Skip to main content
The BMJ logoLink to The BMJ
. 2003 Dec 6;327(7427):1304.

Mental health bill will be subject to pre-legislative scrutiny

Roger Dobson 1
PMCID: PMC286347

A revised mental health bill for England and Wales is to be brought forward as soon as possible and will be subject to pre-legislative scrutiny.

The government also plans to monitor the use of compulsion, an area of the draft bill published last year that proved highly controversial (BMJ 2003;326: 406-7).

The bill, described as the first major overhaul relating to mental health since the 1950s, was said to remove a loophole that allowed people with dangerous and severe personality disorders to avoid treatment by arguing that they got no benefit from it. But critics of the draft bill said that it would mean that many people with incurable personality disorders could be locked up indefinitely in secure mental hospitals, without the need for evidence that they had committed a crime.

The bill was expected to be brought to the last parliamentary session, but it was not. Now the health secretary, John Reid, says that the government is fully committed to reforming mental health legislation.

He said, “We must make significant improvements to patient safeguards, provide a modern framework of legislation in line with modern patterns of care and treatment and human rights law, and protect public safety by enabling patients to get the right treatment at the right time.”

“In order to achieve our objectives it will be vital to get the legislation right. To that end it is important that a strong part is played by parliament in scrutinising the bill.”

Dr Tony Zigmond, vice president of the Royal College of Psychiatrists, said there were still concerns: “We hope that the provisions in the new legislation will be very significantly changed, particularly those on the definition of mental disorder and the criteria for compulsion.”

The chief executive of MIND (a mental health charity), Richard Brook, said: “We welcome the commitment to put the proposed bill before pre-legislative scrutiny. Unless the needs and concerns of people with mental health problems are properly taken into account in this process, and reflected in any subsequent legislation, they [legislators] will once more be neglecting their most important stakeholders.”


Articles from BMJ : British Medical Journal are provided here courtesy of BMJ Publishing Group

RESOURCES