Six out of 10 consultants in England who voted have agreed to a new NHS contract that will change the way they work.
Slightly fewer specialist registrars were in favour of the new brokered deal, with 55% of those who voted saying yes.
The result is a reversal of the first ballot on the new contract last November, when 66% of consultants and 84% of specialist registrars rejected the offer (BMJ 2002;325: 1053) and threatened to take industrial action if a better deal was not offered (BMJ 2003;326: 1165). Altogether nearly 70% of the 29 000 eligible consultants took part in the ballot, and 37% of the 8500 eligible specialist registrars voted.
Dr Paul Miller, chairman of the BMA's consultants' committee, welcomed the result and admitted that the last few months of negotiations with the government have been tense but that ministers had failed to implement local contracts in place of a national deal.
"This is a much improved contract to the one offered last year, and I am pleased to see that most of my consultant and junior colleagues share this view. This result also gives a clear yes to a national contract as opposed to local deals," he said.
Under the new contract consultants stand to see their pay rise by an average of 15%. However, doctors who devote a higher proportion of their time to the NHS could see their salaries rise by as much as 24%.
The major sticking point to accepting the original contract was the "excessive and inappropriate managerial control" over when and how consultants should work, which had more to do with reaching government targets than with the clinical care of patients, said Dr Miller. However, under the new deal the focus will be on "joint planning where consultants and managers sit down and work out what needs to be done," he said.
Consultants in England have until the end of the month to sign up to the new deal.
Results of the BMA's ballot of Scottish consultants are due at the end of the week. Hospital doctors in Wales will be voting on their contract over the next few weeks, with the results due in mid-November. Negotiations are still under way in Northern Ireland, with no date yet set for a ballot.
Figure 1.
Mr Nizam Mamode, chairman of the consultants' negotiating subcommittee, faces questions over the ballot result
Credit: ROB BELL/BMA NEWS

