among the 251 included patients, 123 (49%) had died. Others (n = 41) were excluded for the following reasons: they were not living in the Netherlands or did not speak Dutch n = 28 (11%), they had learning disabilities n = 12 (5%), or they had participated in a pilot study n = 1 (0.5%). One patient was lost to follow up. The remaining 86 patients were invited to participate in the study; of these, 78 patients agreed to participate (91%). Table 1 lists the diagnoses and gives the number of patients per diagnosis or operation.

Table 1.

Diagnosis of 78 patients previously operated on for complex congenital heart disease (number of patients is given in parentheses)

Main diagnosis	Main operation
1. Systemic right ventricle (39)
TGA (22)	Senning (12) or Mustard (10)
TGA + PS (5)	Senning (3) or Mustard (2) with PS repair
TGA + VSD + PS (6)	Senning (5) or Mustard (1) with VSD closure and PS repair
L-TGA + VSD + PS (2)	VSD closure with PS repair (2)
L-TGA + VSD + ASD (1)	VSD closure and ASD closure (1)
L-TGA + VSD (1)	VSD closure (1)
L-TGA + PS (1)	Tricuspid valve replacement (1)
AV discordance + DORV + PS (1)	Tricuspid valve replacement and conduit (1)
2. Conduit or mechanical prosthesis (23)
PA + VSD (11)	Rastelli (3); correction with other conduit (8)
AoS (4); AVSD (1); MI (1)	Mechanical prosthesis (6)
TGA + VSD + PS (4)	Rastelli (4)
TGA + VSD (1)	Arterial switch operation with conduit (1)
TrArt (1)	Correction with conduit (1)
3. Univentricular connection (11)
TA (8); DILV (2); hypoplastic LV (1)	Fontan (11)
4. Palliative operation-shunt (5)
AVSD (1)	Glenn shunt (1)
DILV (1)	Blalock-Taussig shunt (1)
Univentricular heart (1)	Modified Blalock-Taussig shunt (1)
TA (1)	After Glenn shunt: AV shunt axillary (1)
TA + TGA (1)	After banding AP: PH (1)

AoS, aortic stenosis; AP, pulmonary artery; ASD, atrial septal defect; AV, atrioventricular; AVSD, atrioventricular septal defect; DILV, double inlet left ventricle; DORV, double outlet right ventricle; L-TGA, congenitally corrected TGA; LV, left ventricle; MI, mitral insufficiency; PA, pulmonary atresia; PH, pulmonary hypertension; PS, pulmonary stenosis; TA, tricuspid atresia; TGA, simple transposition of the great arteries; TrArt, common truncus arteriosus; VSD, ventricular septal defect.

Measurements

Questionnaires on health related quality of life and subjective health status were completed.

Health related quality of life

The TAAQOL is a Dutch questionnaire developed by TNO and the Leiden University Medical Centre. Psychometric performance (reliability and validity) of the TAAQOL is satisfactory.¹⁹ It consists of 45 questions divided into 12 domains. Each domain contains two to four questions (the actual number per domain is given in parentheses): gross motor functioning (4), fine motor functioning (4), pain (4), sleeping (4), cognitive functioning (4), social functioning (4), daily activities (4), sexual activity (2), vitality (4), happiness (4), depressive moods (4), and aggressiveness (3). For each item, the frequency of occurrence of a health status problem is assessed. If such a problem is reported, the emotional reaction to this problem is also determined. Fig 1 shows an example of the format of the question. The reference period is formulated as “the last month”. The two questions of the domain sexual activity were not appropriate for the present study since the occurrence of problems was compared with one month previously (“Were you less sexually active than a month ago?”). Because such questions are only relevant when an intervention has taken place, this domain was not considered. Scores of each subscale are normalised to a scale ranging from 0 to 100, with higher scores indicating better quality of life.¹⁹

Subjective health status

The SF-36 was used to measure subjective health status.²² This questionnaire is based on 35 items divided into eight domains (the number of questions per domain is indicated in parentheses): physical functioning (10), role functioning physical (4), bodily pain (2), general health perceptions (5), vitality (4), social functioning (2), role functioning emotional (3), and mental health (5). Scores range from 0 to 100, with higher scores indicating better subjective health status.

TAAQOL and SF-36 data of the Dutch general population are available.^19,22

Physical status

Medical data were collected from the medical records. If clinical information was older than one year, patients were re-examined at the Leiden University Medical Centre (by MK and JO or HV). Physical status was scored by means of three indices determined from these data. Firstly, to measure objectively the severity of the congenital heart disease, the presence of cyanosis, arrhythmia, cardiac failure, and residual defects was combined into an “objective physical index”. Because each variable counted for one point, a score of 0 to 4 was possible, with a higher score indicating a more serious cardiac condition. Secondly, the index of Somerville²⁵ and, thirdly, the New York Heart Association (NYHA) functional class²⁶ were determined (table 2). In both, a higher score indicates more complaints or limitations.

Table 2.

New York Heart Association (NYHA) functional class for patients with cardiac disease and ability index of Somerville

Somerville index
1	Normal life: full time work or school, pregnancy manageable.
2	Able to work (part time): interference with life (socio/community imposition).
3	Unable to work: limitations on all activities, pregnancy risk.
4	Extreme limitation: dependent, almost housebound.
NYHA classes
I	No limitations of physical activities. Ordinary activity does not cause undue anginal pain, dyspnoea, fatigue, or palpitations.
II	Slight limitations of physical activities. Comfortable at rest, but ordinary activity results in anginal pain, dyspnoea, fatigue, or palpitations.
III	Marked limitations of physical activities. Comfortable at rest, less than ordinary activity causes anginal pain, dyspnoea, fatigue, or palpitations.
IV	Unable to carry on any physical activities without discomfort. Symptoms of cardiac insufficiency or anginal syndrome may be present even at rest. If any physical activity is undertaken discomfort is increased.

Statistical analyses

Sample size was based on results of the pilot study¹⁹ in which a mean difference of 11 units (on the 0 to 100 scale) was found between patients and the general population on the SF-36 vitality scale. Similar effect sizes are reported in the American SF-36 manual for similar conditions. The sample size (n = 80) was chosen to have 80% power for such a difference. With this sample size there is at least an 80% power to detect a correlation coefficient of 0.30 or more.

The participants' health related quality of life (as measured by the TAAQOL) and their subjective health status (as measured by the SF-36) were compared with those of a random sample of the general Dutch population using analysis of variance with adjustment for age and sex. The sample of the general Dutch population comprised 831 persons for the TAAQOL and 361 for the SF-36.¹⁹ After comparison, the data were summarised as mean values and 95% confidence intervals.

Within the group of patients, the overall association between health related quality of life and subjective health status on the one hand and the objective physical index, the Somerville index, and the NYHA class on the other was quantified using canonical correlation analysis to reduce the number of statistical tests. With this method, the maximum association between two sets of variables is quantified.²⁷ When the canonical correlation was significant, pairwise Spearman rank correlations were used to quantify the association between the various indices.

Since the distribution of a number of these variables was skewed, all statistical analyses were performed on rank transformed data. A probability value of p ≤ 0.01 was considered significant because many statistical tests were done. SPSS for Windows version 10.07 (SPSS Inc, Chicago, Illinois, USA) was used to perform statistical calculations.

RESULTS

Patient characteristics

There was an overall response rate of 91%. Medical data were available for all 78 participants and questionnaires for 76 of them. There were 44 men and 34 women, with an average age of 24.3 (range 18–32) years. At the time of the study, 46 participants had a job for more than 12 h/week (59%; two patients were receiving a partial disability benefit), 15 were receiving a full or partial disability benefit (19%), 11 were still at school (14%), three were housewives (4%), and three (4%) were on sick leave or unemployed. Participants lived with a partner n = 34 (43%) or with their parents n = 31 (40%), had their own house n = 7 (9%), or lived in a student (or other) house n = 6 (8%).

For n = 47 60% of the participants the main surgery had been performed before the patient was three years old. Fifty participants (64%) had undergone a previous palliative procedure (such as Rashkind septostomy or banding of the pulmonary artery). The mean age at first operation or intervention was 2.2 (range 0–24) years; 45 patients (58%) had had an intervention soon after birth.

Fig 2 shows the physical status of the patients. Mean score for the objective physical index was 1.48, for the Somerville index 1.41, and for the NYHA class 1.8. Most patients scored 1 in the objective physical index n =31 (40%), indicating that they had at least one of the physical complications. According to the Somerville index, n = 9 (11%) of the participants were unable to work and were limited in all activities (score 3). For the NYHA class, n = 36 (46%) of the participants were in class II and were thus experiencing slight limitations in physical activities.

Figure 2.

Outcome of physical status in the three indices (n = 78).

Health related quality of life: patients compared with the general population

Fig 3 gives the average TAAQOL scores of the patients and of the general population sample. The patients had lower health related quality of life in almost all dimensions and scored significantly lower on gross motor functioning (p < 0.001) and vitality (p < 0.01).

Figure 3.

Health related quality of life (TAAQOL) in 76 patients with previously operated complex congenital heart disease is compared with that of the general population (n = 831). Horizontal axis: TNO-AZL adult quality of life (TAAQOL) domains. Vertical axis: score (range 0–100). *p < 0.01; **p < 0.001.

Health related quality of life related to physical status: within the patient group

Several health related quality of life dimensions correlated significantly with the objective physical index, the Somerville index, and the NYHA class (table 3). Canonical correlation analysis showed that the first canonical correlation was significant (r = 0.768); in particular the NYHA class was the most important correlate of gross motor functioning. The pairwise Spearman correlations (table 3) showed the following pattern: health related quality of life correlated weakly with the objective physical index but significantly with gross motor functioning and cognitive functioning. The strongest relations were between the TAAQOL dimensions and the NYHA class.

Table 3.

Spearman's r correlation for medical indices correlated with the TNO-AZL adult quality of life questionnaire (TAAQOL) and the 36 item short form health survey (SF-36) for 76 patients previously operated on for complex congenital heart disease

Questionnaire	Objective physical index	Somerville index	NYHA class
TAAQOL
Gross motor functioning	−0.33*	−0.53**	−0.77**
Daily activities	−0.23	−0.46**	−0.45**
Vitality	−0.12	−0.42**	−0.47**
Sleep	−0.25	−0.38**	−0.43**
Social functioning	−0.10	−0.30*	−0.35*
Pain	−0.03	−0.24	−0.36**
Cognitive functioning	−0.30*	−0.33*	−0.32*
Depressive moods	−0.17	−0.24	−0.31*
Fine motor functioning	−0.18	−0.22	−0.29*
Happiness	−0.19	−0.06	−0.22
Aggressiveness	−0.03	−0.15	−0.19
SF-36
Physical functioning	−0.42**	−0.64**	−0.87**
Mental health	−0.36**	−0.16	−0.2
Social functioning	−0.24	−0.54**	−0.45**
Role functioning physical	−0.28	−0.48**	−0.42**
General health	−0.25	−0.41**	−0.47**
Vitality	−0.25	−0.31*	−0.45**
Bodily pain	−0.22	−0.32*	−0.45**
Role functioning emotion	−0.24	−0.20	−0.22

*p<0.01; **p<0.001

Subjective health status: patients compared with the general population

The SF-36 dimensions physical functioning, role functioning physical (p < 0.01), vitality, and general health perception were significantly lower (p < 0.001) in patients than in the general population (fig 4).

Figure 4.

Subjective health status (SF-36) in 76 patients with previously operated complex congenital heart disease is compared with that of the general population (n = 361). Horizontal axis: 36 item short form health survey (SF-36) domains. Vertical axis: score (range 0–100). *p < 0.01; **p < 0.001.

Subjective health status related to physical status: within the patient group

Almost all SF-36 dimensions correlated significantly with the three physical indices (table 3). Canonical correlation analysis showed that the NYHA class was the strongest correlate of the SF-36 dimensions and of physical functioning in particular (r = 0.864). The patterns for pairwise Spearman correlations were the same as those for health related quality of life, with the strongest relations between subjective health status dimensions and the NYHA class (table 3).

DISCUSSION

This study evaluated health related quality of life and subjective health status in adults with previously operated complex congenital heart disease and determined the relation between these parameters and physical status.

Patients compared with the general population

Comparison between the patients and the general population showed significantly lower scores in the patient group in the physical dimensions only: gross motor functioning and vitality (in the TAAQOL) and physical functioning, role functioning physical, general health perceptions, and vitality (in the SF-36). Thus, both physical function and appraisal of physical dysfunction were significantly lower in the patient group.

There was no significant difference in any of the scores for the non-physical dimensions (social functioning, role functioning emotional, daily activities, depressive moods, etc) between patients and the general population. Some studies on social, psychological, and behavioural outcome in children and adolescents with heart disease have reported problems in these fields,^5,28–32 whereas others show normal social behaviour and successful educational and occupational achievements in this group of patients,^8,9,33–36 thus supporting the promising outcome of the present study. These latter studies indicate that, over time, patients may adapt to their disease and that denial may even help to normalise functioning.

To improve the patients' long term quality of life, physical aspects must be taken into account.

Firstly, appropriate exercise should be encouraged to avoid patients imposing unnecessary restrictions on themselves,³⁷ sometimes caused when patients receive insufficient information from the specialist.³⁸ In addition, parents should be informed that overprotection can have a negative impact on the physical activities of the child.³⁹ Counselling should, therefore, be based on a thorough clinical assessment together with the use of specific recommendations.^39–41 Another way to improve physical capacity is to offer exercise training. For example, in adult male patients with chronic heart failure, specific cardiac training has been shown to improve physical capacity and quality of life,^42,43 as in healthy subjects.⁴⁴ In addition, training in children with various congenital heart diseases has been shown to improve physical abilities.^45–47 However, in patients with previously operated complex congenital heart disease the value of exercise training should be further studied, focusing on long term effects in adulthood.⁴⁸

Prevention of postoperative complications may also avoid poor outcome of the physical dimension of health related quality of life, but this topic is beyond the scope of the present study.

Relation to physical status

Relating physical indices to the dimensions of health related quality of life and subjective health status showed weak correlations. The objective physical index correlated less with health related quality of life and subjective health status than the index of Somerville and the NYHA class. This means that variables such as cyanosis, cardiac failure, or arrhythmia (the best indicators for the objective severity of the disease) do not correlate with the patient's health related quality of life or subjective health status. This is a surprising finding, but other reports on these correlations show the same pattern: factors other than the complexity of the disease (for example, parental attitudes and perceptions, mother's concern, and social support) play a more important part in psychosocial outcome.^9,33,49,50 Correlations between all the quality of life dimensions and the Somerville index were significantly weaker than those between the quality of life dimensions and the NYHA class. Thus, although the Somerville index was specifically devised to take into account the adjustment and perception of patients with congenital heart disease,⁵¹ its usefulness for this purpose was not confirmed in the present study. The NYHA class correlated significantly and relevantly with the dimensions gross motor functioning (TAAQOL) and physical functioning (SF-36) (Spearman's r = 0.77 and r = 0.87, respectively). When focusing solely on these dimensions, the NYHA class can indeed provide a good estimate of health related quality of life and subjective health status. However, when evaluating the patients' overall health related quality of life and subjective health status, parameters other than those routinely used in a physically oriented cardiological setting should be included.

Remarks and study limitations

When measuring long term outcome of patients with previously operated congenital heart disease, mortality has to be considered. In the unbiased group of 251 selected patients, 123 (49%) had died and could therefore not participate in the study; at least nine of these latter patients were over 18 years old when they died. In addition, two of the participants died from cardiac causes during the study period. Mortality in the age group 18–32 years is, therefore, at least 8.1% (that is, 11 of 135 patients died). Although the study found good health related quality of life in many aspects, the considerable risk of dying after the age of 18 years has to be taken into account. In addition, studying only surviving patients implies a positive selection bias.

The overall response rate in this study was 91%. There was no significant difference between the participants and non-participants in terms of sex or residence. Similarly, there was no significant difference in response between the subdiagnosis groups. However, there was a significant difference between age groups. The response rate in the 24–32 year age group was lower than in the 18–24 year age group (77% and 95%, respectively; p = 0.02). Communication with some of the non-participants indicated that older patients may have more family or work responsibilities and thus less time to participate in a study; how this may have influenced our results remains, however, unclear.

Conclusions

Patients with previously operated complex congenital heart disease experienced limitations only in the physical dimensions of health related quality of life and subjective health status. Objective medical variables correlated only weakly with health related quality of life and can therefore not be used to assess health related quality of life. Wagner and colleagues⁵² reported that “the routine use of health status measures may enhance patients' care”. The dedicated health related quality of life instrument used in the present study (TAAQOL) is well validated¹⁹ and valuable in patient care since it measures the patients' own health related feelings and problems in daily life. It provides more relevant information than just measuring functioning with subjective health status.^12,16,17 These results indicate that, when evaluating health related quality of life, dedicated questionnaires such as the TAAQOL should be used.

Abbreviations

• NYHA, New York Heart Association

• SF-36, 36 item short form health survey

• TAAQOL, Netherlands Organisation for Applied Scientific Research-Academic Medical Centre (TNO-AZL) adult quality of life TACQOL, TNO-AZL child quality of life