Using Complementary and Alternative Medicines to Target the Host Response during Severe Influenza

Abstract

It is now accepted that an overwhelming inflammatory response is the cause of human deaths from avian H5N1 influenza infection. With this in mind we sought to examine the literature for examples of complementary and alternative medicines that reduce inflammation, and to place the results of this search in the context of our own work in a mouse model of influenza disease, using a pharmaceutical agent with anti-inflammatory properties. Two Chinese herbs, Angelica sinensis (Dang Gui) and Salvia miltiorrhiza (Danshen), have been recently shown to protect mice during lethal experimental sepsis via inhibition of the novel inflammatory cytokine High Mobility Group Box 1 protein (HMGB1). Biochanin A, a ligand of the peroxisome proliferator activated receptors (PPAR) alpha and gamma and the active isoflavone in Trifolium pratense (red clover), has anti-inflammatory properties, and thus could be used as an influenza treatment. This is of great interest since we have recently shown that gemfibrozil, a drug used to treat hyperlipidemia in humans and a synthetic ligand of PPAR alpha, significantly reduces the mortality associated with influenza infections in mice. The inflammation-modulating abilities of these natural agents should be considered in light of what is now known about the mechanisms of fatal influenza, and tested as potential candidates for influenza treatments in their own right, or as adjunct treatments to antivirals.

Introduction

It is now generally accepted that the infectious agent in isolation does not cause the illness and fatal outcome seen in acute systemic infectious diseases. Instead, the pathogen induces host cells to generate excessive amounts of pro-inflammatory cytokines, the prototypic example being tumor necrosis factor (TNF), that alter organ function and host metabolism, thus generating the disease we observe (1,2). This general concept, originally proposed to describe the severe disease caused by malaria infection (3), then sepsis (4) and influenza (5), has taken root in the mainstream, and is now often referred to as the ‘cytokine storm’ (6).

Influenza researchers have embraced the cytokine storm mechanism as an explanation for the fatal human disease caused by avian H5N1 influenza (7–9). Likewise, the pandemic influenza outbreak of 1918 is likely to have induced an overwhelming and fatal cytokine response in humans, as mice and monkeys infected with a reconstructed 1918 influenza virus exhibited a dysregulated immune response and hypercytokinemia, which leads to death (10–12). The inevitable 3–6-month delay in vaccine availability in the event of a pandemic (13) means that treatments to prevent death (but not necessarily infection) are a necessity. Existing problems with antiviral drugs (stockpiles not big enough to treat populations, drugs need to be taken prophylactically or very soon after infection, resistant virus strains have emerged) further necessitate investigation into other treatments (14). Targeting the detrimental host response generated by particularly pathogenic strains of influenza virus would allow disease severity to be reduced to the point where people will be sick, but will not die as a result of infection. We see agents with an ability to damp inflammatory cytokine release [be they natural or pharmaceutical (15)] as ideal candidates for influenza disease treatments, particularly during the period while a new vaccine is being generated, and as useful adjunct treatments to antivirals. As has been suggested for statins (16), using agents that are in use in the human population for the treatment of other conditions means that the safety of such agents is already established, as is the optimal human dose range.

A New Pharmaceutical Treatment for Severe Influenza?

We have found that the pharmaceutical agent, gemfibrozil, already used in the human population to treat hyperlipidemia, protects a significant proportion of mice infected with influenza virus (H2N2) from developing a fatal disease (17). Gemfibrozil belongs to the fibrate class of drugs, which, like statins, are used to lower blood lipid levels, although fibrates differ in their mechanism of action. Gemfibrozil is a synthetic ligand for the peroxisome proliferator activated receptor (PPAR) alpha. This nuclear receptor controls lipid homeostasis, with fatty acids and eicosanoids as endogenous ligands (18,19). We chose gemfibrozil for its known ability to reduce release of inflammatory cytokines, including TNF, interleukin (IL)-6 and interferon-γ (IFN-γ), as well its ability to inhibit the nuclear translocation of the transcription factor nuclear factor κ-B (NF-κB) (20–22), and hypothesized that these drug side-effects might be useful in ameliorating influenza disease, as has already been suggested (23). We have found that the protective ability of gemfibrozil during influenza infections is likely to be a fibrate class effect, since fenofibrate also reduces the mortality of influenza virus-infected mice (unpublished data). Gemfibrozil lowers serum IL-6 levels in mice infected with influenza virus (unpublished data) but its effects on other aspects of the host immune response are not yet known, and remain the subject of our further study.

It is important to note that the use of fibrates and statins in the human population for lipid-lowering has not, to our knowledge, enhanced susceptibility to viral disease. This is probably due to the fact that the innate antiviral response to infection, for example expression of the antiviral protein, Mx, is regulated by type I interferons and not by TNF or IL-1 (24). While TNF has been reported to exert direct antiviral effects against influenza virus in vitro (25) its antiviral effects in vivo are less clear. Administration of neutralizing anti-TNF antibodies during the course of influenza in mice did not increase viral titers, and the infection still resolved (26). Furthermore, the course of infection of H5N1 influenza virus was not worsened in mice genetically unable to produce TNF (27). It is therefore unlikely that agents that interfere with expression of pro-inflammatory cytokines such as TNF will enhance susceptibility to influenza, but this remains to be experimentally tested.

The strategy of selecting agents with anti-inflammatory properties need not only apply to pharmaceutical agents. There are already precedents in the literature for the use of natural agents to treat severe infections such as influenza. Ginseng and Salviae (28) have been trialed for their abilities to improve influenza vaccination outcomes with good results, and may also modulate cytokines to reduce immunopathology during influenza infections. Researchers working during the SARS outbreak used complementary medicines to treat a small number of SARS patients with good results, and suggested that these treatments might be useful in treating cases of avian influenza (29,30). A recent review of the antiviral and immunomodulatory effects of compounds isolated from plants and traditional Chinese medicines describes a Chinese study in which FM1 influenza virus-infected mice were given the traditional Chinese medicine Yiqi Qingwen Jiedu Heji (31). Researchers found that this treatment reduced expression of the cytokines TNF, IL-6 and IFN-γ in the lungs of FM1 influenza-infected mice, all of which are implicated in inflammation, and increased levels of the anti-inflammatory cytokine IL-10, the combined effect being a shortened course of influenza disease (32). Glycyrrhizin, an active component of liquorice roots, when given to mice from one day before infection with influenza virus (H2N2), protected all treated mice from fatality while all control mice died (33). What is most interesting about this result is that glycyrrhizin binds to, and inactivates, the novel pro-inflammatory mediator High Mobility Group Box 1 protein (HMGB1) (34), which is elevated in the serum of sepsis patients who succumbed to infection (35).

With these non-pharmaceutical precedents in mind, we searched the literature for examples of complementary and alternative medicines used to treat conditions other than influenza that are characterized by increased pro-inflammatory cytokine levels, for their potential to mitigate the host response during severe influenza.

Looking Towards Other Conditions for Clues

Sepsis

Experimental models for sepsis provide an excellent avenue for understanding pathophysiology and mechanisms of disease during severe inflammatory states. Because sepsis is characterized by a prolonged inflammatory state that, if untreated, results in death (36), it is comparable to the cytokine storm that ensues in H5N1 influenza infections in people. Any agents that have proven to be of benefit in sepsis models should be considered as candidates for influenza treatments, and we have found several examples in the literature of complementary medicines that do this.

The low molecular weight fraction of an aqueous extract of the Chinese herb Angelica sinensis (Dang Gui) is dose-dependently protective during lethal experimental sepsis and endotoxemia (37). Ninety percent of mice were saved during lethal endotoxemia (when only 30% of controls survived) when the extract was given daily, and 70% of mice were saved during lethal sepsis (when only 25% of controls survived) when the extract was given daily. What is most impressive is that in the sepsis model, the repeated administration of the extract was not begun until 24 h after the onset of sepsis, when some animals had already died. The authors also showed that this late administration significantly reduced serum levels of HMGB1, and attributed the rescue of mice in part to the attenuation of systemic HMGB1 accumulation by the herbal extract. This effect on HMGB1 is important as HMGB1 is the only high mobility group protein with an additional extracellular function, a cytokine-like activity (38,39). It is this function that many researchers have become interested in since the first demonstration in 1999 of the presence of high levels of HMGB1 in the serum of mice and human patients with sepsis (35). What is most unusual about HMGB1 is that its secretion continues for an uncommonly long time, with peak levels detected in cell cultures 18 h after stimulation (35). This is in contrast to TNF secretion, for example, which peaks 90 min after the initial stimulus. In turn, once released into the circulation HMGB1 generates a further wave of inflammatory cytokine production (40) through its receptors, the receptor for advanced glycation endproducts [RAGE; (41,42)], and toll-like receptors 2 and 4 (43). This ability to amplify and prolong inflammation is consistent with observations in sepsis where both HMGB1 and other inflammatory cytokines are persistently elevated (44,45).

Recently, the same group of researchers showed that the aqueous extract of another Chinese herb, Salvia miltiorrhiza (Danshen), traditionally used to treat cardiovascular disorders, was also protective against lethal endotoxemia and sepsis by decreasing HMGB1 levels in vivo (46). As for the Dang Gui extract, the Danshen extract was administered 24 h after the onset of sepsis yet still rescued mice. As a potential anti-influenza treatment Danshen may have a double-pronged attack, as it also possesses anti-viral activity (47,48).

Artemisinin, a Chinese herb traditionally used as an anti-malarial drug, has been shown to possess potent anti-inflammatory effects via inhibition of NF-κB (49). It, too, protects against lethal endotoxemia (50) thus warranting its consideration as a potential influenza treatment. Chloroquine possesses antiviral (51) and anti-inflammatory activities (52) and has already been suggested as a potential treatment for pandemic influenza (23).

Ginseng is another herb with potent anti-inflammatory effects. An extract from Korean red ginseng (Panax ginseng, C.A. Meyer) significantly protected mice in experimental sepsis by decreasing TNF, IL-1, IL-6 and IFN-γ production via inhibition of NF-κB activation (53–55). It is likely that Korean ginseng will also reduce HMGB1 levels, because cytokines under the control of NF-κB, such as TNF and IFN-γ, induce HMGB1 (56). Green tea (Camellia sinensis) reduces endotoxin-induced release of HMGB1 and is also proposed to possess the ability to decrease mortality from sepsis if taken regularly (57).

Pancreatitis

Chronic pancreatitis is characterized by increased serum levels of pro-inflammatory cytokines (58). Acute pancreatitis attacks are often followed by multiple organ failure and death, due to the overproduction of inflammatory cytokines (59) and like H5N1 influenza, the ‘cytokine storm’ mechanism has been used to describe this syndrome (60). Serum levels of HMGB1 are known to be elevated during acute pancreatitis (61). Danshen (S. miltiorrhiza), described above as being protective during experimental sepsis, also protects against acute pancreatitis by reducing levels of reactive oxygen species (62), downstream by-products of inflammation. Its use in two syndromes that are characterized by an altered host response, leading to multiple organ failure and death, should make it a priority for influenza researchers interested in examining the effect of immunomodulatory treatments on the course of influenza disease.

Menopause

Pro-inflammatory cytokines are increased during menopause with ensuing pathologies including osteoporosis and atherosclerosis (63). Red clover (Trifolium pratense) isoflavone extracts are widely used for relieving post-menopausal symptoms in women. Biochanin A is the major isoflavone present in red clover, and activates both PPAR alpha and gamma receptors in vitro (64). Gemfibrozil, the synthetic PPAR alpha ligand that increases survival of mice during severe murine influenza (17), possesses anti-inflammatory side effects including inhibition of NF-κB activity; this transcription factor is essential for the transcription of pro-inflammatory genes (21). Similarly, biochanin A has been recently shown to decrease production of the pro-inflammatory cytokine TNF, as well as its downstream mediators nitric oxide and superoxide (65). The fact that biochanin A activates both PPAR alpha and gamma would be an advantage in treating severe influenza, as the PPAR gamma agonist pioglitazone was recently shown to reduce the mortality associated with PR8 influenza in mice (66). It is possible that combining PPAR alpha and gamma activation in one treatment, using biochanin A, may prove more effective in curbing influenza-related mortality than activation of either PPAR receptor alone.

The above examples of complementary medicines, used in seemingly disparate syndromes to treat essentially the same thing—pathological cytokine excess—should provide researchers working in the influenza field with a solid starting point for in vivo studies in animal models of the disease.

A Traditional Chinese Formula Could Also Protect Against Severe Influenza

Prescribed mixtures of Chinese herbs are given to patients with influenza. A common formula contains Jin Yin Hua (honeysuckle flower), Lian Qiao (forsythia fruit), Bo He (field mint), Jing Jie (schizonepeta), Jie Geng (root of balloon flower), Gan Cao (licorice root), Dang Gui (A. sinensis root), Dang Shen (Codonopsis root), Chai Hu (thorowax), Qianghuo (Notopterygium root) and Sheng Jiang (fresh ginger rhizome). Intriguingly, nine of these 11 herbs have been shown to possess anti-inflammatory properties. A. sinensis is dose-dependently protective during lethal experimental sepsis and endotoxemia (37) via its ability to limit release of HMGB1, as has already been discussed. There are many examples of Jie Geng (root of balloon flower), reducing both production of pro-inflammatory cytokines and pro-inflammatory mediators (such as reactive oxygen species and nitric oxide), with these effects likely to be mediated through suppression of activation of NF-κB [e.g. see ref. (67)]. Sheng Jiang (fresh ginger rhizome), Gan Cao (licorice root) and Lian Qiao (forsythia fruit) also reduce levels of inflammatory cytokines via suppression of NF-κB induction (e.g. see refs (68–70). Thus it seems that a mixture of herbs, as traditionally prescribed, is likely to have profound effects on the inflammatory cytokine balance, warranting further investigation of the mixture itself in vitro and in vivo.

Proposed Methodology

HMGB1 has a growing literature on its involvement in the pathogenesis of severe inflammatory states. Large amounts of HMGB1 have been detected in the serum of sepsis patients who succumbed to infection (35). Similarly, during falciparum malaria levels of HMGB1 are higher in patients who do not recover (71). However recent observations paint a more complex picture of the significance of elevated serum HMGB1 measurements. Sepsis patients with severe organ dysfunction had the lowest serum HMGB1 levels of all sepsis patients tested (72), which probably points to a well-known side-effect of acute infection, immunosuppression. We have shown that despite plasma levels of HMGB1 being low at the time of peak mortality in mice infected with A/Japan/305/57 influenza virus (H2N2), HMGB1 may be elevated via its passive release in the lung at this time (73). Therefore it would be important to first ascertain, using animal models of influenza, how levels of HMGB1, in the serum and/or lung, were associated with pathology and/or fatality. Our own work in this area continues, as does our focus on optimizing the way in which HMGB1 is measured for study. Figure 1 shows the likely sources and role of HMGB1 during infection with influenza virus.

Figure 1.

Amplification and prolongation of inflammation by high mobility group box 1 protein (HMGB1) during influenza. Influenza virus-infected airway epithelial cells may passively release HMGB1 [see ref. (92) as an example], while alveolar macrophages, which become infected with influenza virus (93), secrete pro-inflammatory cytokines and may also secrete HMGB1 both actively and passively. MIP is macrophage inflammatory protein. Cytokines (excluding IL-10) commonly reported to be involved in pathogenesis were compiled from (94–96). IL-10 from effector T-cells was recently shown to limit inflammation during acute influenza (97). HMGB1 up-regulates pro-inflammatory cytokine expression via its cellular receptors, the receptor for advanced glycation end products [RAGE; (41,42,98)] and to a lesser extent, toll-like receptor (TLR) 2 and 4 (43,99). RAGE expression was recently shown to be associated with influenza A virus pneumonia, accompanied by increased levels of HMGB1 in bronchoalveolar lavage fluid (100).

Therapeutic interventions in sepsis models, such as administration of ethyl pyruvate (74), an agent that limits HMGB1 release in vitro, or administration of an anti-HMGB1 antibody (75), save a significant proportion of mice, implicating the inhibition of HMGB1 release or activity as a therapeutic target during immune pathology. As previously mentioned, glycyrrhizin protects influenza virus (H2N2)-infected mice from fatality (33) potentially via its ability to bind to, and inactivate, HMGB1 (34). Therefore it would be important to establish whether or not therapeutic intervention with any of the agents discussed here reverse the fatality of severe influenza in animal models via effects on HMGB1 and/or other aspects of the host response.

However, endogenously produced molecules that dampen the effects of HMGB1 in the circulation are also elevated during severe disease states. Thrombomodulin, which binds to HMGB1 and prevents it binding to RAGE (76) is elevated during severe malaria (77), sepsis (78,79) and influenza (80). Paradoxically, it is this binding of HMGB1 to thrombomodulin that also prevents activated protein C generation (81) and thus its ensuing anti-inflammatory activities (82,83). Thus the balance between HMGB1 and thrombomodulin in vivo is likely to be important (81) and should also be determined as part of these studies.

A second, broader strategy could be to examine the traditional Chinese medicine formula discussed here, indeed, any other traditional formulas in their entirety, for anti-inflammatory activity in vitro. Cultured mouse macrophages could be stimulated with either commercially available recombinant influenza virus H5N1 haemagglutinin (HA) or LPS to induce production of pro-inflammatory cytokines, in the presence or absence of the formula, prepared as traditionally described (simmered in boiling water for 45–60 min). Cytokine assays to profile pro- and anti-inflammatory cytokines secreted over time into the culture supernatant could then be conducted, using a system such as multiplexing to examine many different cytokines in each sample (such as anti-inflammatory cytokines IL-4 and IL-10, and pro-inflammatory cytokines IL-1, IL-2, IL-6, IL-8, IL-17, IFN-γ, TNF and HMGB1). Given results which point towards levels of pro-inflammatory cytokines being reduced by treatment of the cells with the formula, the next step would be to conduct studies in mice infected with influenza virus (such as mouse-adapted PR8) and administered the formula orally, daily, adjusted according to body weight. Parameters measured in the in vivo experiments could initially include analysis of serum and lung cytokine levels, body weight and temperature, and even survival, providing researchers could interact with their institutional ethics committee to arrive at a mutually appropriate end-point for euthanasia for experiments of this nature.

Systematic reviews of the literature on clinical trials using traditional Chinese medicine in influenza patients have demonstrated the need for proper design, using randomized controlled trials and sufficiently large study groups to gain meaningful results (84,85) as well as a more systematic approach to disease diagnosis (86). Thus it would be informative to take the insights gained from results in mice into the clinic. Patients hospitalized with influenza could be recruited [see ref. (87) for parameters relating to recruitment] to a randomized controlled trial to determine if treatment with a traditional Chinese medicine formula (for example, the formula previously discussed here) affected the course of disease. It would be prudent to begin treatment immediately, before laboratory confirmation of influenza virus infection. This is because symptoms are apparent at the time of increased serum cytokine levels (87). Obviously patients testing negative to influenza virus would subsequently be excluded from analysis. The decoction would be prepared in the traditional manner (simmering in boiling water for 45–60 min) and administered to patients by hospital staff. The control treatment could simply be a flavored water solution that is stored in the same way as the decoction (at 4°C for not more than 1 week), and consumed daily in the same quantity as the decoction. Both solutions should be colored identically (with a food-grade dye, for example). It would be ideal to ensure the trial was conducted in a double-blind fashion so that neither the patient nor the staff knew which treatment was active. Previous studies have compared the incidence of influenza-like illness in healthcare workers using an herbal formula against those using no agent (88) but results were questioned because workers given the herbal formula knew that they were taking the ‘active’ treatment. While these trials recruited thousands of patients, we suggest that patient numbers could be kept relatively small in the first instance (20 patients per group) if, in addition to patients being unaware of the activity of the treatment they are given, daily blood samples are taken to measure serum levels of cytokines, as for the in vitro assays described above. One milliliter of blood would provide enough serum to analyze cytokine levels, and daily measurements on the same individual would allow for paired statistical analysis. The appropriate end-point would be convalescence, but obviously if symptoms worsened with treatment (or control) then standard interventions should immediately take place. These basic but necessary experiments could pave the way towards viable, low cost alternatives to planned influenza pandemic treatments— approximately $8 for a fortnight's treatment (88). Figure 2 summarizes the possible inflammation-reducing effects of traditional Chinese medicines (e.g. A. sinensis, S. miltiorrhiza and glycyrrhizin), a natural agent (biochanin A), and pharmaceutical interventions (e.g. statins, fibrates), during influenza.

Figure 2.

Potential mitigation of the action of HMGB1 and other pro-inflammatory cytokines by traditional Chinese medicines, a natural agent, and pharmaceutical drugs. The Chinese medicine glycyrrhizin, from liquorice root, binds to HMGB1 and inactivates its biological activities (34), while the Chinese herbs A. sinensis and S. miltiorrhiza reduce the release of HMGB1 (37,46). Release of pro-inflammatory cytokines is reduced via inhibition of NF-κB activation, by glycyrrhizin (101–103), A. sinensis (104,105), and S. miltiorrhiza (106,107); by the natural agent biochanin A (65,108,109); and the pharmaceutical drugs statins (110,111) and fibrates (21,112,113). Pro-inflammatory cytokine release is reduced by activation of PPARs (21) and conversely, anti-inflammatory cytokine release is increased by their activation (114,115). PPAR alpha is activated by fibrates (21); PPAR alpha and gamma are activated by biochanin A (64); and statins upregulate PPAR alpha and gamma and show molecular signaling properties similar to fibrates (116).

A Note on Non-medicinal Interventions

Direct stimulation of the vagus nerve has been shown to exert potent inflammation-reducing activities in the body (89). Transcutaneous stimulation of the vagus nerve improves survival in mice with sepsis by reducing serum levels of HMGB1 (90). Thus there is a distinct possibility that vagus nerve stimulation by acupuncture could control immune-mediated pathology, by limiting release of pro-inflammatory cytokines. The potential for using acupuncture in this way was recently reviewed (91) with the authors noting that ‘the use of acupuncture as an adjunct therapy to conventional medical treatment for a number of chronic inflammatory and autoimmune diseases seems plausible and should be validated by confirming its cholinergicity’. Thus stimulation of the vagus nerve in patients with influenza could also represent an adjunct treatment in the management of severe influenza cases, provided it can be further investigated.

Conclusion

The example given here of an ancient Chinese medicine formula used to treat influenza containing nine (out of 11) herbs with anti-inflammatory properties provides compelling evidence that the way forward for the treatment of influenza in a pandemic should be immunomodulation. The host response is targeted, rather than the virus itself. Our observation that treatment of influenza virus-infected mice with a pharmaceutical used in humans, the lipid-lowering and immunomodulatory PPAR alpha agonist gemfibrozil, resulted in significantly decreased influenza-induced mortality, further shows that targeting the host response is a valid possibility. The natural immunomodulatory agent biochanin A from Red Clover, which is both a PPAR alpha and PPAR gamma agonist, could have similar effects to gemfibrozil on the course of influenza disease in vivo. Chinese herbs such as A. sinensis and S. miltiorrhiza which independently reduce secretion of the novel inflammatory cytokine HMGB1, and glycyrrhizin from liquorice root, which binds to HMGB1 and inactivates its activity, provide another avenue for investigation, as does the establishment of the role of HMGB1 in severe influenza. The wide availability and low economic price of these agents could make such agents an inexpensive alternative treatment, particularly in countries with large populations who will have no access to pandemic vaccines or antivirals.

Funding

National Health and Medical Research Council Australia (Grant no. 471402).