Corticosteroids to prevent postextubation upper airway obstruction: the evidence mounts

Abstract

Intubation of the airway can lead to laryngotracheal injury, resulting in extubation failure from upper airway obstruction (UAO). A number of factors can help to identify patients who are at greatest risk for postextubation UAO. Three randomized controlled trials demonstrate that prophylactic corticosteroids decrease the risk for postextubation UAO and probably the need for re-intubation.

Extubation failure (the need for re-intubation) is associated with increased intensive care unit and hospital mortality, increased length of stay in the intensive care unit and hospital, greater need for tracheostomy and for long-term acute care, and increased costs. Underlying severity of illness, premorbid health status, and complications directly associated with re-intubation fail to explain the adverse outcomes seen with extubation failure. Clinical deterioration between the time of extubation and the re-establishment of ventilatory support may provide the best explanation. Therefore, preventing extubation failure has the potential to improve outcome.

The study reported by Lee and coworkers [1] is one of a series of recent investigations examining whether corticosteroids can prevent postextubation upper airway obstruction (UAO), which is a common cause of extubation failure. Intubation and the endotracheal tube (ETT) may cause laryngotracheal injury, resulting in inflammation, mucosal ulceration, edema, or granuloma formation. This can lead to glottic or subglottic narrowing, which manifests as stridor, respiratory distress, or respiratory failure after removal of the ETT. Factors associated with increased risk for postextubation UAO include female sex (probably resulting from small airway size), trauma patient, age above 80 years, excessively mobile or overly large ETT size, ratio of ETT size to laryngeal diameter above 45%, ratio of patient height to tube diameter, duration of intubation, tracheal infection, absence of cough, absence of sedation, low Glasgow Coma Scale score, or excess cuff pressure [2-5].

Research into detection of UAO, with the ETT in place, has recently focused on using the quantitative cuff leak test [6]. During this maneuver the patient breathes on assist control ventilation, the endotracheal cuff is deflated, and the difference between inspired and expired tidal volume is compared. An obstructed upper airway results in similar inspiratory and expiratory volumes, whereas a patent airway results in a substantial difference as a large volume of gas escapes around the tube. This quantitative cuff leak can be reported as either a percentage of inspired tidal volume or as an absolute cuff leak volume (CLV). Previous investigators have found that the risk for postextubation stridor is increased when CLV is less than approximately 12% to 25% of inspired volume or an absolute value of less than 110 to 130 ml [2,6-9].

Although previous studies conducted in pediatric patients found that corticosteroids reduce the prevalence of postextubation UAO by nearly 40% and may reduce the need for re-intubation [10], earlier controlled trials in mechanically ventilated adults did not corroborate those findings [11]. Francois and colleagues [12] recently compared 20 mg methylprednisolone (given every 4 hours for 12 hours before extubation) with placebo in nearly 700 adults patients who had been intubated for at least 36 hours. Corticosteroid pretreatment was associated with decreased risk for postextubation UAO (3% versus 22%), need for re-intubation (4% versus 8%), and need for re-intubation secondary to UAO (0.3% versus 4%). The number needed to treat (NNT) was eight to prevent one case of stridor and 26 to prevent one case of re-intubation. Cheng and colleagues [2] used a reduced CLV (≤24% of inspired tidal volume) to define and study patients at high risk for postextubation UAO. Patients randomly assigned to methylprednisolone (40 mg every 6 hours for four doses) were less likely either to experience stridor (7% versus 30%) or to require re-intubation (7% versus 19%) than were those receiving placebo.

The study reported in this issue of Critical Care [1] also targeted high-risk patients by examining those ventilated for at least 48 hours and with a CLV below 110 ml. Patients were randomly assigned to receive placebo or dexamethasone 5 mg every 6 hours for 24 hours, and were then extubated 24 hours later. The dexamethasone group was less likely to develop postextubation stridor (10% versus 27.5%; NNT = 5.7) without a difference in need for re-intubation (2.5% versus 5%; NNT = 40). An important observation is that dexamethasone led to a significant increase in CLV that persisted for 24 hours after the last dose (for example, at the time of extubation). Given that no further improvement in CLV occurred after the last dose of dexamethasone, one could argue for immediate extubation at that time rather than waiting an additional 24 hours.

The study by Lee and coworkers [1] also revealed that 14 out of 285 in the non-randomized cohort (4.9%), who had a CLV above 110 ml, developed stridor. Examining these patients and those randomly assigned to placebo, only 20% with postextubation UAO required re-intubation, possibly a result of the effective use of inhaled racemic adrenaline (epinephrine) and noninvasive ventilation. Among placebo patients, 73% did not develop postextubation UAO, despite a CLV below 110 ml; similar findings have been noted by other investigators. A falsely low CLV may result from secretions adherent to or pooled around the ETT. Alternatively, with the cuff deflated, the patient may breathe additional tidal volume around the tube (in addition to machine delivered volume), leading to a falsely low measurement of inspired tidal volume. The resulting difference between inspired and expired tidal volume will then be falsely low. This phenomenon can be overcome by delivering the machine breath with the cuff inflated and then deflating the cuff just before expiration [13].

The evidence is now mounting that corticosteroids can prevent postextubation UAO, and possibly the need for re-intubation, but should all patients be intubated for longer than 36 to 48 hours receive such therapy? Although a short course of corticosteroids may be relatively safe, further study is warranted. This author believes the focus should continue to be on targeting patients at greatest risk. Although the study by Francois and coworkers [12] examined an 'unselected' cohort, the 22% incidence of postextubation UAO suggests a high risk group. Using the CLV can help to identify a cohort at greater risk, but the sensitivity and specificity of the test is suboptimal. Using this test alone to determine need for prophylactic corticosteroids will result in an unnecessary 12 to 24 hour prolongation of intubation for three out of every four such patients. Another approach is to identify first a high-risk cohort based on clinical factors (for instance, age, sex, tube size, and so on) and then to apply CLV to determine which patients should receive corticosteroids before extubation.

Abbreviations

CLV = cuff leak volume; ETT = endotracheal tube; NNT = number needed to treat; UAO = upper airway obstruction.

Competing interests

The author declares that they have no competing interests.

See related research by Lee et al., http://ccforum.com/content/11/4/R72