OVERALL RATING Very good
STRENGTHS Well researched and referenced
WEAKNESSES Arranged chronologically; too detailed in parts
AUDIENCE Medical professionals with an interest in humanities; historians, amateur or professional
In an age that has brought the world severe acute respiratory syndrome and the threat of pandemic influenza, Dr Ian Cameron’s historical account of quarantine on Lawlor’s Island sheds important light on how communicable disease was managed in Canada during the great period of immigrant expansion. The story is concurrently the history of communicable disease and maritime travel, of health care in Nova Scotia, and of the growth of the Dominion of Canada through immigration.
The American philosopher George Santayana once cynically noted, “History is a pack of lies about events that never happened told by people who weren’t there.” Ensuring the accuracy of the information contained within, Dr Cameron has made a meticulous study of available historical references and relied primarily on first-hand accounts.
Dr Cameron has written a definitive and complete account of the only substantial quarantine station on Canada’s Atlantic coast at the turn of the 20th century. In introducing his book, he reflects on his emotional connection to and curiosity about remnants of old structures that once served the island. In cataloguing the chronology, there are at times tales of mismanagement and ineptitude. More commonly, the reader is given an account of disaster averted. Some anecdotes are heart-wrenching, involving loss, suffering, and despair, and not uncommonly the victims are young children. Intertwined with those are stories of hope and perseverance in the face of adversity. The account of the arrival and quarantine of the Doukhobors is a particularly poignant tale of human migration.
We live in a time when fear of contagion is relatively subdued. To learn the lessons of the effective containment of communicable disease in maritime Canada a full century ago serves to help us gain an appreciation of our public health system today. More important, it beckons us to properly prepare for the next pandemic.