A Comparative Plasmonic Study of Nanoporous and Evaporated Gold Films

Abstract

Previously, we have reported that nanoporous gold (NPG) films prepared by a chemical dealloying method have distinctive plasmonic properties, i.e., they can simultaneously support localized and propagating surface plasmon resonance modes (l-SPR and p-SPR, respectively). In this study, the plasmonic properties of NPG are quantified through direct comparison with thermally evaporated gold (EG) films. Cyclic voltammetry and electrochemical impedance spectroscopy experiments reveal that the NPG films have 4–8.5 times more accessible surface area than EG films. Assemblies of streptavidin–latex beads generate p-SPR responses on both NPG and EG films that correlate well with the bead density obtained from scanning electron microscopy (SEM) images. A layer-by-layer assembly experiment on NPG involving biotinylated anti-avidin IgG and avidin, studied by l-SPR and SEM, shows that the l-SPR signal is directly linked to the accessibility of the interior of the NPG porosity, an adjustable experimental parameter that can be set by the dealloying condition and time.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (doi:10.1007/s11468-007-9048-5) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Introduction

There is continued interest [1–6] in discovering nanoporous metallic materials for sensing, catalysis, and filtration purposes. Recently, we reported a facile approach to the fabrication of large area, thin, metallic nanoporous gold (NPG) membranes. NPG is formed by a spontaneous pattern-forming instability during the chemical etching of silver from gold/silver alloys, the so-called dealloying process. An analytical atomistic model presented earlier [7] has clarified the underlying physics of porosity evolution during the dealloying. In contrast to the majority of porous metallic nanostructures that are generally controlled aggregates of metallic nanoparticles [8], NPG retains a spatially coherent crystal lattice that extends to the scale of the original grain structure of the non-porous alloy. Extending the dealloying time can significantly coarsen the grain structure in NPG [9] as a result of gold atom surface diffusion driven by surface-energy reduction. Therefore, the porosity may be conveniently adjusted from less than 10 nm up to the macroscopic scale of the original starting material [9].

NPG with ∼15 nm pores itself is not gold-colored (it is a dark bronze), and elucidation of its optical properties, as they correlate to its nanoscale morphology, is a clear research direction. Indeed, in our recent report, we have found intriguing plasmonic properties of NPG that point to the utility of this material in (bio)sensing contexts [10]. Specifically, NPG was found to simultaneously support both propagating surface plasmon resonance (p-SPR) modes and localized surface plasmon resonances (l-SPR). Propagating surface plasmons are evanescent electromagnetic waves bound to flat metal-dielectric interfaces that arise from oscillations of the conduction electrons in the metal. If surface plasmons are confined to periodic, colloidal, or other nanosystems, localized optical modes are observed. These optical modes lead to highly localized electromagnetic fields outside the particles. Both p-SPR and l-SPR are sensitive to local refractive index changes that occur if target analytes bind to the metal film or nanoparticles. Surface refractive index sensors have an inherent advantage over fluorescence optical biosensors that require a chromophoric group or other luminescence label to transduce the binding event.

The compatibility of NPG with these two state-of-art sensing methods immediately opens up numerous sensing opportunities for NPG. In our research, we have discovered that the use of NPG is not a reiteration of “another kind of metal” for plasmonic sensing. There are unique properties linked to the porosity. First, NPG provides a greatly enhanced surface-to-volume ratio, which is beneficial for better reaction efficiency and detection sensitivity. Second, porous materials in general are particularly useful as separation media owing to their size-selectivity in chromatographical isolation, adsorption, catalysis, etc. The nanosized porous structure strongly affects the sequential build-up of functional supramolecular architectures on substrates that is inherent in the sensing process itself. The diffusion of molecules to the NPG interior is hindered if the pore size is comparable with the molecular dimension; this “molecular sieve” effect can be used for size-selective adsorption and examination of diffusional kinetics through nanoscale channels. Third, by simultaneously supporting p-SPR and l-SPR modes, NPG effectively probes the interfacial refractive index variations at the drastically different scales associated with each plasmonic mode. Fourth and finally, for supported membrane applications, NPG can double as an effective water reservoir and conductive substrate for electrochemical investigations.

This report presents a quantitative side-by-side comparison of NPG films with evaporated gold (EG) films. We discuss the following experiments. Firstly, an electrochemical oxidation experiment was conducted to study the area ratio of NPG compared to EG films. Secondly, p-SPR modes were employed to monitor the growth of a biological multilayer involving the assembly of streptavidin-coated latex beads, which generate quantifiable signals recorded by two methods, i.e., by p-SPR and by scanning electron microscopy (SEM) images. Finally, a layer-by-layer (LbL) assembling experiment on NPG involving biotinylated anti-avidin IgG and avidin was performed and monitored by both l-SPR and SEM.

Experimental

NPG fabrication

NPG leaf membranes were produced by dealloying ∼100 nm thick, 12-carat white-gold decorative leaf (Ag/Au 1:1 ratio by weight) in 70% nitric acid for certain time period [9] (etching time) and were bonded onto LaSFN9 glass slides (Schott Glass, n = 1.85 at λ = 632.8 nm) pre-functionalized by 3-mercaptopropyltrimethoxysilane to promote adhesion and stability [11] of the metal membranes under aqueous buffer conditions.

By applying a potential during the residence time of the NPG in the nitric acid, the dealloying process happened within seconds, and very small pore sizes (∼5 nm) could be achieved.

Electrochemical experiments

Electrochemical studies including cyclic voltammetry (CV) and electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) were carried out using an Autolab PGSTAT 30 (Ecochemie) with an internal frequency response analyzer. The gold films (nanoporous or evaporated) supported on a glass slide were used as the working electrodes. The electrochemical Teflon cell was tightly clamped to the gold slide with an o-ring, which defined an active surface area of 0.77 cm². A platinum coil counter electrode and a silver/silver chloride reference electrode (World Precision Instruments, DriRef-2) completed the cell. The electrolyte was either 0.1 M KNO₃ or 1 M sulfuric acid. Impedance spectra were fit using the modeling program of the Ecochemie FRA software. The equivalent circuit waswhere R_S was the series resistance, R_F the Faradaic resistance, and C_dl the double layer capacitance. The impedance spectra reported were taken at 0.3 V vs silver/silver chloride in 1 M sulfuric acid; at this potential, no Faradaic peaks were seen in the CV results.

SPR set-up

For the p-SPR measurement, a home-built surface plasmon resonance spectrometer based on the Kretschmann configuration was used, which has been described in detail elsewhere [12]. Briefly, a linearly polarized, frequency-modulated laser source (HeNe, 10 mW, λ = 1152 nm; Laser 2000) illuminates the gold film through a right-angled LaSFN9 glass prism. The reflected laser intensity is measured by a photo-diode detector connected to a lock-in amplifier. The sample (prism, gold slide, and quartz flow cell) and the detector are mounted to two co-axial goniometers, respectively. L-SPR was measured simultaneously using a fiber optic spectrometer (USB2000, Ocean Optics) equipped with a reflection probe (R400-7, Ocean Optics) and a light source (HL-2000, Ocean Optics). The l-SPR experiments measured the reflection spectrum of the gold sample through a quartz window of a flow-cell clamped to the sample. The reflection spectra (R) shown in the figures were measured by taking the ratio between the raw detector spectrum for the measurement sample (I_sample) and the raw detector spectrum for the reference sample (I_ref). The dark signal (I_dark) was subtracted from the raw spectra:

1

Protein multilayer formation

Gold (nanoporous or evaporated) films were first functionalized by a biotinylated self-assembled monolayer containing ∼10% of the biotin groups [13]. Next, a streptavidin layer was formed from a 1-μM streptavidin (Roche Diagnostics) solution followed by a biotinylated IgG antibody (Molecular Probes) layer from a 1-μM IgG solution. Finally, a 1% (w/v) streptavidin-doped polystyrene latex (Roche Diagnostics) solution was introduced into the flow-cell. The streptavidin-modified polystyrene latex beads were obtained from Roche Diagnostics and had an average radius of r = 56 nm; the refractive index was n = 1.56 at λ = 1152 nm. They were diluted in phosphate buffer with 0.01% (w/t) Tween-20^R.

A fast-growing LbL assembly system based on avidin (Sigma) and biotinylated anti-avidin antibody (BAA) was also employed as model system. Gold (nanoporous or evaporated) films were first functionalized by the biotinylated SAMs. Then, avidin/BAA solutions (both 1 μM in PBS buffer with 0.01% (w/t) Tween-20^R) were alternated in the flow cell, leading to the stepwise formation of an avidin/BAA multilayer. The use of BAA significantly enhanced the recognition probability to avidin and accelerated the layer thickness increase (Supporting Materials 1).

Phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) with 0.01% (w/t) Tween-20^R was used as solvent for all the sample solutions. For each layer-forming step, the binding was monitored kinetically and terminated by a PBS buffer rinse once equilibrium was reached.

Results and discussions

Electrochemical characterization

The surface area of the NPG was characterized by CV and by EIS. In the CV, an oxide layer was formed at potentials positive of 1 V during the anodic scans in 1 M sulfuric acid. On the subsequent cathodic scans, the oxide layer was stripped and a sharp peak was seen in the voltammograms [14] (Fig. 1). The area under the reduction peak is proportional to the charge needed to reduce the gold oxide monolayer and is related to the surface area of the gold film [15].

Fig. 1.

The cyclic voltammogram for a 15-min-etched NPG sample is depicted. Gold oxides were formed at positive potentials and reduced at less positive potentials. The sweep rate was 100 mV s⁻¹, and the electrolyte was 1 M H₂SO₄. The current in milli amperes is plotted vs the potential in volts with respect to the silver/silver chloride reference electrode

Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy was used to obtain values for the double layer capacitance of the NPG films [16]. Provided the distance of the closest approach of the counter ions is sufficiently small, the double layer capacitance will be proportional to the surface area of the gold films.

Figure 2 shows the variation in the surface area of the NPG with respect to chemical dealloying time, measured by both CV and EIS. In all cases, it is assumed that the EG films had a surface area of 1, and the numbers shown refer to the surface increase relative to these films. All NPG films show an enhanced surface area relative to EG.

Fig. 2.

CV and EIS measurements reveal a surface area enhancement for the chemically dealloyed NPG samples compared to EG

The NPG films chemically etched under free corrosion for 5 min have surface areas six times larger than the EG. The largest surface increase (∼10-fold) was seen for the sample chemically etched for 15 min. Chemical dealloying times longer than 15 min led to a decrease in the surface area enhancement. This decrease was thought to correlate to the collapse of the porous 3D structure into a 2D structure, which can be seen in the lateral view of the SEM images [9]. The surface enhancement measured by CV agrees broadly with that measured by EIS; in addition, the same trends are seen by both methods with respect to increasing chemical dealloying time.

Streptavidin-doped bead density

A multilayer system was built on NPG substrates that were etched for 5 min. The streptavidin beads, with an average diameter of d = 112 nm, were chosen because they generate a significant SPR signal and the beads can be easily visualized by SEM. Therefore, the bead density could be quantified by both methods, and a comparison could be made in order to verify the applicability of NPG as a SPR supporting substrate. As shown in the schematics (Fig. 3a), two protein layers, streptavidin and biotinylated IgG, were pre-deposited on NPG (5 min etched) and EG films, respectively, to generate a dense layer of biotin functional groups. As reported in our previous paper [10], twice as much streptavidin binding occurred on NPG compared to EG. Only double the coverage was measured because streptavadin is a large molecule, and due to the steric hindrance, only a fraction of the NPG area was accessible to it. The subsequent biotinylated IgG binding amount was comparable for both films, which can also be attributed to the size selectivity of the NPG surface.

Fig. 3.

Multi-layer formation on NPG-a model system: a A schematic representation on which the measurements are based. b p-SPR (λ = 1152 nm) measurements in buffer condition monitoring of streptavidin/ biotinylated IgG bindings on biotin SAM modified 100 nm thick NPG membrane and 50 nm evaporated gold film surface, respectively. Additionally polystyrene latex bead were deposited on top of the supramolecular architecture. For both substrates, curve (1) is for SAM modified sample, curve (2) for after streptavidin binding, curve (3) for after biotinylated IgG binding; and finally curve (4) represents the latex bead binding result

Furthermore, we should note that a near-infrared laser with a wavelength of λ = 1152 nm was used to compensate for the heavy damping loss of SPR propagation on NPG surface, which has also been discussed in our previous report [10].

The bead binding generated a significant SPR minimum shift for both the NPG and the EG films. In this study, we consider a virtual ‘layer’ composed of polystyrene beads and water, with a constant thickness given by the bead diameter (112 nm) and a variable refractive index representing the change in bead coverage. The averaged dielectric constant ɛ_average is assumed to be the weighted average of each component:

2

where ɛ_water and ɛ_bead are the dielectric constants of water and bead, respectively, and χ is the volume ratio of the beads. During binding, the increase of χ leads to the increase of ɛ_average. Fresnel fits were conducted to give the optical thickness change before and after bead binding. Because the thickness of the ‘layer’ is fixed, ɛ_average and χ can be determined by Fresnel fits. We made two simplifications for this calculation process. First, we considered ɛ_average to be constant normal to the surface of the layer, i.e., we treat the spherical bead as cylinders. Due to the exponential decay of the SPR wave, this simplification will introduce a certain error in the output. However, because we used a λ = 1152 nm laser, the evanescent wave of SPR has a 1/e decay length of 350–500 nm, inside which a 112 nm thick layer can be treated as a relatively ‘thin’ layer. Moreover, the overestimation and underestimation caused by top, middle, and bottom part of the spherical bead are, to some extent, mutually cancelled. Second, as can be seen in the Fig. 3b, the binding of the beads not only shifts the SPR curve but also increases the minimum reflectivity (in EG’s case) or broadens the dip width (in the NPG case). This is primarily due to the enhanced scattering loss of the SPR field attributed to the new surface ‘roughness’ introduced by the beads, which have a size comparable to the wavelength of the light and have a refractive index significantly higher than the surrounding medium, i.e., water. Fortunately, this scattering loss, within certain range, should not significantly influence the angular position of the SPR minimum (see Supporting Materials 2). Therefore, the Fresnel fit in the bead binding step was only targeted to fit the SPR minimum position, i.e., only the real part of ɛ_average was adjusted.

The bead-modified surfaces were also imaged by SEM (cf. Fig. 4). One can see that on both surfaces, the beads tend to form similar patterns, i.e., they adhere to each other to form chains and islands and there seems to be a certain spacing distance between islands. Although concentrated bead suspensions were used, the bead coverage was in the range of 20–30%. Both SPR and SEM data provide the bead coverage results presented in Table 1. For both NPG and EG, SPR and SEM give comparable results for the coverage. This leads to the conclusion that NPG can be used as a substrate that supports propagating SPR, and this p-SPR can be used to quantify the binding that happens outside, on the surface of, the nanopores of NPG.

Fig. 4.

Scanning electron images of latex beads assembled on a NPG sample and b evaporated gold sample

Table 1.

Latex bead coverage results obtained by p-SPR and SEM on NPG (two substrates shown) and flat gold samples

Gold film	ɛbead	ɛwater	ɛave	Volume ratio (SPR; %)	Volume ratio (SEM)
NPG	2.434	1.752	1.94	27.6	29 ± 2%
NPG			1.892	20.5	21 ± 2%
EG			1.945	28.3	27 ± 2%

LbL deposition study

Further refractive index studies on different samples were carried out using the same optical setup. The refractive index was tuned either in the bulk by glycerol solutions or at the interface by multilayer deposition (Fig. 5). The refractive index change was experimentally compared for two NPG substrates possessing different pore sizes (5-min etched NPG as NPG5 min, 24-h etched NPG as NPG24h) and for an EG film. After injecting various glycerol concentrations (from 5 to 60%), the EG film showed only a limited absorbance at a wavelength range (∼400–500 nm) near the noise range of the white-light lamp serving as the excitation source. This absorbance also seen, even more pronouncedly, for both NPG samples, which still lacks a satisfying explanation. In addition to that, both NPG samples soaked in glycerol solutions that permeate into the pores exhibited significant changes in their absorbance spectra (∼530–800 nm). Exposure to higher glycerol concentrations caused an obvious increase in the peak intensity and a slight red shift of the peak position; both are strong evidence for the excitation of localized SPR [17]. The peak wavelength is slightly higher for NPG24h (λ = 625 nm) than for NPG5min (λ = 590 nm) due to the larger nanosized features in NPG24h.

Fig. 5.

Relative reflection absorbance spectra of a a flat evaporated gold film, b a 5-min dealloyed NPG, and c a 24-h dealloyed NPG, upon exposure to a series of glycerol solutions (5, 15, 35, and 60%). The relative reflection absorbance spectra of d a flat evaporated gold film, e a 5-min dealloyed NPG, f a 24-h dealloyed NPG, during LbL deposition of 3.5 Avidin/BAA double-layers. The gold (evaporated or nanoporous) film was pre-functionalized by a biotinylated self assembled monolayer containing ∼10% functional biotin groups. Then an avidin layer was formed followed by a biotinylated antiavidin antibody layer. The spectra were recorded after the respective protein layer was complete

A LbL assembly system (different from the LbL system used in our previous work) [18] was employed in this study to dynamically and quickly alter the interfacial refractive index. The use of biotinylated anti-avidin IgG and avidin formed a mutual recognition system and greatly enhanced the thickness of each double layer (d∼9.3 nm with an assumed refractive index of n = 1.45). This fast-growing LbL system has been studied extensively in our group [19].

In comparison to the LbL system used in our previous report [10], which involved oppositely charged dendrimers with a molecular weight of ∼35 kDa, the current system has a molecular size that can cause dramatically different binding pattern on NPGs with different pore sizes. As shown in the SEM pictures (cf. Fig. 6), the protein layers on NPG5min have a distinct interface to the NPG film, meaning that the proteins are mostly binding onto the NPG. In contrast, in the NPG24h image, it is hard to tell where the protein layer starts, which clearly indicates binding of the proteins inside the pores.

Fig. 6.

SEM images of a a 5-min-etched NPG after LbL deposition of 18 double layers of avidin/BAA. b A 24-h-etched NPG after deposition of 11 double layers of avidin/BAA

The SEM observation is confirmed by the l-SPR results. For clarity, we only show the 3.5 double-layer-depositing process (cf. Fig. 5d–f). On the EG surface, there is a growing peak between 430–600 nm. This turned out to be a typical reflective interference phenomenon caused by the deposited dielectric layer, as manifested by the later periodical oscillation in reflectivity as the protein layer grew (data not shown). A similar interference pattern was observed on NPG5m. In the NPG24h curves, we saw not only a similar interference pattern but also a distinctive peak at 625 nm, exactly matching its peak induced by glycerol irrigation. In contrast, the curves of NPG5min sample are free of the peak at its characteristic wavelength, 590 nm. This observation is in agreement with the SEM image that only proteins binding into the nanopores can modify the dielectric environment and thus alters l-SPR signal. The fast saturation of l-SPR signal is also in agreement with the fact that l-SPR has very short evanescent decay (∼10–20 nm).

Conclusion

A series of comparative experiments between NPG and EG samples are reported. The electrochemical experiments indicate a nearly one order-of-magnitude enhancement of surface area for NPG over EG. The streptavidin-doped bead binding experiment shows the utility of NPG for quantitative p-SPR measurement. Finally, the LbL assembly experiment reveals the different binding mode of large biomolecules (e.g., avidin and IgG) to NPGs possessing different pore sizes, a hypothesis supported by both l-SPR and SEM observation. Our observations will help to further understand the character of NPG as a novel plasmonic substrate for wider applications.