Boron deficiency

Abstract

Boron (B) is an essential micronutrient for vascular plants. Boron plays a structural role in cell walls through binding to pectic polysaccharides. It still remains unclear how B deficiency, and hence probably alterations in cell wall structure, leads to various metabolic disorders and cell death. To understand the process, we analyzed the physiological changes in suspension- cultured tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum) BY-2 cells under B deficiency. The results indicated that the cells deprived of B did not undergo a typical programmed cell death process. Oxidative damage was proven to be the direct and major cause of cell death. We discuss possible mechanisms for the generation and accumulation of reactive oxygen species under B deprivation.

Boron (B) deficiency is the most widespread micronutrient deficiency around the world and causes large losses in crop production both quantitatively and qualitatively.¹ Boron deficiency affects vegetative and reproductive growth of plants resulting in inhibition of cell expansion, death of meristem and reduced fertility.²

Plants contain B both in a water-soluble and insoluble form. In intact plants, the amount of water-soluble B fluctuates with the quantity of B supplied, while insoluble B does not.³ The appearance of B deficiency symptoms coincides with the decrease of water-insoluble B, from which it is concluded that the insoluble B is the functional form while the soluble B represents the surplus. We found at least 98% of the insoluble B in tobacco cells bound to the cell wall,⁴ and identified their molecular entity as the borate diester with rhamnogalacturonan II (RG-II) regions of pectic polysaccharides.⁵ The diester crosslinks pectic polysaccharides to form a network and thereby contributes to construction of a supramolecular cell wall structure.⁶ Mutant plants with altered RG-II structures are dwarf and sterile, indicating that the B-RG-II complex is essential for normal plant growth and development.⁷ Increasing evidence indicates that B is also essential for animals.⁸ The requirement for B in organisms lacking cell walls implies that B may also have additional roles in plants. To date, however, no molecule other than apiosyl residues in pectic polysaccharides has been demonstrated to form a borate ester which could be stable enough under physiological conditions. Thus it is reasonable to consider that B functions primarily, if not exclusively, as a structural component of the cell wall, and B deficiency symptoms arise from disturbance of the cell wall structure. How, then, does the disturbed cell wall structure lead to the damage and cell death that are observed under B deficiency? To understand the linkage, we have analyzed physiological changes of suspension-cultured tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum) BY-2 cells under B deficiency.

When cells at the log phase of growth were transferred to B-free media, cell death was detectable as early as 12 h after the treatment. As cell walls play pivotal roles in plant development and growth, we assumed that the B deprivation, which probably causes aberrant cell wall structure, might induce programmed cell death (PCD) as an active response to eliminate damaged cells. Then we examined if the known biochemical hallmark of PCD could be observed in cells deprived of B (hereafter referred to as -B cells). However, internucleosomal DNA fragmentation, decrease in antioxidant content and antioxidant enzyme expression,⁹ or protection from death by cycloheximide, were not detected in these cells, suggesting that the cell death is necrosis. We found oxidative damage to be the direct and major cause of cell death, because -B cells contained more reactive oxygen species (ROS) than control cells, and because cell death was effectively suppressed by supplementing the media with lipophilic antioxidants. The deprivation treatment did not induce an oxidative burst, as the extracellular H₂O₂ concentration was not significantly different between -B and control cells at all time points examined. Resupply of B immediately suppressed cell death. Collectively, these results suggest that low but persistent ROS production occurred under the -B condition.

In the study described above, we demonstrated that B deprivation, and hence probably a defective cell wall structure, leads to oxidative damage. How and why B deprivation induces ROS overproduction remains to be clarified. We hypothesize that ROS are originally produced as a signal for disturbance of the cell wall structure, and build up to a toxic level unless B is resupplied and the cell wall structure is restored. It has been reported that the mechanical strength of the squash root cell wall decreases within minutes after B deprivation.^10,11 The mechanical change could be brought about by insufficient crosslinking of pectic polysaccharides at RG-II regions, as the B-RG-II complex significantly contributes to the wall tensile strength.¹² If the cell wall becomes weaker and less resistant to turgor, then the plasma membrane would stretch. The change may lead to opening of mechanosensitive channels¹³ and generation of signals for the altered cell wall structure. To test this hypothesis, we are now analyzing the immediate and early responses of tobacco BY-2 cells to B deprivation, and preliminary results do indicate the involvement of Ca²⁺ influx in the responses. Identification of the mechanism by which cells sense the external B status will greatly contribute to our understanding of the cell wall-symplast interaction in plants.¹⁴

Addendum to: Koshiba T, Kobayashi M, Matoh T. Boron nutrition of tobacco BY-2 cells V. Oxidative damage is the major cause of cell death induced by boron deprivation. Plant Cell Physiol. 2009;50:26–36. doi: 10.1093/pcp/pcn184.