Adenovirus DNA is detected at increased frequency in Guthrie cards from children who develop acute lymphoblastic leukaemia

Abstract

Epidemiological evidence suggests that childhood acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (ALL) may be initiated by an in infection in utero. Adenovirus DNA was detected in 13 of 49 neonatal blood spots from ALL patients but only in 3 of 47 controls (P=0.012) suggesting a correlation between prenatal adenovirus infection and the development of ALL

Acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (ALL) is the most common malignancy in children (Greenlee et al, 2000). Recent studies have shed light on the natural history of this disease. Identification of leukaemia-associated translocations in neonatal blood spots (Guthrie cards) of children who will develop leukaemia years later indicates that the initiating event(s) of ALL usually occur before birth (Gale et al, 1997; Wiemels et al, 1999). Epidemiologic studies (Kinlen, 1988; Kinlen and Doll, 2004) suggest that at least one step in the process of ALL development involves an infectious agent (reviewed in Greaves, 2006). The hallmark genetic mutations, notably translocations, of childhood ALL arise when repair of DNA breaks is faulty or inhibited. Infection with some DNA viruses, notably herpesviruses and adenoviruses, interferes with cellular DNA repair mechanisms (Weitzman and Ornelles, 2005; Wilkinson and Weller, 2006) and could lead to these characteristic genetic changes. To determine whether a prenatal virus infection could lead to the development of pre-leukaemic cells containing characteristic translocations, a correlation is sought between detection of viral DNA in Guthrie cards and the eventual development of leukaemia. This approach showed no association between infection with polyoma viruses (Priftakis et al, 2003), herpesviruses (Bogdanovic et al, 2004; Gustafsson et al, 2006), or parvovirus B19 (Isa et al, 2004) and childhood ALL.

The common, endemic species C adenoviruses (serotypes 1, 2, 5, and 6) normally cause respiratory tract infections in young children (Brandt et al, 1969; Avila et al, 1989) and persistent infection of lymphoid tissues (Garnett et al, 2002). We investigated whether adenovirus infections could be correlated with ALL by studying Guthrie cards from children who later developed ALL and healthy controls.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Guthrie cards

Neonatal capillary blood spots from newborn Swedish infants were used for this study. These blood spots were collected at 3–5 days of age. Four droplets of capillary blood were taken and blotted onto filter paper (Guthrie card). One blood spot contains about 3 × 10⁴ nucleated cells. Guthrie cards were stored at 4°C.

Patients

Guthrie cards were identified from 49 children born between 1977 and 1998, who were diagnosed with ALL between 1980 and 2001 (Table 2). As a control group Guthrie cards from 47 healthy children, matched for birth date and birthplace, were analysed, using the Swedish Medical Birth Register to identify these children. Written informed consent was obtained from all patients, controls and parents. The local ethics committee of the Karolinska Institutet at the Karolinska University Hospital approved the study protocol.

Table 2. Patient characteristics.

Characteristic	No.	Adenovirus DNA
Diagnosis
Pre-B ALL	44	11
B ALL	1	0
T ALL	4	2
Sex
Female	25	6
Male	24	7
Risk group
Standard risk	20	8
Intermediate risk	12	0
High risk	17	5
Karyotype
Hyperdiploid	23	7
t(9;22)(q34;q11)	3	1
t(10;11)(?;q23)	1	0
t(12;21)(p12;q21)	1	0
t(1;19)(q23;p13)	1	0
t(Y;15)(p11.23;q11.2)	1	1
inv(17q)	1	1
add(1), add(7)	1	0
add(6)(q27)	1	0
No abnormality detected	10	3
Inconclusive	17	6
Outcome
Disease-free >5 years	32	10
Stem cell transplantation	23	8
Deceased	7	2

ALL=acute lymphoblastic leukaemia.

DNA extraction from Guthrie cards

Three uniform discs, 3 mm in diameter, were punched from one of the four blood spots from the stored material and the DNA extracted as previously described with minor modifications (Barbi et al, 1996).

PCR assays

Two different nested PCR assays were used in this study (nucleotides 18 838–19 205 and 20 721–21 572 of the Ad2 sequence (RefSeq AC000007)). Both assays amplified DNA from all species C serotypes, but not from members of other adenovirus species (A, B, D, E, and F). In some cases, samples were also tested with a quantitative real-time PCR assay (Garnett et al, 2002). As a control, PCR with a set of HLA-DQ alpha primers was performed as described (Saiki et al, 1986).

Statistical analysis

Categorical parameters were evaluated using the Fisher exact test and the Cochran–Mantel–Haenszel test. Logistic regression was used to determine if the clinical outcomes were jointly associated with patient characteristics and adenovirus DNA.

RESULTS

DNA extracted from Guthrie cards from 49 ALL patients and from 47 normal controls was analysed for the presence of species C adenovirus DNA. Individual samples were assayed on at least three separate occasions using two different PCR assays. Thirteen of the ALL samples and three of the control samples contained amplifiable adenovirus DNA (Table 1). These results show a significant association (P=0.012) between species C adenovirus DNA and leukaemia. The odds ratio shows a 5.2-fold (95% CI:1.3–31) greater likelihood of detecting species C adenovirus DNA in the neonatal blood of a child that subsequently develops ALL than in the neonatal blood of a child that does not develop ALL.

Table 1. Adenovirus DNA detected in Guthrie cards of ALL patients and controls.

	Adenovirus DNA status
Disease status	Positive	Negative	% Adenovirus DNA-positive
ALL	13	36	27
Normal	3	44	6

ALL=acute lymphoblastic leukaemia.

Adenovirus DNA levels in positive patient samples were quantified by real-time PCR, which is slightly less sensitive than the nested assays. Five of the 13 ALL samples and none of the three adenovirus DNA-positive control samples contained detectable DNA by real-time PCR (data not shown). The range of DNA copies in these assays was from 1 to 30 with a median of 2.3 copies.

Contingency tables and logistic regression were used to determine if the detection of adenovirus DNA was associated with any patient characteristics or clinical outcomes summarised in Table 2. A non-random (P=0.032) distribution of adenovirus DNA among risk groups was observed. However, the very limited number of adenovirus-positive samples analysed here requires further investigation to determine if this distribution is indeed non-random and if the exclusion of adenovirus DNA from the Guthrie cards of patients in the intermediate-risk group is significant. No other relationship (P>0.5) was found between adenovirus DNA in the neonatal blood spot and the remaining characteristics identified in Table 2.

DISCUSSION

For species C adenovirus to contribute to the earliest steps in development of childhood leukaemia, this virus must infect the fetus at least as frequently as the incidence of neonatal pre-leukaemic clones in the population, estimated at 1–5% (Mori et al, 2002). In addition to being a likely fetal pathogen (Towbin et al, 1994; Van den Veyver et al, 1998; Oyer et al, 2000; Baschat et al, 2003; Reddy et al, 2005), adenovirus DNA is also detected in the amniotic fluid from apparently normal pregnancies. Of 1187 unique samples in four large studies, 64 (5.4%) contained adenoviral DNA (Van den Veyver et al, 1998; Wenstrom et al, 1998; Baschat et al, 2003; Reddy et al, 2005), which compares favourably with 6% adenovirus DNA-positive samples among the normal controls in the present study (Table 1). And, as is the case with children infected post-natally, adenoviral DNA is retained in latently infected T lymphocytes for years following primary infection (Garnett et al, 2002). Thus, the finding of species C adenovirus in neonatal blood spots is evidence of prenatal infection, as is the case for other prenatal viral infections (Barbi et al, 1996; Johansson et al, 1997; Fischler et al, 1999).

Adenovirus DNA sequences have not been detected in cell lines derived from childhood ALL (LR Gooding, unpublished), and, indeed, MacKenzie et al (2006) recently reported that no potential ‘exogenous’ DNA could be detected in leukaemia cells by representational difference analysis, indicating that no DNA virus was present in the cells. Gene products of adenovirus can transform cells in culture by a hit-and-run mechanism that leaves no viral DNA in the transformed cells (Nevels et al, 2001). Because species C adenoviruses profoundly block double-stranded DNA-break repair (Weitzman and Ornelles, 2005), it is conceivable that infection with species C adenovirus could lead to the acquisition of genomic mutations common to childhood ALL.

The finding of a significantly elevated frequency of species C adenovirus DNA in Guthrie cards of children who later developed ALL suggests a potential role for adenovirus at an early stage in the development of this disease. Further research is necessary to determine if this species has a causative role in this disease.